Although Xia Qing and Gao Yuan met several times during the period of separation, Gao Yuan came to Zhang Fang's house to beg Xia Qing to go home with him, but Xia Qing insisted on divorce, she said that it was too crowded to sleep three people in one bed. Ladies and gentlemen, you can think about it from Ms. Xia Qing's point of view, is it still necessary to maintain such a marriage? ”

Again there was an uncontrollable burst of exclamation, and the chatter rang out again. Presiding Judge Li Ming struck the gavel again, "Silence, silence!" ”

Wang Yuhe continued: "Ms. Xia Qing has given Gao Yuan a chance, but he has not seized it. On the other hand, they have been separated for more than half a year, and in the past six months, Ms. Xia Qing has been living at the house of her friend Miss Zhang Fang, and now that Miss Zhang Fang is present, she can testify. Judge, do you need Zhang Fang to testify? ”

Li Ming said: "Yes, please ask the witness to come forward." ”

Zhang Fang stood on the witness stand. Wang Yuhe began to ask: "Miss Zhang Fang, can you take legal responsibility for your words?" ”

"Yes, I promise you're true."

"Okay, may I ask Miss Zhang Fang, what is the relationship between you and Ms. Xia Qing?"

"Good friends."

"Why did she come to your house?"

"Because her marriage with her husband is in crisis, her husband cheats, and she wants a divorce."

"Then has she ever been back to her husband's apartment in the past six months?"

"No, not once."

Wang Yuhe turned to Li Ming, "Judge, my question is over. ”

Li Ming said: "Please leave the witnesses." Zhang Fang returned to the audience.

Li Ming said: "Plaintiff lawyer, do you have anything else to add?" ”

Wang Yuhe said: "No. ”

Clerk Zhu Lei took an appraisal and handed it to Li Ming, "Judge Li, the recording just now has been identified." ”

The judge looked at it, and then announced it on the spot. "The recording of the conversation just submitted by the plaintiff has been authenticated by the court and is accepted by this court."

Gao Yuan and Yang Minghai were dumbfounded. Gao Yuan thought to himself when Liu Xiaolan met Xia Qing and left this recording, what did they want to do? It's really the most poisonous woman's heart. He decided to interrogate Liu Xiaolan after returning to the company. He understands that with this recording, his cheating is already a certainty.

Li Ming said: "Now I ask the defendant's lawyer to defend in court. ”

The authenticity of the recording greatly reduced Yang Minghai's confidence, he didn't expect the other party to come to this hand at all, and now his original plan has been disrupted, and the defense strategy needs to be adjusted.

Yang Minghai quickly adjusted his mood and began to refute Wang Yuhe's statement, he said: "My client, Mr. Gao Yuan, is a successful person, has a successful career, and there are naturally many women who admire him, and the statements of the plaintiff's lawyer in front may not be all facts, and it is difficult for outsiders to understand marriage in depth, there is a good saying that 'marriage is like wearing shoes, and only those who wear shoes know whether they fit or not', we can't judge the breakdown of their marriage just based on the words of the plaintiff Ms. Xia Qing, We should listen again to what Mr. Takato has to say. ”

Yang Minghai faced Gao Yuan, "Mr. Gao Yuan, do you still love Ms. Xia Qing?" ”

Gao Yuan's face was a little red, he was angry with the recording just now. He adjusted his mentality and said: "Of course I still love her, I never thought of divorcing her, now maybe she doesn't love me anymore, I only learned a few days ago that she has empathized with her, she is likely to like a surgeon, in fact, the person who cheats should be her and not me." ”

Xia Qing looked at Gao Yuan angrily, and was about to open his mouth to refute, but was stopped by Wang Yuhe, Wang Yuhe said: "Don't argue with him, some things will get darker and darker, he is in a hurry now, so he wants to clear his name by thinking of such clumsy words, you just ignore him." ”

Wang Yuhe stood up and said: "I oppose the defendant's words, now it is the court, please don't talk about it, and if there is no basis, please retract it." ”

Li Ming said: "The opposition is valid, please state the facts of the defendant, and do not say anything if there is no evidence." ”

Gao Yuan looked at Yang Minghai helplessly, Yang Minghai gave him a look and asked him not to make remarks easily, so as not to disgust the judges, and it would be beneficial for us to restrain a little. Yang Minghai turned to Xia Qing, "Ms. Xia Qing, as far as I know, you are pregnant, and the child in your womb is Mr. Gao Yuan's. Am I right? ”

Xia Qing was afraid that they would talk about the child, she knew in advance that they would definitely make a fuss about the child, Wang Yuhe also knew that Xia Qing was pregnant, and he was ready to deal with it. Xia Qing looked at Wang Yuhe, and Wang Yuhe nodded to her encouragingly, "It's okay, you can say it." ”

Xia Qing met Yang Minghai's gaze and said, "I am pregnant, and the child is indeed lofty." ”

Yang Minghai smiled, "Everyone heard it, right?" Since he has no feelings, how can he still be willing to get pregnant for Mr. Gao Yuan? Just imagine, if a woman doesn't love a man, will she bear a baby for him? ”

Wang Yuhe hurriedly refuted: "I object, judge, the defendant's lawyer is misleading everyone, I think his statement is not all right, there have been many cases, that is, some women are ** caused to become pregnant, is she willing to give birth to a child for ** criminal?" ”

As soon as Wang Yuhe's words landed, they attracted a burst of laughter, and everyone actually agreed with Wang Yuhe's statement. Judge Li Ming also felt that Yang Minghai's statement was a bit ridiculous, he couldn't help laughing, he knocked on the gavel, "Keep quiet!" Objections are valid. ”

Yang Minghai felt very helpless, he continued: "Judge, what I said is the truth, Gao Yuan and Xia Qing are husband and wife, and there is no such thing as ** between them, so I think they had feelings before this. Forget it, what I want to elaborate on below is the issue of the child, no matter how the final verdict is, we must first make the problem of the child clear, Ms. Xia Qing has no formal job, she quit her job before that, and now her income is not stable, I think that the child will be born in the future, and it should be raised by Mr. Gao Yuan. ”

Wang Yuhe hurriedly said: "I object, the verdict has not yet come down, and it is too early to talk about the custody of the child." ”

Li Ming said: "The objection is valid, the defendant's lawyer, please ask you to ask questions about the divorce or explain your views." ”

Yang Minghai thought about it and felt that the current situation was very unfavorable to Gao Yuan, and the recording in their hands was ironclad evidence, and it couldn't change the situation at all. He had no choice but to say: "Gao Yuan has indeed made a mistake that a man can make, and no one is perfect, who has not made a mistake?" You can't be doomed to divorce just because of one cheating, right? At that time, there were more couples who needed to divorce, so I always believed that their current situation was not divorced, and the relationship had not broken down. ”

Li Ming said: "Does the plaintiff's lawyer have anything else to say? ”

Everyone fell silent, perhaps pondering questions about marriage and cheating.