158. The witness is also the defendant?
"I want to ask you, what do you think about this incident?"
Li Chen looked at the judge, wanting to probe the other party's tone.
"So what do you think? What do you want to defend yourself? ”
Judge Wang did not answer his question, but asked Li Chen rhetorically.
"I will defend according to the actual situation, and as far as the current situation stands, I still prefer to defend not guilty."
Judge Wang nodded when he heard this, but did not speak.
How to defend it, that's what the other party thinks, and it has nothing to do with you...
Leaving the court, Li Chen was ready to appeal.
At worst, this is the case, if it really doesn't work, apply for a retrial.
is still the same sentence, no one can turn over their own rice bowl.
At present, Li Chen has already made up his mind that it is legitimate defense.
Take a taxi back to your hotel and prepare to prepare your own defense.
Sit down at the desk in the room and take out your computer to write your own defense.
Serious illness also requires heavy medicine, and only by magnifying the situation can the judge's attention be aroused.
There are four points to be made:
1. The place of the incident is at the school.
It's infuriating that something like this happens at school.
What kind of place is a school, it is a place to teach and educate people.
Such an incident naturally brings to mind a very controversial topic...
2. The concept of the time of the crime for Zhang Zhenyu himself.
In the case, Zhang Zhenyu was woken up at two o'clock in the morning, unconscious, and didn't take it seriously for the first time, most likely thinking that he had a nightmare.
In the second time, Zhang Zhenyu was forcibly pulled out of the dormitory, and in the face of a group of people outside the door, Zhang Zhenyu naturally felt afraid and afraid, and it was in this situation that he would use a knife to defend himself.
In the course of the case, Zhang Zhenyu was dragged to the corner of the corridor, but the so-called shelf behavior was not seen from the video, but a bunch of people surrounded Zhang Zhenyu.
Third, the witness's confession does not match the logical basis of the content of the surveillance video.
If they really want to fight, then Zhang Zhenyu's subsequent behavior is intentional homicide, and he should be sentenced to death in order to defend the dignity of the law.
It's puzzling why the other party behaves unbelievably under video surveillance.
If it's a racket, why can't these many people stop one person's behavior?
Therefore, there is also reason to prove that they wanted to drag the person into a corner of the surveillance and beat him.
The fourth point is the convergence of opinions.
The place of the crime was in the school, and such an incident occurred, due to the urgency, there is no possibility of risk avoidance.
When the number of participants is several times greater than their own, the person's act of holding a knife should be considered to protect himself from being beaten by others, and in this case, the perpetrator still chooses to continue the violence, which is the main cause of the homicide.
However, the party did not act superfluously after stopping the unlawful infringement, so it should be regarded as legitimate defense.
Finalize the draft and refine the content, and it is not almost complete until half past nine.
At nine o'clock the next day, Li Chen came to the trial court with his defense draft.
At 9:20 a.m., he submitted his reply to the trial judge.
Judge Wang, who was in charge of adjudicating the case, took the draft of defense from Li Chen's hand and took a brief look at it.
When he saw the first one, he almost broke the defense.
Good guys, this defense draft, there is a level!
According to him, the angle of the problem is serious.
Judge Wu began to carefully review every word of the defence.
Boy.
According to you, all the witnesses have to be the accused?
"On what basis do you say that?"
Judge Wu raised his head and asked Li Chen, who replied with a serious face: "It can be seen from the video."
At the first 18 minutes in the video, a group of people surrounded Zhang Zhenyu in the middle.
I think that if they really want to fight, there is no reason why they can't stop Wang Guowei who is drunk and picking quarrels and provoking trouble, and similarly, it is precisely because of their existence that Zhang Zhenyu's fear in his heart is increased, and he will make the action of holding a knife.
In the face of such a group of people, whether anyone stopped Wang Guowei's atrocities, it is reasonable for Zhang Zhenyu to defend himself with a knife. ”
Judge Wang didn't know how to refute Li Chen's remarks when he heard this, because judging from the feedback from the video, he could think so.
He faltered.
From the intentional injury identified at the time of the first reading of the case file, it is now possible to be justified defense.
How do you hit this hammer?
Everyone has raised the problem to a new level, so they have to renew the problem from the other person's point of view.
The incident happened at school, and many people were involved...
Well...
After pondering for a while, it was decided to leave the matter to the prosecution and the prosecution to see how they responded...
"Alright, you can go back."
"Yes, Judge Wang."
After Li Chen heard this, he left the trial court and planned to go to the school to learn about the relevant situation and see if he could talk to Zhang Zhenyu's classmates and let them be the main witnesses in the case.
Inquisition.
Judge Wang sent copies of Li Chen's defense draft in triplicate to the district prosecutor's office in charge of prosecution and the civil prosecutor.
District Attorney's Office.
Liu Xue, the prosecutor in charge of prosecuting the case, was a little surprised when she received the defense draft.
She was a little puzzled, there was still a lawyer to take over such a criminal case?
With a puzzled look, he opened the email and first glanced at it.
Well??
When I saw the other party's first answer question, I couldn't calm down.
Take a deep breath and carefully review the content above, feeling a little tangled in my heart.
Record the content of the opponent's defense, and then start to make a targeted defense.
The other side.
Both parties to the civil prosecution also received the defense draft, and as relatives, their first reaction was anger.
Some can't figure out why there are still lawyers to take such cases.
When they saw Li Chen's content, they were extremely angry in their hearts.
What kind of lawyer is this, who actually talks like that?
The children in his own family are all dead, and he said something about the campus.
It's really outrageous, and there are really people who exonerate the prisoner.
What kind of people are their children, can they not know?
If it weren't for the other party's fault, how could his own child hit him?
There are so many people in the school, why do they go to your trouble?
So many people are there and no one is fighting, is it not enough to explain the problem?
Angry, they contacted the lawyer who taught them to write their reply and asked if there was any reason to send the opposing defense lawyer in.
This lawyer is so unconscionable!
The answer they got was a little difficult for them to accept.
The lawyer's defense opinions in the trial court will not be held criminally responsible.
If the other party's lawyer does not have any illegal operations, is it possible that the other party will send it in.
At the same time, they are also curious, who is this lawyer, and the defense opinions can be so tricky...
I don't know how to answer for a while...
The heroine is gone.,The fifth chapter can't come out before six o'clock.,It's definitely five more today.
(End of chapter)