"Okay, then I'll say a few words. The pen "Fun" Pavilion www.biquge.info "Tai Wenhui does not shirk.

"Let's not discuss whether Ms. Feng Xiu's inference just now is logically valid, let's assume that it is valid, then I would like to ask Ms. Feng Xiu, how did you draw the conclusion that 'Ye Zi's behavior is wrong' from your inference just now? Even if all the previous inferences are correct and logical, I have not found a necessary logical relationship between your inferences and this conclusion. ”

"Ms. Fengxiu, how do you explain this?"

Tantai Wenhui's tone was not aggressive, but the question was quite sharp, pointing to the most lacking point in Li Liang Fengxiu's reasoning just now. As Wenhui said, even if Li Liang Fengxiu deduces the status of classical music and pop music from the level of value, there is no necessary logical relationship between this and the conclusion that "Ye Zi's behavior is wrong".

This does not require a high degree of logical thinking to reach this conclusion, but from a secular point of view, such a judgment can indeed be derived from the previous inferences. This is like Ah Q rashly interjecting when the fake foreign devil was talking, and his behavior was naturally wrong in the eyes of Zhao Baiyan and the idlers, so he was immediately coaxed out and not allowed to participate in the revolution. If it is assumed that Li Liang Fengxiu's inference is not problematic, then Ye Zi's behavior is a bit similar to Ah Q who rashly interjected, which is completely wrong.

Such an inference is indeed valid from a secular point of view, but it is very unfortunate that such an inference based on a secular point of view is completely untenable from a strict logical point of view, and there is no real causal relationship between them. You can't say the sentence "Because the status of classical music is higher than pop music, it is wrong for Ye Zi to sing pop songs at classical concerts", there are still big logical loopholes in this.

Li Liang Fengxiu is so powerful that she didn't say such a conclusion in person, so she was not stunned at all in the face of Wenhui's question.

"President Tangtai, you should have heard all my inferences clearly just now, and I didn't say that 'Ye Zi's behavior is wrong', which was added by Mr. Huang later."

Li Liang Fengxiu shook his head and said lightly.

"Oh? But at the end of your speech, when you say that Huang Baiwen's assertion is correct, isn't that implying such a conclusion? Wenhui continued to ask.

"There is also no logical relationship between the two, and you can think that this is some kind of hint on me, but I deny such accusations." Li Liang Fengxiu has long considered this aspect of the problem, and it is impossible for Wenhui's questioning to have any results.

The first meeting between these two women failed to take advantage of anyone and could only end in a draw.

Of course...... And that's just the beginning.

……

The show is getting better and better, Lin Liming doesn't need to control the guests' speeches all the time, she just needs to say a word or two at the right time, add a fire or remove a firewood, and control the size of the fire.

Just like now, Lin Liming thinks that there is no need for her to say anything, and the two sides are arguing that they can't be contained now, and they will definitely continue to go on consciously.

Sure enough, as soon as Li Liang Fengxiu's voice fell, Li Renguang picked up the microphone.

"President Tantai, I don't think there's anything wrong with Sister Feng Xiu's inference just now."

Li Renguang's voice is quite magnetic and very good, which may be the reason why the program team chose him to be the reporter on location. A good voice always makes the interviewee feel good, and there is a good chance that you will be interviewed after being suddenly stopped outside.

In fact, in Li Renguang's location interview experience, Ye Zi and Tantai Wenhui's unappreciative faces were rarely encountered by him, and this resentment was still hidden in his heart.

"I think we should have the courage to admit that pop music is really not as important as classical music in the hearts of the people, and that's an undeniable fact, we ......"

"An undeniable fact?" Wenhui immediately interrupted him: "Where did the facts come from? Is Xiangjiang here? I'm sure more than half of the people here in Hong Kong don't know about the noble classical music you are talking about, but pop music is well-known. ”

"Classical music has a higher status? Don't you think it's ridiculous that no one knows what no one understands about what they are? ”

"President Shantai, there may be the situation you mentioned in Xiangjiang here, but there is a huge audience for classical music in Europe and the United States, and its status is quite respected, you can't deny this, right?" Li Renguang was caught off guard by Tantai Wenhui, but Li Liang Fengxiu immediately took over.

As soon as he heard this, Ye Zi, who was hiding to the side and watching the battle, began to snicker. Isn't it looking for abuse to talk about this with the former ace agent of the WMA?

……

"Europe and the United States?" Wenhui sneered: "Even in the European continent, the origin of classical music, classical music is still a niche art, and the audience is large and wide, but the number of fans who really like and really love classical music is not dominant. The European public knows and loves the superstars of pop music, such as the Beatles, the Rolling Stones, MJ, Madonna, Queen, Wham, Elton. John and so on, fans of these shining names can all have a number of treasures, and their works can be sung by any person. If you ask them about classical music, I am sure that they can only blurt out the famous three tenors, and very few other composers, conductors, and performers they can clearly know. ”

"Even when it comes to the three most famous tenors, it was only after a kind of packaging design similar to that of a pop star that they got their current superstar status. Don't tell me, do you really think that these three tenors are the best singers in the world of classical music? ”

"It's a big joke!"

The more Wenhui spoke, the faster he spoke.

"According to what Ms. Feng Xiu just said, value determines status, so why should pop music, which has created countless values, be inferior to classical music? Don't talk to me about who creates more value in classical music or pop music, everyone knows that. ”

"So may I ask, can anyone tell me who has the higher status of classical music or pop music?"

Speaking of this, Tai Wenhui stopped abruptly, and her head was slightly raised, showing pride and disdain. Although the paragraph just now was said quickly and quickly, and the logic in the words was not very strict, the momentum had risen significantly.

The two armies win against the brave, and momentum is, of course, also a kind of courage.

However, the momentum of Tangtai Wenhui could not suppress the other party, Huang Baiwen patted the table lightly, and said loudly: "President Tangtai, please don't change the concept, the commodity value of the work and the artistic value of the work itself cannot be confused, you only use the commodity value to measure the overall value of the work now, and there is no mention of the artistic value of the work, which is a completely unacceptable method of judgment." ”

"Inadmissible?" Tantai Wenhui became more and more courageous the more he fought: "Why can't it be trusted? The so-called value must always have a standard to measure, Mr. Huang, what is your so-called artistic value used to measure? What do you personally think? Then I can also consider the artistic value of a certain pop song to be extraordinary and unparalleled! ”

"If the artistic value cannot be truly reflected in some intuitive way, then the artistic value itself is empty."

Li Liang Fengxiu patted the armrest of the sofa and stood up: "How can this be empty?" The artistic value of the work has existed since it was created, and it cannot be transformed into commodity value is another thing, and the main reason for this is that the people's ability to appreciate art is not enough, but this has nothing to do with the artistic value of the work itself. ”

"How can you be so ridiculous!"

Speaking of this, Li Liang Fengxiu stretched out her hand and pointed directly at Wenhui, her face seemed to be covered with a layer of frost, and the cold air was pressing.

Li Liang Fengxiu was really angry. (To be continued.) )