The pre-trial court opened, and this was the first time Cao Yun had seen the real Zhuge Ming. Zhuge Ming is bald, but he is very bald, giving people a sense of eagle vision. Paired with a handmade fitted suit, it's more like a successful businessman. There was a beautiful assistant with glasses sitting next to him, and in contrast, it brought out Zhuge Ming's domineering president's style. He sat in the control seat, and his confident eyes were like looking at the mountains at a glance on Mount Tai.

The beautiful assistant began to briefly explain: The suspect is a certain woman, what is the identity of Balabala. The deceased is a woman from a certain country, and her identity is ala. Prosecutors accused Yue Sanchi of intentionally killing Jiang Hanyue.

The judge looked at Cao Yun and Ouyang Yi, Ouyang Yi was about to make a stand according to the process, Cao Yun pointed to the glasses beauty: "Who are you?"

Everyone was stunned.

Cao Yun: "Who are you? What is your name if you are not on the list? Where are you from? What position do you hold in the procuratorate? Does the prosecution understand the rules?"

That's right, before you can explain it, you must explain your identity. The chief prosecutor in this case only wrote Zhuge Ming, and did not write the name of the assistant. This is a violation of the rules of the court.

Cao Yun stood up: "I am now going to accuse this Zhuge Ming prosecutor of abusing his private power and disrupting the order of the court. As a defense lawyer, it is our duty to create a fair trial environment for the defendant, so I ask the court to take this matter seriously. ”

The judge said, "Lawyer Cao, this is just a procedural error. Moreover, if you can't hold a preliminary court today, you will still have to open it tomorrow, so why delay everyone's time?"

Cao Yun said: "Your Excellency, acting in accordance with the law is the basic criterion for our judicial personnel. Before the trial began, the prosecution blatantly violated basic procedures. Either the prosecution is extremely unprofessional, then I have to persuade the prosecution to replace its prosecutor. Either the prosecution has flouted court and has not taken you seriously at all, Your Majesty. I did not expect you, Your Excellency, to succumb to such a violation of law and discipline, and I am skeptical about the fairness of the judicial trial. I will write to the Supreme People's Court, asking for a more transparent trial environment, and I will not rule out making this matter public. Thank you. ”

The judge took a deep breath and looked at Zhuge Ming, Zhuge Ming's face did not change, and the judge said: "Bailiff, take the woman who broke into the courtroom down, and I will consider whether to accuse him of disturbing the order of the court." ”

The glasses woman looked at Zhuge Ming incredulously, and Zhuge Ming said softly: "Go ahead." "The glasses woman is a trainee prosecutor, and Zhuge Ming temporarily decided to bring her to Dongtang to study, so there is no assistant's name in the list of attendees in the preliminary court.

The glasses girl is trespassing, which does not mean that the glasses girl and Zhuge Ming are together. If Cao Yun identified the glasses girl and Zhuge Ming, there would be no way to make the accusation of disrupting the order of the court. It can only be admitted that it was negligence and mistakes.

Order was restored. Who is it? Everyone looked at the defense seat, and Cao Yun pointed at Zhuge Ming: "Prosecutor, are you dumb? Do you understand the rules?"

That's right, the glasses girl is an illegal person, and she must be re-balabalaed by Zhuge Ming. It's a pure waste of time.

Zhuge Ming pursed his lips and nodded in his heart: Yes, you have a kind.

Zhuge Ming took the indictment and began to read it, his voice was very thick and very good. This is not a good thing for the suspects, and the jury has somewhat subjective preferences. A handsome guy like Shrimp has the urge to kick to death when he sees an extremely rare more handsome brother. Appearance is a plus. Therefore, before the original defendant, witnesses or suspects appear in court, the marine lawyers will persuade them to appear in court in formal attire and show as much self-restraint and grace as possible.

Zhuge Ming read the accusation very carefully, and he had already seen that Cao Yun was here to find fault. Against this kind of person, no flaws can be exposed.

After Zhuge Ming finished reading, Cao Yun asked, "By the way, who are you?"

Zhuge Ming replied calmly: "My name is Zhuge Ming, and I am the prosecutor in this case. ”

Cao Yun asked curiously: "Who is Zhuge Liang to you?"

Zhuge Ming: "It's not me." ”

Cao Yun saw that Zhuge Ming didn't move at all, so he shut up and went backwards. Ouyang Yi stood up, he was very careful by Cao Yun's hand, first introduced himself to the two defenses, and showed the power of attorney signed by Yue Sanchi and the lawyer's cards of the two people, to show that he and Cao Yun were qualified to accept the commission of this case, and they were Yue Sanchi's carte blanche lawyers. Finally, I get to the point: "On behalf of the defendant, I deny the charges. ”

The judge was speechless and neurotic, and this was the pre-trial chamber. What is a pre-trial chamber is a meeting between the judge and the prosecution and defense, getting to know each other, and then making a statement. The normal pre-trial chamber is over in five minutes. It took forty-five minutes today.

Judge: "At the end of the pre-trial chamber, the trial will be held on a later date, and the prosecution and defense will be notified in writing of the trial time." ”

……

Out of the preliminary court, Ouyang Yi said: "Your-stirring stick didn't stir up Zhuge Ming. ”

Cao Yun agreed: "He is more stable than I thought. ”

"Lawyer Cao, Lawyer Ouyang, please stay. ”

The two stood and turned around, and Zhuge Ming stepped forward quickly: "I have heard the names of Lawyer Cao and Lawyer Ouyang for a long time. ”

Cao Yun and Ouyang Yi looked at each other, and Cao Yun shook hands with Zhuge Ming first: "Let's shake hands in court, you have to endure it in court." ”

"Haha. "Wang X egg, Zhuge Ming just wants to open his words and say, everyone don't play these tricks, okay?" Zhuge Ming and Ouyang Yi shook hands: "I can fight with the king of criminal discrimination, Sansheng is lucky, please be merciful." ”

Ouyang Yi said politely: "Don't dare, Prosecutor Zhuge is famous all over the Tang Dynasty, and my false name makes Prosecutor Zhuge laugh." ”

"Don't bother, I'll take my leave first and see you in court another day. ”

"Goodbye. ”

Seeing Zhuge Ming leave, Cao Yun said: "This kid is a little yin, and by the way, he will provoke our relationship." "How to provoke, Zhuge Ming complimented Ouyang Yi and didn't care too much about Cao Yun. Although Cao Yun's reputation is not as good as Ouyang Yi's, his victory lies in his youth...... It's a pity that Old Man Cao is only physiologically young, but his mind is very mature.

Ouyang Yi: "It seems that this is a tough battle. ”

Cao Yun raised his hand to greet the nine-tails who walked by: "Nine-tails." ”

Nine-tails didn't look at Cao Yun, and moved lightly: "Hey." "Walk away quickly.

Cao Yun frowned and pondered: "There are ghosts." The Nine-Tails are not very good at lying...... Could it be that she is standing on Zhuge Ming's side?"

Ouyang Yi: "Her face is very red, is it ......?"

The two looked back at the corridor, no, this is the courtroom. The Nine-Tails shouldn't mess around in this place. Ouyang Yi: "There's nothing wrong with being careful. It cannot be ruled out that although Sima Luo, Wang Lei and Jiuwei hope that Yue Sanchi will be innocent on the surface, they may secretly engage in nonsense. ”

Wise men are suspicious.

……

The Yue Sanqi murder case officially opened, and it was difficult to find a vote for the hearing. There are three major highlights in this case, first: the little detective Yue Sanchi is a star in the judicial world. Second: Zhuge Ming personally accused. Third: the two lawyers of Dongtang jointly defended. No matter from which entry point it takes, this case has attracted the attention of the industry.

The opening is the same as the prosecution's presentation of the case and the charges made.

After that, the first step of the criminal trial was officially entered: the head of the physical evidence team and the forensic doctor appeared in court to testify.

Through questioning, Zhuge Ming uncovered the entire murder case step by step. The gun is more than three feet, the killing bullet is more than three feet, no residual drug was found in the body, and then the shooting and blood splash angle are demonstrated. It's almost the one who killed the three feet directly.

When Zhuge Ming questioned the two technical witnesses, Cao Yun and Ouyang Yi kept talking to each other, the two covered their mouths with their hands, spoke quickly, and their eyes were always looking at Zhuge Ming. In the end, Ouyang Yi nodded, and the two sat quietly and waited for Zhuge Ming to finish asking.

The examination of technical witnesses is a dialectical stage, they do not belong to any party and are witnesses of a neutral third party. Therefore, when one party asks, the other party can ask and answer. This is also a very important part of the evidence defense in criminal cases. It is also the suspect's biggest opportunity to turn the tables.

Ouyang Yi stood up, and Cao Yun played the live photo slideshow, which was an animated version of the slideshow. The physical evidence team determined that it was basically the same as the scene.

Ouyang Yi began to formally interrogate: "Is there a light in this room?"

Physical Evidence Team: "There's a light in the middle ceiling. ”

Ouyang Yi: "How many switches control this lamp?"

Physical Evidence Team: "One, on the right hand side of the door, the green dot in the picture is the light switch. ”

Ouyang Yi: "Excuse me, did you find fingerprints on the switch?"

Physical Evidence Team: "No. "The patrol officer wore white gloves.

Ouyang Yi: "Are there water stains or other marks on the switch?"

Physical Evidence Team: "No. ”

Ouyang Yi: "Does the defendant have gloves?"

Physical Evidence Team: "No. ”

Ouyang Yi nodded and faced the jury: "In other words, the defendant killed the deceased in complete darkness in the room. And the lights were not turned on to check the vital signs of the deceased. ”

Zhuge Ming said: "I can answer this question." There are almost no occupants in this villa area, so the patrol police of the southern suburbs police station have stepped up patrols in this area. The patrolmen knew very well which villa had occupancy. If the lights are turned on, the patrol will be suspicious and knock on the door to ask. ”

Ouyang Yi said: "Everyone looks at the terrain, even if the lights in this room are turned on, not only are there windows and curtains to shade the light, but the location of the windows is the backyard, and there are walls to block it." The patrol officer couldn't see it at all. ”

Zhuge Ming said: "Yes, in terms of physical conditions, it is difficult for the patrol officers to find even if they turn on the lights. But there are people who are thieves, or they are cautious and don't take the risk. ”

Ouyang Yi: "Then I don't understand, why is the bathroom and so on open? The toilet uses ground glass and has no curtains, which makes it more transmittile. The defendant was worried that the light in the room would be discovered by the patrol police, so he did not turn on the light, but he was not worried that the light in the bathroom would be discovered by the patrol police? Let me introduce the defendant again, the defendant is called a little detective, and in the five years he has been on the job, he has cracked eight major cases and more than 10 major cases, including the donation case that shook the whole country and the corruption case of the temple chief. If nothing else, at least the defendant's IQ is above the passing line. How can you worry about the lights being discovered and not worry about the lights being discovered?"

Zhuge Ming said: "This situation seems to be contradictory, but it is actually very easy to explain. I admit that at his best, the defendant was a highly intelligent businessman. However, a check of the defendant's records shows that the defendant did not have a real history of killing. After the murder of the deceased, the defendant's mood swings affected his judgment, and the defendant forgot that the lights would attract the attention of the patrol officer, so he turned on the bathroom lights when he went to the bathroom to take a shower after the killing. ”

Ouyang Yi thought about how to answer, Cao Yun stood up and said, "Prosecutor, you are very interesting. In the beginning we were talking about objective details, objective evidence. When the objective evidence was against the prosecution, the prosecutor discussed the emotions with us. Is it not that the mood is not good for the prosecution, and the prosecutor still has to analyze men and women with us?"

Cao Yun faced the jury: "Please note that what we are debating now is the scene of the crime, and it is a technical dialectic. The prosecutor subjectively analysed the defendant's emotions. This is not only a stealing of concepts, but according to the rules of the court, if it is non-technical evidence such as dialectical subjective consciousness, one party may ask questions, and the other party may not deliberately interrupt. Now I don't know if the prosecution really understands the rules of the court, Zhuge Ming, do you have a backstage? I really can't imagine that a person like you can be the first prosecutor in the Tang Dynasty. ”

Zhuge Ming tried to squeeze out a smile: "Let me explain, I just explained to the defense lawyer why there is a contradiction in turning on the lights, which belongs to on-site technical dialectic." ”

Cao Yun glanced at Ouyang Yi. Ouyang Yi, who had gained enough time, asked, "Witness, may I ask if the light switch in the bathroom has been found?"

The physical evidence team replied: "It is basically the same as the room switch, no fingerprints, no water stains." ”

Ouyang Yi said: "The prosecution just explained that after the killing, the defendant had mood swings and lost a certain ability to think about the incident. But what is surprising is that the defendant, who has lost his ability to judge and does not carry gloves, how can he turn on the lights in the bathroom?"

Zhuge Ming: "Naturally, after turning on the light, I wiped the fingerprints on the switch. ”

Cao Yun applauded: "That's too good, it's just a hooligan." Contradiction in turning on the light: You say that the defendant has lost the ability to judge, and the switch in the bathroom is contradictory, and you say that the defendant has the ability to judge. Are you a roundworm in the defendant's stomach?"

Zhuge Ming: "I'm just...... It is just that the possibility of such a possibility cannot be ruled out. ”

Ouyang Yi: "Let's sort it out, what the prosecution means is that the defendant was worried that the lights would be discovered by the patrol police, so he shot Jiang Hanyue without turning on the lights in the room. The defendant then turned on the light in the bathroom, wiped his fingerprints on the light switch in the bathroom, and went into the bathroom to rinse his body. Not to mention that this statement is far-fetched, the testimony of the patrol officers who came to the scene showed that the lights in the bathroom were always on. The defendant did not turn off the lights in the bathroom and did not turn on the lights in the room...... How do you explain it? ”

Zhuge Ming said: "The lamp is just a small detail......

Cao Yun: "Witness, he means that your work is not important at all. ”

Zhuge Ming: "I didn't say it. ”

Cao Yun: "The physical evidence team, the forensic doctors are all detail workers, but you said that it was just a small detail. You viciously slandered their work contributions in front of two professionals, are you embarrassed? Do you want face?"

Zhuge Ming hurriedly said: "I didn't mean that. ”

Cao Yun asked, "OK, are the lights and switches just small details?"

Physical Evidence Team: "Our physical evidence team will try to restore the crime scene as much as possible, and conduct a comprehensive and professional investigation of all the small details. There are no unimportant details in our eyes. Thank you. ”

Grass, mud, horses!

Zhuge Ming forced out a smile: "I think the work of forensic personnel is very important. I mean, the switches and lights don't say anything. Maybe the lights were turned on before, maybe they were turned on later, maybe they didn't use their fingers to turn on the lights. For example, if you touch it with a hard object, you can also turn the light on and off. So...... So while the details are important, they don't mean that the defendant didn't kill someone. ”