The auditorium is quiet again!

Another subversive remark!

Many people are chewing and thinking about Zhang Ye's arguments!

A male teacher in his fifties from the Department of Economics and Management of Peking University in the corner below couldn't help but say, "Where did this Zhang Ye pop up?"

A female history teacher next to her said, "You don't know him?"

The male teacher said: "I don't watch the news much, and I don't pay attention to the entertainment and literary circles. ”

The female teacher said: "This Zhang Ye is still a little famous in the capital, and his literary literacy is very high. ”

The male teacher of the Department of Economics and Management said: "I can see it, so I am curious about where this is a genius who came out, I also like "Dream of Red Mansions", I have paid attention to it for a while, and I have seen a lot of comments and analysis on "Dream of Red Mansions", including some experts, scholars and red scholars, but dare to question who the author of "Dream of Red Mansions" is, only Zhang Ye is alone, and it is definitely not simple to dare to put forward this point of view. He looked at Zhang Ye with a relaxed expression on the stage, and said: "Have you found it, he has no manuscript from beginning to end, he only brought a few materials to the stage, all of them are off-script, this is to eat "Dream of Red Mansions" to the bones!"

The female teacher kowtowed slightly, "This remark is indeed too novel, if Zhang Ye doesn't bring it up, no one may ever consider and question the author of the Red Mansion." Blinked, he said, "But although what he said has a little bit of truth, I still reserve my opinion." ”

The male teacher said: "I have to listen to it again, such a little evidence is still not enough, if you want to subvert such a perception that the whole world has been closed, at least you have to come up with more than one convincing ironclad evidence, and use a large number of documents to prove it from a large number of angles, otherwise no one will agree!"

An intern teacher from Peking University who had just arrived next to them said: "I don't think it's gone, after all, the red scholars have studied 'Dream of Red Mansions' for decades and have made no progress, and the literature has also been searched through, where is the evidence so easy to find? Zhang Ye can find such a few small details to support his point of view, it is already a miracle!"

Reporters are also talking to each other.

Peking University students also whispered.

"God!"

"That's a scary view!"

"If it's true, then ...... Then the literary world will be in chaos!"

"It's the first time I know that "Dream of Red Mansions" can still be said like this!"

From the time when Zhang Ye did not come to Peking University, from the moment it was just announced that Zhang Ye had joined the Chinese Department of Peking University, almost everyone was questioning his level and qualifications, although the students were very interested in Zhang Ye and hoped to have such a unique style teacher, but that was only from the perspective of entertainment, really to talk about how well Zhang Ye could teach this "Appreciation of Classical Classics"? I am afraid that these Peking University students have no expectations, let alone people in the education and literary circles, and even most of the colleagues, teachers and professors of the Chinese Department of Peking University maintain a skeptical or even simply distrustful attitude towards Zhang Ye, and they are very repulsive to Zhang Ye! Then Zhang Ye said that he wanted to talk about "Dream of the Red Mansion" that no one dared to touch, and threw out a shocking remark, and everyone's distrust of him grew greater, such as Professor Yan of the Chinese Department sitting below, such as Chang Kaige, the head of the department, and others, all took Zhang Ye as a madman!

An hour later!

But now!

It's time for the first class to come to an end!

No matter whether what Zhang Ye said was right or not, no matter how much they didn't believe in this argument, they now had to put aside their resistance and self-esteem, and admit that Zhang Ye's research and research on "Dream of Red Mansions" had really reached an extremely high level and point!

Professor Zeng?

Professor Yan?

A teacher in the Chinese department?

Even Professor Wang, who specialized in this course before?

There is no doubt that in the research of "Dream of Red Mansions", they are indeed inferior to Zhang Ye, and in this field, Zhang Ye's new way of finding a new way has convinced most people! The evidence that all the ancient books are derived from the version of Yan Zhai is enough to make the red academic community a sensation!

It's a big find!

This is a breakthrough in red research!

Even the poem given to Gao Yi by the poet of the Qing Dynasty is also a very valuable material for research!

Listening to Zhang Ye talk about this, many people couldn't help but be a little puzzled, why? Why didn't anyone else discover such a key information and literature? Or did they find it but didn't notice it? Why did Zhang Ye notice this alone? This guy alone can your mother top the entire red academic world!

……

More than a dozen seconds passed.

Everyone has come back to their senses from their thoughts.

Senior Sister Song took a breath and raised her arm, "Teacher Zhang!"

Zhang Ye took the projection information and said with a smile: "Xiao Song, you say." ”

"Your discovery is indeed very valuable, but ......" Senior Sister Song said stubbornly: "Even if many ancient books of the Red Chamber are derived from the version of Fat Yan Zhai, if you have to be more serious, this still can't explain the problem, and you can't use Fat Yan Zhai's criticism to say "Dream of Red Mansions" The last forty episodes were not made by Cao Xueqin, even if Fat Yan Zhai and Cao Xueqin have a very close relationship, and may have participated in the discussion and creation, but it is still the same sentence, when Fat Yan Zhai wrote the criticism, the Red Mansion may not have finished the creation, but later Cao Xueqin changed it, and did not write according to the original intention, you just refuted me and said that Fat Yan Zhai's comment is very positive, saying that he has read the whole "Dream of Red Mansions", which is still no evidence. ”

Professor Zeng nodded, Xiao Song is a thorn in the thorn, research is like this, keep picking thorns, keep looking for problems, only then do you see more and more clearly.

Senior Sister Song said, her thinking became clearer, "So this is just a word of Fat Yan Zhai, according to this reasoning, many things also make sense, no one in that era has read the whole book of "Dream of Red Mansions", and the closest relationship with Cao Xueqin Fat Yan Zhai only knows a general idea and outline, so it caused those Fat Yan Zhai to think that the comments, this is also the ancient books handed down from that era have not recorded the whole book of "Dream of Red Mansions" one hundred and twenty times After Cao Xueqin finished writing "A Dream of Red Mansions", the manuscript was sealed for some unknown reason, and it was obtained by Gao He many, many years later, so that it was disseminated and circulated at that time! As for why Gao He referred to the comments of Fat Yan Zhai, and also strayed into the popular version, this can only show that Gao He was academically rigorous, and he studied the comments of Fat Yan Zhai when he 'supplemented' "A Dream of Red Mansions", and maybe even Cao Xueqin's 120 completed copies of " The previous content of "Dream of Red Mansions" has a comment from Fat Yan Zhai, Gao He is a collator, but he copied it by mistake, so the one hundred and twenty times of Red Mansion was written by Cao Xueqin!"

"yes!"

"That's a good point. ”

"Senior Sister Song is mighty!

"If you guess like this, it makes sense! Teacher Zhang Ye's point of view is a little untenable! Sure enough, it's Senior Sister Song, a scholar!"

The students of Peking University are suddenly enlightened!

A few Peking University teachers also glanced at Senior Sister Song more, this student is very clever!

However, Zhang Ye didn't care, but laughed, looked at Senior Sister Song and said, "You mean, no one has read the whole "Dream of Red Mansions" in that era?"

Senior Sister Song affirmed: "It must be like this, if you infer it like this, your views can be overturned, the whole one hundred and twenty episodes of "Dream of Red Mansions" were circulated for the first time in the hands of Gao E, so Yan Zhai's comments are not tenable at all." ”

Zhang Ye smiled and shook his head.

"You don't agree?" Senior Sister Song looked at him.

Zhang Ye said: "Hehe, I'm actually very happy, why? Because when I first said some opinions, everyone thought I was quibbling, thinking that I was using some unreliable or even subjective speculation to force the reasoning, but you found that no, the current situation is reversed." ”

Senior Sister Song blushed, "I'm not a strong word and a supervisor's speculation, there is indeed this possibility, no, it must be like this!"

"Sure?" said Zhang Ye.

"Definitely!" Senior Sister Song said resolutely.

"Then you must have to put a question mark on this, in fact, there were people who watched "Dream of Red Mansions" in that era!" Zhang Ye had already made a preparation, how could he be asked by a student? He fluttered and took out another piece of information and put it into the projection, "Everyone, please look at this." ”

What is this?

Poetry?

Everyone is glued in!

Don't ask about the golden marriage and the jade relationship, gathering like a spring dream and scattering like smoke.

There is no aura at the foot of Shigui Mountain, and it is always in vain to be able to speak.

Everyone looked at each other very much, what kind of poem is this? Why haven't you heard it?

Zhang Ye said: "This information, I spent a lot of time in the Beijing library to find it with the internal system entry, the person who wrote this poem is called Fucha Mingyi, self-fasting, is a small nobleman in the Qing Dynasty, but he is not willing, by this time his family has been very declining, his poems, written is not very good, lower than the general level, no fame, he writes poems is a self-appreciation, or with relatives and friends in a small area, the name of his poetry collection is "Green Smoke Window Collection". ”

Everyone is inexplicable, who is this person?

Some students searched the Internet and found nothing.

Zhang Ye looked at everyone's expressions and said: "It can be seen that everyone doesn't know this person, but, please remember the name Fucha Mingyi, in the study of "A Dream of Red Mansions", this person is a very important role, everyone please look at this poem on the projection, it is obviously some "A Dream of Red Mansions", what does the poem mean? There is a story of a golden and jade marriage in the Red Mansion, and he said, don't ask again, it's unbearable to look back, why? Because Fucha Mingyi has seen the golden and jade marriage inside. Gathering like a spring dream', then he also saw the part of 'scattered like smoke', and Fucha Mingyi saw a whole book of "Dream of Red Mansions" with a beginning and an end!"

Someone questioned, "Was there such a man in history?"

"Yes, the red academic community has not verified this poem? This is really written in "Dream of Red Mansions"? So why has no one found out?"

"What's so strange about this person looking at the Red Mansion?"

"Yes, I've also seen one hundred and twenty times of the Red Mansion, and it also has a beginning and an end!"

Senior Sister Song also raised a lot of doubts, and one question after another was thrown over by everyone.

In this world, Fucha Mingyi basically no one cares, because his poetry level is not good, he is not even a celebrity, no one will care, and the "Green Smoke Trivial Window Collection" is incomplete, the original "Dream of Red Mansions" There are no more than a few words left, and there are only three or four of the twenty poems written about the Red Chamber on this earth, no title, no fame, and they are so hidden that they have never been discovered by red scientists in this world, but Zhang Ye, as a traverser, knows these things, and knows the importance of this person and these poems. Others can't find these poems, but Zhang Ye knows that the result is the other way around, so he can naturally find it easily.

It can't be said that his level is higher than that of the red scientists in this world, it can only be said that Zhang Ye has seen more than them and knows what they don't know!

Zhang Ye said: "I see that everyone has some questions, it doesn't matter, I will answer them one by one, first of all, when did this Fucha Mingyi write this poem, according to my research and research, Fucha Mingyi's "Green Smoke Trivial Window Collection", the poems in him are arranged according to the chronology. One by one, he put the information on the projection, "You see, these are all materials for research, you can clearly see that the last of these poems in the "Green Smoke Window Collection" can be examined and completed, and the poem I just saw for you to write "Dream of Red Mansions" was before this, that is to say, Fucha Mingyi read a complete Red Chamber before 1781 and wrote this poem, but when did Gao E's 120 copies of "Dream of Red Mansions" appear? It's 1791!"

Senior Sister Song was stunned!

Many people were also stunned!

Zhang Ye smiled and said: "So Xiao Song's inference and conjecture just now are not valid, before Gao E, someone had read the entire "Dream of Red Mansions", but it was not this one hundred and twenty times!"

Senior Zhou helped Senior Sister Song speak, "Even if someone else has seen it, it is not considered evidence, this Fucha Mingyi may have just read it, but there was no hand-copied ancient book left, so everyone else has read it, and the finished ancient book was obtained by Gao E, and it was issued by Gao He many years later." ”

Zhang Ye smiled, "Did you find it? The reasons for your argument are getting narrower and narrower, and they are becoming more and more subjective. ”

Senior Zhou stiffened his neck and said, "But that's it." ”

"Okay, then I'll show you another poem, which is also one of the poems in a group of poems written by Fucha Mingyi in "Dream of Red Mansions". Zhang Ye said: "If everyone thinks that the poem just now doesn't explain anything, and they understand that it is not a poem about the Red Mansion, then this one is ironclad evidence." ”

The information is out.

After a few springs, Wang Sun was thin and bone-like.

Where does the moth red powder go, ashamed of Shi Jilun back then.

Zhang Ye explained: "What do you mean? He said that the Jia clan in the book, life is very luxurious, but not a few springs, their extravagant life did not last long, not a few springs, then we immediately recalled the first eighty times of the Red Mansion that we had read, which said very clearly, after the three springs are gone, the three springs are not long, and the life of glory and wealth is only three years, obviously Fu Cha Mingyi saw such a prophecy eighty times ago, but at the same time, he also saw the protagonist in the novel, Jia Baoyu, the son of the prince, what kind of image is it in the endSkinny and skinny! It's skinny and skinny!"

A lot of people were thoughtful.

Professor Zeng and others kept revisiting the poem.

Zhang Ye looked at everyone, "Then I want to ask, in the 120 editions of "A Dream of Red Mansions", does Jia Baoyu have this image? Is there any skinny and crumbling bones? It is completely none! Therefore, the whole "Dream of Red Mansions" that Fucha Mingyi saw is different from the 120 episodes of "A Dream of Red Mansions" that you have seen! Because the last 40 chapters that everyone sees are Gao E's sequel! Not Cao Xueqin's original pen!"

This evidence is indeed a bit big!

Several Peking University professors glanced at each other!

"Lao Li, what do you think?" asked a teacher in the Chinese department to another teacher in the history department.

The history teacher pondered for a moment, "I need to verify it first." As he spoke, he picked up the phone and called a few friends, "Hey, help me send a few materials, about the ...... of Fucha Mingyi" Zhang Ye's shocking remarks have not only affected the literary and educational circles, but also their historical circles.

A junior in the history department said: "Is what Fucha Mingyi said reliable?"

Zhang Ye smiled, "I have a piece of information about Fucha Mingyi here, let's take a look at it, and then determine whether it is reliable or not." Taking the information up, he said: "The data shows that Fucha Mingyi was born later than Cao Xueqin, but they all belong to the same era, and there is a common time in their lives, that is, when Cao Xueqin was alive, Fucha Mingyi was also alive, and the data showed that both of them lived on the ground in the capital and were both suburbs, so these two people are likely to have dealings, not people who can't be beaten by eight poles!"

Senior Sister Song stopped talking.

Many people are also desperately digesting the evidence given by Zhang Ye!

Zhang Ye said: "You can think about it, and then listen to me, the second half of this poem is also a very important proof, where does the moth red powder go?" That is, those young women in the book, in the end, they don't know where to go, ashamed of Shi Jilun, the ancients love to use allusions, Shi Jilun is a person in the Western Jin Dynasty, his name is Shi Chong, this person is a rich man, extravagant, but this person's final fate is very tragic, failed in the struggle for power, when his political enemies chased into his home, he has a side room, called Green Bead, this Green Bead took an action, to show resistance, but also to show loyalty to Shi Chong, ran upstairs, jumped to his death, became a famous thing in history- Green Bead fell from the building, Shi Chong is actually very bad, and there is nothing to sympathize with, according to our eyes today, there is nothing worth singing about Green Bead, but that's it, I saw "Dream of Red Mansions" in Fucha Mingyi After the ending, they all sighed that when the Jia clan finally collapsed, there was not even a character like Lu Zhu, and none of these Qing'e fans stood up to express even a little resistance, so what Fucha Mingyi saw was a tragic finale, a "Dream of Red Mansions" in which the Jia clan fell into a white land, this is Cao Xueqin's original intention of "Dream of Red Mansions"!

Once again, the crowd was dumbfounded.

Everyone didn't clear their minds, and they didn't know how to refute it.

Zhang Ye then said: "Then on the whole, the answer is already obvious, if you have to say that Yan Zhai just listened to Cao Xueqin's outline and ideas, at that time "Dream of Red Mansions" had not yet been written, and finally it was sealed? So there is no ancient book revealing the story after 80 times? How should these poems of Fucha Mingyi be explained? This is already too detailed, right? He obviously saw the finale of "Dream of Red Mansions" with his own eyes! And it is different from the current 120 editions! I still saw it many years before Gao E! Against this backdrop, who is going to explain why this inexplicable situation is happening?"

Voiceless.

"Is there no one? Then I can explain it! The "Dream of Red Mansions" that is now circulating was not written by Cao Xueqin at all after 80 episodes!" Zhang Ye asserted again!

At this time, the phone call of the history teacher also came back, he obviously had a friend who worked in the library, and searched directly from the internal index, and soon found it!

"Lao Li?"

"How?"

"Does this person and these poems really exist?"

The history teacher hung up the phone and nodded solemnly to his colleagues, "What Zhang Ye said is true, at least those materials can be verified, Fucha Mingyi really has these poems, his life, background, Zhang Ye is not bad." Then he showed everyone the information sent by the other party on his mobile phone, "And there are not only these two poems, there are others, and although these poems do not indicate that they are written in "Dream of Red Mansions", the meaning between the lines is indeed talking about the Red Chamber, but it is too hidden, and you can't detect it if you don't have confidence in analysis and observation!"

Professor Zeng was far away, and after listening to their words, he simply changed his seat, and quickly came over to look at the information, "This ......"

The nearby Peking University teachers were all convinced for a while, not convinced of Zhang Ye's point of view, but completely convinced of Zhang Ye's ability to find information and literature!

Such an inconspicuous piece of information!

Such a painless character!

You can find this? You can find this.

From this point of view, several Peking University teachers and professors all felt that Zhang Ye was really too perverted! I knew that this host surnamed Zhang knew a little bit about the Three Kingdoms, and what he said was quite interesting and interesting, but who would have thought that he had also studied "Dream of Red Mansions" in such a meticulous way! And whether the research results were right or wrong, in their opinion, Zhang Ye was already ahead of all red scientists!

Wu Zeqing smiled elegantly, "It seems that Teacher Xiao Zhang is still competent for this class, right?"

Yan Jiantao, a professor in the Department of Chinese, said with a calm face: "There are many things that have yet to be verified. He still doesn't look down on Zhang Ye, a person who is not from a history or literature class.

But others are different.

Everyone present can see that if Zhang Ye has more powerful evidence below, this is to rewrite the rhythm of historical celebrities through the ages!?