First instance judgment.

Not only did Guo Xiaojun's appeal request be dismissed!

He was also convicted of extortion and sentenced to five years in prison!

As a result, he lost his job, his daughter's health, and. I also suffered this great grievance.

In the final analysis, the verdict of the first instance has only three words for him: injustice!

Faced with the verdict of Xu Chunxing, the presiding judge of the second instance, Guo Xiaojun's heart was full of excitement at this time.

Of course, he not only wants to thank the presiding judge, but also Subai!

After all

If it weren't for Su Bai's trial, defending him, it would have been another lawyer. It doesn't have to be that way.

Guo Xiaojun set his eyes on Su Bai, his eyes were full of gratitude, and Su Bai smiled slightly and nodded.

At present, it is only a dozen and three, and the prosecution has been beaten.

But

And that's just the most basic of this lawsuit!

Win the case.

Then you have to do your best, there are still two left to fight!

The other two are the point!

At this time, Wang Manting, an old lawyer, felt a little uncomfortable in his heart when he heard the presiding judge's temporary verdict, and sighed.

All right

The bonus that Dong Cheng promised him is gone.

Still, there is hope.

It's just that.... The trainee solicitor across the street kept an eye on him.

He always felt a little weird, uncomfortable, unnatural.

Never mind.... It should be a mentality, some small litigants, they like to engage in such a mentality.

Wang Manting didn't pay too much attention to it in his heart, sorted out his emotions a little, and prepared to continue the trial.

Outside the courtroom.

The audience of sailors in the live broadcast room of Luo Daxiang's trial were equally excited when they heard this temporary verdict!

"! This is the presiding judge! How did the presiding judge of the first instance decide! Really speechless to death. It's good that justice is not late! ”

“？！！？”

"Justice is not late? What are you talking about, Guo Xiaojun's daughter has a big health problem, plus they have been in for a while, and they were sentenced to five years in prison before, and they lost their job with an annual salary of one million! What does it mean that justice is not late? ”

"Justice if not late!"

"Then you should kill that Aibao milk powder in the first trial!"

"!!"

“.”

"Well, just like this lawyer Su said before, late justice is not justice! I think this Aibao milk powder needs to compensate Guo Xiaojun for all losses! “

"That's right! In the tank!! And I think that the judge of the first instance should be sent in! What a! Not professional at all! ”

"! This relationship is good! TM's, go in, go in, send it all in! ”

“.”

Seeing that the wind direction in the comment area was getting more and more crooked, Luo Daxiang explained with a smile, and pulled the wind direction back in the comment area:

"About this. What is said later in the comment area is a bit too extreme, and the verdict of the first instance is indeed not too reasonable, but it has not yet reached the level of sending the judges in."

"Please stay sane"

Fan commented: "We also know it's not too possible, but it's just to vent the resentment in our hearts."

After all, if it is like the judge of the first instance who sentenced like this, then some innocent people are so resentful! We're just complaining. ”

Luo Daxiang nodded with a smile, and then spoke: "It's indeed okay for everyone to complain." ”

"However, this verdict has been made clear enough in the trial, and I will add why the presiding judge made such a decision."

"The most critical reason why the presiding judge of the second instance ruled that Guo Xiaojun was not guilty was that there was no strong evidence to prove that Guo Xiaojun was suspected of extortion."

"The difference between the second-instance judgment and the first-instance judgment is the issue of evidence, and the conditions on which the first-instance judgment is based are: Guo Xiaojun's subjective intention to seek compensation, and his wife Ma Li's written accusation."

"The judgment of the second instance rejected the judgment of the first instance, that is, these pieces of evidence cannot be used as direct evidence of Guo Xiaojun's extortion."

"At the same time."

"This judgment also laid a certain foundation for a series of subsequent lawsuits, that is, Guo Xiaojun's accusation against his wife Ma Li and the accusation against Aibao milk powder."

Comment area: "It's annoying to be watched by the people in the litigation seat, especially Guo Xiaojun's wife, all sent in!" ”

Looking at the comments in the comment area, Luo Daxiang opened his mouth and smiled:

"Can you send it in. This mainly depends on the trial results of the trial, okay, the trial verdict of the prosecution against the prosecution has been explained, let's continue to read. ”

Meanwhile.

In the office of the general manager of Aibao milk powder.

Dong Cheng looked at the presiding judge's verdict on Guo Xiaojun in the courtroom, squinted slightly, and did not speak.

But the heart is breathing fire!

Guo Xiaojun was found not guilty, so his hard work in the early stage was all in vain!

moreover

The follow-up targeting of his company will also have a certain impact

The impact is huge!

Guo Xiaojun was found not guilty, and the facts have already happened, but

There must be no more accidents and moths in the future!

Dong Cheng thought silently in his heart.

On the court court.

Su Bai set his eyes on Ma Li and Wang Manting's litigation seat.

One dozen three.

At present, the prosecution has finished fighting, and all that remains is to accuse Ma Li of perjury and compensation for Aibao milk powder.

There is the issue of compensation for Aibao milk powder, which is not difficult, after all, the fact has happened, and Aibao milk powder does have the issue of liability for compensation.

The evidence is there.

The other side has no room for excuse at all, unless it is nonsense

But nonsense

Gee

That's interesting.

Difficulties in making claims.

It is nothing more than a question of how much or less compensation is claimed, if you can fight for it, try your best to fight for it, and winning the lawsuit is definitely a certainty!

The key point is that.

Ma Li's perjury verdict.

This is the main point of contention in the next trial.

Of course, whether Ma Li can be convicted of perjury.

It still depends on the presiding judge's interpretation of the legal provisions and his own accusations.

After noticing Su Bai's gaze, Ma Li whispered:

"Lawyer Wang's lawyer is so good, we won't lose the lawsuit."

"I don't want to go in"

Wang Manting smiled and said:

"Don't worry, your accusations are not perjury, how can you get in?"

"I've already learned about this case, so there shouldn't be any problems."

Should

Hearing these two words, Ma Li felt a little uneasy in her heart.

"Let's hope"

The trial continues.

On the trial platform, on the presiding judge's seat, Xu Chunxing nodded slightly after hearing Guo Xiaojun's thanks after the verdict: "The trial continues!" ”

"This court summarizes the three controversial points of this trial."

"First, as to whether Guo Xiaojun is extortion, this court has already stated and judged him, so I will not make too many statements here."

"If the parties disagree with it in the future, they can raise it during the course of the trial. However, there must be relevant factual evidence and legal basis! ”

"The second point is about Guo Xiaojun's alleged false accusation against his wife Ma Li."

"The third is about Guo Xiaojun's claim against Aibao milk powder."

After summarizing the general questions, the presiding judge, Xu Chunxing, raised his head slightly and looked at the seat of the litigant:

"Litigation party, do you have any objections to the summary issues sorted out by this court?"

"Presiding Judge, we have no objection."

Su Bai spoke.

Xu Chunxing summed it up very well, and there was no big problem.

"Good!"

Knock knock!

Xu Chunxing rang the gavel: "Since the litigation party has no objection." ”

"Litigation party, this court needs to confirm, what is the amount of compensation you apply for Aibao milk powder?"

In response to the presiding judge's question, Su Bai had already prepared the relevant compensation materials, and said directly:

"Presiding Judge, we lost our job due to the innocent accusation of Aibao milk powder, which caused us to suffer great financial and mental damages, plus our client's purchase of milk powder caused his daughter's medical compensation costs.

According to the relevant laws and regulations, the amount of compensation we apply for Aibao milk powder is 1,785,696 yuan and five cents. ”

Fang Xuan, legal lawyer of Aibao milk powder:.

If the amount of compensation is zero or whole, why don't you divide it all?

Knock knock!

Xu Chunxing rang the gavel again: "This court has learned about the litigation party's application for compensation costs, is there anything that the respondent Aibao milk powder has not said?" ”

Fang Xuan is a corporate legal lawyer who has practiced for many years, specializing in economic compensation, and Fang Xuan immediately raised objections to Su Bai's request.

"Presiding Judge"

"We have objections."

Knock knock!

"What's the difference between the objections? Please state the subject of the lawsuit. ”

"Okay presiding judge."

Fang Xuan sorted out the materials in front of him a little, and then spoke:

"For the claim for compensation filed by the litigant against our company."

"As for the litigation party, the other party was sued by us, so it led to the loss of work, mental and financial losses, so we made a claim for compensation."

"We dispute this."

"First: The accusation we filed is aimed at our legitimate rights and interests, and it is not specifically aimed at Guo Xiaojun."

"Second: We are only filing a case, and the investigation of the case and the judgment of the case are not our rights and interests, so it is obviously unreasonable to ask us to compensate for the request made by the litigation party."

"Because the other party was sentenced, lost his job, and suffered mental losses, which has nothing to do with our Aibao company, we are only legal, and we protect our legitimate rights and interests through legal channels."

"We propose to dismiss the claim that we should be liable for the moral and economic losses suffered by the litigant."

Knock knock!

Xu Chunxing frowned slightly, then looked at the litigation materials in front of him and sounded the gavel.

"Litigants...."

"Do you have anything to say about Aibao milk powder, the respondent?"

"Can you prove that the mental damage caused by the accusation or the loss of your job is directly related to Aibao milk powder?"

Facing the presiding judge's question, Su Bai tidied up his suit slightly.

Fang Xuan's statement does have a certain legal basis.

Roughly speaking, it is.

Aibao milk powder is protecting its own rights and interests.

There was no intention to deliberately cause Guo Xiaojun to lose his job.

You have lost your job and suffered mental damage that has nothing to do with our business.

It should not be claimed like our business.

What Su Bai needs to prove is that there is a certain direct causal relationship between the two.

To put it bluntly, it is necessary for Su Bai to prove that Aibao milk powder maliciously accused Guo Xiaojun of extortion.

For this

The corners of Su Bai's mouth raised slightly

Since he proposed it, there is a compensation of zero and a whole amount, it has been strictly calculated!

After taking out a piece of material from the litigation materials, Su Bai slowly spoke:

"Presiding Judge"

"In the first instance, one of the conditions of the judgment determined that our extortion was a request for compensation."

"According to our party's statement, our claim for compensation was made because it was affected by the company's notification that we could negotiate the amount of compensation."

"And Aibao milk powder, when it clearly informed us that we could negotiate the amount of compensation, it took us to court for extortion."

"We can subjectively conclude that this is a malicious accusation of Aibao milk powder."

"I would like to ask the opposing lawyer, when we originally claimed 700,000 yuan, why did Aibao milk powder inform us that we can negotiate the amount of compensation?"

"When we filed a claim for 5 million, we were sued in court for extortion?"

"Isn't that malice? From the judgment conditions, it can be seen that the malicious guidance of Aibao milk powder has a certain effect on the judgment. ”

"So."

"That's what we decide."

"Aibao milk powder has a certain influence and relevance on our first-instance judgment."

"Presiding Judge, we've finished our statement."

Su Bai ended his statement.

On the presiding judge's seat on the trial platform, Xu Chunxing looked at the litigation materials, his eyes swept over Su Bai on the litigant's seat, and then looked towards Fang Xuan, who was in the litigant's seat.

"Regarding the statement of the litigant, the lawyer representing the litigated party, Aibao milk powder, is there anything else to make a statement?"

Facing the presiding judge's question, Fang Xuan rubbed his eyebrows.

on the subject

He is really not easy to answer, according to his defense line just now, Guo Xiaojun was punished by the first-instance judgment and lost his job.

suffered a certain amount of mental loss, but this has nothing to do with Aibao milk powder company.

But

Immediately afterwards, Su Bai brought up the correlation again.

And put forward the topic of malicious accusations by Aibao milk powder companies.

If the defense continues on this topic

When the time comes.

It is estimated that Aibao milk powder companies are much larger than they are now

moreover

Fang Xuan understood that the legal direction he was targeting was the issue of corporate debt and economic disputes

For criminal law, it cannot be said that it is ignorant, it can only be said that it is not proficient.

He always felt that if he continued to defend this topic, he would continue to fall into the pit.

Simply.

Directly stated: "Presiding judge, our side has finished speaking. ”

Knock knock!

Xu Chunxing sounded the gavel: "The litigant and the subject of the lawsuit have defended whether Guo Xiaojun's mental loss and job loss are related to Aibao milk powder company. ”

"Based on the evidence submitted by the law enforcement party and the statements of Guo Xiaojun's client."

"Aibao milk powder company, for Guo Xiaojun, the party is indeed ready to negotiate to increase the amount of compensation."

"Do you have any objections to this matter?"

What objection can he have to the evidence submitted by the law enforcement side?

Can he overthrow it?

Fang Xuan spoke: "Presiding Judge, we have no objections. ”

"Hmm!"

Knock knock!

"The party to the lawsuit has no objection to Aibao Milk Powder's previous negotiation to increase the amount of compensation."

"Now the court has ruled that there are certain factors in raising the compensation amount of Aibao milk powder through negotiation, which indirectly led to Guo Xiaojun's increase in the compensation amount from 700,000 yuan to 5 million yuan."

"Is there any objection to the Aibao milk powder enterprise room?"

"Presiding Judge, we have no objection."

Knock knock!

"Does the litigant dispute this decision?"

Su Bai: "We have no objection!" ”

After the words fell, Su Bai locked his eyes on Ma Li's litigation seat.

This judgment has been determined, and the reasonableness of the lawsuit application he just filed to demand more than 1 million compensation from Aibao milk powder company!

Just wait for the final verdict!

One dozen three!

So far, two have been overturned!

Only the last one remains!

The last one.

Su Bai slightly showed a small white tooth.

Ma Li also noticed Su Bai's gaze and the little white tooth at this time.

It was inevitable that there would be a trace of panic in my heart

PS: Ask for a monthly pass~

End the case in the evening~

Ask for a monthly pass~

(End of chapter)