"Before the trial, the plaintiff applied to this court to obtain the registration record of this mobile phone number, and now I will show it to both of you for cross-examination." The round-faced male judge said and asked the clerk to give the materials to the original defendant.

"We accept the evidence we have gathered." Fang Yi glanced at the registration records retrieved and smiled.

Zhao Yuejiao looked at the materials in her hand, a little stupid.

"Defendant, according to the materials we obtained from the telecommunications company, this mobile phone number was registered with your own identity document. Is this phone number yours? The round-faced male judge looked playful.

"I ...... I have lost my ID card, and it should be someone else who took my ID card to get the number. Zhao Yuejiao used her brains to come up with such an answer.

"Do you have any evidence of the loss of your ID card? When was it lost? If you do not submit the additional evidence, you will bear the legal consequences of not being able to present evidence. The round-faced male judge said coldly.

"Judge, why do you only ask me, why don't you ask them, the plaintiff fooled people to do beauty, the technology is not good, the craftsmanship is not good, the spots on my face have not been done five or six times, why don't you ask?" Zhao Yue said squeamishly.

"Defendant, let me explain to you that this case is a dispute over the infringement of the right to reputation by the plaintiff, and if you think that the plaintiff has defrauded you, you can sue separately, which is not within the scope of this case. Got it. The round-faced male judge explained.

"Got it!" Zhao Yuejiao jumped off the wall a little in a hurry just now, and after calming down, although she was angry, she was helpless.

"Plaintiff, on what basis is the amount of compensation you are seeking to be claimed? Is there any evidence? The round-faced male judge turned his head to look at Fang Yi.

"There is no evidence, but the defendant's false statements in the owner group did cause some damage to the plaintiff's reputation and lowered the plaintiff's social evaluation." Fang Yi said.

Fang Yi inquired, Sun Yuanyuan's beauty salon is not very well-known in the county, although the decoration is very good, but the technology is really not flattering, so there are not too many customers, basically the customers are mainly acquaintances, Zhao Yuejiao's remarks about walking can do much harm to Sun Yuanyuan and her bright beauty salon, I am afraid that there are only a handful, at most it can be regarded as worse. Fang Yi really couldn't provide any evidence to quantify the amount of loss.

……

"Now for the closing arguments, the plaintiffs make the closing arguments." The round-faced male judge said.

“…… The plaintiff argued that WeChat groups composed of unspecified related persons had the nature of a public space, and that citizens publishing insulting, defaming, slandering, or derogatory remarks in such WeChat groups constituted infringement of the right to reputation, and should bear legal responsibility in accordance with law.

According to Article 101 of the General Principles of the Civil Law of the People's Republic of China, citizens and legal persons enjoy the right to reputation, and the personal dignity of citizens is protected by law.

Article 120 stipulates that if a citizen's right to name, portrait, reputation, or honor is infringed upon, he or she has the right to demand that the infringement be stopped, that his reputation be restored, that the impact be eliminated, that he make a formal apology, and that he or she may demand compensation for the damages. Where legal persons' rights to name, reputation, or honor are infringed upon, the provisions of the preceding paragraph apply.

With regard to the economic losses caused by the infringement of the reputation rights of Liangmei Beauty Salon, although Liangmei Beauty Salon could not provide relevant evidence and could not prove the actual amount of economic losses, Liangmei Beauty Salon carried out business activities at the bottom merchant at the gate of Wanyue Community.

The defendant's inappropriate remarks in the WeChat group of the owners of the community will inevitably have a negative impact on the operation of Liangmei Beauty Salon, so the court is requested to comprehensively consider the defendant's degree of fault, the content and impact of the infringement, the duration of the infringement, the actual business situation of the beauty salon and other factors to support the request of Liangmei Beauty Salon. Sun Yuanyuan's solatium for mental injury should also be determined on the basis of the above factors.

Now the plaintiffs Sun Yuanyuan and Liangmei Beauty Salon demand that the defendant Zhao Yuejiao claim a formal apology and compensation for losses and mental damages based on the infringement of the right to reputation, which is in line with the above-mentioned legal provisions and requests the court to support it in accordance with law. Complete. Fang Yi said.

……

After Fang Yi walked into the Justice Law Firm, he was immediately called into the office by Director Sun.

"What? I give free representation to my own relatives in my village, which is not allowed? That one says no free proxies? Listening to Sun Zhengyi's complaint, the incomprehension and depression in Fang Yi's heart rose suddenly.

"Don't worry! Isn't this the Bar Association asking us to come over tomorrow to talk about this matter, I think it shouldn't be a big problem to explain everything clearly.

Complaining about our unfair competition is indeed a bit nonsense. But the people from the Bar Association also said that they need to go through the motions, after all, someone has complained, and they have to deal with it. Don't worry!

In addition, I invite someone to dinner at night, and then ask about this matter, I always feel that this matter is not simple, to say that there is no charge or only a small amount of labor fees for the lawsuit for my relatives and friends, basically in that law firm, so many years no one has complained, but you have been complained, I think there is something strange in this. Son touched his chin and thought.

"Well, I think so, tomorrow I happen to be in court, I'll go with you to the Bar Association." Fang Yi calmed down and thought for a while.

"Have you heard?" When he was about to get off work, Chu Huai mysteriously walked up to Zhao Zhongzhong, bumped him with his shoulder and said.

"What did you hear?" Zhao Zhongzhong glanced at Chu Huai impatiently.

Recently, there have been more cases, everyone has been busy, and Zhao Zhongzhong's mood has improved a lot, at least he doesn't have to be jealous of the more cases that others have taken and earned more commissions.

People are like this, when everyone has money to make, no one will be jealous of others for three melons and two dates, long and short, once the business is less, the distribution is uneven, some people earn more, some people earn less, naturally there will be gossip all over the sky, the air is filled with vinegar, which is called "not suffering from widowhood but suffering from unevenness".

"Our law firm and Fang Yi have been complained, and I heard from a buddy who works in the Bar Association this afternoon." Chu Huai gloated.

"Complained? Because of what? The case was messed up, or did you collect the money and didn't do anything? Zhao Zhongzhong was stunned for a moment, and then asked.

"No, it's because lawyer Fang represented a case for free and was complained of unfair competition. Originally, it was lawyer Fang who caused the trouble, but unfortunately it implicated our law firm. Chu Huai said with a smile.

"Free representation? No, the lawyer is not stupid, if the ordinary party wants to represent the lawyer for free, Director Sun will not agree. I don't think it's that simple. Zhao Zhongzhong rolled his eyes and said.

"I don't know exactly what's going on, but according to the grapevine, there is a high probability that Fang Yi will be punished this time, if he is punished, the reputation of the law firm will also be affected, I guess Sun Lao will ask him for an explanation.

Lao Zhao, when the time comes, you will be the pillar of our law firm, there is a source of my case outside, and you are in charge of taking the case at home, let's have a combination of two swords, and we will definitely be able to kill a piece of the world. Chu Huai said with a smile.

(End of chapter)