"With the progress of science and technology and the increasingly detailed division of labor in society, it is indeed possible that human beings' own skills and cultivation learning may be narrowed. However, the main culprit of this narrowing should not be counted on the head of technology, but on the mainstream values of society and the social environment. ”

If you want to summarize the views that Feng Jianxiong and Yu Meiqin have just discussed in the most concise and concise words, it takes 69 words, and it can hardly be simplified. This kind of tricky angle really makes the layman of the debate feel terrible to think about it.

And to say that the most profound understanding of the combat effectiveness of Feng Jianxiong and Yu Meiqin in the field at this moment is undoubtedly Su Qin and Tian Haimo - even the other three opponents of the business school who are playing against Feng Jianxiong on the field are obviously crushed, and they can't reflect where the opponent is.

Because, only Su Qin and Tian Haimo know that Feng Jianxiong's elevation of the debate today is something that the University of Malaya team led by Hu Biao, the "King of Malay Spraying", three years ago, had never imagined.

At that time, many members of the University of Malaya team resisted steadily, but finally failed on the point that "the development of science and technology will inevitably lead to the learning of human skills tends to be sophisticated and not knowledgeable". In the end, we can only stick to the second core point of this debate, that is, "whether the excessive use of scientific and technological tools will lead to the low and deterioration of some traditional human abilities".

It's a pity that on the second point, the University of Malaya team also failed to have a clear advantage, so it finally lost to the Wanwan team in Bai Zhizhong.

"Feng Jianxiong can attack from such a tricky angle, doesn't it mean that he already has a level close to the 'Malay Squirting King'?

Host Su Qin's mind crossed a terrible thought.

Malaya is certainly not a great country, with a population of just over 30 million, and although it participates in the Chinese-language international college debate tournament, in fact, the population of the country that speaks Chinese is only more than half.

In other words, even if you fight all over the country in Malaya and get it to China, it is only the level of "dominating half of the province".

And now that this topic has been reviewed for more than two years, there are many people who have studied it, even if the level of performance is better than back then, there is a suspicion of hindsight.

But in any case, Su Qin estimated that if Feng Jianxiong could maintain today's level, or even make progress, it would be no problem to "dominate half of Jiangnan Province". In other words, in addition to the Jinling University team, he can already beat invincible opponents in the province.

If Feng Jianxiong is really so strong, where will he be diligent?

It's chilling to think about.

It should be just a coincidence, in the final analysis, it is with the help of Yu Meiqin's broad vision. At the beginning, Hu Biao and Huang Zhizhong couldn't imagine this layer, it should be just that East Asian civilizations are too utilitarian in terms of reading teleology, and they can't look at the outside world. Well, definitely. ”

Su Qin comforted himself and felt better.

After all, East Asian civilization has believed since ancient times that "learning and excellence will lead to excellence", and reading well should be rewarded. So much so that no matter what major you study now, you always feel that you should be able to find a job, and if you can't find it, the society is not good, or your grades are not good.

But in fact, many college students who are majoring in the profession should not be able to find a job in their daily life! The major they study is not inherently for work!

Isn't it natural to read history, read sociology, and fight the streets for the rest of your life? Why struggle? These things are meant to be fun for you to learn as a hobby. Is the mode of thinking still stuck in the era of feudal imperial examinations?

Therefore, the lethality of Yu Meiqin's words just now can almost be compared with that Peking University professor Sun Dongdong, who has always been unstoppable-

In addition to "99% of the old petitioners are mentally ill", Professor Sun also made a shocking remark, that is, "the reason why there are many medical disputes and the conflicts between doctors and patients are intensified is that the expectations of the people are wrong."

Everyone expects that when they get sick and go to the hospital, they will go in lying down and come out standing. In fact, the common people should be guided to make it normal to go in standing and come out lying down. It is normal for a doctor to die, and it is a surprise to be cured, so there are not so many doctor-patient disputes. ”

Yu Meiqin's "It's normal to go to college and can't find a job, and you should be grateful if you find it", which can be regarded as the same thing. Ordinary people can't think of it, so what's so strange.

……

The host Su Qin was thinking wildly in his head, and he didn't realize that the free debate in the venue was already halfway through.

After two minutes of fierce firefighting, the business school team led by Tian Haimo unsurprisingly completely lost on the first point.

Now, they are sticking to the last point of the debate.

Tian Haimo puffed up Yu Yong, and eloquently argued:

"May I ask the opponent's defense friend, people who use too many computers cannot concentrate, use too many mobile phones, fragment their reading habits, use too many calculators, and reduce the mental arithmetic ability of primary school students - these are several ironclad facts, we have previously adduced sufficient research evidence to prove, do you still want to deny them?

This is not enough to prove that the development of science and technology and the abuse of scientific and technological tools have led to the degradation of some human skills? You can't blame this on the social system!"

Feng Jianxiong didn't seem to have consumed much sharpness because of the previous few minutes of confrontation, and his response was still calm and composed:

"Even if we admit that using too many mobile phones will lead to a person's lack of concentration and fragmented reading ability - but please pay attention to the opponent's defense friend, even if a person's reading is fragmented, does he read more or less?

If, although he loses patience, he reads more widely, doesn't this prove that the progress of science and technology has made people's development more comprehensive? The ancients' mental arithmetic ability has not degraded, and it is even very strong. But it's based on the premise that they don't know much, so what's there to be proud of in that ability?"

Speaking of this, the other three people in the business school are already making soy sauce, and they can only rely on Tian Haimo to continue to be tired without rest:

"But the qualities of 'focus' and 'patience' are also excellent qualities that human beings need to 'develop'. Once again, I would like to remind the opposing side of the debate that the topic we are talking about today is about the 'all-round development of human beings', not just 'the all-round development of human knowledge and skills'. If human beings lose their virtues and qualities because of the progress of science and technology, even if they have acquired a wide range of knowledge and skills, it will also be in full development!"

"That's a good point! Sister Tian said it so well!" The atmosphere in the venue was slightly saved, and countless spectators who originally thought that the business school would lose also nodded slightly, secretly praising Tian Haimo for finding a good entry point.

There is no longer much value in talking about skills with law schools, since we are talking about all-round development, we will bring in all the factors of comprehensive quality of people.

Moreover, although Feng Jianxiong and Yu Meiqin's previous debate skills were exquisite, in general, their views were too cold, and the social prospects revealed were too cold, which made many people emotionally unwilling to accept them.

So even if Feng Jianxiong has a lot of fans, now that he sees Tian Haimo fighting back with morality and quality, he can't help but want to stand with Tian Haimo.

After all, even if the weak know that "the strong will rule the world" is a truth, they still subconsciously want to huddle together to keep warm.

Feng Jianxiong captured the change in the atmosphere of the manufacturer, he carefully considered it, and retorted in a tone of discussion: "However, I don't think that the development of science and technology will damage the virtues and qualities of human beings such as 'focus, patience, and perseverance'. Senior Sister Tian, the argument you just cited has no causal relationship at all. There are computers, mobile phones, and calculators, and when you use them, they will be fragmented and make people lose patience - then you don't need to, no one will force you to use them. Even if you have to use it because of work and study, you can use it in moderation. ”

Tian Haimo immediately sneered: "How can you not use it! The progress of science and technology will force you to use it by the whole society." Once it is used, no matter how moderate and controlled it is, it can only be done by a few people with an extremely strong will, and the general public cannot do it. According to the data of Yang Zhaomeng, an authority in the Internet addiction and withdrawal industry, there are 200,000 Internet addicted teenagers in Jinling alone. There are millions of Internet addicts in the country who should be electrotherapy because of World of Warcraft, are you going to turn a blind eye to these data?

Does the opponent's defense friend want to tell us that harming the moral integrity of the general public is not 'inhibiting the all-round development of mankind', but must be 'even the most determined among the human beings has been harmed', then it is really called 'inhibiting the all-round development of mankind'?"

It's 06 years now, and "World of Warcraft" is at its hottest, and it's also the year when the mainstream media is most criticized for Internet addiction. The name of the magnetic storm infantry Yang called the beast is now known to everyone.

Feng Jianxiong heard that the other party had moved out this great god, and hurriedly denied it: "Of course I didn't mean that! But I think that this kind of people who can't control themselves and become addicted are still a minority, not the mainstream of society."

How can those people blame the development of science and technology for their poor self-control? A person who cannot control himself and is mentally empty, even if he travels back 100 years, without a game console or a computer, maybe he will still smoke a cigarette. If society can find something meaningful for him, he can easily do it even if he quits DU, let alone Internet addiction! So this is still a social problem, not a technology problem. ”

Tian Haimo couldn't help but be stunned when she heard Feng Jianxiong's last two sentences, as if she had heard something ridiculous that did not conform to basic logic: "Are you kidding? You said that quitting DU can be done by willpower or 'finding something more meaningful'?

"I can give you a real-life example – everyone should have heard of the KB attack at Heathrow Airport in London, England last year. Originally, in the eyes of the British security department, according to their perennial experience in handling cases, KB elements should have come from the Middle East.

But this time at Heathrow, they were dumbfounded enough to capture a decent native Briton among the operatives - a young man in his 20s, his father was a decent property developer, his mother was a professor at the University of Edinburgh, but his son was not a good student, a gentleman, a drug addict with a history of 7 years.

His parents had tried all means to get him to quit DU and do something serious, but to no avail. Until two years before the incident, he quit DU without warning, and even his parents didn't know it. Later, when the investigators reviewed the case, they found out that he had come into contact with some extremists from the Middle East two years ago, and then converted to their religion, and his family told him that 'people with DU addiction are easy to be noticed by the police, which is not conducive to carrying out their work', and then he quit DU without saying a word - so, it turns out that most addictions should not be blamed on objects or even technology itself, but just a person's spiritual emptiness. After he found his faith, he can even quit this kind of thing, what is Internet addiction? If he can't quit, that's a human problem, don't let technology take the blame. ”