There was a brief silence.

"Still not right!"

"This argument is untenable!"

"Yes, it can't be written by Gao E!"

"Although there is no evidence, but, what evidence is needed for this?"

Many people who are not the elective course of "Appreciation of Classical Masterpieces" are also talking about it, but at this time, everyone also feels that this class is worth it, because no matter what Zhang Ye's point of view is, this open class will definitely cause a sensation in the education and literature circles!

Xueba Sister Song just kept standing and didn't sit down at all, because after sitting down, she had to stand up and ask questions, it was too troublesome, she had too many questions about Zhang Ye's point of view, I saw her raise her hand, and spoke directly, "I'm sorry Teacher Zhang Ye, I still can't accept your point of view, the evidence that Gao He wrote in the last forty times is still not enough to explain the problem, there is too little information, too much imagination out of thin air, and Gao He is a person who is responsible for sorting out the books, and he does not have the literacy to write "Dream of Red Mansions", so it is impossible to continue to write so well." ”

Zhang Ye shook his fingers, "Xiao Song, you're wrong." ”

"Why?" asked Senior Sister Song rhetorically.

Other teachers and students from Peking University also looked at Zhang Ye.

Zhang Ye swore again, "Gao He has the quality and conditions to continue writing "Dream of Red Mansions", and in that era, I think only Gao He has it! Hehe, don't look at me like this, you may not know enough about Gao E, most of you just know that he is a collator, but you don't know his other background, if you don't believe it, okay, I am arguing from the perspective of information above, and I will talk about it from the perspective of feelings, well, this paragraph is actually not the point, you can talk about it or not, do you want to hear it?"

"Yes!"

"Of course you have to listen!"

"It's a must!"

Senior Sister Song also nodded.

Disagree or disagree, but everyone still wants to hear it.

Zhang Ye said, "Then I'll briefly say that Gao He has always been a preservator, disseminator and organizer, in fact, many people don't know, in fact, Gao E's literary literacy is his most dazzling." He saw Professor Zeng below nodding slightly, and said, "Professor Zeng seems to understand." ”

Professor Zeng affirmed: "What Mr. Zhang said is right, everything that has a purpose, forgiveness is appreciated - this is the evaluation of Gao Yi by the people of that era. ”

Zhang Ye said with a smile: "That's the case, Gao He is a very talented person, with the words of distress and frustration, talent can summarize Gao E's life, and he has a similar life experience with Cao Xueqin. Advise the disciples to be loyal and filial piety and take the road of career. His eight-strand essay is very well written, his thinking is fine, and his pen is strong. In his poems, he often smeared the sentimental feelings of life like a dream with a layer of Buddha color. We can vaguely feel all of this in the last forty episodes of "A Dream of Red Mansions", so from the perspective of feelings, Gao He was the most suitable person to continue writing "A Dream of Red Mansions" in that era, and he was also capable of doing it!"

After a pause, Zhang Ye said: "I said before that Gao E's continuation of the Red Mansion is a bit out of place with the previous one, but that is just a difference in personal style, I did not deny Gao E, on the contrary, I still respect him very much, he wrote the ending for the Red Mansion, which facilitated the wide dissemination of "Dream of Red Mansions", and Gao He has made great contributions!"

Sweat!

The more you say it, the more true it becomes!

A senior student of Peking University in the Department of History suddenly raised his hand and spoke, "The qiē you said is based on the premise that "Dream of Red Mansions" is continued by people after 80 episodes, I think it is not a question of arguing whether it is Gao E's continuation or an anonymous resume, but ...... Why do you say that only 80 episodes of "Dream of the Red Chamber" are the original manuscripts of Mr. Cao Xueqin? Why do you say that the 120 episodes of "Dream of the Red Chamber" were continued by people and not the original works of Mr. Cao Xueqin? Is it just a poem by a Qing Dynasty poet and a small note with 80 words?"

Zhang Ye smiled and said, "You're quite excited." ”

The history student couldn't help but laugh and cry, "Can you not be excited, what you said is too subversive of cognition, we have learned all the history lessons wrong for so many years? The educational circles of the entire republic have made a low-level mistake? Even the author of "Dream of the Red Chamber", one of the four famous novels, has not been clarified?"

This is also the main reason why everyone doesn't believe Zhang Ye!

With so many experts and so many scholars, could it be that all of them are wrong?

Although the truth is often in the hands of a few, you are one of the few!

One is the educational and academic circles, the authority within the authorities.

One is Zhang Ye, a hooligan in the literary circle and a thorn in the broadcasting and hosting circle.

Who do you say is more trustworthy? The answer is already clear at a glance, no need to ask!

"We have no evidence to refute your ......"

"Yes, but you can't argue with that!"

It's like "Journey to the West", you have to say that this book was not actually written by Wu Chengen, but by Wu Chengen's twin brother, and his twin brother was also named Wu Chengen, and he impersonated Wu Chengen since he was a child, but only Wu Chengen's family knew that Wu Chengen was not Wu Chengen, but his brother, and others didn't know that this Wu Chengen was not that Wu Chengen, but they thought that Wu Chengen was Wu Chengen -- if you really want to say that, isn't it okay? If someone expresses this point of view, and no one else can refute it without evidence, then "Journey to the West" Does the author have to be changed?

In that way, the literary world will not be chaotic!

But Zhang Ye said: "Who said I have no evidence to refute?"

Senior Zhou, a junior in the Chinese department, said: "But all the information you just now ......"

With a smile, Zhang Ye said: "It's just an opening just now, to help everyone get into the atmosphere, since I dare to let go of my words like this, I naturally have other evidence and materials to corroborate it, so first of all, I want to ask you one thing, the earliest ancient books of "Dream of Red Mansions", except for the version compiled by Gao E, whether it is this book or that book, among the earliest ancient books that have been handed down, are there any stories recorded more than eighty times later?"

Everyone was stunned.

"Is there one?"

"I don't know. ”

"Uh, wait for me to search!"

The students began to take out their phones to check the facts.

Professor Zeng also frowned, closed his eyes and contemplated, recalling.

A Peking University student from the Department of Liberal Arts suddenly said, "Yes! There is an ancient book here that is one hundred and twenty times!"

Zhang Ye smiled, "This classmate, then you check again, in which era this ancient book was printed and issued, I can tell you, the original of this ancient book you read is only thirty-five retrospectives, and it was supplemented and printed after 1791, it was changed, and it was added unchanged according to Gao E's version." "He also did a lot of homework.

The liberal arts student checked it, sweated for a while and stopped talking, really.

Professor Zeng and Chang Kaige Zhen Shuquan also have a few children, strange, there really isn't!

Zhang Ye spread his hands and said: "So the most complete ancient book you have ever read is compiled by Gao E, which was printed and distributed in 1791, so I have a question, why has there been no story after eighty times in all the ancient books before?

Yao Mi spoke, "Because the ancient book was lost and destroyed, it was too powerful?"

The preservation of the ancient copy of "Dream of Red Mansions" in this world is indeed miserable.

But Zhang Ye said: "But it's too coincidental, isn't it? Don't you all have this doubt? Some of the ancient books are only a dozen times left, and some are a little more, and forty or fifty times have been preserved, but these ancient books, which are much older than Gao E's version, have not recorded the story after 80 times, and in 1791, all of a sudden, "Dream of Red Mansions" suddenly appeared 120 complete ancient books, and from a logical point of view, is it too strange? If the last 40 chapters were also written by Cao Xueqin, why is there no Cheng Weiyuan? Someone other than Gao Yi copied it? No one else got it from the 'drum burden'? Such a large space, even if you can't copy it completely, you can copy part of it. But why before Cheng Weiyuan and Gao E, no one copied out even one copy of the text and attached it to the back of the first eighty times?"

This question stopped many people at once!

Even a few Peking University teachers who had studied "Dream of Red Mansions" choked for a while!