Senior Sister Song spoke, "It may be a coincidence, this is not evidence." ”

Zhang Ye shook his head, "Coincidence can't be explained, the only explanation is that the real Cao Xueqin's "Dream of Red Mansions" has only been handed down eighty times, and Gao He saw it, he studied it carefully, and continued to write, and Gao He was very lucky, he saw a relatively complete eighty ancient books that we have not seen, but it can't be said that we have not seen them at all, because Gao E's version has already issued this eighty ancient books, of course, it has been modified and filled in by him, but it has not changed in general." ”

Senior Sister Song insisted: "Then why didn't Gao He get an ancient copy of "Dream of Red Mansions" one hundred and twenty times and sort it out and publish it?"

Zhang Ye didn't answer this question, but said, "Who of you has ever heard of this person?"

Senior Sister Song shook her head.

Many Peking University students also shook their heads.

There is only one elementary school girl from the history department who said in a crisp voice: "It's also an ancient book, I remember calling it Fat Yan Zhai to re-evaluate the stone record, but this ancient book has not been handed down a few times, it is the most incomplete, and the comments in it are also some inexplicable, so many experts, scholars and red science lovers do not count this as an ancient book, because they think it is not very authoritative, and it may be written casually." ”

The students looked it up on the Internet, and sure enough, there was this ancient book.

"That's right. Zhang Ye said with a smile: "The ancient book of Fat Yan Zhai is not taken seriously, one is too incomplete, and the other is that it is not understood, so everyone has never studied it seriously, even if it is studied, it is passed by, I don't care much, hehe, but I want to tell everyone here now, if I can't understand it, I will say that it is not reasonable to be written by graffiti, which in itself is disrespectful to academics, in fact, the ancient book of Fat Yan Zhai is the most authoritative version of the ancient book of "Dream of Red Mansions" that has been handed down to this day!" In Zhang Ye's earth, the ancient book of Fat Yan Zhai is the most complete and detailed commentary, and he has read the original version!

"How could it be!" Senior Sister Song didn't believe it.

Many students at Peking University also shook their heads.

Zhang Ye's expression was mocking, "It's just that the people who study the ancient books of Yan Zhai can't understand what he says, but others can't understand it, I understand, I believe that if you base your thinking on the premise that "Dream of Red Mansions" is only eighty times, you can also understand it." He took out another piece of information, which is the existing information stored in this world, although Zhang Ye has read the original version of several ancient books in Fat Yan Zhai, but this world has almost all been lost, and he can't talk about this, so he can only use the existing evidence.

Everyone looked up.

Zhang Ye pointed to the projection and said: "Fat Yan Zhai has such a comment, Jia Baoyu later 'choked on sour food in the cold winter, and broke the felt on a snowy night', I want to ask, does the first 80 episodes of the 120 chapters of "Dream of Red Mansions" have this plot? No! Is there such a plot in the last 40 episodes? No!" and pointed again, "In Fat Yan Zhai's comment, Xiaohong helped rescue Baoyu in the 'Prison God Temple', is there this plot in the last 40 episodes? Or no! Even what the 'Prison God Temple' is in the last 40 episodes! Even simply Yan Zhai directly told us in the comments that one of the eighty times was returned, called-Xue Baochai borrowed words with sarcasm, Wang Xifeng knew that he was a strong hero, did he have this back in the last forty times?

Senior Zhou said: "This comment itself is not authoritative. ”

Zhang Ye asked rhetorically: "Then what is authoritative? If an ancient document cannot be called authoritative, the research of red scholars is considered authoritative? What is the reason? We rely on known materials to study Dream of Red Mansions, and do you think that the ancients of Fatty Yanzhai were idle and had nothing to do? Just to mislead everyone, they wrote something headless and brainless?"

"Uh, this ......" Senior Zhou was also speechless.

Senior Sister Song carried it and said: "Fat Yanzhai may have communicated with Cao Xueqin, thinking that Cao Xueqin would write like this, and some plots and retrospective names were revealed, which is what we now call the outline, but in the end, Cao Xueqin did not write according to the previous ideas, which is also possible!"

Zhang Ye looked at her and said, "But don't you think the tone in Fatty Yanzhai's comments is too sure? His tone is not hearsay a little bit of Cao Xueqin's thinking, but he has really seen or knows the story after eighty times! Fatty Yanzhai is very determined! Therefore, the reason why Fatty Yanzhai's comments are incomprehensible to the world is because of "Dream of Red Mansions" The story after eighty times is not Cao Xueqin's original intention, but Gao E's continued writing, Fat Yan Zhai is too critical to the process of studying Red Studies, he may be Cao Xueqin's wife, may be Cao Xueqin's father, or may be Cao Xueqin's close friend, we don't know, but I can be sure of one thing, this Fat Yan Zhai is not an ordinary person who has only borrowed the manuscript of the Dream of Red Mansions! It can be seen from the comments! Fat Yan Zhai participated in the entire creation of "A Dream of Red Mansions"! He is reading, I wrote the comment after communicating and discussing with Cao Xueqin!"

Another bomb!

It's blowing up in the auditorium again!

A red researcher has never faced up to the fat Yan Zhai, but Zhang Ye said that he was the most authoritative and participated in the creation of "Dream of Red Mansions".

You're going to be more talkative, not amazing, and you're going to die!

The students of Peking University have fried the pot again, and they are looking at each other!

A Peking University girl from the history department quibbled, "Even if what you say is reasonable, there is no record of the history of this person, he is still a pen name, his origin is unknown, he doesn't know whether he is a man or a woman, of course his words are not credible, and they cannot be used as evidence." ”

Zhang Ye was happy, "I don't agree with this, from the comments, we can already see the close relationship between Fat Yan Zhai and Cao Xueqin, what we don't know is just what the specific identity of Fat Yan Zhai is, not from an unknown origin, if Fat Yan Zhai is to be regarded as an unknown origin, according to what you say, Cao Xueqin is also a person of unknown origin, our academic and red academic circles still can't figure out whether Cao Xueqin is Cao Hao's son or Cao Fu's son, so these identities cannot be used as negative evidence. ”

Cao Xueqin is also unknown?

The history girl's face was red and white, and finally she sat down.

"And, I'm sure a lot of people haven't noticed, and even countless red scientists haven't noticed a thing. Zhang Ye uploaded the information again, pointed to the projection and said: "You can see, this is one of the ancient books of "Dream of Red Mansions", a manuscript, there are many errors, and there are also big problems with typesetting, compared with many ancient books, it is not on the table, but there is a very important information hidden in such an ancient book, you look here, do you see it, this line seems to be mistaken, there are more words in plain language, if you look at these words alone, you can't understand anything, but what if this is the case?" Zhang Ye took another piece of information and spelled it out.

The crowd exclaimed.

"That's right!"

"Why is this line the same?"

"This is the comment of Fat Yan Zhai?"

"Damn! How can the comments of Fat Yan Zhai be in other ancient books?"

Professor Cao and others were also shocked, the handwriting and handwriting were obviously different, not written by one person, but ...... The words turned out to be the same!

Zhang Ye kept smiling, this is a confident smile that has already mastered a qiē information, "Dream of Red Mansions" has been studied to the "sweat pores" in his world, it can't be more transparent, and many things have already been decided, Zhang Ye is a broadcast host again, and his mouth is very slippery, so the people present, even the people in this world, can't talk about him in the field of Red Mansions.

He said, "It's already clear, isn't it? The person who wrote this ancient book also referred to the version of Fat Yan Zhai, so here he was a little distracted, and the result was a mistake, and he directly put a comment on Fat Yan Zhai inexplicably, and I didn't want to do it with the text before and after, many people have read here, but I thought it was a typo or confused, so I didn't care and didn't study it deeply, but I studied it, and everyone saw it, this sentence is actually a comment on the head and tail of Fat Yan Zhai in a certain time, or the original words!

Zhang Ye gave another example, "If you don't believe in this ancient book, then there is still this paragraph, which is simply the Gao Yi version, and it is also the words in a hundred and twenty times that everyone commonly sees." ”

The details are as follows:

Then he came to the cherished spring room. Because of the young spring, I haven't learned anything yet. I was so frightened that I didn't know what was going on, so Sister Feng had to comfort her, but she found a large bag of silver bills in the painting box, about thirty or forty in total. In order to detect adultery, he got thieves. There is also a pair of jade belt plates, and a bag of men's boots and socks.

Zhang Ye looked at the people below, "The sentence in it 'In order to investigate adultery, but to get thieves', if someone who is careful has read all the ancient books of "Dream of Red Mansions", they will find that there is no such sentence in it, but only in the version of Fat Yan Zhai, this sentence is not Cao Xueqin's original text at all, in order to investigate adultery, but to get thieves - this is the comment of Fat Yan Zhai at all!" plus a comparison of information, so that everyone can see clearly, "Look, the source is here!" Of course, it can't be that Fat Yan Zhai mistakenly copied Gao E's ancient book, and the logic doesn't make sense at all, so this is the situation where the missing fat batch is mistakenly mixed into the text of Gao E's version, because Gao Yi is using the ancient book of Gao Yan Zhai as a template!"

"This ......"

"Really!"

"What does this mean?"

"yes, what does that mean?"

Several students couldn't help but ask.

Even Professor Zeng couldn't help but say, "What do you think?"

Zhang Ye smiled slightly, "In this case, I think, or I can be sure, that all the ancient books of "A Dream of Red Mansions" actually come from the Fat Yan Zhai Re-evaluation of the Stone Record, and all the versions of "A Dream of Red Mansions", including the Gao Que version system, are all derived from the Fat Commentary system!" And the most complete ancient book in Gao E's hand, which I just said, that everyone has not read, can actually be concluded to be the version of Fat Yan Zhai, but one of the versions of Fat Yan Zhai has been handed down and is incomplete and Yan zhòng, and we found it and didn't care, but what Gao He got was a relatively complete eighty rounds of "Dream of Red Mansions" by Fat Yan Zhai! So under this inference, the comments of Fat Yan Zhai are too precious and quite reliable, so some of the comments I said about Fat Yan Zhai after eighty times are valid, which also shows that " After eighty episodes of "Dream of Red Mansions", it was not written by Cao Xueqin at all!"

"Really?"

"I'm tired!"

The students of Peking University are in a commotion!

Even Professor Zeng and a few teachers who had a deep understanding of "Dream of Red Mansions" obviously showed shocked looks on their faces for the first time! Zhang Ye's citation at this moment, the support and analytical reasoning of the data and literature, it seems that it is really not impossible!

Wu Zeqing smiled, and now he won't pretend to play with his mobile phone!

Chang Kaige and Zhen Shuquan of the Chinese Department were finally a little shaken!