182. Is the problem of the school morally corrupt or instigated?
"Your reply is a bit too aggressive."
After reading Li Chen's reply, Judge Chen put the manuscript aside.
Since the other party is not defending the criminals, he does not need to wear a cold and arrogant face.
"Do you think I'm going too far with the school?"
Li Chen asked the other party rhetorically when he heard this.
Regarding Wang Jiaxin's question, based on the judge's attitude when they first met, Li Chen can be sure that he is definitely not referring to him when he speaks excessively.
Judge Chen nodded when he heard this, and said, "The school affirmed Wang Jiaxin's performance in school, which in itself is not wrong.
Although he was an intentional homicide, there is no denying what his previous performance was like in school.
You can't put someone in the dock just because the school came forward to make a suggestion, right? ”
"Judge Chen, do you think the problems exposed by the school are not enough?"
When Li Chen heard this, he opened his mouth and asked the other party, and Judge Chen looked at Li Chen very seriously and said, "I don't deny that there is a problem, but it's also a minority, isn't it?"
We can't dismiss a student as a whole and their school's grades because of a few individual problems.
This public trial will also be live-streamed, if your remarks really appear at the trial scene, will bring real consequences, have you ever thought about it? ”
"Of course I thought about it, and I didn't deny the fruits of the work of other schools, did I?"
Hearing this, Li Chen looked at Judge Chen with a serious face and said, "Do you think the problem of this school is not serious?"
They just saw Wang Jiaxin's daily performance, ignoring Wang Jiaxin's role in the case and how cruel his methods were.
I don't know what you think, at least I think that Wang Jiaxin's behavior must be executed, and only the death penalty can comfort the victim's soul, make the victim's family feel the fairness of the law, and maintain the dignity of the law.
In this case, the school's actions subverted society's perception of criminal behavior, which was an act of defiance of the law.
Just because Wang Jiaxin did well in school, they wanted to come out and intercede for him, and the method adopted was, in my opinion, to threaten the judicial organs, and their purpose was clear from the beginning.
Shouldn't these teachers and students who are jointly interceding be coerced into coming forward or purely voluntary? ”
"Do you suspect that someone is behind it?"
Hearing Li Chen's words, Judge Chen's expression immediately became serious.
If that's the case, then they're really breaking the law.
"There are only two possibilities for Wang Jiaxin's behavior.
The first is that they have the same purpose.
I don't know what you think, but my first reaction when I came into contact with a case was disgust.
From his confession and his behavior, I don't know what his family conditions are like, which will make him have the idea that rural people are difficult, which is a serious class antagonistic contradiction.
It is precisely because of this kind of thinking that he will have the aftermath of killing people once and for all.
However, even in this case, there are people who come to intercede for him, and they are not morally corrupt or something. ”
"The second situation is that these people are disgusted by Wang Jiaxin's behavior, but for some reason they have to violate their conscience.
I hope it's the second type, if it's one, it's terrible, it shows that there are many, many people like Wang Jiaxin in their school, and they also have a very clear class position in their hearts, thinking that rural people are difficult, and they look down on rural people in their hearts. ”
Regarding the students' behavior, Li Chen also didn't believe that they really wanted to defend Wang Jiaxin.
Just such a person, must come forward?
But any normal person with a conscience will be disgusted by Wang Jiaxin's methods, right?
It's understandable to hit someone and run away, that's a normal reaction to fear and fear.
Hit someone and get out of the car and stab someone to death, is this kind of thing you can do?
To sum up, Li Chen believes that the behavior of these people is abnormal, and it is very likely that his client spent money to buy off the school, and the school came forward to find the students to threaten them, so that they had to say something against their conscience.
And it is precisely because the prisoner is a student that the trial court will listen to the opinions of the society and comprehensively consider the trial of Wang Jiaxin.
Whether to strictly enforce the law or give him a chance, Li Chen felt that this judge was also entangled at the moment.
But what's there to worry about?
The law has always been a red light, and it is the last resort to restrain the perpetrators.
When a person loses the bottom line, then he must be punished by the law and pay the due price for his actions.
Judge Chen listened to Li Chen's words and fell into deep thought.
It seems like so...
After thinking for a long time, Judge Chen looked at Li Chen and said, "Are you sure that your reply does not need to be amended?"
In fact, you can also file only the first reply. ”
Li Chen shook his head when he heard this: "No need, this is my defense opinion." ”
Judge Chen couldn't help but twitch the corners of his mouth slightly when he heard this.
What a defense!
"Okay, I'll send a copy of your reply to the prosecution, and they should look into what you said."
After handing in the reply, Li Chen also walked out of the courtroom.
"Judge Chen, what is this Lawyer Li talking about?"
After Li Chen left, the female assistant sitting next to Judge Chen was also puzzled.
Because she could also see from the words of the two that Li Chen's remarks must have been sharp, otherwise the old judge would not have had such a solemn expression.
What the hell is it about school or something?
"Take it and make a copy, send the first copy to the civil litigation agent, and the second copy to Inspector Zhang in charge of the District Attorney's Office."
Regarding Li Chen's argument draft, Judge Chen chose to distinguish between the two.
As for the female assistant's question, he didn't say it explicitly, but asked her to see it herself.
"Okay, Judge Chen."
Hearing this, the female assistant picked up the reply and walked out of the reception room.
Walk out of the door and look at it as you walk with the reply.
Fang saw the second part, and the shocked heroine couldn't help but stop and look at it twice.
Boy...
This has directly pushed this school to the forefront.
Sure enough, this lawyer Li, who is active on the Douyin platform, is really bold.
Shaking his head, he walked to the copy room to copy the reply.
In the afternoon of the same day, Inspector Zhang of the Anxi City District Prosecutor's Office received a reply from the trial court.
He couldn't figure it out, how could he still have a reply when the trial was about to start?
Is it possible to find a lawyer to defend such a serious issue?
I opened the file bag and glanced at it very casually.
it?
On closer inspection, he was a little dazed.
Is this a reply from the opposing defense lawyer? Are you sure it wasn't a mistake?
Begin to take a pen to record the opponent's reply for analysis.
After the analysis, Inspector Zhang couldn't help but frown.
It seems like...
That's what happened!
(End of chapter)