The heated debates on the stage were like a rising tide one after another, and the audience was not quiet. "What should I do? After studying law for so many years, I suddenly found that I was very ignorant, and I agreed with all of them who said it.

Xiao Fang scratched his ears and cheeks, and looked at his mentor in distress, "Boss, you tell me, who you say makes sense, I listen to you, and I don't listen to any of them." ”

Lu Wenqiang looked at the apprentice who was not angry, and sighed deeply: "There are too many problems involved, this is an unsolvable topic, don't ask me, I'm also distressed." ”

The debate on the stage continued to be intense, and the questions were one after another, and Nie Yifeng just asked: "Of course, China's constitution stipulates the principle of monogamy, does it mean that Chen's behavior of changing sex is not a sabotage of monogamy? Isn't Chen's act of marrying someone else without authorization a violation of Ms. Qin's right to know about her spouse's rights?"

Shang Luoyu immediately stood up: "The crime of bigamy stipulated in China's criminal law must be the overlap of two or more marital relationships, please tell everyone which two marital relationships coincide with Chen?"

Wen Zhixia was also a little dizzy: "He can turn monogamy into monogamy, why isn't it the overlap of the two marriages?"

This is not like a debate but a consultation, Huang Yixi didn't think about letting Shang Luoyu open his mouth to answer her, and immediately shot back: "The crime of bigamy emphasizes the overlap of two marital relationships, and the crime of bigamy refers to the fact that he is the husband of this wife, or is the husband of another wife, but Chen was a husband before, and he is now a wife, not that the two marriages coincide at the same time." ”

Shen Chang came back to his senses now: "He is someone else's wife, but he is still a husband compared to his wife." ”

Shang Luoyu stood up calmly: "The opponent's defense friend must understand that the premise of the crime of bigamy is that a man marries two or more women at the same time, or a woman marries two or more men at the same time, but a person cannot marry a man and a woman, this is the key to this case, Chen has obtained the status of a woman after undergoing sex reassignment surgery, so how can he be a husband? Having lost the basis for the crime of bigamy, how can he constitute the crime of bigamy?"

It's a pity that when Wen Zhixia heard Shang Luoyu speak, she always felt that he was talking to her, and the whole person was in a trance, and she forgot to ask the question: "Has he obtained his ID card?

There is no need for Huang Yixi to come out now, Kang Mingyang stood up and patiently taught her: "You take a closer look at the debate, Chen has already obtained a female ID card." ”

The building was about to fall, Nie Yifeng closed his eyes, stood up and wanted to redeem himself: "I also told the other party that on August 6, 2002, the General Office of the Ministry of Civil Affairs issued a reply on how to dissolve the marriage relationship after one of the parties to the marriage is transgendered, and the private office letter No. 200227 fully explains that as a matter of the dissolution of a transgender marriage, the request of the parties to the marriage registration authority to revoke the marriage relationship should not be supported. However, if there is no dispute between the parties on the property issue, the registration authority may handle the divorce by agreement. The effect of divorce is calculated from the date of dissolution of the marriage relationship, does this not mean that the marriage of a transsexual person should be calculated from the date of dissolution or judgment of divorce by the people's court or the marriage registration authority?"

It's a pity that Huang Yixi also remembered such a reply and didn't give the positive side a chance: "The defense has noticed this reply made by the civil affairs department, this can only be an internal guiding opinion, and it can't even rely on a regulation, don't forget that only the obligations stipulated by the Constitution and the law are the obligations that citizens should drive." In addition, this reply is contrary to our country's cultural and educational traditions, theories, ethics and current legislation. If same-sex people can get divorced, doesn't that mean same-sex people can get married?"

"Beautiful!"

"Wonderful!"

"This sentence is absolutely counter-attacked!"

Everyone in the audience applauded.

If the previous debate made everyone feel that the winning side might be the opposite side, Huang Yixi's sentence made everyone understand that the positive side has no chance to turn the tables, and the more you say, the more you make mistakes.

Zhuo Lijun saw that Wen Zhixia couldn't turn the tables, so she looked at the time and stood up: "Thank you to the players on both sides, although the players on both sides are still talking about it, The meaning is still unfinished, but everyone has noticed that this debate topic is true and false, true and false, their tricks are virtual and real, the combination of virtual and real, true and false is because this Chen is a man or a woman, whether the virtual and the real are we arguing a virtual case, or combined with the actual local situation, this is the style of free debate between the two sides, and then we want to ask both sides to make a concluding speech. ”

Summarizing the argument is very much about the debater's ability to summarize on the spot, not only to highlight the advantages and characteristics of his own side, but also to grasp the mistakes of the other party, Shang Luoyu and others' hearts raised, Tang Zhan's ability is extraordinary, and every summary is the icing on the cake for their team, on the other hand, Zhou Liufang's ability is mediocre, and the response is also very flat.

The hearts of everyone in the audience are also delicate, they hope that Tang Zhan will come back to life and win back a city, except for the defeated men of the Minyue team, few people can accept that the Minyue team won the first place, especially when they looked at the pot-bellied Huang Yixi, their hearts were more complicated, could they tell others that they lost to the Minyue provincial team in the little-known Nanban land, and one of them was still a pregnant woman.

Ke Wenxiu's heart was even more raised, the Minyue Provincial Team could come to this point, she couldn't believe her eyes, if she had supported them at the beginning, it was to fight against Sun Qinghai, but after achieving her goal, she had already gone with the flow a little, if she knew that the Minyue Provincial Team could come here, she would definitely give the choice of the fourth player to Shang Luoyu.

But now it's too late to think about this, as a cadre, a staunch atheist, praying or something is not suitable for her, her heart panicked, she could only stare at Zhou Liufang, her eyes were so hot that Zhou Liufang felt that there was already a hole in her body.

Tang Zhan is undoubtedly the leader of the Kyoto team, and as soon as he exited, he immediately convicted the opponent of three crimes: "Moderator, judges, summarize the debate points of the opponent's defense friend just now, there are three mistakes: First, the misunderstanding of the essence of the crime of bigamy, Article 258 of the Criminal Law of our country cannot see that the essence of the crime of bigamy is the overlap of the two marital relationships in time, and Articles 31 and 32 of China's new marriage law clearly stipulate that the marriage relationship must be invalidated by the marriage registration authority and the people's court.

That is to say, before the marriage is invalidated according to the legal procedures, the marriage relationship between Chen and Qin is still in the effective stage. At this time, Chen's marriage to another person still constituted the crime of bigamy.