Unexpectedly, it was Hu Ling'er who was the first to speak, and it could be seen that on her small cheeks, the reddish eye circles were particularly obvious.

Hu Ling'er adjusted her emotions and tried her best to reply in a steady voice

"The mind is a dog that tries to find happiness for its master, Xiao Yi's death it can do nothing, can only try to protect its only owner Chan Yi, of course, it also did it, it used its own efforts to resolve Chan Yi's resentment, and also let Chan Yi survive until the return of her mother, but the mind left permanently"

Hu Ling'er's voice became smaller and smaller, and she became more and more choked.

He Jing smiled, took the lead in applauding, and gave Hu Ling'er encouragement, and the class suddenly burst into thunderous applause.

When Hu Ling'er sat down, Cheng Siyu handed her a tissue across an aisle.

He Jing looked at the rest of the class again, "Is there anything else?"

"Teacher, I actually hate Chanyi, dogs are good friends of humans, how can Chanyi treat Xinyi like that, especially Xinyi, which is not his at all, he stole it, since he has to get it after all the hard work, why don't you know how to cherish it"

"No, no, Canyi stole the heart for Xiao Yi, when the ice cave appeared, Xiao Yi and Xin Yi fell into the water, but in the end, Xin Yi survived Xiao Yi died, and it is human nature for Chan Yi to be resentful."

"But the mind is clear and tried to save Xiao Yi"

"But Chan Yi doesn't know, the dog can't speak."

"Even if the dog can talk, can Chan Yi still expect it to be able to save such a big living person as Xiao Yi with a dog, he is so resentful that it is unreasonable"

"Chan Yi lost her sister who depended on each other, it's normal to be irrational under sadness and despair."

"Isn't it sad that the mind has lost an owner who often accompanies it?"

The daily debate of the Chinese class in the first year of high school.

Anyway, the public said that the public was reasonable, and the mother said that the mother was reasonable, and the two sides had a heated discussion, and no one could convince anyone.

He Jing held her forehead, stretched out her hands to signal everyone to be quiet, and then looked at Su Nandao

"What do you think?"

Everyone's eyes are focused on Su Nan, and many times, when Su Nan watches a movie, he can catch the point that they can't grasp.

Su Nan stood up and said after a moment of silence

"Actually, isn't it Xiao Yi and Chan Yi's mother who should be blamed the most, since she gave birth to them, why didn't she raise Chan Yi When she went to find her for the first time, her first reaction was to apply for a passport and go abroad to hide, she never thought about it, the brother and sister who had been obediently and obediently waiting for him to come home, why would it be Chan Yi who came to look for her alone in the end."

"Even if this thought only flashed for a moment, she wouldn't do that, Chan Yi wouldn't wander into a fraud syndicate in the future, and she wouldn't die being beaten to save Chan Yi."

"Let's go further, if it weren't for my mother's abandonment, Chan Yi wouldn't have stolen the dog in order to make Xiao Yi happy, the happiness of the two brothers and sisters is that they are not wrong with each other, but they are also companions, if their mother doesn't leave, maybe they will live well with their mothers, and they will be fine."

Speaking of this, Su Nan paused for a moment and concluded in the last sentence

"If happiness is not lost, there is no such thing as being found."

The last word fell, and the class fell silent for a long time.

Yes, the happy recovery dog, the process of helping the owner find happiness is touching, but all this could have been avoided, it could have been happy on its own, not for the happiness of others.