It is impossible to debate a result on a topic such as whether 'ruffians talk about history' is good or not.

So after seeing that the two were arguing, but no one could convince anyone, Yu Fan finally couldn't help but intervene.

"Ahem, it seems that neither of the two professors can convince anyone, so what about Lin Xiao, what about you? As the author of "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty", the representative work of the 'ruffian talking about history' trend, what do you think of the views of the two professors?" Yu Fan asked Lin Xiaodao.

"I said before, in fact, my understanding of history is only scratching the surface, whether "ruffians talk about history" is good or not, this topic is a bit big, just like movies have literary and commercial works, I can't answer this question. Lin Xiao shook his head and said.

Feng Zhiyuan and Song De were a little surprised by Lin Xiao's answer, but Yu Fan was a little dissatisfied, you don't talk about it, can we still talk this day?

However, if you don't talk about it, it's okay, and I force you to talk.

In fact, don't look at "Controversy" is a non-entertainment show, but it also needs ratings, otherwise the guests "Controversy" is looking for, and they will not specifically look for those guests who are topical and controversial.

The guests of this issue, Feng Zhiyuan and Song De, yes, they are both professors, but in fact, there are really not many people between the two, but Lin Xiao is different, he is a star and a writer, and his popularity is not low, and the key is that this time it happened because of him, if you don't talk about it, then what are you doing on the show?

"So put aside the question of 'ruffians talking about history', purely from the perspective of the work, what do you think of "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty"?" Yu Fan quickly changed the topic, if you don't want to talk about it, then force you to talk about it.

It's not torn, there's no conflict point, how can anyone watch the show, isn't it?

"Generally speaking, in addition to the lack of writing and subjective assumptions in many places, if you look at "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" as a historical cross talk, it is not bad, at least there is nothing wrong with it. Feng Zhiyuan said with a deep groan.

On the other side, Song De shook his head and said, "Before judging, I have a few questions I want to ask Lin Xiao, I don't know if it's okay?"

"Of course, I know everything. Although Lin Xiao doesn't have a good impression of Song Dezhi and his ilk, after all, people are so much older than themselves, and respecting the old and loving the young is a fine tradition of the Chinese nation, isn't it?

Of course, the premise is that Song De should not go too far.

"What did you major in college? Not history?" asked Song De.

Lin Xiao shook his head and said, "It's not history. ”

"And how many history books have you read? I don't mean those, but the canonical history. Song De asked again.

"I've read some, but I don't read much of the official history, and more often than not, I will look for this kind of information in order to verify some historical events and figures. Lin Xiao said.

"How old are you? not thirty, right?" asked Song De again.

"No!" Lin Xiao shook his head, many people were puzzled, Song De asked what these things were for.

"You might be wondering, why do I ask these questions?"

"In fact, it's very simple, history is different from others, the study of history needs to be supported by a large number of books and materials, because those are all things in the past, don't read more books, don't look for more information, it's hard for you not to make mistakes, although I agree that 'ruffians say history' has a positive effect on the popularization of historical knowledge, but because of this, therefore, 'ruffians say history' should be built on a more professional basis, otherwise, it is not to promote the popularization of history, but to mislead people's children and mislead the public. ”

"A young man who has not read too many historical materials, and even knows only a little bit about history, rashly writes 'history books', isn't this misleading the public? ”

"Because what is not supported by historical materials and has not been verified is easy to mislead the public. The ridiculous thing is that there are still many people who regard "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" as a model work of history, which is simply absurd. ”

Lin Xiao couldn't respond in his heart, Feng Zhiyuan was better, people just talked about things, and they were targeting "ruffians talking about history", not him Lin Xiao himself, Lin Xiao couldn't get along with him, and he didn't care too much.

But Song De's words are very disgraceful, Nima, don't you count 13 in your heart?

I'm not qualified, is it just someone like you who is qualified?

If you want to say that he has no other purpose, and he doesn't believe it when he kills Lin Xiao, Song De's meaning is obvious, professional things are left to professional people to do, what is a professional person, refers to Song De himself, right?

"Professor Song, I also have a question in particular, have you really read my "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty"?" Lin Xiao asked.

Song De smiled when he heard this: "What, do you think I came to comment without reading it?"

"Of course I've read it, but I haven't read it all, it's not that I don't want to read it, but because your writing is really unsightly. ”

In fact, Song De really hasn't read it, he just read some excerpts from "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" sorted out by some netizens on the Internet.

It's just that as soon as Song De's words fell, Feng Zhiyuan frowned, and Yu Fan also frowned, always feeling that there was something wrong with the question Lin Xiao asked, and he also felt that there seemed to be something wrong with Song De's answer.

"Just now Professor Song said that if you want to write history, you must first study history, which I agree with, in fact, I also think that I am not qualified to govern history, and I have not done this, but there is a saying that there is no right to speak without investigation, Professor Song, you said that you have read "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty", I am a little puzzled, "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" has not been published at all, and it has not even appeared in written form at all, where did you read it from?" Lin Xiao looked at Song De with a puzzled look and said.

Hearing Lin Xiao's words, Yu Fan and Feng Zhiyuan finally understood why they felt that something was wrong when they heard the question they asked Lin Xiao and the answer that Song De answered just now.

"Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" was not written at all, nor did it appear in the form of written words, Song De said that he had read it, but he had not read it all, it was impossible.

Since there is no such thing as this book, how do you read it?

Song De was also a little confused, "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" has been discussed so much, but there is no book?

"Actually, there are some things that I really feel wronged and feel weird. Lin Xiao ignored Song De's embarrassment and confusion, but continued.

"Do you know how the work "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" came about? How did I come up with the idea of talking about "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty"?"

"I didn't say it, so it's impossible for people to know, so I'm even more confused. ”