The judgment seat.

Knock knock!

On the presiding judge's seat, Cao Liqiang glanced at Su Bai without leaving a trace, and rang the gavel: "The defense refuses to settle, and the trial continues." ”

"Plaintiff, please state your defense of Penguin Holdings Limited and exercise unfair competition against you, legal justification or submit evidence."

"Okay presiding judge."

Su Bai slowly spoke: "But before that, we need to ask the defendant a question. ”

"First: According to the defendant's lawyer's previous statement, the removal is the internal handling regulations of the platform, but may I ask, which internal regulations of the platform are the reasons for the delisting?"

This issue.

They've been through it many times.

Chen Chao is no stranger to this kind of question, and slowly said:

"It is based on the risk assessment of the mini games from the outside world, and it is due to the security of our platform, so the mini games produced by the plaintiff are removed from the shelves."

For this kind of question, Chen Chao immediately spoke.

Shake the pot directly.

You mean to accuse me of unfair competition, but I am doing it for my own safety, so why do you say that my removal is unfair competition?

If you ask, what's the security impact, sorry, I don't know.

Or, this is a certain mistake in our operation, sorry, we will change it immediately.

Admit mistakes with sincerity.

In this way, even if there is any problem, it does not involve the issue of legal competition.

This is equivalent to pulling a big banner and throwing the pot everywhere, without bearing any responsibility.

Gee

The corners of Su Bai's mouth raised slightly, this security department has carried the boss with a pot!

But he studied penguins so deeply!

He knew that once his side sued, the other party would have 800 reasons for being suspected of monopoly and unfair competition, of which 699 would be blamed by the risk security department.

But the penguin thinks it's useful to find a backstabber?

Joke

Or the same sentence, I have studied you to death, what are you going to fight with me?!

The corners of Su Bai's mouth raised slightly, and he continued to ask:

"May I ask the defendant, the removal behavior involved in the risk control department.

In accordance with the regulations on the management of enterprise norms and cooperation, it should be publicized or notified in detail to our Nanyou studio. ”

"But our Nanyou studio did not receive a detailed notice, only a notice of removal from the shelves, without any reason, plus, the penguin and we have a sense of cooperation."

"But when we refused, we received a takedown notice from Penguin Holdings Limited.

And after the crazy elimination was taken off the shelves, Happy Elimination was put on the shelves immediately after, and it was plagiarized on the shelves. ”

"There is no detailed notice, the purpose of cooperation has not been achieved, and our products will be directly removed from the shelves during the cooperation period.

Based on the above conditions, may I ask the defendant, how did you determine that our company violated the rules and was removed from the shelves by risk control? ”

Faced with Chen Chao finding a temporary worker to take the blame, Su Bai directly asked a series of rhetorical questions and threw the questions back to him.

Prove yourself!

If you say you don't, then you show evidence that you don't have.

If you come up with evidence, there will be a loophole!

Then I'll look for it from your loophole!

If you do come up with evidence that there is a problem with crazy elimination

Then just wait to get in!

You must know that Su Bai has thoroughly studied the penguin risk control rules for a long time, and has long asked Lin Quan to find a professional organization to test the risk control problem of crazy elimination, and has been tested many times to ensure that there is absolutely no problem!

That's why he dared to say it so directly!

At the same time, he also knew that the penguin was originally a big family, and if he copied this and that, others couldn't do anything about him.

If you want to copy the games of some large manufacturers, you still have some scruples about lawsuits, which may involve some legal issues.

Copying the game of the small studio, it is not at all left with any emotion.

I'm used to being arrogant!

It's straightforward, what I say is what, take it to you!

Therefore, there will be many legal loopholes.

Faced with Su Bai's question, Chen Chao didn't know how to answer for a while.

Because he found that the other party seemed to be particularly familiar with the process of their lawsuit!

As a result, no matter which aspect he starts from, he is blocked to death!

Kong Hao, who was on the side, frowned slightly, and muttered in a low voice: "This lawsuit is smashed in the hands of the two of us."

Facing his colleagues, Kong Hao couldn't understand better, this lawsuit has gone on so far, it can be said that they have lost and lost the kind of body that is not complete, and there are no pants left.

Chen Chao took a deep breath, patted Kong Hao's shoulder slightly, said that there was still a chance, and continued to speak:

"Regarding the fact that our risk control did not give a detailed notice, I am not very clear about this aspect, and I can further understand it, but the plaintiff cannot sue us for unfair competition on the grounds that we did not show the detailed rules for the removal of risk control."

Tut.

The question is thrown back?

Yes!

Your mouth is so hard, I'm going to blow your head off now!

Su Bai took out a bunch of materials from the litigation materials and said:

"Presiding Judge, these materials are the latest risk control rules of Penguin, and the risk control appraisal report that we have done.

If the defendant does not agree, we have invited relevant professionals to test on the spot whether our original version of the crazy elimination and risk control problem meets the requirements of Penguin! ”

"The defendant can apply for an on-the-spot inspection!"

Chen Chao: "?!? ”

No, what are you doing?

Are you well prepared to hammer the penguin to death in the courtroom?

Chen Chao is 10,000 speechless

After taking a long breath, after receiving the relevant materials from the hands of the staff, he was directly silent.

According to the evidence of the other party, this preparation, even if the director of their legal department comes over, it is estimated that they will lose the case!

At this time, on the presiding judge seat on the trial platform, Cao Liqiang looked at the defendant's seat and asked:

"Whether the defendant applies or not, it will be tested on the spot."

Taking a deep breath, Chen Chao calmed down, and there was no need to test it on the spot.

He already saw it.

The other party had to hammer the penguin's head flat in the trial, and was fully prepared to accuse the penguin of unfair competition.

It is very likely that the on-site inspection will not deviate too much as described on the material.

Chen Chao shook his head slightly: "We do not apply for on-site inspection. ”

Knock knock!

Cao Liqiang rang the gavel: "Does the defendant have any objection to the evidence provided by the plaintiff?" ”

Chen Chao: "We have no objection. ”

Knock knock!

Cao Liqiang glanced down at the materials of the trial, and then looked at the plaintiff Xi Subai:

"Is there anything else the plaintiff has to add..?"

The trial is conclusive, and it makes no sense to add anything to the other party.

It might backfire.

Su Bai spoke: "Presiding Judge, we have nothing to add. ”

Knock knock!

Cao Liqiang nodded slightly, and after a few glances at the trial materials, he looked at the defendant again:

"Defendant, can you accurately explain why Nanyou Studio's crazy elimination mini-game was removed from the shelves?"

Chen Chao sighed for a long time, he had no mental strength, the other party's evidence was pressed, and it made no sense to say anything now.

And, this is a problem of vulnerabilities left over from the gaming department.

He couldn't answer either....

Chen Chao spoke:

"We can't say exactly why we removed Nanyu Studio's crazy match game."

Knock knock!

"May I ask the agent of Penguin Holdings Limited if he cannot give an effective answer to the plaintiff's questions?"

Chen Chao: "Yes." ”

"Okay."

After Cao Liqiang confirmed it, he briefly flipped through the trial materials to confirm that there were no other problems, followed the plaintiff's seat, turned to the defendant's seat, and then closed his gaze.

The gavel sounded.

Knock knock!

"Now let's start the court presentation stage, and ask the plaintiff to make a statement."

Please come to Cao Liqiang's voice, Su Bai exhaled!

So far, this lawsuit has been won!

The final stage of the court presentation is to pull the banner,

Isn't the little wings very fierce, this time give your little wings a discount!

"Okay presiding judge."

Su Bai nodded slightly, and then began to state:

"In this case, we state as follows:"

"According to Article 1 of the Anti-Unfair Competition Law, this Law is enacted for the purpose of promoting peaceful social and economic development, encouraging and protecting fair competition, stopping acts of unfair competition, and protecting the legitimate rights and interests of business operators and consumers."

"Monopolies against certain large corporations."

"The products produced by small studios have been severely squeezed, which has completely violated the principles of legislation."

"Therefore, we believe that for the monopoly of some large enterprises, relying on their own huge foundation, we will seriously punish the oppressive behavior of some small and medium-sized enterprises."

"Presiding Judge, we've finished our statement."

Cao Liqiang looked at Su Bai with a slight smile, nodded subconsciously, and then turned his gaze to the defendant's seat:

"The plaintiff has finished his presentation, and it is now up to the defendant to make the statement."

Penguin Legal has a certain understanding of the presiding judges and senior management of the Nanshan Court.

Therefore, Chen Chao also has an understanding of Cao Liqiang's character.

The trial has already reached the stage of court statements, and Judge Cao estimates that he has already had the verdict in his heart.

The court statement did not have a very great impact on the presiding judge.

Therefore, if you say too much, you will lose, and no matter how far you say, there is no evidence to have a good effect, so Chen Chao simply gave up the statement.

"Presiding Judge, we give up our statement."

Knock knock!

"Is the defense sure to waive the statement?"

"Sure."

"Hmm!" Cao Liqiang nodded slightly, and after confirming that the defendant gave up his statement, he rang the gavel again!

Boom!

"Do the parties to the trial still have any objections to the evidence or legal justifications presented by the other party?"

Su Bai: "No objection. ”

Chen Chao: "No objection. ”

Boom!

"Since both sides have no objection, we are now entering the adjournment stage, and the adjournment time will be one hour, and the court will be announced in one hour!"

Boom!

"Adjournment!"

The words fell, and the two judges, Cao Liqiang, Jiang Hongyan and He Yongan, left the scene.

.

….

In the courtroom, the defendant is in the seat.

Kong Hao's brows furrowed tightly: "This time the court is adjourned. At the end of the adjournment, there is a high probability that the verdict will be announced. ”

"This case...."

"How likely do you think you are to win the case?"

Facing Kong Hao's inquiry, Chen Chao frowned: "What are the odds?" ”

"If the game has been judged to be plagiarized, the lawsuit has been lost, and the lawsuit has not been won, but on the aspect of unfair competition, it may be given a lenient sentence."

"Wait for the verdict."

"The verdict in this case has not yet come out, so it is useless to say more."

Chen Chao took a deep breath and said, he was making trouble now, and he didn't want to continue talking about this topic.

Seeing this, Kong Hao nodded seriously and did not continue.

And at the same time.

In the plaintiff's seat, it seemed much more relaxed and cheerful.

Su Bai unscrewed the mineral water from the table, took a sip, felt the nourishment of the water, and exhaled a long breath.

I pleaded just now, and I talked so much that my mouth was dry.

Li Xuezhen on the side chuckled, and her little face was full of excitement: "Lawyer Su! ”

"This time, let's not even discount the wings of the little penguin...."

The corners of Su Bai's mouth narrowed slightly, and he discounted the little penguin's wings, which was too underestimating him!

For now!

It's not a matter of wings anymore, the key question is. He's already cracked the little penguin's brain.

The myth of Nanshan's invincibility has been shattered!

"Ahem."

Su Bai coughed twice: "Of course!" ”

Li Xuezhen smiled very sweetly, and her eyes narrowed into crescent moons: "Check in, the first civil case was successful!" ”

Oh no.

The verdict has not yet been pronounced!

Forget it, no matter what, anyway, it's impossible to lose!

Punch in successfully, Meizizi....

.

….…

Meanwhile.

The case is being discussed by three members of the collegial panel.

Cao Liqiang said slowly: "I was quite surprised by today's trial plea. ”

"I didn't expect Penguin's legal counsel to fall into the case in the defense of the infringement case, and it seems that the original party is very well prepared."

"It's certain that the penguins will lose the lawsuit, but I haven't decided on the scope of the penguins' punishment yet, so we can talk about it."

….

Jiang Hongyan nodded slightly, agreeing with Cao Liqiang's point of view.

"There is really no problem with the penguin's defeat, and according to the plaintiff's statement, the penguin is indeed suspected of unfair competition."

"There is even monopolistic behavior, which can be severely punished."

"What about you, Yong'an, what do you think?" Cao Liqiang saw He Yongan standing aside, didn't speak, and took the initiative to ask.

He Yongan was silent for a few seconds, and then slowly spoke: "I agree with Hongyan's point of view. ”

Cao Liqiang nodded slightly, and said with a smile: "It seems that when you were the chief judge of the High Court, you all had some resentment towards penguins...."

"Hmm!"

"The verdict on the penguins, so let's do it! However, in terms of the amount of compensation, according to the normal compensation standard, the court has already made a form, so let's follow that! ”

"Hmm!"

"Okay!"

Jiang Hongyan and He Yongan agreed.

.

….

Soon, an hour passed.

In the standing of all the clerks, Cao Liqiang, Jiang Hongyan and He Yongan, three members of the collegial panel, entered the venue again.

Knock knock!

Cao Liqiang rang the gavel, and his voice was serious:

"Court opens!"

"The trial continues for the case of Yu Nanyou Studio's accusation against Penguin Holdings Limited for plagiarism and improper competition!"

Knock knock!

The gavel falls.

"Whether the original defendant and the defendant still have any objections to the pre-adjournment stage."

"It can be raised in court."

Su Bai: "No objection. ”

Chen Chao: "No objection. ”

Knock knock!

"Since both sides have no objection to this, we are now ready to pronounce the verdict!"

Clerk: "All stand up, and now I ask the presiding judge to announce the verdict!" ”

Boom.

All stand up.

In the defendant's seat, Chen Chao and Kong Hao both looked a little nervous.

Although they already expected the verdict.

But after all, this lawsuit is about whether it will break the record of almost 100% victory of penguins in Nanshan!

So before the verdict, they still had a glimmer of expectation!

The eyes of the two men fell on the presiding judge.

Just listen.

Presiding Judge Cao Liqiang slowly opened his mouth and announced the verdict:

"The cause of this case: The plaintiff sued the defendant for plagiarizing the game produced by the plaintiff and accused it of unfair competition, and the case was heard by the Nanshan High Court of this court."

"This court has jurisdiction over this case, and the law applicable in this case is entirely based on domestic law."

"The verdict is announced now!"

"According to the research decision of the members of the collegial panel, the lawsuit application filed against the plaintiff."

"One: It was decided that the happy elimination produced by the defendant company plagiarized the game works of Nanyou Studio, and it was crazy to eliminate it. For the huge losses caused to Nanyou Studio, the defendant compensated Nanyou Studio, economic losses, 8,685,465 yuan and nine cents. ”

"And, remove the plagiarized game works from the shelves, and have a good time!"

When the first point was announced, Chen Chao and Kong Hao in the defendant's seat did not have much emotional reaction.

Because about plagiarism, it has been judged before!

The key issue they care about is the determination of unfair competition!

Just listen.

Presiding Judge Cao Liqiang continued to speak: "Two: Judgment, the defendant is suspected of unfair competition!" ”

"The defendant cannot provide accurate evidence and complete factual basis for the removal of the plaintiff's mini game, and what kind of risks the plaintiff's mini game has, the defendant's platform is not clear, and it needs to bear certain responsibilities,"

"Request, the defendant's platform, re-launch the mini-game of Nanyou Studio, and eliminate it wildly."

"At the same time!"

"A public apology for its actions and unfair competition!"

"Three: This case is caused by the defendant's plagiarism, and the plaintiff's litigation costs are borne by the defendant, but the lawyer's fees are not borne by the defendant."

"Four: All the litigation applications filed by the defendant are rejected!"

"According to the provisions of China's Civil Procedure Law, if the defendant believes that the judgment and award are erroneous or has other doubts, it may initiate a supervisory review or initiate a retrial procedure."

"At the end of the verdict, the verdict will be sent to both the original defendant and the defendant within ten days!"

Knock knock!!

"Closed!!"

Cao Liqiang's serious voice fell, and in the defendant's seat, Chen Chao and Kong Hao were both stunned.

They know that there is a possibility of adjudicating unfair competition, but.... I didn't expect that the sentence would be so heavy!

Hiss~

Now, my head is blown up!

How did the two of them get back to the legal affairs?

PS: Ask for a monthly pass~

Whew, catch up on sleep.

Make up for sleep, wake up and continue.

(End of chapter)