140. The trial is over, and the verdict will be announced on a later date!
When he heard that the other party had no opinion, Judge Liu looked at Li Chen and asked him to continue the debate.
"Okay, Presiding Judge."
Li Chen continued to reply when he heard this: "Regarding Wu Yong's role in the Yunsheng Business Platform, it belongs to the employee, and his salary is paid by the Yunsheng Business Platform, which is an employment relationship.
In the confession, he also clearly explained the details of the management, which also indirectly proved that the rider was really hired by Yunsheng Business Co., Ltd.
The second point is about Zhang Xiaodong's behavior.
I don't even bother to defend this.
Zhang Xiaodong's remarks on the Internet, the spearhead is to eat the platform quickly, what does it have to do with your subcontracting? ”
People are talking about the takeaway platform, and the takeaway platform has not come out to speak, are you here to say that people are spreading rumors?
It's really salty and don't worry about eating radishes.
If you want to say that it is also a platform that comes forward to put forward opinions, what rights do you have?
"The third point is about the other riders.
In the original complaint, many riders reported the problems of the site, and these problems were also demonstrated by Wu Yong, not for nothing.
A problem was verified and became a real illegal crime, and then, the rider who reported the problem turned against him, saying that Zhang Xiaodong had induced and deceived them in the name of buying insurance.
In the chat records between the two parties, Zhang Xiaodong did not have any inducement rhetoric.
The rider reported the problem, and Zhang Xiaodong expressed his opinion, and I think there is no infringement at this point.
First, he did not retweet it, and second, he did not distort the facts of the problem and take it out of context, so how can he talk about infringing on the right to reputation?
If there is a problem, then the source of the problem must also be those riders, who are distorting the facts. ”
The riders who were sitting on the bench of the trial and defected heard that Li Chen had pulled the root of the problem on them again, and they instantly panicked, and an ominous premonition came to their hearts.
They all signed a letter of guarantee, which clearly informed the witnesses of the relevant regulations and explained what penalties they would receive for false testimony.
looked at Jiang Zhengjia in the defendant's dock with some confusion, and Jiang Zhengjia also looked at the witness stand, several eyes converged, with an inquiring meaning in his eyes, but he didn't understand what the other party's blink meant...
Jiang Zhengjia's eyes were very simple, let them not panic, there was no big problem...
On the other side, Li Chen was still expounding his debate opinions: "Then according to the situation of Wu Yong's arrest, the problems reported by the riders are also real, and there is no possibility of false facts."
And the rider said that he was deceived by Zhang Xiaodong, I can't figure this out, how did he deceive, and what evidence can prove that Zhang Xiaodong was indeed deceived?
The second point, insurance and Zhang Xiaodong's purpose, I will first talk about Zhang Xiaodong's purpose.
His purpose is very clear, that is, to ask Yunsheng Business to pay his brother's medical expenses in advance, and his brother Zhang Dazhuang's accident during work is a work-related injury, so it is reasonable and legal for the platform to pay for it, if you feel that his behavior is unreasonable and illegal, you can choose to go to the law enforcement agency to report the case, instead of wasting time here.
As for insurance, this is also the management responsibility that the employment platform should bear.
In recent years, with the rise of the Internet, it is also convenient for people to consume and shop online, and the takeaway industry has become a very hot industry.
The more common and frequent traffic accidents come from riders not following traffic rules, ignoring traffic lights, making random U-turns, and so on.
There are also some cases where the order is completed by using the mobile phone during the ride, and these are all problems between the platform and the rider, although they have nothing to do with this case, I still hope that the presiding judge will give me a chance to talk about it. ”
This sentence was also prepared by Li Chen in advance, and he also wanted to inform more people through the online trial.
Because of these problems, no one will bear the medical expenses for them.
As the party at fault, the traffic police will definitely not favor them when determining responsibility, and the other party's insurance company will definitely not settle the claim.
If they really have problems, they have to bear the responsibility themselves.
If it's a little lighter, you may lose some money, and if it's serious, your life will be gone.
Originally, Li Chen didn't plan to mention it, because there was no public trial and online trial, and he said that these didn't make much sense.
It's all in a hurry, and when it comes to this, there is a feeling of not vomiting and unhappy, mainly because of the other party's words.
How can you, a lawyer, argue like that?
In order to keep the client from taking responsibility, shirk the responsibility to others, and say that the plaintiff's behavior is rumor-mongering, and the behavior is very serious?
You're really not afraid of being given something by the other party one day?
However, the presiding judge did not agree to his request: "It is forbidden to discuss matters unrelated to this case. ”
Of course, the presiding judge didn't let it be discussed, mainly because it was useless.
It's not a public trial and an online trial, but there are only a few people in attendance, who do you say to listen to this?
Tell the other party that if people have this awareness, it is impossible for them to come to the lawsuit, so they will mediate with you at that time.
Tell me?
I've tried so many cases in the past few years, and I'm used to hearing all kinds of stories...
"Okay presiding judge."
Hearing the rejection, Li Chen took a deep breath and didn't say much.
"Do you have any other points of debate?"
After listening to him, Judge Liu continued to ask, and when Li Chen heard this, he said, "No." ”
The presiding judge nodded when he heard this, and then began to announce the adjournment of the court and announce the verdict on the outcome of the dispute.
At the end of the trial, the three judges discussed the case.
"What do you think about this case?"
Judge Liu, the presiding judge of the trial, asked the other two for their opinions.
"This case is not as complicated as it was at the beginning.
Based on the actual issues and the plaintiff's arguments, the defendant should admit the corresponding medical expenses. ”
"I always feel that there is something wrong with the testimony of witnesses and I need to check it"
After Judge Zhang of the collegial panel finished speaking, another judge also took over.
"Well, I think the same thing as you.
The plaintiff's elder brother encountered an accident on the way to work, and he was not at fault, so Yunsheng Business Co., Ltd. had to treat it as a work-related injury and pay his medical expenses in advance.
In addition, there is a possibility that the witnesses of the defense have given false testimony, and it is very likely that they have been bribed, so they should be investigated. ”
"I'm okay with that."
"I'm okay with that."
Judge Liu saw that the other two had no opinion, so he immediately made a decision.
And the riders who testify falsely will soon be punished exclusively for them...
(End of chapter)