In the next link, Jiang Shuiyuan deliberately let the other team members play freely, and almost no longer handed small notes. The Shanyang High School team also realized that it was difficult to take advantage of the debate, so they simply resorted to turtle tactics, turning a blind eye to the problems thrown by the Huai'an Fu squadron, and throwing historical materials out of the sky, many of which they had never even heard of the water source of the river, and they did not know which source they came from.

In this way, the two sides talked to themselves, and the game went into a dull garbage time.

The players on the stage were confused, and the audience was even more confused: "What are you talking about? Are you sure it's Chinese? Why can't I understand a word?"

"+1 for the same feeling. I could understand every word they said, but I didn't know what it meant!"

"+2 for the same feeling. I can only say that the hypnotic effect is very good, more powerful than Wang Ba's chanting!"

"It's no wonder that the theory of national studies is so declining now! If it weren't for the sake of my family's water source, I wouldn't have come to find me for a hundred yuan!"

"Awesome, I have two hundred!"

"You say if I snore will I be kicked out? I know it's rude to sleep in the arena, but I can't help it, and my upper eyelids fall straight down like a scale. ”

"Uh-huh, you haven't slept yet, you're so energetic!"

Listening to the buzzing discussion in the audience, the debaters on the stage became even more impetuous, and they could not speak with a preface or a follow-up, and in the end, they couldn't even figure out what they were saying. Fortunately, the game lasted only 60 minutes, and finally ended the boring debate before the audience's emotions exploded.

Zhou Zhiwat touched his shiny head, as if trying to clear his mind: "The game is over." Before the judges give a score, ask both sides to describe in the most concise sentence how you feel about the game. Let's start with the square!"

Jiang Shuiyuan stood up: "Ban Ma actually has its own advantages and disadvantages, the opponent's defense friend did not grasp the main advantages of Sima Qian and the "Historical Records" to discuss it, and our side did not explain the problem thoroughly when reasoning. ”

"What about the opposing view?"

Huang Dongpei said angrily: "Ma is better than Ban, or "Historical Records" is better than "Hanshu", this is well-known and self-explanatory, the opponent's debaters have not dared to argue head-on, but to generalize and use strong words to reason, naturally the argument is not clear, the argument is not clear!"

Zhou Zhiwat then asked: "The two sides will each use one sentence to tell us what is the most outstanding performance of their own side in this game? This time, we will start with the second argument of the opposing side." ”

The second female of the opposing party replied: "The biggest highlight of our side is that we have rich information and insist on convincing people with evidence. ”

"Where's the square?"

Gao He said: "The most eye-catching performance of our side is that when we make our arguments, we limit the advantages and disadvantages of Banma to the scope of historiography and historians, and the opponent's debaters have not been able to refute it from this perspective, making our arguments as solid as a rock. ”

Zhou Zhiwat stroked his palms and laughed: "You are self-aware!"

The other woman's second argument was a little inexplicable: "Is there something wrong with this?"

Zhou Zhihu looked at Gao He: "You can answer what's wrong." ”

Gao He said: "First of all, although China has the concept of 'history' for a long time, it has appeared very late to regard history as a discipline and history as a book category. At least in the Han and Han dynasties, everyone's understanding of historiography was still very vague, which can be seen from Ban Gu's "Hanshu Art and Literature Chronicles", which placed the "Historical Records" and the Spring and Autumn Three Biography together under the "Spring and Autumn" category of the "Six Arts Strategy". The history department as a book category was not created until the Western Jin Dynasty, when Xun Xun wrote the "New Book of the Chinese Classics", and was formally established in the "Sui Shu Jing Ji Zhi" compiled in the Tang Dynasty. It is in itself a very debatable matter that we use the standard of official history of later generations to define the "Records of the Historians" and the "Book of Han", and the arguments we have established on this basis are obviously all the more worthy of discussion.

In addition, when Sima Qian and Ban Gu wrote the "Records of the Historians" and the "Book of Han", although they both had the historical concept of taking the "Spring and Autumn Period" and covering the old stories of the world, we cannot interpret them only with historical works, because they are both great works with large and profound thoughts, and the content is all-encompassing. The simplest example is the history of Chinese literature, which cannot be avoided by these two books, in addition to religion, geography, philosophy and many other perspectives. When we discuss the merits of Banma, we limit ourselves to the scope of historiography and historians, but in fact we are narrowing the scope so that the debate is as favorable as possible to our side. In other words, it's a fit for purpose. ”

After Gao He's explanation, the Shanyang High School team also woke up. The second female debater wrinkled her nose and said: "You deliberately misinterpret the defense topic and mislead the other party, this is a violation!"

Qian Zhongmin couldn't help but sneer: "Why did you violate the rules? I don't study the catalog well, and I'm embarrassed to blame others!"

Zhou Zhiwat nodded: "Learning Chinese culture is not only to study and recite ancient books, but also to firmly grasp the six most basic knowledge, such as text, phonology, exegesis, version, catalog, and proofreading, otherwise you will indulge in it and have no place to return." According to the famous scholar Mr. Xu Shuofang in his Treatise on Historical Records, 'As a literature, the Book of Han is inferior to the Records of the Historians, and as a historiography, the Book of Han has developed over the Records of the Historians.' If someone in the Shanyang High School Squadron is more familiar with bibliography, grasps the opponent's weaknesses, and makes a big fuss about literature, then the Huai'an High School Squadron will be very sad. ”

Gao He said modestly: "The opponent's defense friend has all kinds of evidence in an endless stream, which has made us sad!"

Zhou Zhiwat said: "Before announcing the results of this game, I would like to ask one last question: If the game is repeated, what are your chances of winning? ”

Yuan Baoshan, the opponent, said confidently: "At least eighty percent! Because we won't wrestle twice in the same place." As long as we are not misled, and the evidence is sufficient, there is no reason why we will lose to the opposing party!"

"Where's the square?"

Chu Taisong glanced at Yuan Baoshan contemptuously: "Even if you do it again, the opponent's defense friend will have no chance of winning, because our captain has already calculated before the game that you will definitely use the views in Zhang Fu's "Theory of the Advantages and Disadvantages of Famous Scholars" to make an argument, and the result is not true." This is called knowing oneself and knowing one's opponent, and winning all battles. At least 80 percent chance of winning? Friend of the other side, where do you get your confidence?"

Everyone was amazed: before the game, they had the other party's point of view, what kind of operation was this, and it was too godly!

Zhang Hong couldn't hold it back, and asked repeatedly: "Xiao Jiang, how did you calculate it?"

Jiang Shuiyuan replied with a shallow smile: "Actually, it's not calculated, but it is guessed that the opponent's debater is likely to use Zhang Fu's views in "The Advantages and Disadvantages of Famous Men" to make an argument, because among the many discourses of Ma Yiban, although Zhang Fu's views are not the most profound, they are definitely the one with the highest popularity, the clearest structure, and the most deeply rooted views. As luck would have it, I guessed it!"

Zhang Hong took the lead in applauding: "Awesome!"

The audience was even more impressed: "It's really amazing! If it were me, I wouldn't even know who Zhang Fu was." ”

"Yes! Even if they say it N times, I still don't know how to write the word 'Zhang Fu', let alone who has said good things about Sima Qian for thousands of years. ”

"So, people can't be compared with each other. People have to die more than people, and goods have to be thrown away!"

"Tears, I'm the one who threw the goods. So Mr. Jiang, please allow me to film you for a second!"

In the interval of applause, Zhou Zhiwat announced loudly: "In this debate competition, the Huai'an Fu squadron won!"