"Are you going to report it?"

Zhang Hong was a little surprised: After last year's contest on the difficulty of Chinese studies, who still doesn't know Jiang's famous and murderous name? Who doesn't know Jiang's super memory? To be honest, just in terms of mastery of the classics of Chinese culture, let alone high school students of the same generation, everyone present has to kneel down and shout "big brother." Dare to catch bugs in his hands, I don't know whether to praise this child's newborn calf for not being afraid of tigers, or laugh at him for being ignorant and fearless?

Huang Dongpei saw the remaining stunned on Jiang Shuiyuan's face, and his heart became more and more determined: "I am convinced, I will report them for violating the rules!"

"Okay, tell me where they violated the rules?"

Huang Dongpei thought for a while: "The other party's second defense mentioned in his speech that although 'Yi Ma kills the dog in the road' is streamlined, for future generations, it is not as valuable as 'there is a horse in the street, and the lying dog is killed', and 'there is a dog lying in the thoroughfare, and the horse is killed by the hooves'. If I'm not mistaken, the word 'value' should belong to Western philosophical discourse, right?"

Gao He felt like he was in trouble, his face turned slightly pale, and he frowned and hurriedly searched for the origin of the word "value" in his mind. The more nervous I was, the more confused my head became, as if what was in it at the moment was not knowledge, but steaming freshly baked white batter, and I couldn't remember which ancient book I had seen the word "value", but the more I thought about it, the more I felt that it was a foreign product!

Zhang Hong turned his head and asked, "Huai'an Mansion Squadron, what do you have to say?"

Gao He, Chu Taisong and others all looked at the source of the river. Jiang Shuiyuan shook his head slightly and said: "The opponent's defense friend said that if I am not mistaken, the word 'value' should belong to Western philosophical discourse. - But the problem is, you're mistaken!"

The audience burst into laughter.

Zhang Hong seems to have expected this outcome. He smiled and asked, "So, what is your basis?"

Jiang Shuiyuan himself laughed: "It's really a coincidence, the Ban family of 'Ban is better than horses' used the word 'value'! According to the record of the Book of the Later Han Dynasty, Volume 47 of "The Biography of Ban Liang Lie", around the seventh year of Emperor An of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the Dunhuang Taishou Cao Zong wanted to send troops to attack the Xiongnu and restore the Western Regions. Empress Dowager Deng ordered the minister to discuss the matter in the court. Ban Gu's nephew, the youngest son of Ban Gu's younger brother Ban Chao, named Ban Yong, put forward his own opinion, believing that the Western Regions should be recovered, one of which is 'those who will be in turmoil, the Western Regions will be restored, and the northern captives will send reproaches to the countries, prepare their rents, and the price will be high, and they will be strict in the hope of meeting'. It can be seen that 'value' does not come from Western philosophy, but is a native Chinese word. ”

Zhang Hong asked Huang Dongpei again: "Regarding the answer of the Huai'an Fu squadron, does the Shanyang High School team agree or have different opinions?"

Huang Dongpei gritted his teeth and said: "There is the principle of 'isolated evidence does not stand' in the study of evidence, unless the opponent's defense friend can come up with more than three examples, it is difficult to convince the public, and it is difficult for our side to recognize!"

The audience immediately booed, and even the relatives and friends of Shanyang High School and the cheerleaders felt that Huang Dongpei was a little lacking in grace.

But Zhang Hong did not reject Huang Dongpei's request, but took out a lively posture and threw the question directly to Jiang Shuiyuan: "Jiang Shuiyuan, how do you think we should answer the other party's question?"

Jiang Shuiyuan said: "Since the opponent's defense friend has a request, then we will convince people with reason, no, and convince people with evidence." I have just given an example from the Eastern Han Dynasty, and I will give another example from the Middle Ages and the Early Antiquity to prove that the use of the word 'value' is not an isolated case, but a normal situation. In the Book of Sui, Volume 36, "The Biography of the Concubine", which was revised in the Tang Dynasty, it is mentioned that "the Turks tasted the market with China, and there was a pearl worth eight million". In the early Qing Dynasty, Li Yu's "Idle Love and Occasional Mail" also has such a sentence, "Collect cattle and horses into the medicine cage, use them appropriately, and their value is above the ginseng Ling". I wonder if the opponent is satisfied with the above three examples?"

Seeing that Jiang Shuiyuan reported two more examples, the enthusiasm of the audience was instantly aroused, and cheers mixed with applause and whistles soared into the sky: "Well said!

"If they are not satisfied, we will hammer them one after another, and we must knock them out!"

"That's it! We have always insisted on convincing people with evidence, and we are not convinced that you bite me?"

"Mr. Jiang is the highest!"

"Yuanyuan, I'm going to have a little monkey with you!" Okay, this is a fan girl, please automatically block her noise.

Huang Dongpei finally stopped resisting. Zhang Hong did not give a conclusion, but looked at Zhou Zhiwat and the other judges: "Mr. Zhou, what do you all think?"

Zhou Zhiwat cleared his throat: "From the report and reply, it can be seen that Huang of the Shanyang High School team is very sensitive to some words in Western philosophical discourse, and Jiang Shuiyuan, a student of the Huai'an Mansion Squadron, is far more proficient in ancient classics than ordinary people. Indeed, at this stage, we use the term "value" in the field of humanities and social sciences, which is often defined in Western philosophy, which means socially necessary labor embodied in commodities, or value expressed in various equivalent standards or exchange standards. But as Jiang Shuiyuan said, the word 'value' was also used in ancient China, but!"

Huang Dongpei subconsciously raised his head, Gao He also straightened his waist, and the audience became silent, waiting for his further explanation.

Zhou Zhiwat whetted everyone's appetite before he said slowly: "The example he gave may not be appropriate! We used the word 'value' in ancient times, usually referring to the price of goods, and the first and second examples cited by the Huai'an Fu squadron belong to this situation. The 'more valuable' mentioned in the second argument obviously does not refer to the price of the item, but to another layer of meaning derived from its original meaning, that is, the positive effect of the thing. From this point of view, of the three examples cited by Jiang Shuiyuan, only the last one in Li Yu's "Idle Love" is the most appropriate. ”

Zhang Hong applauded again and again: "Mr. Zhou still has a unique eye, and the candle is faint. Admire, admire! So how do you deal with this report?"

Zhou Zhiwat rubbed his shiny head a few times: "In my opinion, it is better to settle the dispute than to settle it, not to mention that this is a friendly match, and it is not a regular game." Why don't you just report it this time?"

Huang Dongpei hurriedly said: "We have no opinion!"

The audience on the stage gave him a wave of white eyes: Nonsense, you got cheap, of course you have no opinion!

Jiang Shuiyuan shrugged: "Friendship first, competition second." We don't have an opinion either!"

"Well, the game continues. Next, the three arguments of the positive side will ask one question to the first, second and fourth arguments of the opposing side, and the opposing debaters will answer them separately. Each question should not exceed 20 seconds, and the cumulative time for answering the three questions is 3 minutes. Now the timer begins!"

The name Chu Taisong has misled many people, it sounds like a rough man with five big and three thick, but in fact he is a cute and soft girl. Her hobbies are also different from ordinary people, she likes the anthologies of various families since the Song, Yuan, Ming and Qing dynasties, and her memory is also good.

Time is limited, and the soft girl didn't have the slightest grinding, so she went straight to the point: "The other party argued, just now you mentioned the difference between complexity and simplicity when you argued that 'horses are better than classes', so you came to the conclusion that Sima Qian's pen power and insight are better than Ban Gu's." Wang Ruoxu, a famous scholar of the Jin Dynasty, in the "Historical Records Debate" of the "Collection of Old Men in Southern Hunan", believes that "this statement is a big fallacy", because "the transfer of the record is sparse and there are many words left, and the solid account is detailed and deleted, but it seems to be simple and complex, solid and simple", in fact, it should be better than the horse. What do you think about this?"

Huang Dongpei was confused when he heard this: What do I think? I didn't watch it at all, okay?

Forced by the situation, he still stood up stubbornly, and his answer was concise: "In my opinion, it is completely Wang Ruoxu's own opinion, and it is not enough to train!"

This is really a standard phrase for raising the bar that is universally applicable!

The soft girl didn't entangle with Huang Dongpei, and aimed at the other party's second argument: "The other party's second argument, just now when you made your argument and refuted our argument, you mentioned that Ban Ma and the two have different human qualities, and think that Ban Gu's "Book of Han" is stagnant. However, Zeng Wenzhenggong of the Qing Dynasty said in the "Preface to Sending Zhou Xun Nong to the South", "Cai Yong, Fan Weizong and below, such as Pan, Lu, Shen, Ren and other comparisons, are all teachers of the Ban clan." Chen Tianni, a scholar in modern times, said: "The Book of Han is a whole text, inheriting the relics of the classics, Mo, Xun, and edicts, and establishing the rules of the early Huang Dynasty and the Dianwu, and its flow is the six dynasties, which confront the "Historical Records"." What do you think about this?"

The other party's second argument was also full of bewilderment: I have never heard of what you said, how else can I see it? Alas, why should women be embarrassed by women!

Fortunately, with Huang Dongpei blocking the gun in front, she didn't have so much pressure when she raised the bar: "The reason why we think that Bangu's "Book of Han" is stagnant is a conclusion compared with the rich changes in Sima Qian's "Historical Records", not itself. - Well, that's it!"

The soft girl continued to conquer the city, this time it was against the other party's four arguments: "The other party's four arguments, just now when you made your argument, you thought that Ma was better than class, mainly based on three points: different difficulty, different complexity and simplicity, and different literary quality. However, Xu Qianxue, a scholar of the Qing Dynasty who served as the official of the Japanese lecture and the president of the "History of the Ming Dynasty", believed that "history is a book, the body is broad and the righteousness is secret, the core of the matter is spoken, and the essence of the selection is taken. In other words, the quality of a history book has little to do with the quality and complexity of the text. What do you think about that?"

The other party blinked his stupid and cute eyes, and he also had a confused face: Hmm? Xu Qianxue is nothing to do, and he also said this? He said that he didn't tell me before, what can I think? Anyway, the teammates in front of him have already knelt twice in a row, and they don't care if they kneel more standardly. So he borrowed the routine of the previous two very simply: "That Xu Qianxue's personal opinion is not enough to be believed." - Well, that's it!"