"The defender may respond to the prosecutor's opinion." The presiding judge said.

"Based on the prosecutor's defense opinions and responses, the defense counsel issues the following defense opinions:

The defender argued that the 'minor circumstances of the crime' of the crime of dangerous driving should not be based on whether a traffic accident occurred.

Where a traffic accident occurred, but the consequences of the accident were not serious, and the defendant actively made compensation, admitted guilt, or repented, it may still be found that the circumstances of the crime were relatively minor after comprehensive consideration of the circumstances of the entire case, and a suspended sentence may be announced for the defendant in accordance with law.

In this case, the defendant Zhou Kaidong's car was in a state of stop when it was rear-ended by a bus, and the time of the crime was around 6 a.m., there were few cars on the road, and neither party to the accident suffered major property damage or personal injury, nor did it harm others, so the harm to society was relatively small.

Although this circumstance cannot be a reason for his 'offense', it reflects that his willingness to drive while drunk is not strong, and the reason why he is drunk driving is not related to his lack of awareness of the fact that the alcohol in his body has not been completely metabolized and he is still in a drunken state.

In addition, when the defendant Zhou Kaidong found that the fog was heavy and the visibility was low, he took the initiative to stop in order to prevent a traffic accident, reflecting his subjective willingness to prevent the danger of a traffic accident.

After the incident, Zhou Kaidong truthfully confessed his crime, actively compensated the other party responsible for the economic losses and obtained forgiveness.

In summary, the circumstances of the defendant Zhou Kaidong's crime were relatively minor, his subjective malice was small, he showed remorse, and there was no danger of committing another crime, and the suspended sentence against him would not have a major adverse impact on the community in which he lived, so the defender believes that the provisions of the first paragraph of article 72 of the Criminal Law can be applied and a suspended sentence can be declared. Complete. Yun Qiao responded.

……

When he was about to get off work in the afternoon, Fang Yi was discussing the case with Song Hui, Sui Xia and others, when the mobile phone suddenly rang, it was Yun Qiao calling.

"Master, the case has been won, and the court of second instance has really changed the verdict." As soon as Fang Yi answered the phone, Yun Qiao's voice came out, and she was as excited as a child.

"Oh? How was the second instance verdict? Fang Yi's heart moved.

"The collegial panel adopted our defense opinions, revoked the first-instance criminal judgment, and sentenced the defendant Zhou Kaidong to one month's criminal detention, a two-month suspended sentence, and a fine of 1,000 yuan for the crime of dangerous driving. Reprieve! Yun Qiao screamed excitedly.

Before the trial, she was very worried in her heart, not knowing whether the defense plan set by Master Fang Yi was good or not, and it was not until the moment the verdict was pronounced that she realized that luck was really on her side.

"Alright, stay safe on the way back. Hang up! Fang Yi hung up the phone after speaking.

Because Yun Qiao spoke loudly, Song Hui was the closest to Fang Yi, and he heard it clearly, and he laughed secretly in his heart, laughing at Yun Qiao who had never seen the world, and it was a fuss to win the case.

If Yun Qiao could hear Song Hui's heart, he would definitely shout loudly, "As for."

Yun Qiao didn't have any confidence in this case, and even she had already thought about how to persuade the parties to accept the reality after the court of second instance upheld the original verdict, but the ending was reversed.

Compared with those cases where she was sure of the outcome and even confident, Yun Qiao felt that the result of this case was simply a big easter egg, if it wasn't for her full trust in Fang Yi, she would even want to push this case away.

"This little girl is always shocked, so excited to win a case. Let's move on. Fang Yi said with a smile.

Everyone could see that Fang Yi was in a good mood after answering Yun Qiao's call.

……

After Du Yong got the case file of the intentional homicide case, he took Cheng Du to the detention center to meet with the defendant Rongyang.

Defendant Rong Yang is 28 years old, not very tall, about 1.65 meters, his body is thin, his skin is dark, his hair is much whiter and less black, and he looks like a man in his 40s when he looks at him.

When Du Yong was introducing himself, Rong Yang on the other side kept his eyes glazed over, and he looked very unbright, and even Du Yong wondered if he had a mental problem.

But when Du Yong mentioned his sister Rong Juan and his mother, a trace of fluctuation flashed in Rong Yang's eyes, followed by endless pain and never-ending tears.

Moments later, Rong Yang told his story.

Defendant Rong Yang is the son of the victim Lu Yanlan.

In 1990, Lu Yanlan suffered from a stroke that caused the left half of her body to be unable to live normally, and her condition was relieved after treatment, but her condition recurred four years later, accompanied by rheumatoid and other diseases, resulting in pain and cramps in her limbs, and she was unable to walk normally.

In addition to his son Rong Yang, the Rong family also has a daughter named Rong Juan, who is eight years older than Rong Yang. Before Lu Yanlan got sick, Rong Juan had married into a village below the neighboring county, Rong Juan's in-laws lived in average conditions, and Rong Juan and his wife opened a clothing store in the county to make a living.

After Lu Yanlan fell ill, Rong Juan often ran over to help at first, but she couldn't stand it all the time, the children and clothing stores at home were inseparable from people, and they lived far away, and her father Rong Shuyou also persuaded her not to run back and forth, but then she couldn't run away, so she came less.

Since then, Rong Shuyou and Rong Yang's father and son have been taking care of Lu Yanlan's daily life, and are responsible for Lu Yanlan's medical treatment. The Rong family is poor and can't afford the high medical bills, Lu Yanlan can't bear the torture of long-term illness, and she doesn't want to see her family being crushed by debts, so she has the idea of committing suicide. If it weren't for the neighbors who came to visit the door and rescued Lu Yanlan in time, she would have hanged herself on the beams of the house.

After that, the father and son put away the ropes, knives and sharp knives at home to prevent Lu Yanlan from committing suicide again. Although life is hard, the Rong family's father and son do some odd jobs outside, and the family can barely survive.

Two years later, Rong Yang's father Rong Shuyou died of illness, it turned out that Rong Shuyou was sick, but his family was poor and he was reluctant to spend money on treatment, so he secretly bought some cheap painkillers.

The Rong family lost an income, and life was even more difficult, Rong Yang had to work three jobs a day to make ends meet, and he fainted on the way home several times when he was tired. Mother Lu Yanlan didn't want to drag down her son anymore, and had the idea of suicide many times.

In April, Lu Yanlan asked her son Rongyang to buy pesticides for her. Rong Yang understood his mother's thoughts, so he persuaded his mother not to think too much, and continued to run for life by gritting his teeth alone.

In May, the factory where he worked closed down, the boss ran away with the money, and nearly 100 employees lost their wages for three months. It was this salary of more than 1,000 yuan per month that became the last straw that overwhelmed the Rong family.

Rongyang and his co-workers ran to the labor bureau several times, but the boss ran away, the equipment and real estate in the factory have been seized by the bank in the court, the creditors are wave after wave, no one takes over, and the employees can only go through the dry labor arbitration procedure, everyone understands that in the end they can only get two weak A4 papers, which cannot change the reality at all. (End of chapter)