Wang Yuhe said: "Personally, I think it is very inappropriate for Gao Yuan to do this, and I am very puzzled by what he did. Presiding Judge, to sum up, all kinds of facts show that the relationship between the plaintiff Xia Qing and the defendant Gao Yuan has been seriously broken, and there is no need for their marriage to continue any longer, so I ask the presiding judge to agree to their divorce. That's my statement. Thank you!"

Presiding Judge Li Ming said: "Lawyer for the defendant, what else do you have to add? ”

Yang Minghai thought that at this time, he could only be a dead horse and a live horse doctor, and he wanted to start with the ambiguous relationship between Xia Qing and Dr. Xiao, so that there might be a chance of winning. Yang Minghai said: "Judge, I have a few questions to ask the plaintiff, Ms. Xia Qing. ”

Li Ming said, "Didn't you ask just now?"

"Now a new question comes to mind. ”

Li Ming and the two clerks pondered it for a while, and then tacitly agreed. Li Ming said, "Okay, give you ten minutes." ”

Yang Minghai turned to Xia Qing, "Ms. Xia Qing, may I ask what happened between you and Dr. Xiao Mo? Is there an ambiguous relationship?"

Xia Qing looked at Yang Minghai very angrily, and only after a while did she say: "I haven't had an affair with Xiao Mo, this is completely nonsense, you are a lawyer, you should have professional ethics, and you should know that groundless speculation is very inappropriate and a kind of damage to my reputation." ”

In order to avenge Gao Yuan, Yang Minghai was almost aggressive towards Xia Qing, and he said, "Please answer the question head-on." Don't judge my work ethic. ”

"I didn't!"

"And how do you explain having dinner with you?"

"I didn't say anything to explain, we met by chance, I went back to the hospital that day for a follow-up, and I happened to meet him, he had operated on me, and I treated him to a meal in order to thank him, and it was as simple as that. ”

Seeing that Yang Minghai was making trouble unreasonably, Wang Yuhe immediately retorted: "Presiding judge, I oppose the defendant's agent conducting unreasonable cross-examination of my client, and these issues have nothing to do with this case. ”

The presiding judge, Li Ming, and the others deliberated for a moment, and then said: "This is the end of this issue, and the defendant's lawyer is invited to answer the next question." ”

Xia Qing let out a long sigh of relief. Yang Minghai continued: "As far as I know, Gao Yuan and Xia Qing are college classmates, they came together naturally after graduating from college, they have been together for fourteen years now, over the years, the relationship between them has been very good, if there is a little conflict, it is only a matter of the last few months. Then I would like to ask the plaintiff, was Gao Yuan good to you in the past? ”

Xia Qing thought for a while and said, "It was good to me before. ”

"What's a good idea?"

"I don't worry about food and clothing, and I am relatively rich in material terms. ”

"What else?"

"No more. ”

"Absolutely. You're pregnant now, which means that you don't have no feelings between you as you say, right? If the relationship between husband and wife really breaks down, they won't share a bed at all, let alone **, right?"

Yang Minghai got off the donkey down the slope, "It can be seen that since they still have the crystallization of love before, it can be concluded that they are not completely without affection, but only because of various trivial factors in life that cause a crisis in their relationship." Let me ask you, what couple doesn't quarrel or make awkward?"

"I'm against it. Wang Yuhe said, "The defendant's agent is simply nonsense, pregnancy and relationship can not be equated at all, besides, the responsibility for my client's accidental pregnancy lies entirely with the defendant." ”

Wang Yuhe's argument had a certain strength, and Yang Minghai didn't know how to refute it for a while. But he immediately adjusted his mentality and continued: "My client, Mr. Gao Yuan, is indeed a little impulsive in his personality, but it does not mean that he does not love his wife. Gao Yuan loves his wife, in order to provide her with a richer life, and he works day and night, all because he loves his wife. However, his wife Xia Qing was a young grandmother at home, and her life may be too comfortable, so she thought about changing her lifestyle and thinking about divorce, which shows that the plaintiff Xia Qing is a woman who is not satisfied with the status quo, she is a writer, please note that the nature of a writer is probably more romantic. She may have lost interest in a ten-year marriage, as far as I know, there are quite a few women who like to seek excitement and hope to live in passion forever, and I think that Xia Qing is such a woman, saying that Gao Yuan's cheating is just an excuse for her to want a divorce, and the real reason why she wants to divorce should be that she feels that her current marriage has no passion..."

Xia Qing didn't expect Yang Minghai to slander her like this, and her anger caused her to appear very excited, "Nonsense, please don't slander me here! What you said is completely unfounded suspicion." ”

Wang Yuhe said: "Presiding judge, I strongly oppose Yang Minghai's slander of my client, and I think the presiding judge will disqualify Yang Minghai from defending him. ”

Li Ming also felt that Yang Minghai was a little out of the way, and he hurriedly reminded: "Please don't make baseless speculations, please don't deviate from the topic, you should reply to the plaintiff's statement just now." ”

Yang Minghai and Gao Yuan looked at Xia Qing very proudly, and they seemed to have found the pleasure of revenge for Xia Qing's slander.

Yang Minghai continued: "There is a good saying, 'No one is perfect, practice is infallible'? If you make a mistake, you should give people the opportunity to correct your mistakes, and it is not bad to be a good person to sincerely repent after making mistakes. Isn't that right? From this point of view, I don't think they should be divorced, they have been in a relationship for three years, wouldn't it be a pity to give up like this? Husbands and wives are inevitable, and all of you here, can any of you guarantee that you haven't had an awkward relationship with your spouse? ”

"Against!" Wang Yuhe said, "It's not up to you to decide whether the relationship between them is good or not, and you should use facts to prove it, and I think the defendant's lawyer is messing around and deliberately delaying the trial." ”

Li Ming said: "Attorney of the defendant, your speech should be as concise as possible, and time is limited. What else do you need to defend? ”

"Okay, then I'll pick the key points. I would now like to focus on the issue of children. ”

Xia Qing suddenly became nervous, she was most afraid that Yang Minghai and Gao Yuan would talk about the child. She expected that Yang Minghai would launch a new round of time attack on her, so she prepared to fight.

As Xia Qing expected, Yang Minghai quickly set his eyes on her, "As far as I know, the plaintiff Ms. Xia Qing has no regular job, she has not been at work for more than half a year, may I ask the plaintiff Ms. Xia Qing, have you thought about what to do if you don't have a child born in the future? You don't have a regular job, will you be able to raise a child in the future?"