Cao Yun and Ouyang Yi are one positive and one strange. Zhuge Ming had to deal with Ouyang Yi's problem head-on. Cao Yun seized Zhuge Ming's flaws from time to time to kill, making Zhuge Ming tired of coping.

Cao Yun glanced at Ouyang Yi and returned to his position, Zhuge Ming breathed a sigh of relief, which meant that Cao Yun had temporarily retreated.

Ouyang Yi looked at the forensic doctor: "Was the deceased killed by a single shot?"

The forensic doctor nodded: "Yes, the bullet hit the heart at close range and penetrated the body." ”

Ouyang Yi: "Judging from the position of the deceased at that time, what posture was she?"

The medical examiner said: "According to the judgment of the scene, the deceased should have been in a standing position, and after being hit by a bullet, he slowly sat down, leaned his back against the wall, and finally fell to the left. ”

Ouyang Yi: "One shot is not accurate?"

The forensic doctor nodded: "To be precise, it was a rapid loss of physical strength, but at that time, the deceased still had a certain consciousness. The heart stops supplying blood, the cranial cavity is deprived of oxygen, vision and hearing are blurred and stop working. Unlike a blow to the head, a blow to the heart is not instantaneous. ”

Ouyang Yi: "I've been doing criminal cases for some time, and I've been in contact with a lot of shootings. I found that the palms of the deceased in this case were clean. ”

Medical examiner: "Yes, in most shootings, because of the pain from the muzzle of the gun, or because of doubt, the hand touches the body to look at it, resulting in a lot of blood in the palm of the hand. However, there are a few exceptions. Whether or not there is blood on the palm of the hand is not telling. ”

Ouyang Yi asked: "In this case, as far as the corpse is concerned, is there a defensive injury?"

Defensive injuries usually refer to cold or unarmed attacks. Defense is not just about defense, it means to be beaten, it includes the meaning of attack. For example, if A's fist hits B's body, A's fist will cause defensive damage. Through the identification of defensive injuries, it is possible to infer many situations at the time of the crime. A part of the attack, the force of the blow, the direction, etc.

When A is pointed at by B with a firearm, his body instinctively makes some useless defenses. For example, sideways, such as blocking with the palms of the hands, such as the scarlet, such as raising both hands.

Of course, the forensic doctor knew what Ouyang Yi meant: "From my experience in autopsies for so many years, the deceased was shot suddenly. Sudden doesn't mean instantaneous, but it does contain instantaneous. Assuming that A shot B, and B's body is the same as the deceased in this case, I will write my personal opinion after the autopsy report, which contains several possibilities. After A pulls out the gun, and B does not react, A shoots ......"

The forensic doctor said a lot, and the forensic doctor subjectively ruled out a possibility, that is, Yue Sanchi used a firearm to hold Jiang Hanyue hostage for a long time.

Ouyang Yi asked: "What do you mean, A has already thought about killing B, and after taking out the gun, there is no hesitation or consideration." ”

The forensic doctor was embarrassed for a long time: "I am personally biased towards your statement. But technically, I can't prove that, because there are so many other possibilities. "The forensic doctor's personal opinion is to detect clues, which is not accurate, and only provides a possible direction. It is not established in court.

The forensic doctor did not dare to give technical conclusions, which was expected by Ouyang Yi, but he was still a little disappointed. This question is a foreshadowing of the testimony of the three feet in court.

The first battle, technical witnesses.

Through electric lights and light switches, the defense added points, but not much. Overall, the testimony of technical witnesses was extremely favourable to the prosecution. This is nonsense, and the prosecution will not rush to prosecute without technical evidence to support it.

Second Battle: Defendant Testimony.

As a defendant, you must explain the circumstances at the time of the crime, and it does not matter whether it is true or not. But if you don't say it, you're dead.

Yue Sanchi began to explain his testimony, that is, the experience of that night. She fully cooperated with the lawyer, and what she said in court was exactly the same as what she said to the lawyer.

Step 1: She received a call from the informant Ye Lan and went to Villa 7, where she took Ye Lan's low-powered telescope to see the car floating not far away. For about twenty or thirty seconds, she felt dizzy and didn't know anything.

Step 2: Wake up to a bathroom with the lights on and water rushing all over her body.

Step 3: She found that the room where the bathroom was located was not lit and that someone had died in the room, and she did not know the identity of the deceased at the time, nor did she know that the firearm she was carrying caused the death of another person.

Step 4: Yue Sanchi's mobile phone is flooded and cannot be used, and he collides with the patrol officer when he goes out for help.

This is also the transcript and testimony that Yue Sanchi eventually provided to the prosecution. This stage is the prosecution's offensive phase, which wants to expose the lies of Yue Sanchi's testimony.

The first witness of the prosecution, Cao Yun's ex-girlfriend Ye Lan.

Although it is a case of his girlfriend's suspicion, because his girlfriend's identity is not recognized by law, it does not affect Cao Yun to become the lawyer in this case.

Ye Lan: "I don't know why Prosecutor Yue said that, because I wasn't near the villa complex at all that day. ”

Zhuge Ming asked, "At about ten o'clock that night, where were you?"

Ye Lan thought for a while and replied: "I was living in Gaoshan Law Firm at the time, and my boyfriend was busy with work, so he went out for a walk at eight o'clock. Lawyer Wei Junwei helped me and took me to the gate of the law firm. I didn't go far, I just sat on the edge of the cliff less than 300 meters from the law firm, watching the mountain in a daze. At about 10:30 a.m. I returned to the lawyer's office. ”

Zhuge Ming: "Does anyone have a certificate?"

Ye Lan said: "Yes, before ten o'clock, it was almost ten o'clock, and lawyer Wei Jun came to me. Ask me if I'm okay. I said it's okay, I want to sit a little longer, and she'll go back first. ”

The second witness, Wei Jun, appeared in court: "Ye Lan is sitting on the side of the mountain, and my boss asked me to go and see what the situation is." Nine fifty-five a.m. ”

Zhuge Ming said: "According to the defendant's testimony, she and Ye Lan met at around 9:45, Jiang Hanyue's time of death was between 10:10 and 10:10, and the time when the patrol police entered the scene of the crime was 10:17. Ye Lan's Gaoshan Law Firm arrived at the scene of the crime, even if it was a speed of 100 kilometers per hour, it would take 24 minutes. Ye Lan had witnesses who proved that he was near the lawyer's office at 9:55, so the defendant's testimony was pure lying. ”

Ouyang Yi stood up and began to question.

Ouyang Yi: "Wei Jun, how far did you talk to Ye Lan at that time?"

Wei Jun replied: "About ten meters, the night is very quiet. I walked very clearly, Ye Lan didn't look back after approaching, and I vaguely heard her crying. She buried her head in her knees and shook slightly. I just asked, are you okay? Ye Lan replied, it's okay, let me leave her alone. ”

Ouyang Yi: "You didn't see Ye Lan's face clearly. ”

Wei Jun: "Yes. ”

Zhuge Ming said: "Oppose, Ye Lan can't foresee whether Wei Jun or others in the law firm will approach her and comfort her." Normally, comfort and viewing are more likely. Ye Lan's creation of a dummy at this point proved that it was too easy to be exposed. Ye Lan can't be fake. ”

Ouyang Yi: "Don't worry, I haven't finished asking yet." Ye Lan, what did you cry about?"

Ye Lan was silent for a while: "I am Yue Sanchi's informant, Yue Sanchi told me that she can help me marry the man I love." On the condition that I inform my boyfriend's father of his whereabouts and any information. By the way, my boyfriend's father's name is Cao Lie, and he is a wanted criminal in many countries in East Asia. I didn't want to lose my boyfriend, but we weren't happy with each other at the previous stage, and I agreed to Yue Sanchi's offer. She helped me analyze my boyfriend's personality and achieved great results. But I feel sorry for my boyfriend and am very embarrassed...... I decided to end it that day and break up with him. I don't want to hurt him. The next day, I ...... to my boyfriend That is, lawyer Cao proposed to break up. ”

Zhuge Ming looked at Cao Yun: "Is there a problem with your ex-girlfriend's testimony?"

Cao Yun: "No. ”

Zhuge Ming looked at Yue Sanji: "Ye Lan is your informant, is what she said true?"

Yue Sanchi nodded: "Yes." ”

Zhuge Ming: "Thank you, please continue." ”

Ouyang Yi asked, "Wei Jun, what does your law firm think of Ye Lan, especially what do you think of Ye Lan living in the lawyer's house?"

Wei Jun replied: "We don't like Ye Lan very much, but because of Lawyer Cao, we are still polite every day." But we have a very strong relationship. My boss thinks that Ye Lan is a very ordinary girl, who is nothing but beautiful, and is not worthy of Lawyer Cao at all. Because of Ye Lan's entanglement and other reasons, after Ye Lan moved into the law firm, Lawyer Cao's work was seriously delayed, and even Lawyer Cao himself asked the boss to find a way to get Ye Lan away. ”

Ouyang Yi: "The people in your law firm don't care what Ye Lan is crying about?"

Wei Jun replied: "That's right, it's just a polite greeting." ”

Ouyang Yi asked, "Ye Lan, do you know that the people in the law firm have such an attitude towards you?"

Ye Lan replied: "Attitude...... It's really cold. I stayed for more than ten days and no one took the initiative to chat with me. The daily polite greetings are also cold. For lunch and dinner, they would only call me once, and if I didn't come downstairs or back in time, they wouldn't pay attention to me. For example, that night, they were reluctant to call me, preferring to walk to say hello to me. Greeting them means they're going to rest. ”

Ouyang Yi: "In other words, if someone Li Dai Taozhuang replaces Ye Lan and you sit on the edge of the cliff, the people in the law firm will not find out." ”

Ye Lan nodded: "The light is very poor...... Yes. ”

Ouyang Yi: "This means that you can go to Villa 7 in your own right." ”

Ye Lan admitted: "Yes, but I didn't do it. ”

Ouyang Yi faced the jury: "That is to say, ......"

Zhuge Ming: "Wait a minute, I'm sorry to interrupt." You can see that this is the location of Takayama Law Firm, and there is a seven-kilometer dedicated road. There are 24-hour cameras at the crossings. The data captured by the camera is intact and has been inspected by technicians. According to the surveillance, from 8 p.m. on the night of the incident to 7 a.m. the next day, no cars entered or left the crossing. ”

Zhuge Ming: "Let's calculate the time, Ye Lan wants to frame the defendant." First of all, a fake Ye Lan is needed to carry Ye Lan's voice and walk seven kilometers to the edge of the cliff near the lawyer's office. Then Zhen Yelan walked seven kilometers to bypass the surveillance, rushed down the mountain, took a car to Villa No. 7, and after the incident, he was sent back to the bottom of the mountain by car, and Zhen Yelan walked seven kilometers back to the lawyer's office. ”

Zhuge Ming: "This is Ye Lan's ankle injury report, and the doctor judged that even if Ye Lan disregarded the wound tear, it would take at least two hours to walk seven kilometers at his maximum potential. The return of seven kilometers takes at least three hours because it is uphill. It is impossible for Ye Lan to be near the scene of the crime. ”

Cao Yun stood up and organized his words: "Ye Lan, on the day we broke up, you came to the hotel where I stayed at half past eight. And according to the evidence given by the prosecution, at seven o'clock, the first car is you driving your car out of the crossing. "One foot can turn on the automatic transmission, as long as it doesn't hurt the foot that steps on the accelerator and brakes.

Cao Yun: "I'm sorry, no one in the law firm noticed you driving away, otherwise they would definitely help." I was staying in a hotel in the second district because of the case. In other words, it takes you an hour and a half to get from the law firm to the hotel. And it's still in the morning rush hour...... It's impossible. ”

Cao Yun: "After eight o'clock in the evening, the people in the hotel are not you." It's normal that you either go out for a walk or are in the room and no one takes the initiative to talk to you. I'm really sorry for you, they even consciously make you feel their dislike for you. You have been in the lawyer's office for more than ten days, and it is clear that no one will get up until half past seven in the morning. ”

Ye Lan said: "I don't know the time, but I know that I will leave before seven o'clock and go to the hotel where you live." ”

Zhuge Ming said: "Lawyer Cao, is it difficult to drive 90 kilometers in an hour and a half?"

Cao Yun said: "It's okay to be normal, but you can't do it in the morning rush hour." ”

Zhuge Ming said: "Please look at the second evidence. ”

The violation data appeared on the big screen, and Ye Lan's car was violated the next morning. Speeding by 20%, speeding by 50%, and running a red light twice.

Zhuge Ming: "According to the shooting of the surveillance bayonet, the car passed through the law firm crossing at 7 o'clock, arrived at the first district of the villa in the southern suburbs at 7:30, and arrived at the Nanqiao at 50 o'clock. Arrived near the hotel at 8:15, entered the underground parking lot of the hotel through the congested section in 10 minutes, and arrived at the hotel where Mr. Cao was located at 8:25. Ye Lan's illegal driving behavior is definitely wrong, but Lawyer Cao's speculation is also wrong. ”

Cao Yun: "I know, I know it's possible to rush to the hotel. ”

Zhuge Ming: "Then why are you questioning?" ”

Cao Yun: "She...... Breakfast was eaten that day. "After breakfast, the time was completely wrong. Because the law firm didn't have breakfast at seven o'clock in the morning. How do you know that Ye Lan has had breakfast? Isn't this kissing at the hotel?

Zhuge Ming was stunned: "What about the evidence? Is Lawyer Cao planning to appear in court as a witness?"

Cao Yun said: "I guess it's right, you got on the bus halfway...... I have no proof. ”

Zhuge Ming said: "Based on the argument just now, Ye Lan's testimony is completely standable. Then the defendant's testimony that he was invited by Ye Lan to the scene of the crime before the crime is perjury. ”

Ye Lan looked at Cao Yun and shook his head lightly, as if he was persuading Cao Yun not to resist anymore.

Cao Yun suddenly smiled evilly, which shocked Zhuge Ming and Ye Lan, Cao Yun slapped the information in his hand on the table, and said, "Please witness No. 4, Sima Luo, prosecutor Sima Luo, appear in court." Witness No. 5, Li Mo, head of the first section of the search section, is invited to appear in court. Witness No. 6 Detective Sonny is invited to appear in court. Witness No. 7 is invited to appear in court. ”

Zhuge Ming, who had obtained the list of witnesses before the trial, wondered in his heart: A series of judicial personnel who had basically nothing to do with the case appeared in court to testify? and prosecutors also appeared in court to testify. These are all witnesses for the defense, which makes Zhuge Ming feel uncertain. But they refused to answer Zhuge Ming's inquiry. Sonny told Zhuge Ming that it was not that he didn't want to say it, first of all, he said that it was not in accordance with the rules, and the most important thing was that someone would turn his face.

Sonny also patted Zhuge Ming on the shoulder: Don't fight him, you're still too tender. The angry Zhuge Ming wanted to kick Sonny to death, but when he learned about Sonny's character and records, he didn't think so. After all, when he was a little agent, he dared to provoke Li Long, called Li Mo, and didn't even pay attention to the judge.

But Sonny's sentence that you are still too tender makes Zhuge Ming feel guilty about this witness. This group of people went to court to testify together, and it would be child's play if they didn't have any urine spilled out.