The scene of the trial.

The prosecution and the defence are in two completely different states.

On the bench.

Facing Wan Yuping's questioning, Yu Caixia frowned slightly, but didn't say anything.

As the vice president of the Southern High Court.

and majored in criminal law, sentenced to death row.

After the death penalty was imposed in court, various situations were encountered.

But today, after Wan Yuping announced the closure of the courtroom, she questioned loudly and directly said that such a sentence was a direct murder and sued them.

Such an extreme situation is quite rare.

Yu Caixia looked at the defendant's family seat:

"The court is based on evidence and legal provisions, and if you are not satisfied with the verdict of the retrial, then you can apply to the Supreme People's Procuratorate to revoke the verdict."

"But only if there is evidence that can overturn the verdict."

"For the adjudicators of the verdict, if you think there is any problem, you can also initiate a review and supervision procedure."

Yu Caixia finished speaking.

The bailiff had already taken control of the scene.

Prevent the unexpected.

Wan Yuping was comforted by Qin Anhai, and her emotions had calmed down at this time.

But before she could say anything, Yu Caixia and the other two judges had already left the trial scene.

Wan Yuping looked at Qin Anhai nervously.

Qin Anhai glanced at Qin Xiaofeng in the defendant's seat.

At this time, Qin Xiaofeng was occupied by fear and looked at Qin Anhai, but before he could say anything, he was controlled by the bailiff on the side and was not allowed to speak.

Qin Xiaofeng's eyes were complicated, and he followed the bailiff out of the trial scene.

Counsel for the defense is in the seating.

When Jiang Min heard the verdict, he glanced up at Su Bai again and let out a long sigh.

Now it's all right

Ye Fei was sent in, Zhang Xiao's client went in, and his own client went down.

He could see it.

They Nanyuan Law Firm and Su Bai are on the bar, and every time they have a lawsuit, they are randomly sent in

Rubbing his eyebrows.

If it goes on like this, then the lawyers and clients of their Nanyuan Law Firm will not be able to run out? !

But this time the trial.

Jiang Min looked at Qin Anhai and Wan Yuping in the family seats.

This trial is the biggest problem for Qin Anhai and Wan Yuping.

First of all.

Judging from the fact that he has been practicing lawyer for so many years, the Supreme People's Court rejected the second-instance judgment and held a retrial.

The judges previously arranged by the Nandu High Court were not allowed to try the case on the basis of the principle of recusal.

Vice President Yu Caixia conducted the trial, and there were no problems in the entire trial, and the evidence was sufficient.

It is unlikely that they will appeal to the Supreme Court for a retrial and change of judgment.

I can't say it's not big, I can only say that it's not.

There is no chance at all.

The death penalty has been set, and there will be no more chances.

Moreover.

This is not the most critical point, the most critical thing is the case and the problems encountered in the whole trial.

Question, avoid!

There is also a problem with the determination of the circumstances of voluntary surrenderAlthough the definition of resistance is vague, slight resistance generally does not affect the determination of voluntary surrender too much, and it is a normal situation, and the law enforcement party should express it in detail in the circumstances of voluntary surrender.

It was then determined that he had surrendered voluntarily.

However, in the evidence provided by the law enforcement side, there was no indication that Qin Xiaofeng had a plot of resistance

On this basis, the court found that the evidence provided by the law enforcement party was insufficient and the judgment was reasonable.

As for Qin Xiaofeng's resistance, Jiang Min didn't know too much about it.

But as an experienced criminal lawyer, I obviously understand the connection.

This matter is estimated to be inseparable from Qin Anhai and Wan Yuping.

Call.

After sorting out all the relationships, Jiang Min packed up the materials for the trial and glanced at Qin Anhai in the family seat.

Based on statements from previous trials.

Jiang Min does not think that Su Bai will initiate a supervision and review procedure for this trial.

If I make a lift

Then the result can be imagined.

Meantime.

Su Bai also looked at the family seat, and silently recited: The rest should be submitted for review procedures.

this case.

There are many doubts.

It is estimated that there are a lot of things hidden, but after having pointing evidence and proof, it is completely possible to initiate review and supervision.

When the time comes.

Tsk tsk.

Li Xuezhen's little face was full of smiles, and she won the lawsuit again!

Su Bai smiled: "Okay, the trial is over, let's go back." ”

"Okay lawyer Su!"

Li Xuezhen smiled with a small face, and followed Su Bai with a dada.

At the same time, the trial was on the sidelines.

In the face of the death penalty, the audience outside the live broadcast was relieved, but there were still many questions.

Now the verdict is down.

The audience only went back and cleaned up the situation.

First: Why didn't the judge who started the trial recuse himself, and is there something in it?

Second: Some netizens told that about the law enforcement side, the details of the arrest and the decision to surrender must be written into the materials, but why did Qin Xiaofeng not include the judgment of voluntary surrender in this case?

Why didn't Qin Xiaofeng's psychology of resisting law enforcement and intentionally escaping be written?

Does Qin Xiaofeng surrender voluntarily?

The first point is the questioning of the adjudicating party.

The second point is the confusion about the law enforcement side.

The above two points are also the unreasonable findings of many netizens for the first-instance and second-instance judgments.

"Why this is happening, we need to understand the actual situation!"

"That's right, we must understand the actual situation, why the above two situations occur, is it the negligence of the adjudicators or other problems, we would like to ask the relevant departments to give us a satisfactory answer!"

After the end of the trial.

The popularity of Qin Xiaofeng's case has not only not decreased, but has also increased a lot.

What more people want to know is whether there are any problems with the relevant adjudicators and other parties.

Meantime.

After the conclusion of the trial, Su Bai also initiated the procedure of supervision and review, and found that there were many doubts in the first and second trials of this case, and that the prosecution and the members of the collegial panel did not understand the facts clearly in the original first and second trials, and made a judgment.

The law enforcement party provided evidence materials for violations.

Request the relevant departments to initiate a review procedure for this case.

Due to the high heat of this case, and there are doubts.

The request for review was quickly accepted by the relevant authorities.

And at the same time.

The Qin family's home.

Wan Yuping's face was anxious: "The surname is Qin, what do you think, is there a way!" ”

"Now the High Court is submitting some application for the death penalty, if you don't hurry up, then Xiaofeng will be gone!"

"You have to think of a way!"

"That woman is gone, why should she take our son's life!"

"You're in a hurry! Think of a way to find your old classmates and friends! ”

Qin Anhai frowned slightly: "I must be more anxious than you when something happens to Xiaofeng, but what I am anxious about now is not this matter, what I am anxious about is whether we made a mistake in the procedure at the beginning, and whether it will be reviewed." ”

"I've found everything I can! It didn't work! ”

"Don't you see the heat of netizens' questions about this case on the hot search now!"

"And!"

"Don't you still blame you for this!"

"If you hadn't asked me to find someone in the first place, we would have let people hold it at trial! If you can't hold it, it is impossible for Xiaofeng to be sentenced to death! ”

"It's all stupid for you to do!"

"What stupid thing I did?? Now you're blaming me again.? No, Qin Anhai, Xiaofeng is my son, not your son, is it?! “

"Tell me!"

"Let's just this one son, why can't you get into it!"

Qin Anhai: "That's the death penalty!" Not a reprieve! It needs the approval of the Supreme People's Court! You let me think of a way to do it now, don't worry! ”

"Okay, okay, you want to think."

Wan Yuping knew that it was useless to be in a hurry now, so she simply didn't mention it.

Qin Anhai exhaled, smoked a cigarette, squinted his eyes slightly, and didn't know what to do for a while.

It's not just Qin Xiaofeng who has a problem now.

And their problems ....

On the investigation of the case.

The personnel of the relevant departments quickly found out the problem, not only found out that there were certain problems with the certification of the circumstances of the voluntary surrender.

The review of the second instance was also found.

He Hui and Qin Anhai had close contacts.

Nandu High Court.

He Hui was sitting in the office, picking up the hot search on his mobile phone, feeling uneasy.

Several law enforcement officers pushed the door open and walked in.

After He Hui looked at the surveillance clothes of the law enforcement officers, he was stunned for a few seconds, and then spoke: "Excuse me.. Is there anything you guys are up to? ”

The law enforcement officer's voice was serious:

"After our investigation, during the second-instance judgment, you violated the rule that relevant adjudicators are not allowed to contact the litigants, and we would like to ask you to come with us to learn about the relevant situation."

After the law enforcement officer has produced the relevant law enforcement documents.

He Hui paused slightly.

"Good"

"However, when I made the judgment, it was all in accordance with the laws and regulations, and there was no illegal act, have you investigated this clearly?"

Faced with this situation.

Law enforcement officers have seen a lot.

What does it mean to come in accordance with laws and regulations?

Some of the interpretation of the law is originally tendentious, and since there is a close relationship with the family members of the parties, it is certainly not wrong.

The law enforcement officer's voice was cold: "We have investigated clearly, and we ask you to cooperate with our work." ”

Hearing this tone, He Hui sighed in his heart and nodded with a sad face.

"Okay, I'll cooperate."

.

….…

Meanwhile.

Two other judges in the second instance.

Former presiding judges, Zhou Qiangsheng and Zhang Guangquan, were also investigated.

After learning about it, Zhou Qiang was so angry that he was about to scold his mother!

What do you mean?

This He Hui, no wonder he has been helping Qin Xiaofeng to exonerate himself in the original second-instance trial.

It turned out that there was a connection between them!

Now it's okay, pit him too....

However, Zhou Qiangsheng is also very glad that if he hadn't directly adjourned the court in the retrial and applied for recusal....

Then he should be greeted with a heavier punishment.

Thinking of this, Zhou Qiangsheng exhaled a long breath, faced the law enforcement officers, and nodded easily.

"Okay.... I am open to any scrutiny. ”

.

….

Equally.

The Qin family.

When Wan Yuping was worried about how to exonerate her son.

Relevant law enforcement officers came to the door.

"Hello, is this Wan Yuping and Qin Anhai's home?"

Wan Yuping saw that law enforcement officers came to investigate, and her heart chuckled.

But he still pretended to be calm and said: "Yes, this is our home, and I am Wan Yuping." ”

"Hello, after our investigation, we know that Qin Anhai is suspected of obstructing the judicial process, we would like to ask where Qin Anhai is now?"

Qin Anhai.... Suspected of obstructing the judicial process....

This....

Wan Yuping was a little nervous, and asked, "How do you think that Qin Anhai is suspected of obstructing the judicial process?" ”

"We have the right to refuse to answer this question, we just want to learn about Qin Anhai's current situation from you, and we ask you to cooperate with our work."

Wan Yuping was a little flustered, and before she could speak, Qin Anhai walked out of the house.

"Hello, I am Qin Anhai, and I am willing to cooperate with your investigation."

"Okay, then please come with us."

With that, the relevant law enforcement officers left the Qin family with Qin Anhai.

After Qin Anhai was taken away, Wan Yuping's whole person looked extremely nervous.

What to do....?

Nothing could go wrong....?

What if something goes wrong....

Meanwhile.

In Bai Jun Law Firm, Su Bai was leisurely drinking tea.

Reviewing and supervising is now going through the process....

I don't know where we are at this point.

I'm looking forward to it....