"Professor Feng was present who opposed 'ruffians talking about history', and felt that "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" was not rigorous enough, with personal subjective assumptions, and could not be called a historical work. ”

"There are people who support ruffians to talk about history, and there are many people on the Internet who regard "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" as a classic of the history of the Ming Dynasty. ”

"The reason why I haven't responded to these comments during this time, whether positive or negative, is because I myself am a little surprised, a little confused, and a little puzzled. ”

"I don't understand how "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" became a masterpiece of history?"

"I don't understand that "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" has become a model for ruffians to talk about history. ”

"I still don't understand why some people like Professor Song, who have never watched "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty", can comment on it. ”

"What I don't understand is that "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" has been raised to the level of blasphemy of history, I really can't afford it. ”

"I want to tell you a story, a story about the birth of "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty". ”

Lin Xiao ignored the reactions of the others, but spoke up himself.

"My grandfather is an old storyteller, he has learned to comment on storytelling since he was a child, and when he is old, he still takes this as a business, our family has three generations of single transmission, and storytelling is such an old craft, in modern times, it has begun to decline a little, and the decline is not only because of its form, but also because of a very fatal point, that is, I can't find people who are willing to learn this job. ”

"Cross talk pays attention to speaking, learning and singing, and storytelling is actually more important and requires a lot, but in the eyes of most people, it is an industry with no great future. ”

When I was a child, I often followed my grandfather and watched him comment on books, not because I liked it so much, but because, following my grandfather, he would buy me delicious food. ”

"I don't know when my grandfather pinned his hopes on me, the third generation, but I still disappointed him, because I, like everyone else, found that storytelling really didn't have a big future. ”

"Grandpa opened an old teahouse, in fact, the old teahouse has never made money, but grandpa still opens, I know, that's because, grandpa only has a platform to talk about storytelling. ”

"Grandpa's body is quite strong, but when he is old, it is inevitable that there will be some common geriatric diseases, such as high blood pressure. ”

"When Grandpa was telling a story, he was too emotional, which led to a coma, although there was no major problem after that, but the doctor said that it was best for him not to have too many mood swings, but when it comes to storytelling, it is to integrate into emotions, without emotion, how to show the ups and downs of the plot?"

"Our family is in a hurry, grandpa is very stubborn, he doesn't listen to people's persuasion at all, just at this time, the tiger cat platform is on the air, I am a small shareholder of the tiger cat platform, so I naturally want to give my own platform a show. ”

"Grandpa's greatest wish in this life is to be able to watch the successors of the art of storytelling, and to see that this skill can survive without so difficulty. ”

So I told my grandfather that storytelling should also keep pace with the times, and if you want more people to like storytelling, you must innovate. ”

"In the eyes of many people, storytelling is something that only older people like, but I don't think so, because in ancient times, storytelling was a form of entertainment that could cover all ages, so why has Lin Xiao become something that only older people like now?"

"So I thought, first of all, why don't I try to see if young people really don't like storytelling, or just because everyone is already familiar with the storytelling, so they don't like it?"

"So, I thought of using the online live broadcast platform, the audience of the online live broadcast platform is all young people, and at the same time, the stories in the past storytelling books are not fresh for a long time, so I thought, what if it is a new script?"

"Because of my grandfather's words and deeds, I usually read a lot of miscellaneous books on history, but most of them are stories about those historical figures, scripts, romances, not official history. ”

"To be honest, the history of the Ming Dynasty is the first time I have read a book on official history, so Professor Song said that I am not qualified to govern history, and I agree, and I am still self-aware in this regard. ”

"It's just that I wonder that "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" was not a history book in the first place, at best, it is just a historical commentary, or historical cross talk. ”

"My original intention of writing this work is also to comment on books, I don't understand that a book of commentary will be regarded as a true history by so many people, and it is still regarded as a classic. ”

"What makes me even more puzzled is that there is still a topic of ruffian history, I feel blushing when I read those comments, I obviously wrote a historical cross talk, but there are so many people who want to go online, this judgment of my history can't be like this, that one says this is a historical masterpiece, I can't afford it, I really can't afford it. ”

"Careful people should be able to notice that in "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty", I used speculation in many places, rather than research. ”

"Because I know that my knowledge is limited, the amount of reading is limited, and there are not many references, so it is impossible to be as rigorous as a history book, as for personal subjective assumptions, as the author of a book, of course I will have my own ideas, but this is a work that will win everyone's pleasure, by the way, promote the art of storytelling, and make some money by the way. ”

"So, here, I want to solemnly clarify that "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" can be regarded as a commentary, a historical cross talk, and a historical romance, but please don't elevate it to the height of historical works, I can't afford it, and "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" can't afford it. ”

"Also, Professor Feng, Professor Song, if you want to judge whether 'ruffians talk about history' is the right way, please don't use "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" as an example, because "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty" itself is just a work of "notes" for everyone's after-dinner pastime. ”

"It can't create a 'ruffian to talk about history', and it can't afford to be a leader in 'ruffian talking about history'. ”

"I'm just a singer, a storyteller, or a writer, but I'm definitely not a historian. ”

"Also, friends who like "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty", let's just take a look, don't say anything I, the author, has a deep foundation in Ming history and rigorous academic research, and excessive exaltation is a killing, everyone, please, let's listen to the book, if you think it's good, you can just hold it, you can not listen to it if you think it's not good, don't do this, it's not interesting. ”

Song De was stunned, Feng Zhiyuan was stunned, Yu Fan was also stunned, and the audience at the scene was also stunned.

Yes, people originally said it, and the live broadcast said that it was a storytelling, but it never said that this was governing history, and treating a storytelling book as a true history is also wishful thinking on everyone's part, and the author didn't think so at all.