Chapter 65 She didn't commit a crime, because subjectivity and objectivity are not unified

Nanatsuki Koshisui was sentenced to three months' detention with a three-month probation.

What is Probation?

It is a suspension of the sentence.

If the probation time and jail time are the same, it means that you don't have to go to jail again.

However, during the probation period, the person must not commit another crime, and if the offender is caught again, the probation will be revoked and the punishment for several crimes will be combined.

After leaving the courthouse, Komimen went to the detention center where Nanatsuki Koshisui had been held.

In the detention center, Koshisui Nanatsuki had just completed certain formalities and was about to leave.

Seeing Gu Meimen coming, she smiled and said hello.

"Lawyer Gu Meimen, thank you very much for defending me this time, so that I can come out of here with dignity."

"Don't say polite words."

Gu Meimen waved his hand and stared at her face.

"Miss Yue Shui, this murder case, in fact, everything was planned by you, right?"

Nanatsuki Koshisui blinked and said with a smile, "Mr. Lawyer, I don't understand what you mean. ”

"Don't pretend." Gu Meimen shook his head and said, "You were going to admit it to me in the morning, but now you don't recognize it, such a very ungraceful young lady." ”

"Well, I did plan it."

Seeing Gu Meimen say this, Koshisui Nanatsuki smiled and stopped hiding it.

Then, she was generous and told what had happened.

"Actually, before I went to the ship on the uninhabited island, the first time I saw Hiroo Ao's eyes, I knew that he was going to kill people soon." Nanatsuki said lightly, "Especially the way he looked at Tokizu's eyes, the feeling of hesitation, nervousness, and a little excitement that only those who were about to commit murder would have." ”

"Oh, you're pretty sharp, then."

Gu Meimen nodded.

Nanatsuki's words sounded, but he could understand it.

In this world, sophisticated detectives have an intuition of "looking for the murderer", such as the case where Gu Meimen sued Conan for kicking someone into a concussion, when Conan just glanced at the eyes of the real murderer and determined that the person involved definitely killed someone.

"So you're going to do it."

Gu Meimen said.

"You were planning to kill people and trap everyone on the island, but you thought that if someone rescued you from the island in the future, you would have to face the criminal law of intentional homicide, so you changed your plan on the fly."

"When you killed someone, you deliberately left your strength to knock the prisoner unconscious, and in order to get away with it later, you didn't wear any gloves and tools, and deliberately left your DNA and fingerprints and other information on the murder weapon."

"You have to act first, because you don't know for sure if you give up your plan to kill, whether Ryozo Koya and Hiroo Tsuyo will carry out their plan, because you guess that their plan may be to use you as a scapegoat after the killing."

"The whole thing was premeditated by you, and after you left, Hiroo followed him out of the dining table, sneaked into Tokitsu Junya's room, and killed him with a knife."

"After you leave the island, you will come to me to defend me, and you are sure that after your plan, I will definitely defend your crimes to a minimum, because you investigated me at the beginning and thought that I was a person who would do anything to win the lawsuit."

"Am I right? Miss Koshisui. ”

After Komimen finished speaking, he looked into the eyes of Nanatsuki Koshisui.

Nanatsuki Koshisui kept smiling.

After listening, she snapped her hands.

"Everything was said by you, worthy of lawyer Gu Meimen, I didn't misunderstand your ability at the beginning."

There was a pause.

"So, Mr. Lawyer, what will you do? Will you hand me over to the public prosecutor again? ”

The girl licked her tongue and looked at Gu Meimen's big eyes fluttering, and her face, which originally looked innocent, turned a little bewitching at this moment.

"Tsk, do you think I'm the kind of lawyer who shouts justice and will betray his client for the truth?"

Gu Meimen raised his eyebrows and sneered.

"You are my client, and my job is to defend you, no matter what you have done or what the truth is, it has nothing to do with me."

Nanatsuki stared at Komito's face.

"Really? Looks like I've got the right person in place. ”

She smiled and said.

"And you didn't commit any other crimes, did you?"

Gu Meimen smiled.

"By the legal definition, you are only guilty of attempted intentional homicide, and even if it was really planned by you, there is no way to put you in prison."

"Isn't this a crime of omission? I don't save anything when I see death. Xiao Ai interjected beside him.

Gu Meimen glanced at her: "Dora Waimeng, it seems that you still need to study law more." The crime of omission can only be finalized if there is an obligation to help, but it is not committed. What does the dead have to do with him? Does it matter? Is it her long-lost father? Or a sweet husband? If it does not constitute an obligation to help, it is not a crime. ”

"But she knocked the deceased unconscious in advance, and did not save people, so that the real murderer behind could kill the deceased, isn't this an 'omission' constituted by 'previous acts'? Shouldn't indirect intentional homicide be convicted? ”

"Stupid, there's something wrong with your 'only way to kill the dead'. Doraemon, how many times do you want me to say it to understand? ”

Gu Meimen sighed, revealing an expression of hatred for iron and steel.

"The fact that she knocked the deceased unconscious and the real murderer killed the deceased cannot be objectively linked, because if the deceased just faints all the time, there will be no danger to his life, and then being killed by someone is objectively a different situation, and does not constitute a 'prior act', understand? You can only say that she subjectively had such a premeditation, but objectively the death of the deceased had nothing to do with her. In the matter of omission, subjectivity and objectivity are not uniform, so she is only charged with attempted intentional homicide, do you know? ”

"Okay."

Xiao Ai looked at Gu Meimen and pouted.

The law is understood by this guy.

If this kind of guy really wants to commit a crime, no one can really put him in jail.

"Your lawyer's knowledge is really complicated."

Nanatsuki Koshisui on the side watched the conversation between the two and couldn't help laughing.

"When I was a child, I also had a dream of becoming a lawyer, but then I saw such a big thing to learn, and I felt like my head was big, so I gave up."

"If you are not a lawyer, you are also very talented as a detective."

Gu Meimen turned his head to look at her and said meaningfully.

"In this whole matter, everyone was deceived by you, and I have to admit that your methods are indeed very clever, and even I was almost deceived."

"Oh? So when did you find out? ”

Nanatsuki Koshisui showed an expression of interest.

"In court."

Gu Meimen said.

"Because your performance at that time was so realistic, almost everyone was moved by you, and there must be something wrong with a woman who can shed tears so easily. So, at that time I knew that you were planning it all. ”