669 Early ventilation
In the interval before the official meeting, everyone first stepped forward and said that the Hengdian product was absolutely fine, and the Japanese were purely framing Yunyun. However, everyone knows that this is to say to you face to face, and only you know what you think in your heart.
Zhang Yifu privately asked Professor Li Minghe's opinion with more respect, and the old professor's attitude was also very clear, we have made some achievements in this field for several generations and so many years, and it is impossible to deny it.
As a result, the meeting was launched in the same hatred and hatred, and Zhang Yifu also unabashedly expressed his thoughts, hoping that the Electric Power Research Institute would invite IEC experts to supervise the site to test and evaluate the microcomputer protection products of Mitsubishi and Hengdian, and break the rumors in one fell swoop.
In the face of this proposal, the Electric Power Research Institute undoubtedly expressed embarrassment, in the final analysis, it was due to a lack of confidence in itself.
Hu Haitao, vice president of the Electric Power Research Institute, expressed his attitude in a tactful way: "Mr. Zhang, this proposal is indeed valuable, and once the test results are excellent, it will undoubtedly block everyone's mouths." I believe that you are confident enough to propose this method, because in the previous appraisal organized by the Institute of Electrical Engineering, Hengdian's products are indeed not inferior to the world's first-class products. ”
"'But' used to be all nonsense. Xiang Xiaofei muttered in a very low voice, and was secretly kicked by Zhang Yifu.
Zhang Yifu said politely: "President Hu, please tell me your opinion, our attitude is correct, the Electric Power Research Institute is a scientific research unit of the Ministry of Electric Power, we can only plead and propose, it is impossible to forcibly entrust." ”
"No, no, that's not what it means, this kind of testing and evaluation is really only what we can do, after all, we are a certified national laboratory. The conversation changed and interpreted Xiang Xiaofei's statement. "However, we must face up to the fact that the last time we compared the data of imported products was a few years ago, two years shorter, and more than five or six years. Because not every imported product used in our country will be sent for testing. So we are actually relative to a few years ago, 866A is not inferior, how fast the development of technology in this area Mr. Zhang, you know best, however, we proposed that 866A is a world-class level, in fact, ignoring a premise, that is, on a relative scale, we have the data under the premise, it is world-class, which is not absolute. ”
Hu Haitao's words are also pertinent. And the logic is very reasonable, and it has been responded to by many people.
As a member of the relay protection professional committee, Hu Lingling also said: "Now the 866A put into production by the North China Bureau is running stably, which is already a very good achievement for domestic microcomputer protection. On the contrary, it is necessary to compete at such times, if the results are not satisfactory......"
Another person also chimed in: "We are all technical cadres. It will definitely be a factual review, let alone if it is invited to the IEC. It is also impossible not to seek truth from facts. Mr. Zhang, this is not only a face problem of your company, but a face problem of the entire domestic relay insurance industry, is it too risky to do this?"
Chang Jiang, who was sitting next to Zhang Yifu, shook his head the more he listened, after listening to Zhang Yifu's thoughts. This is indeed his first reaction, because of his lack of confidence in himself, everyone hopes to keep this "relative" world-class good, why do you have to fight for this breath? Take the latest products of others, maybe you will be dumbfounded. In this way, not only the reputation of Hengdian will be discredited, but the self-confidence and reputation that the domestic successor has just established will also be hit.
Zhang Yifu also anticipated this situation for a long time, and said directly: "First of all, I know the level of Mitsubishi's latest microcomputer protection products, in the domestic test, its score is compared with 866A, it will only be lower and not higher, this is the information I obtained when I went to Japan last time I visited, absolutely accurate, don't think about it." ”
"We believe in you, Mr. Zhang. One of the commissioners laughed.
There is a kind of "the more you draw black" in this smile.
Zhang Yifu didn't care, the front was just to lead to the main topic. To make them do things, take risks, it is not enough to rely on words and righteousness, no one will take the risk of no profit, the key is to gamble worthwhile.
In fact, this contradiction in front of us also exposes a little rule that we have been neglecting. Zhang Yifu spread his arms and said, "Why, domestic relay products and imported relay products are double standards." ”
After Zhang Yifu said this, he deliberately stayed for a moment to let everyone reminisce.
Zhang Yifu cut his left hand on the table. "Domestic relay products always need to be strictly tested by the Electric Power Research Institute, learn to organize identification, and then the power plant substation trial operation before it can be officially launched. ”
Then, he cut his right hand on the other side of the table: "And imported products, there is no need for this process at all, where you want to purchase, just buy it directly and use it." ”
When a person wanted to explain, Zhang Yifu preemptively explained: "I know that generally everyone thinks that imported products generally have quality assurance and have passed the IEC standards, so there should be no big problem, while the technical foundation of domestic products is thin, and they dare not use it without evaluation or trial operation." In the past, this did save time and improve work efficiency, but now, in 1994, this rule can be considered to be changed. ”
Zhang Yifu said and gestured to Ruan Mei not far away.
Nguyen Mae quickly pulled out a stack of charts and handed them out to every attendee.
"There are two tables on this, the above is the application of 866A in the North China Bureau in the past six months, and all the mismovements and refusals are recorded, as you can see, 80 line protection, half a year, only 1 misoperation, no refusal. Zhang Yifu said and pointed to the chart below, "The following is the application record of Mitsubishi's same product in a power grid in the south, 30 units are in operation, 3 times by mistake within half a year, and 1 time refused." ”
Everyone nodded while watching, and occasionally a smart person had realized what Zhang Yifu was going to say.
"Through this fact, can it be shown to a certain extent that the quality of imported products is not necessarily superior to domestic products?"
Hu Haitao raised his glasses and nodded: "There is no problem with what Mr. Zhang said, but after all, this is a comparison of individual cases, and on the whole, there is still a gap." ”
"Yes, I admit the gap, Dean Hu. Zhang Yifu continued, "What I want to say is, since this kind of case has already occurred, can we consider changing our previous rules?" ”
Without waiting for Zhang Yifu to continue, the director of the Relay Protection Division of the Dispatching Bureau of the Ministry of Electric Power took over the conversation, Zhang Yifu had already passed the stage of being stunned and bored, this seemingly honest and innocent young cadre was Lin Lizheng's most trusted subordinate, Zhang Yifu had already passed the qi, as for the qi he passed, it was naturally far more than this. (To be continued......)