Of course, the improvised investigation team also found Ding Qi himself to talk to him, asked him about the situation, or asked him to explain the situation. Ding Qi had been mentally prepared for a long time, and said very frankly that he had nothing to say, that there was police supervision at the scene, and that there were complete audio and video recordings, so he would investigate according to the facts, and his own retelling afterwards was not the most effective evidence.

Ding Qi also admitted that this matter was his own initiative and had nothing to do with his mentor Liu Feng, Liu Feng did not know in advance, and he pretended to be in the name of Liu Feng. At the same time, he declared that he would bear whatever responsibility he should bear on the basis of facts and the law, and that he would neither take the initiative to admit anything nor evade any responsibility according to the judicial procedure.

In the case of clear facts and no conclusive evidence, no one can force Ding Qi to take the initiative to admit that he killed Tian Qi.

At noon on Sunday, in Lu Che's office of the Municipal Public Security Bureau, Lu Che and Xiao Cheng were looking at the surveillance data of Ding Qi's diagnostic meeting with Tian Qi. Unlike the silent video circulating above, the surveillance data has sound, not only the volume is turned to the maximum, but also after technical processing, in an attempt to find out the neglected microsounds in the back noise.

In the second half of the surveillance record, Ding Qi stood opposite Tian Qi with his back hand, and the surveillance camera was facing Ding Qi's side and back, and the expression on his face could not be recorded, and it was impossible to tell if he had said anything to Tian Qi during this time. After standing like this for half an hour, Tian Qi suddenly died of convulsions.

The purpose of the technical processing was to see if Ding Qi had said anything else during that time, but he didn't find out.

In fact, Ding Qi had spoken, and he had whispered softly, like the voice of the devil ringing in Tian Qi's head. But he had tested the equipment in the clinic in advance, and knew that at this angle, the camera could not capture his facial movements, and at this distance, this kind of sound, the microphone could not be collected at all, even through technical means such as noise reduction.

In fact, Lao Lu and Xiao Cheng have watched it several times from beginning to end, and even Lao Lu can see that his scalp is fried, if there is no Director Lu to accompany him, Xiao Cheng himself doesn't want to watch it anymore at all. Lao Lu asked Xiao Cheng again: "You recall it carefully, what was the situation at that time, are you sure you didn't hear Ding Qi say anything later?"

Xiao Cheng palpitated: "Since Dr. Ding patted me on the shoulder, I haven't heard him speak, just like in the surveillance records." But I was a little dazed at the time, although I was awake but I couldn't react, I must have been hypnotized by him, Dr. Ding hypnotized me and Tian Qi."

Lu Che's face turned cold, and he reprimanded: "Xiao Cheng, I want to seriously remind you, don't say this again! A dignified policeman, whose task is to supervise the scene, and his duty is to record the situation and prevent accidents, was he hypnotized without vigilance, is it a shame to be ashamed? If it spreads, you will become a joke of the entire system, and it will have a very bad impact on you.

Xiao Cheng lowered his head and said, "I was defenseless at all, I didn't expect Dr. Ding to lead the education at all, and I was just suspicious, and I didn't tell anyone, I just reported to you." ”

Director Lu: "It's right to report to me, but your suspicions will end here, and they will be held in your stomach and rotten in your heart in the future." Don't forget that you are the only witness on the scene, and every word you say may have an impact on the investigation, so you must talk about it realistically, say whatever you have, and don't say anything that you don't have, just your own blind guess. You're going to go to a meeting with me in a moment, and I'll give you a vaccination first, remember?"

Xiao Cheng nodded and said, "I remember, just four words, seek truth from facts." Speak with evidence and don't add anything else that can't be determined. ”

Lu Che looked at Xiao Cheng again and said, "You seem to be scared?"

Xiao Cheng wiped his sweat and said ashamedly: "You don't know, the scene at that time was too weird. ”

Lu Che's tone became much softer: "It's the first time you've seen a living person die in front of you, right?"

Xiao Cheng lowered his head again: "Yes." ”

Lu Che said earnestly: "You have just joined the work not long ago, and it is normal for some situations to be uncomfortable, but you are a criminal policeman, and you may become a forensic doctor in the future, I am afraid that there will be a lot of bloody and terrifying scenes, and you must have this mental preparation and psychological quality, today's events can be regarded as a workout." ”

Xiao Cheng nodded again and again: "The leader of education is right." ”

Lu Che looked at his watch: "It's almost time, let's go to a meeting, we can't let the bureau leaders wait." When he went out with Xiao Cheng, he glanced back at the computer screen and cursed, "If you die well, I want to kill him! ”

No matter how stupid Xiao Cheng is, he can understand the attitude of the leader at this moment, Director Lu wishes that Tian Qi would die early, and he is very sympathetic to Ding Qi, he just wants to try his best to keep Ding Qi okay. The two of them came to the conference room, where there were already about twenty people. They will formally meet today to draw an internal investigation into the incident and report back to the city leaders.

Originally, the investigation of such an incident could be carried out by the district bureau where the Ankang Hospital is located within the public security system, but because it has become a national social hot spot, the city leaders specially greeted them, and the leaders of the city bureau personally took the lead. The relevant comrades of the district bureau were also present, and Director Tang of the Municipal Public Security Bureau made an opening speech.

Director Tang's speech was not long, to the effect that this matter has become the focus of public opinion, so the city leaders attach great importance to it, and Mayor Song also specially greeted the public security department to come up with the official investigation results as soon as possible. Director Tang also specifically mentioned that the medical appraisal unit was also working overtime this weekend, and the cause of Tian Qi's death had been determined to be cardiogenic respiratory failure.

It is said that cardiogenic respiratory failure should be Tian Qi's own reason. However, the purpose of the public security department's investigation is mainly to see whether Ding Qi has a direct causal relationship with this. Only by clarifying this can the judicial responsibility of Ding Qi be clarified and misunderstandings by the public and the families of the deceased can be avoided.

Some rumors in the society are untrue, Tian Qi was not abused and tortured in Ankang Hospital, although he had many scars on his body, but they were all old injuries, and there were no traces of internal and external injuries left in the past month. So the focus of the investigation is whether Ding Qi is responsible for Tian Qi's death?

At the time of the incident, there were both human and physical evidence, the human evidence was Officer Xiao Cheng, and the physical evidence was the surveillance record. After Director Tang finished speaking, the curtains were lowered, the projector was opened, and everyone watched the surveillance video together. In fact, everyone present had already seen it more than once, but in order to show the formal seriousness of the investigation discussion, everyone still sat together and watched it again from beginning to end.

This look was a full hour, and when the curtains were pulled back up, everyone's faces were not very good-looking, and their expressions were even a little trance and tired. In the first half of the surveillance video, Ding Qi and Tian Qi's "perverted" conversation was creepy. The second half is almost a motionless still image, and whoever stares at it for half an hour will probably not feel good.

Director Tang took off his glasses, rubbed his eyes, and said, "What conclusion do you have?" Lao Lu, you are an expert, you can talk about it first. ”

Lu Che replied angrily: "We have watched the surveillance video many times, and it is the most direct evidence at the scene." The reason why Ankang Hospital keeps this kind of monitoring record is that it is afraid that the accident situation will not be clear. Now that the facts are clear, I would like to ask, should we file a case based on such evidence and then submit it to the procuratorate?"

Director Zhao of the sub-bureau hurriedly shook his head and said, "No, no, no, this can't be opened at all." Even if we file a case and the materials are submitted to the procuratorate, 200% of them will be rejected. Those people from the prosecutor's office are waiting to see our jokes now!"

Lu Che: "Since it is impossible to prosecute, then we should discuss a piece of! So many people don't rest on weekends, just to work overtime and talk nonsense? A murderous psychopathy dies by himself, so he is so busy with the people, working the people and money, is there nothing else to do?" He is a technical official, who has come up with professional qualifications, and sometimes he speaks so stinky and hard.

Director Tang waved his hand helplessly and said: "Lao Lu, you can't say that, we have to give an explanation to the public, and even more to the leaders." If you have something to say, just draw conclusions, there is no need to be emotional. For example, there are now rumors that this Dr. Ding used hypnosis to kill people. ”

Lu Che interrupted him and said, "First of all, let the academic community admit that hypnosis can indeed kill people, and secondly, we must find evidence that can conclusively prove that Ding Qi killed Tian Qi with hypnosis." If you can't do both, it's. We've all watched this video, and if Ding Qi kills someone, then he's the one who killed with his eyes!"

In fact, a lot of what Lu Che said was the voice of many people present, but it was inconvenient for them to express this dissatisfaction. Now that Lu Che has come out, everyone is silent, and some people can't help but want to laugh at this moment.

Lu Che then said loudly: "Then our reconnaissance department must first prove to the people of the world that eyes can kill, and secondly, we must prove in court that Ding Qi did kill Tian Qi with his eyes, comrades, what do you think?"

Everyone finally burst out laughing, and Director Tang saw that the scene was a little out of control, so he quickly knocked on the table and said: "Pay attention to your attitude, be serious!" Our discussion is by no means what we mean, but to come to a conclusion, whether there is a direct causal relationship between Ding Qi's diagnosis and Tian Qi's death, and whether we need to bear legal responsibility for it?"

At this time, Director Zhao of the sub-bureau interjected: "From the perspective of judicial procedures, there is no doubt about the crime, and we cannot be sure that Ding Qi is responsible." ”

Lu Che took over the conversation and said: "Someone went to the mall to buy something, died of a heart attack, and then the family wants to hold the salesperson responsible, it sounds ridiculous, but now there are more and more people who are so ridiculous, do we want to promote this kind of atmosphere?"

Director Tang smiled bitterly: "It seems that the official conclusion has been reached, so how can I report it to the city leaders?"

Lu Che said: "I'll report!"

Director Tang thought for a while and said, "Then I'll take you to report tomorrow, and I have to sort out a formal written material, and I have to get it done tonight." ”

Just after the public security department announced the dismissal of the meeting, a special guest came to the office of Liu Feng of the Mental Health Center of Jinghu University, who was Tian Xianglong, the father of Tian Qi. Tian Xianglong has been exhausted in the past few days, and he has spent a lot of money to issue two waves of revelations one after another, the first wave is to create rumors to exert pressure, and the second wave is to try to fight back in the face of overwhelming abuse, pointing the finger directly at Ding Qi.

However, he was scolded even more, and the social image that he had worked hard to manage for many years plummeted. He is also a good-looking man, but the abuser doesn't seem to understand his pain of losing a child. At this time, I'm afraid that few people can call him over to meet alone, but Liu Feng has been invited, and he has to come.

Tian Xianglong owes Liu Feng a thank you and an apology, Liu Feng is Tian Qi's appraiser, and has made a judicial psychiatric evaluation to exonerate Tian Qi, on the other hand, his son Tian Qi stabbed Liu Feng and almost killed the other party.

In just a few days, Tian Xianglong seemed to have aged a lot, and the hair on his head was even thinner, and after he entered the room, he gave Liu Feng a shallow bow: "Professor Liu, I'm really sorry, I came to make amends to you last time, but you don't want to see me." ”

Liu Feng didn't have a good face, and said coldly: "I am Tian Qi's forensic appraiser, you are Tian Qi's guardian, and you should not have been in private contact in the first place." But today I need to call you here, and there are some things that must be made clear, and I can't watch you make a fool and incite social incidents there. ”

Before the National Day Golden Week, Liu Feng was stabbed by Tian Qi, and Tian Xianglong also came to visit, not only to apologize and make amends, but also to bear medical expenses, recuperation fees and other expenses. But Liu Feng refused, and just passed a message to him to bear the loss of the mental health center, and did not pursue other things.

The immediate loss of the mental health center is that one of the cabinets was broken, and now it has been replaced with a new one. In this office, there is almost no trace of the last incident, except for the trophy. The broken crystal ball on the trophy was glued back with glass glue and placed on Liu Feng's desk at the moment.

Tian Xianglong felt a little weak in his heart, and said in a low voice: "Is there something wrong with Professor Liu looking for me?"

Liu Feng said quietly: "You should already know the news, this morning, the autopsy results came out, and your son died of cardiogenic respiratory failure." The so-called torture and abuse at Ankang Hospital is an outright rumor. Just now, the public security department also came to the conclusion that there is no direct causal relationship between Tian Qi's death and Ding Qi, and Ding Qi does not have to bear any legal responsibility.

But now that some people are spreading rumors everywhere, saying that Ding Qi killed Tian Qi, what evidence is there? Where is the source of the rumors, Boss Tian should know in his heart, right?"

Tian Xianglong raised his head and said: "I also want to pay attention to this, so that I can investigate the facts as soon as possible, and Professor Liu must also understand my feelings, after all, it is my son, my own son."

Liu Feng said coldly: "Your son is a human being, even if he kills someone, even if he does no evil, you must protect him and go through the judicial process to protect him." Ding Qi is my student, and my student is not a human being, and he can slander and slander him at will? The judicial process exonerated Tian Qi, but do you really understand justice, and did you do this before the results of the investigation came out?"

Tian Xianglong explained: "It's the child's mother, she must do this, she thinks that Ding Qi killed my son." ”

Liu Feng diverted the topic and said: "Now that the conclusion has come out, it is impossible to prosecute, Ding Qi does not have to bear legal responsibility, do you still want to file a civil lawsuit?"

Tian Xianglong sighed: "After the lawyer read the surveillance records, he told me that there was no way to file a civil lawsuit. ”

Liu Feng: "Is there no certainty of winning the lawsuit?"

Tian Xianglong shook his head and said, "According to the existing evidence, the court will not accept it at all. ”

Liu Feng's tone softened a little: "This lawyer is not confused, but I also want to ask, put that video on it, and spread rumors that Ding Qi was a murderer, what is going on, is it also the lawyer's idea?"

Tian Xianglong: "It's indeed the lawyer's idea, because my daughter-in-law thinks that Ding Qi killed my son, so I must not let him go." The lawyer gave another suggestion, maybe you can't do anything to Ding Qi in court, but it will definitely not make Ding Qi feel better, and you can bring this person down and make it stink.

The lawyer also said that Ding Qi was not a doctor at Ankang Hospital, and that his presence there may have violated internal rules. There is no direct causal relationship between him and Tian Qi's death, and there is no way to pursue these in court, but as long as he makes a big fuss, he will definitely be punished by Jinghu University, so that this person can't get involved. ”

Liu Feng's face changed again: "Who is the lawyer you hired?"

Tian Xianglong: "The surname is Miao, called Miao Duxin, do you know Professor Liu?"

Liu Feng secretly wrote down the name in his heart, and said: "People with evil hearts, you have to be on guard, it's better to change legal counsel." You keep saying that you mean to be your daughter-in-law, but you are doing everything, and you are contributing money and efforts, harming others and yourself! Since you are telling the truth today, I will also tell you one thing, and you must remember it carefully. ”

Tian Xianglong: "Professor Liu, you said. ”

Liu Feng: "The judicial appraisal has already concluded that Tian Qi's death has nothing to do with Ding Qi, and you were spreading rumors and slander before." And take 10,000 steps back and say, even if someone kills Tian Qi, it is equivalent to saving your life and saving the life of your whole family!"

Tian Xianglong was stunned: "How do you say this?"

Liu Feng: "I have done an assessment for your son, who has delusional mental disorder and is severely aggressive. He can kill, and he has already killed people, and when he has an attack, he will not know his parents, and if he doesn't make it, he will even kill you. It is not uncommon for such psycho patients to have seizures and kill their entire families.

I know your plans, and I want to fish Tian Qi out of Ankang Hospital one day, thinking that he will pass on your ancestry. If you really do this, let alone pass on the lineage, you and your daughter-in-law's lives may not be saved. I don't understand, with the conditions of your husband and wife, the age is not too big, why drill this horn tip and have another one!"

Tian Xianglong bowed his head and said: "Professor Liu, you don't understand the situation, my daughter-in-law has had an operation and can't regenerate."

Liu Feng was stunned, and then sighed: "I understand! There are some suggestions that I am not suitable to say, but you are not a fool, if you must want to pass on the ancestry, you know what to do." ”

Tian Xianglong nodded silently, and Liu Feng said again: "Whether you go to the public prosecution or the civil prosecution, you can't get through." But your wife is irrational and too extreme now, and she still wants to be unfavorable to Ding Qi. The public security department also asked me to say hello, if Ding Qi is injured in any accident, the first suspect will be you, some things are too obvious, you can find out when you check it!"