Chapter 371 was acquitted, accountability was carried out, and the detective overturned!

Regarding Xu Xingwang's case, in fact, this is the key.

That is, to accept or not to accept Xu Xingwang's confession.

Although Xu Xingwang's confession is not directly objective, there are no direct objective facts that can prove the authenticity of his confession.

However, there is circumstantial evidence and circumstantial facts.

Regarding the relevant punishments, Lin Yuanfeng, as the presiding judge, simply made a certain summary of the defense.

Then the gavel was sounded.

"Based on the content of the existing defense, as well as the certification of relevant facts."

"The collegial panel is already aware of the case."

"Now for the adjournment of the court."

Adjournment for deliberation.

Facing the adjournment, Su Bai didn't say much.

In fact, the most important thing in this trial is the certification of the presiding judge.

The Supreme People's Procuratorate appealed because of the lack of direct evidence against Xu Xingwang.

If the High Court agrees with the Supreme People's Procuratorate's protest.

Then the case is very simple.

In general, Su Bai has certain expectations for the result of the judgment.

The original verdict of the previous trial will certainly not be upheld.

On the other hand, the audience watching the live broadcast is also curious about the final outcome of this trial.

Why?

Because in this case, the person in charge is Wang Fang.

In addition, Wang Fang also has a certain degree of popularity on the Internet, 100% of the detectives who solve the case, and this name has been spread on the Internet for several years.

Although the popularity is not as big as Shubai's popularity on the Internet, it is also not small and occupies a lot of traffic.

During the trial of this case, Xu Xingwang directly stated in his statement that Wang Fang carried out illegal operations in the procedure.

Then if the case is judged to be unjust, false and wrongly decided.

Wang Fang's 100% detective who solves the case will be questioned.

And how did this detective come about, there will also be a huge storm.

More importantly, will Wang Fang be sentenced for this?

This is also the point that many people are concerned about.

During the adjournment, many viewers were discussing the final verdict.

However, based on the existing conditions, no final verdict has been discussed.

…

Discussion room of the collegial panel.

Lin Yuanfeng is also discussing the final verdict of this case with two other judges.

This case was not originally a complex case, and there were not many questions to be answered.

It's just that in terms of judgment, there are more things to pay attention to.

Lin Yuanfeng first expressed his opinion:

"The issue involved in this case is whether or not we accept Xu Xingwang's existing confession."

Xu Xingwang said that the previous procedure was irregular, but he could not produce evidence.

"It is illegal to now declare your innocence and then use your confession to state your previous confession."

"However, it was unable to produce evidence to substantiate the existing confession and let the collegial panel admit it."

"What do you two think about that?"

On the side, Li Shang, as the judge of this time, was silent for a few seconds, and then spoke:

"Yuanfeng, have you fallen into some misunderstanding in this case?"

Although Li Shang served as a judge in this case, he was relatively old in the Jiangdu High Court.

He had also served as the presiding judge, but for personal reasons, he was reluctant to continue his career as a judge.

Occasionally, he will serve as a judge.

Hearing Li Shang's words, Lin Yuanfeng asked, "What misunderstanding have you fallen into?" ”

Li Shang spoke: "The statement of the appellant's lawyer is very clear. ”

"The key to whether this case is judged to be unjust, false and wrongly decided is not whether it can confirm whether Xu Xingwang's current confession is true."

"It's about whether the direct evidence at that time can confirm whether Xu Xingwang committed a crime."

"What can prove that Xu Xingwang has committed a crime?"

"It was his original confession and the confession he submitted."

"As for other evidence, it cannot prove that Xu Xingwang has committed a crime."

"There is a conflict between the original confession and the existing confession."

"Then you need to look at the stolen goods."

"Didn't you find that batch of stolen goods?"

"If it is not found, it means that the most important physical evidence is missing."

"Based on this, the chain of evidence in this case is incomplete, and Xu Xingwang should not be convicted of crime."

At this time, another judge spoke: "But there is a problem in front of us now. ”

"What's the problem?"

"The problem is that when Xu Xingwang was found to have committed a crime, he pleaded guilty and accepted punishment from Xu Xingwang's confession."

"But now, according to Xu Xingwang, he has no evidence to prove that the confession at that time was illegal."

"This is also the most crucial point of the judgment in this case."

"He has no way to prove that the confession at that time was illegal evidence, so how can he be acquitted?"

Li Shang's brows wrinkled together: "But didn't I say it just now, the stolen goods were not found." ”

"In the transcript at that time, Xu Xingwang said that his gold chain was stolen, and he admitted that the gold chain came from the stolen goods, but where did the other stolen goods go?"

"The main evidence is that the stolen goods have not been found!"

"This is also a very important link in the chain of evidence, can't this be used as direct evidence to overturn the original confession?"

"It is not necessary to use illegal evidence to overturn Xu Xingwang's original confession."

"You can also use the stolen goods left behind as direct evidence to refut the original confession."

"We can disagree with Xu Xingwang's current confession, but based on the previous point, there is no direct evidence to determine that Xu Xingwang was the perpetrator at that time."

"Do you understand?"

Li Shang said it very directly, and he said it very clearly, to put it bluntly, he is a point of view.

Support the verdict of acquittal.

Lin Yuanfeng and the other judge were silent for a few seconds after listening to what Li Shang said.

While they were silent, Li Shang continued:

"One more point."

"Although the forensic inspection belongs to two departments, the Supreme People's Procuratorate has protested in this case."

"Our court should also make a judgment based on the corresponding evidence."

"I'll just ask Yuanfeng, do you have anything to do with that Wang Fang?"

Lin Yuanfeng: ....

"It's okay."

"It's okay, according to the evidence, the biggest impact of this case is what reputational impact it may have on that Wang Fang, and there will be accountability."

"But it has nothing to do with you...."

"I know your worries, you are thinking about Xu Xingwang's decision, will there be any other problems."

"I said it directly."

"I've tried a lot of cases in the past, and I've dealt with law enforcement a lot."

"I've also heard about Wang Fang's evaluation in their department, it's not very good."

"Although Xu Xingwang has no evidence to prove that Wang Fang violated the procedure illegally, this case may be what Xu Xingwang said."

"It's a typical unjust, false and wrongful case."

"Just as I say."

"Do you two have any other opinions?"

Lin Yuanfeng: "In fact, my inclination in this case is to find me not guilty, but I may think about it more. ”

"I don't have any other ideas now."

"I agree with the verdict."

"If you don't have any opinions, you can make a judgment based on this."

The other judge nodded.

He also has no inclination for the verdict of this case, believing that the unanimous need to use facts and evidence to speak.

His initial rebuttal was only to express the doubts in his heart, and now Li Shang thinks that he can judge.

Naturally, he would not refute.

"You two don't have any opinions, and I don't have any opinions."

"Okay, if that's the case, then let's judge it like this."

"Yuanfeng, you are the presiding judge, you decide."

Hear Li Shang's words.

Lin Yuanfeng smiled and nodded, he didn't care too much, when he entered the high court, Li Shang had helped him several times before.

So for Li Shang, Lin Yuanfeng still had some respect, and nodded: "Okay." ”

Soon....

The adjournment ended.

When the trial was held again, Lin Yuanfeng sat on the bench and sorted out the case.

At this point, the prosecution does not have any inclination, but only hopes that the court will be able to make an objective judgment of facts.

Su Bai had already stated the corresponding situation in his statement just now.

When Lin Yuanfeng asked for a court statement, the prosecution made a corresponding statement based on objective facts.

Su Bai also made a statement from the aspect of the stolen goods, and after making the corresponding general statement.

On the judgment table, Lin Yuanfeng began to directly announce the verdict.

"The parties have been presented by the courts and there are no other objections to the case."

"The verdict will now be announced."

When the verdict was announced, the audience who was most interested in the verdict was actually watching the live broadcast of the courtroom.

Among them is Wang Fang herself.

Wang Fang looked at the live broadcast room of the trial, waiting for the presiding judge to announce the final verdict.

On the court court, Lin Yuanfeng continued to speak:

"The cause of action in this case was filed by Xu Xingwang, who held that his judgment was wrong and filed an appeal against the judgment he announced 23 years ago."

"The court conducted an investigation based on the relevant facts and relevant evidence."

The verdict reads as follows:

"This court believes that for Xu Xingwang's burglary and murder case."

"Based on the available evidence, it is not enough to determine that Xu Xingwang is the perpetrator of burglary and murder."

"Lack of primary physical evidence."

"The evidence is insufficient."

"That is, the previous judgment is dismissed."

"Verdict Xu Xingwang is not guilty!"

The gavel sounded, the final verdict fell, and Xu Xingwang breathed a sigh of relief in the appellant's seat.

He doesn't know the law.

In his plea to the case, he had always felt that he might be found guilty.

Now I hear that I am not guilty .... To be honest, I was very excited.

In the appellant's lawyer's seat, Su Bai took a long breath after hearing the outcome of the case.

At present, the client's litigation claim is partially completed.

The verdict of not guilty has also come down.

After the verdict of not guilty is handed down, the rest of the process is much simpler.

Why?

Because the result of the not-guilty verdict is down, then it is necessary to consider why the guilty verdict was made before.

Those responsible must be held accountable.

Only when a verdict of innocence can the relevant responsible persons be held accountable, which is a necessary process.

On the side, Li Xuezhen's eyes lit up:

"Lawyer Su.... If this case is found not guilty, can the client's other entrustment claims be continued? ”

Other appeals?

Isn't the other appeal an accusation against the Detective?

Su Bai smiled: "Almost." ”

…

On the other hand, many viewers watched this live broadcast and saw the verdict come down.

Discuss directly in the barrage: "I lose!" This case is overturned! ”

"Isn't this a typical unjust, false and wrongful case?"

"Judging that there is no primary physical evidence, what else can be said?"

"Accountability!"

"That's right! If the case is overturned, doesn't that mean that this case was problematic a few decades ago! ”

"Do you want to hold the people involved accountable?"

"With such a heavy punishment as a suspended death sentence, it is definitely necessary to hold the relevant personnel accountable, according to the confession of the appellant Xu Xingwang just now."

"This case was tried by Wang Fang at the beginning, and I estimate that it is very likely that Wang Fang will be held responsible."

"Wang Fang? Detective overturned?! ”

“.….”

On the barrage of legal commentary, many people discussed Wang Fang's body from the final verdict of the case.

When it was judged to be an unjust, false and wrongly decided case, everyone's attention was also focused on whether the original trial procedure was illegal.

Meanwhile.

Wang Fang also frowned after hearing the final verdict.

Although in her heart, she thinks that this case does not involve her.

But now that he has been found not guilty, the supervision department will definitely hold him accountable.

When the time comes.... It does have a certain impact on her.

"But the evidence should be gone by now."

"It's just a little bit of trouble."

"It doesn't matter."

Besides, although Xu Xingwang was acquitted this time.

However, the main basis for the verdict was the lack of primary physical evidence.

There is no connection with her procedural irregularities.

What could she have been wrong with?

Wang Kexin meditated in her heart.

…

PS: Ask for a monthly pass~

Mobile version:

『Click here to report error』『Add to bookmark』