Chapter 327 verdict result, the original victim was transferred to the case for review

With the guidance of the Supreme People's Procuratorate, Fang Rufeng's case is basically equivalent to a verdict of not guilty.

on this.

After Su Bai asked Li Xuezhen to re-sign the entrustment contract, he waited for another trial.

This time the trial....

Basically, there will be no other problems!

…

However, for the guidance of the Supreme People's Procuratorate in this case, Lin Fengru, who is the presiding judge of this case, and other members of the collegial panel.

and prosecutor Wu Chunmei, who has been paying attention to this case, and Xu Xia, Xie Tingting's entrusted lawyer.

I also saw the details of the Supreme People's Procuratorate's guidance on this case.

Especially Xu Xia, after learning about the Supreme People's Procuratorate's guidance on first-instance cases.

hurriedly called Wu Chunmei, who was the prosecutor, and after connecting, she couldn't wait to speak:

"Prosecutor Wu...."

"Is there any new evidence from the law enforcement side and the procuratorate in the case of Fang Rufeng?"

Wu Chunmei spoke: "There is no new evidence in this case. ”

"We previously found this case guilty, and there may have been a certain deviation in the understanding of the law, but now the Supreme People's Procuratorate has given corresponding guidance."

"A verdict of not guilty should be given."

"But..."Xu Xia hesitated for a few seconds:

"As you know, the Supreme People's Procuratorate may not know much about this case, and there is a certain deviation between the reality and the legal interpretation."

"So can Wu Inspector .... See what new evidence is there not? ”

Facing Xu Xia's opening, Wu Chunmei was silent for nearly a minute, and then spoke flatly:

"Look again, the prosecution is just presenting the prosecution and the evidence.

I'll see if there is any new additional evidence.

However, the specific trial still needs to depend on the views of the presiding judge and the collegial panel.

You prepare yourself mentally in advance. ”

"No, Prosecutor Wu, shouldn't we stand in the perspective of being a woman in Xie Tingting's case?"

"How can you be mentally prepared?"

"Prosecutor Wu...."

Xu Xia's voice was a little anxious, but she hadn't finished speaking.

I only heard a snap, and the phone was hung up.

Looking at the phone that was hung up, Xu Xia was even more anxious, but there was no other way....

"Hey—"

Xu Xia sighed helplessly, but thought about it again.

Silent recitation: "As long as it does not affect the subsequent divorce lawsuit, it will be okay whether you are convicted or not..."

After sorting out this idea, the sadness on Xu Xia's face dissipated a little.

…

Meanwhile.

On the court side, Lin Fengru learned about the first-instance case and received a reply from the Supreme People's Procuratorate.

And after watching the comments of the relevant short videos and the influence of public opinion.

The relevant matters of the case were discussed again with two other judges before the trial.

This time, Lin Fengru expressed a different point of view than the last time.

"The Supreme People's Procuratorate has given guidance.... The public opinion of this case is very high. ”

"I'd like to talk to you a little bit more about the decision."

The female judge frowned: "This case has the guidance of the Supreme People's Procuratorate, and it is almost impossible to make a judgment according to the legal situation." ”

"It's just a pity...."

"From Xie Tingting's point of view, Fang Rufeng does have the possibility of committing a crime."

"If it weren't for the guidance of the Supreme People's Procuratorate, it would have been sentenced, but now.... Obviously not easy to judge. ”

"Judge Lin.... Can this case be rethought from other angles? ”

On the side, the male judge, who had been silent many times, couldn't listen anymore.

After accumulating resentment for so long, he finally found an opportunity to open his mouth and explode.

"Are you still from Xie Tingting's point of view?!"

"Think, think about what?"

"Now that the Supreme People's Procuratorate has given guidance, can't you not stand in Xie Tingting's perspective?"

"I still want to think from other angles, are you just waiting for the Supreme People's Procuratorate to take the guidance and slap it on your face and say that Fang Rufeng is not guilty, right?"

"Earlier, you said that Xie Tingting was a victim, but I didn't say anything, but is it still now?"

"All day long here relying on his own subjectivity to influence the judgment of the law.... Can you stop having bad ideas? ”

"I...."The female judge's face turned red with anger, and she was about to say something but was beaten again.

"What am I?"

"I will inform the court and the adjudication committee that you can make suggestions on the collegiate council according to your own feelings!"

"In this trial, there is no need for collegiate deliberation at all, Fang Rufeng is not guilty, and there is no need to discuss, what do you say, Chief Lin?"

After several previous silences, the male judge finally broke out this time.

If the female judge just now is allowed to stand from the perspective of so-and-so, it will affect the outcome of the verdict.

Then all three of them will be punished!

The Supreme People's Procuratorate has already issued guidance for first-instance cases, so why are you waiting for the second-instance case to be overturned?

If he doesn't open his mouth now, when something really happens, then he will inevitably be punished as a member of the collegial panel.

In the trial, according to one's own subjective tendencies, that is not responsible for anyone!

I held my breath several times before, but now it has erupted at one time, one word, cool!

On the side, facing the inquiry about herself, Lin Fengru fell into silence.

After a while, he spoke: "Well, let's wait for the trial." ”

…

Soon after, the trial was held again.

This trial was different from the previous one.

This time, Su Bai reviewed a statement to the Supreme People's Court and participated in the trial after having clear guidance.

Even if the presiding judge and the collegial panel disagree, the verdict is not guilty.

However, he can continue to ask the court for an explanation from the arbitration commission and submit it to the relevant supervision review.

There is no disputing this.

On the bench, Lin Fengru couldn't help frowning when she looked at Su Bai, who was sitting in the appellant's entrusted seat again.

But he didn't say anything more and continued the relevant process of the trial.

This time, although Lin Fengru was slightly dissatisfied with the last time Su Bai directly interrupted her at the trial.

But after all, Su Bai participated in this trial with the guidance of the Supreme People's Procuratorate.

For the last judgment, Fang Rufeng objectively carried out the act of preparing for the crime.

This time, Lin Fengru directly rejected his previous judgment.

This one decision was overturned, and the rest was much simpler.

Why?

Because the other conditions for criminal preparation are very simple to achieve, the most important thing is this one judgment.

Again.

The crime of preparing for a crime must be constituted by four basic points.

As long as one article is dismissed, then the facts of the crime are not established.

Bottom line – this trial is not a big problem.

…

After rejecting the previous relevant ruling, Lin Fengru continued the trial.

Let the parties begin their court presentations.

Wu Chunmei didn't have much to say, just briefly elaborated.

The reason for the prosecution and the criminal conduct identified.

After all, in her existing views and existing evidence, she did not think that Fang Rufeng had committed a crime.

It's just that when Xie Tingting's side was asked to elaborate, Xu Xia still wanted to fight again.

"The presiding judge .... I have something I would like to present in this case. ”

"Although the provisions of the law and the guidance of the Supreme People's Procuratorate have shown that there are no objective facts in this case, it can prove that Fang Rufeng is guilty."

"But Fang Rufeng's approach does have certain problems."

"It has also had a certain impact on our client, especially mentally."

"We believe that no matter what the verdict is, we accept it."

"But for the mental damage caused by us, we need to give a certain amount of compensation."

"From this point of view, we hope that the other party can issue a relevant apology to us."

"We hope that the presiding judge will accede to our request."

？

Put the question mark on the top of your head.

Apologize?

Isn't this what you want to use in divorce lawsuits and property divisions?

The abacus jingled, and Su Bai heard it when he sat in the appellant's seat.

How to say it....

In this lawsuit, the main purpose of the other party is to get property.

Knowing that this trial is going to be lost, do you want to continue to play the emotional card and ask them to issue an apology letter?

Don't even want your face?

Su Bai immediately retorted: "Presiding judge, we don't agree with the other party's request. ”

"First of all...."

"The other party's stated point of view is that we need to make moral compensation and make us apologize."

"But why should we apologize?"

"The other party cheated first, betrayed the marriage in the marriage, and asked us to apologize, what is the reason?"

"Even if it is determined by the statutory scenario, after we learned that the other party was cheating at that time, did we have this practice, are there any other problems?"

"Nope!"

"Therefore, we resolutely disagree with the other party's point of view and issue any apology."

"But women are more vulnerable in the family and are a vulnerable group." Xu Xia retorted.

"In Fang Rufeng's marriage, Xie Tingting is not fragile and is not a vulnerable group."

"Did Fang Rufeng cause any physical harm to Xie Tingting?"

"If you talk about mental damage."

"Then we think that our derailment is more mentally damaging, and we ask Xie Tingting to give us a certain apology!"

Xu Xia's statement is completely untenable and has no legal basis.

It can be seen that he just wants to make some relatively unreasonable demands through the presiding judge.

But....

Lin Fengru, who was sitting on the judgment table, directly struck the magic hammer.

"The application made by Xie Tingting's side just now has no basis."

"Fang Rufeng was found not guilty, which is the relevant litigation defense of this trial."

"In this process, whether Fang Rufeng is at fault or not has nothing to do with this trial, so the application submitted by Xie Tingting's party is rejected!"

After Lin Fengru opened his mouth to reject Xu Xia's application, he sounded the magic hammer again.

The verdict was announced,

There is nothing wrong with the verdict this time.

directly announced Fang Rufeng's innocence in court.

Of course.... This was also something that Su Bai expected.

After all, the Supreme People's Procuratorate has already given guidance, and if you make a hard judgment, do you really think there is nothing you can do?

Even in the trial, the presiding judge has the right to interpret the relevant laws, but it is not such a hard interpretation!

After hearing that Fang Rufeng was found not guilty, Su Bai exhaled lightly.

But at this time, Li Xuezhen's eyes were shining.

kept swinging back and forth on the trial table and Xie Tingting's seat.

At this time, Xie Tingting's expression looked a little worried:

"Lawyer Xu.... Now that Fang Rufeng has been found not guilty, what should we do with our divorce lawsuit? ”

Xu Xia: "Don't worry about the divorce lawsuit, now that it's like this, the two of you can definitely divorce and separate with a broken relationship." ”

"But.... That is, there may be certain problems in the division of property. ”

Property division?

Before Xie Tingting could ask, Xu Xia interrupted her: "Let's talk about it when we go back!" ”

"Okay."

Xie Tingting nodded.

When the two walked out of the courtroom, at this time, there were several law enforcement officers standing outside the door.

The two didn't pay much attention to it, bypassing several law enforcement officers as they prepared to leave.

was stopped by these law enforcement officers.

Xu Xia raised her head, and when she was puzzled, one of the law enforcement officers showed the relevant materials.

"Is it Xie Tingting and Xu Xia?"

"We received a report to file a case, and now there is a case, please cooperate with the investigation."

"Please come with us..."

Xu Xia looked puzzled: "The two of us?" ”

"Yes, aren't you Xie Tingting's entrusted lawyer? It's you. ”

Xu Xia turned her head to look at Xie Tingting, and found that Xie Tingting's expression was not quite right.

Glancing at the report description of the case filing materials again, his brows furrowed.

Silent thought in my heart: I fell into the pit....

…

PS: Ask for a monthly pass~

Mobile version:

『Click here to report error』『Add to bookmark』