Chapter 385: Final Judgment! Interrogative statement, what do you take life for?! (Little Boom)
Chapter 376 Final Judgment! Interrogative statement, what do you take life for?! (Little Boom)
During the adjournment.
The bailiff guarded Wang Fang, who sat on the bench, constantly thinking about her future.
It is said that there is a future, but in fact there is no future.
Her future is to sit in prison for a few years, and her pension will be gone.
Lost the main source of income.
Let's be honest ....
Today's scene was something Wang Fang had never expected.
Now during the adjournment, Wang Fang can only sit on the bench, secretly hoping that the court will give a verdict she is looking forward to.
The other side.
Spectators watching the open trial are also waiting for the hearing after the adjournment.
At the same time, there is a constant discussion of the case, and the final sentence will be sentenced.
Discussing what Wang Fang's specific sentence might be.
"The court is now adjourned, and the verdict will be announced after the court presentation is completed."
"Is there a big guy who can guess what kind of penalty will be given in the end?"
"It's not very clear, according to the provisions of the domestic criminal law, the crime of dereliction of duty depends on the circumstances, and the main core content of this dereliction of duty is the abuse of power, causing losses to public property or state individuals."
"The circumstances are less than three years or less, and the circumstances are more than three years if the circumstances are more serious."
"What kind of punishment will be imposed depends mainly on whether the circumstances are less serious or more serious."
"Judging from this case, it is very likely that a more serious circumstance will be judged, after all, the impact of this case is too great, and the behavior is very vicious.
Wang Fang has solved cases at a rate of 100% over the years.
To be honest, in addition to Xu Xingwang's case, I don't know how many other cases have been judged because of this.
A serious circumstance must be judged! ”
Some viewers spoke, and many viewers echoed.
"Yes, yes, yes...."
The audience who watched this trial had a very enthusiastic discussion of this case, and the heat was very high.
Discussion room of the collegial panel.
Li Qingyuan sat on the sofa, facing the other two judges, discussing whether the case should be judged to be serious.
"I think this case should be a relatively light sentence, why?"
"After all, more than 20 years have passed since this case, and the death sentence was suspended that year, and it is estimated that the judges of that year also took into account the qualitative issue of this case."
"Otherwise, by virtue of burglary and intentional homicide causing death, this situation will definitely be sentenced to death."
"However, in this case, Wang Fang did not do it right, it involved serious dereliction of duty, and I personally think that the sentence of two years and six months in prison should be raised, and the sentence should be raised in the less serious aspects."
"That's my opinion."
As one of the judges of the collegial panel, Wang Shui opened his mouth to express his views on this case and Wang Fang.
However, after Wang Shui stated his opinion, Li Qingyuan frowned slightly.
didn't wait for Li Qingyuan to reply.
Another judge also denied this view.
"Whether the plot is serious or not depends on what the result is."
"The death sentence in this case is a suspended death sentence, which is a judgment handed down by the court, but under normal circumstances, it has already constituted a death sentence."
"Burglary and murder, as judges, we should know how serious this characterization is, right?"
"If you don't say 100%, most of them will be sentenced to death!"
"In this case, Wang Fang must know that the death penalty will be imposed for burglary and murder, and she also wronged Xu Xingwang as a criminal suspect."
"The sentence to Xu Xingwang's death is a matter of the court's judgment."
But from Wang Fang's point of view, does she know that Xu Xingwang may be sentenced to death? must know that just looking at this, she is already suspected of constituting a serious circumstance. ”
Plainly.
It was Wang Fang who knew that the burglary and murder caused death, and if nothing else, he would definitely be sentenced to death.
When Wang Fang knew that Xu Xingwang might be sentenced to death, she still decided that Xu Xingwang would fight the crime.
Is this nature bad?
Very bad!
From Li Qingyuan's point of view, Li Qingyuan actually supports the latter.
Because from Wang Fang's subjective point of view, he did it knowingly.
It's about using someone else's right to life to achieve one's own ends.
This is already trampling on other people's lives!
This kind of plot must constitute a bad plot!
Facing the mutual statements of the two, Li Qingyuan nodded slightly: "Let's discuss it from Lao Feng's point of view." ”
"My opinion is that the plot is serious."
"After all, from Wang Fang's subjective point of view, this case is very serious."
"But the exact length of the sentence can be discussed again."
After Lao Feng heard Li Qingyuan speak, he nodded slightly.
"Okay."
"I don't have a problem with that."
Wang Shui faced the unanimous opinion of Li Qingyuan and Lao Feng, and quickly reversed his relevant views.
He expressed his agreement with the idea of supporting a resentence.
The three members of the collegial panel continued to discuss the specific sentence.
…
Soon the adjournment ended, and the trial was reconvened.
Li Qingyuan sat on the bench of the courtroom, briefly sorted out the opinions just discussed, and then looked at the seats in the trial.
"The adjournment ends, and the trial continues."
"Now for the final part of the courtroom, the courtroom presentation."
"Please start making court presentations."
In this case, Wang Lixuan, as the public prosecutor, has been accusing Wang Fang of criminal dereliction of duty.
Now that the presiding judge has made a decision, what he needs is to supplement the circumstances and all aspects.
Faced with the presiding judge asking the prosecution to make a statement in court, Wang Lixuan said:
"Okay, presiding judge, the prosecutor's court statement is as follows."
"In this case, the facts of Wang Fang's crime are clear, and the consequences are clear."
"For the victim Xu Xingwang, the result of a suspended death sentence was caused."
"In accordance with the relevant provisions of the law, where dereliction of duty causes major harm to public property or individuals, the circumstances are judged to be serious."
"In this case, the prosecution believes that Wang Fang has constituted the aggravating circumstances of the crime of dereliction of duty."
"Based on the above."
"The prosecution recommended a sentence of four years and six months in prison."
"The prosecution has finished its case."
The prosecution's statement was very brief, only from the objective facts, whether the circumstances were serious, and the length of the sentence.
I didn't say much about the rest.
After the prosecution's statement was completed, Li Qingyuan took a fancy to the seat entrusted by the defendant's lawyer on the courtroom seat.
It's just that for the relevant circumstances of Wang Fang's case, Zhang Liang handed over the right to make a statement to Wang Fang.
After all....
When Zhang Liang asked Wang Fang to admit guilt and accept punishment just now, a wave of contradictions broke out.
According to Zhang Liang's own understanding of Wang Fang, if this court statement is made by himself, if it does not reach the level of Wang Fang's satisfaction.
There is a high probability that it will bring yourself an inconvenient situation.
So let's just let the defendant make a statement in court.
Facing the court's statement, Wang Fang spoke: "Presiding judge." ”
"I don't know if it's too late for me to plead guilty and accept punishment now, this case happened 23 years ago."
"I know I'm at fault, I'm at fault."
"But I still hope that it can give me a chance based on my attitude of pleading guilty and accepting punishment."
"Actually, at the beginning, I really had no choice, so I did this."
"I forgot a lot of the details at that time, as well as my thoughts, I don't know why I had this idea in the first place, and I regret it very much when I think about it now."
"So I hope that the presiding judge will look at this point and lower the sentence imposed on me."
"That's my statement."
To put it simply, Wang Fang's statements were all intended for the presiding judge to give her a lighter sentence.
What to say about regret and remorse, in fact, this has no other great effect in court statements except for being able to calm down one's heart or express one's guilt.
After not regretting only yourself knows best.
The presiding judge and the collegial panel only look at what acts have been done and what objective facts have been done.
Therefore, the members of the collegial panel did not say much about Wang Fang's statement.
After listening to Wang Fang's statement, Li Qingyuan spoke:
"Okay, the collegial panel has heard the defendant's statement."
"Now, please sue and entrust a lawyer to make a statement."
“.….”
Facing the presiding judge's opening, Su Bai briefly sorted out the courtroom statement.
The court statement is mainly about the sentence above the sentence.
The sentence is determined by the circumstances.
To be honest, did Wang Fang do something wrong in this case? Is the plot serious?
It's definitely done wrong and seriously involved!
Knowing that Xu Xingwang was innocent, he had to send Xu Xingwang in.
What if the court sentenced the death penalty not to a suspended death sentence?
Burglary murder and death, this case is likely to be sentenced to death.
If the law enforcement side had sorted out all the evidence chains, Xu Xingwang would not have appeared in the trial seat today.
This case is closed!
has become a permanent unjust, false and wrongful case, and there may only be a 100% solving rate recorded in Wang Fang!
Su Bai didn't know if Wang Fang, who was sitting in the defendant's seat, would regret that Xu Xingwang was only sentenced to death with a reprieve, and whether he had any hope that Xu Xingwang would be sentenced to death.
But from another point of view .... Wang Fang's behavior must be heavily sentenced!
Organize your thoughts.
Su Bai began to make a statement in court: "Presiding judge." ”
"Our court statement is to get the defendant to give us an explanation."
"Let the defendant give me an explanation that he has been imprisoned for 23 years and has been sentenced to death with a reprieve."
"From the very beginning of this case, Xu Xingwang's appeal was very simple."
"That is, he hopes that he can be innocent, and that he hopes that he will be the person who has been imprisoned for so many years in vain and suffer the legal punishment he deserves."
"That's what he's asking for."
"Is it difficult?"
"To be honest, it's hard, but it's not hard."
"It's not difficult to say, that's from a legal point of view, it's hard to say, it's been nearly 23 years since he was wrongfully imprisoned."
"But as an innocent white man who has been innocently imprisoned for 23 years."
"What do you hope for the most? What I hope most is to be able to wash away the grievances on my body. ”
"Thinking of this, I suddenly want to ask the defendant a question, why did the defendant Wang Fangzai insist on letting Xu Xingwang bear this charge when he knew that Xu Xingwang was wronged?"
"Of course, according to objective facts, Wang Fang wants to complete the task and solve the case."
"But has the defendant ever thought about a question, that is, what is this crime?"
"Burglary and intentional homicide causing death!"
"The defendant should be very clear about the punishment for this crime, right?"
"Death is on hold, and there is a high probability of a death sentence!"
"A felony within a felony!"
"In this case, the defendant still used the illegal procedure to burden Xu Xingwang with this crime even though he knew how heavy the punishment would be."
"Defendant, what do you think of Xu Xingwang's life?!"
"Is it a tool for your stepping board?!"
In the face of Su Bai's questioning, Wang Fang looked calm and remained silent.
She didn't know what she was supposed to say, but she knew what she was saying was wrong, so she could only remain silent about it.
Seeing this, Su Bai didn't say anything too much, but chose to continue to state.
"The right to life is equal for all!"
"This is a criminal law provision."
"In view of this, all parties in the trial, whether it is a lawyer, a prosecutor, or a judge, are very clear about this."
"If you don't stand from the perspective of the law, what will the defendant's actions be seen in the eyes of ordinary people?"
"It will be regarded as Xu Xingwang, that is, the defendant Wang Fang, as a stepping stone for promotion and enjoying reputation, and it is a stepping stone at the cost of life!"
"I don't know what the defendant thinks, and I don't know if the defendant did it on the spur of the moment, or if he was confused, or if he just wanted to do it."
"But since the result has been decided, then we can fully assume that the defendant's conduct has involved a very serious degree of circumstance."
"At least that's how we see it from our client's point of view."
"As the victim's lawyer, I also hope that the collegial panel will consider this issue from many aspects."
"And then determine whether the defendant's circumstances are serious."
"The presiding judge is our court statement."
Su Bai's statement is inspiring.
On the judgment bench, silence and silence remained on all sides.
A moment later.
Li Qingyuan slowly rang the gavel and spoke: "The collegial panel has heard the statement of the lawyer entrusted by the accuser. ”
Then he turned his head to look at the other two judges, and after seeing Wang Shui and Lao Feng, they both nodded slightly, and Li Qingyuan stood up.
"The court presentations of the parties have been completed, and the verdict is hereby announced!"
Everyone stood up, and their eyes were focused on Li Qingyuan.
Li Qingyuan began to read out the verdict: "The cause of action in this case is to prosecute Wang Fang for dereliction of duty in an unjust case 23 years ago. ”
"The trial will be conducted by the Beidu Intermediate People's Court of this court."
The verdict reads as follows:
"Based on the testimony of witnesses and objective facts, the court found that Wang Fang violated the provisions of the Criminal Law and committed the crime of dereliction of duty."
"And subjectively intentionally, knowing that a burglary and murder would result in Xu Xingwang's death sentence, he still used his position and power to convict him."
"Based on the above."
"The court found that Wang Fang's involvement in the circumstances was serious."
"Sentenced Wang Fang to four years in prison!"
"And publicly apologize to Xu Xingwang...."
“.….”
Regarding the follow-up, Li Qingyuan also stated a number of measures and regulations.
But Xu Xingwang, who was in the accuser's seat, couldn't control his emotions anymore.
His eyes were red, and he looked at the seat of the judgment table.
Twenty-three years!
He had been imprisoned for twenty-three years, and at the time of the original verdict, he had been thinking about what he had done wrong.
In the past 23 years, he has always hoped that those who convicted him in illegal procedures would be punished.
Now, he's finally waited!
…
PS: Ask for a monthly pass~
Mobile version:
『Click here to report error』『Add to bookmark』