"I later said, 'In the future, he will become a big money, and it will not be too late to give it to her', and he agreed, does this count?" Li Yue'e had a bad premonition in her heart and added.

"Do you have proof?" The female judge said.

"Yes, there are QQ chat records. I'll open it for you to see. As she spoke, Li Yue'e took out her mobile phone and called up the QQ chat record and handed it to the clerk.

"Defendant, the plaintiff has now submitted new evidence, and you are cross-examining it." The female judge handed the mobile phone to Fang Yi, then turned to the plaintiff and said, "You can supplement the copy of the evidence in court." In duplicate, if not submitted we will not use it as evidence. ”

"Okay." Li Yue'e said.

Fang Yi had seen the relevant content when he looked through Zhou Hai's chat history before, so he recognized this evidence.

"This evidence does not prove the existence of a creditor-debtor relationship between the plaintiff and the defendant, 'if you become a large sum of money in the future, give it to me, I will take it', this sentence itself is a hypothesis, even if the defendant agrees, it does not mean that a relationship of rights and obligations is formed between the plaintiff and the defendant, nor does it constitute a unilateral promise of the defendant. The cross-examination is complete. Fang Yi said.

……

"The parties make their final statements." The female judge looked at the plaintiff after speaking.

"We have a divorce agreement, and it is very clear that the defendant should give me money, it's over!" Li Yue'e said confidently.

"The defendant makes a final statement." After speaking, the female judge began to pack up the case file.

"The defendant should not pay $50,000 to the plaintiff.

First of all, the defendant argued that the discharge of debts is a unilateral legal act, and the legal effect of debt extinguishment can be produced according to the expression of the creditor's intention without cause, and no matter what the reason for the discharge of debts, and regardless of whether the reasons are established, it does not affect the effect of the relief, so the plaintiff cannot deny the effect of debt cancellation on the grounds that the reason for the debt cancellation has changed at that time.

Second, the plaintiff did not attach any conditions or deadlines when forgiving the debt, and the defendant did not refuse after the plaintiff made an offer to forgive the debt.

In summary, the plaintiff's forgiveness of the defendant's debt is legal and valid, and the defendant should not pay the plaintiff 50,000 yuan. The court is requested to reject the plaintiff's claim in accordance with law.

That's it! Fang Yi said.

"Okay, the original defendant will print out a copy of the final statement and hand it in, and the trial of this case will end here......" After speaking, the female judge had already put the case file aside and asked the clerk to call the parties in the next case to come in and prepare for the trial.

After signing the trial transcript, Fang Yi walked out of the courtroom and happened to meet the round-faced male judge who had tried Zou Kaiyuan's divorce case before.

Fang Yi asked if the verdict of Zou Kaiyuan's divorce case had been released, and the round-faced male judge made a phone call to confirm that the verdict had been handed down, probably because the assistant had not had time to notify the parties to collect it.

Then Fang Yi followed the round-faced male judge to the courtroom, and the judge's assistant sent the verdict over. After Fang Yi received the verdict, he looked at it, and sure enough, as he expected, the court ordered He Zhen to repay Zou Kaiyuan 110,000 yuan, and the remaining 34,000 yuan was considered by the court to be living expenses, and it was not confirmed that it was a debt between husband and wife.

Fang Yi walked out of the door of the court, called Zou Kaiyuan, and asked him to come to the office to get the verdict. After work, Zou Kaiyuan came to the law firm.

"Lawyer Fang, I'm really sorry, when you called, I was at work and couldn't get out." Zou Kaiyuan said with a smile as soon as he entered the conference room.

"It's okay, it's not far from here anyway. This is the verdict of the first instance, you can read it. Similar to what I expected before, the court did not support the 34,000 yuan you transferred to the other party after marriage. Fang Yi handed the verdict to Zou Kaiyuan and said.

Zou Kaiyuan glanced at the verdict and frowned: "Lawyer Fang, you said that if I appeal, how sure are I that I can get the money back?" ”

"It's not very likely, it's very small. I don't think there is any obvious error in this decision, and even if you appeal, it is just a procedure, and there is a great chance of rejection. It's better to settle in the bag as soon as possible. Fang Yi said truthfully.

"Okay, I'll think about it again." After Zou Kaiyuan finished speaking, he took the verdict and left the law firm.

Fang Yi could clearly feel that Zou Kaiyuan was a little unwilling, not because he didn't want to earn lawyer fees, but because he really couldn't satisfy Zou Kaiyuan's thoughts.

In the evening, he returned to his residence, made a boiled noodle soup, mixed it with Lao Gan Ma, and ate it with two cloves of garlic.

After eating, he wiped his mouth, leaned against the head of the bed, lit a cigarette, and stared blankly at the night outside the window, feeling of loneliness hitting his heart like in the past.

In the past six months, only Li Shuming is left among the friends who have been contacted in the past, there are no more text messages for treats, no more calls for karaoke, and WeChat gradually no longer rings.

At first, he was a little uncomfortable, always trying to find something to do, but there was really nothing to do, so he would pick up the law and read it one by one, and throw himself in the pile of books, or in the liquor, so that he had no time to take care of other things.

He was escaping, yes, he was escaping, he didn't dare to face the loneliness of reality.

Slowly, he understood that some things could not be solved by escaping, and that loneliness would not be reduced by half a point due to the anesthesia of alcohol, and he slowly tried to enjoy this loneliness.

Reading books and listening to music is no longer to escape, but to live better. Now he has adapted to this kind of life, as if he has quit some kind of addiction.

The song rang in the mobile phone, it was Zhao Chuan's "Be Brave": ...... I tried to be brave, but you were not by my side, and my strength and self-confidence were staged because of love...... I will definitely be brave, even if you are not by my side, your decision and sorry will not change my tomorrow......

The singing pulled Fang Yi back to reality, Fang Yi hurriedly jumped out of bed and grabbed the mobile phone on the table: "Hey, daughter-in-law...... Xiaohui, what's wrong? ”

This bell was specially set up by Fang Yi for his daughter-in-law Cao Xiaohui on the day of the divorce, and it has never sounded since the divorce.

It was his daughter-in-law's divorce stick that woke him up, and he had to face the reality bravely and bravely assume the responsibilities that a man should bear. This bell is a commemoration and a lovesickness.

Cao Xiaohui's voice came from the other end of the phone: "Xiaozhi this month's child support, when are you going to give it?" Didn't I say you, a big man, who even struggled to pay child support, and returned to the lawyer! ”

"Here, I'll give it to you when I go to pick up Xiaozhi on the weekend! I bought a gift for Xiao Zhi, and I will give you one piece when the time comes. Fang Yi said.

When he returned from the city on Sunday, he wanted to give his laptop to his son, so he called Cao Xiaohui to see them, but Cao Xiaohui told him that Xiaozhi was attending cram school and it was inconvenient to meet. Fang Yi could only give up.

"It's been half a year...... Even if you have a conscience, you still know how to buy gifts for Xiaozhi. Xiao Zhi has been busy tutoring recently, you can meet this week, but you can't pick him up. Cao Xiaohui said.