Ling Li cleared her somewhat hoarse throat and said hurriedly: "We deny the authenticity of this evidence......

Before she finished speaking, Nan Zhiyi raised her head and said in a clear voice: "I signed it, I admit it." ”

Judge Cheng was ready to listen to Ling Li's tugging of the law, but he didn't expect that it was Nan Zhiyi who gave him a startle and directly admitted that this IOU was from him.

He blinked incredulously: "Defendant, are you sure you accept this evidence?" ”

Ling Li was a little anxious, turned her head to him and said, "You can't admit it, and you can't admit it when you mention the appraisal, are you stupid?" ”

Nan Zhiyi looked at her for a few seconds, and his voice was indifferent: "What about the appraisal?" What effect can it have other than procrastination? ”

Then, looking at the judgment seat: "I don't deny that this is indeed my signature, but, like the previous evidence, the signature is mine, but I don't agree with the content, it was forged by them." Otherwise, why is it that the signature is handwritten by me, but the content is printed? Stealing my blank signatures and forging evidence, repeating the same tricks again and again, and pouring dirty water on me. If such evidence is also accepted by the court, then what authority does the law have? What credibility does the court have? ”

When he asked, his voice was impassioned and his tone was bright and clear. It's a pity that this is a courtroom and not a podium, and it's about evidence, not contagion.

Hearing him say such a dismantling of the stage, Ling Li was angry for a while, and blurted out: "Is it reasonable in court?" Why don't you do it yourself? If you don't understand, you still pretend to understand, you are angry, what is wrong! ”

The two people on the plaintiff's bench looked like they were watching a good show, and Judge Cheng on the trial table shook his head slightly.

I heard that the younger brother of Nanyuan was an extraordinary genius, entered the juvenile class at the age of fifteen, and got a doctorate at the age of twenty-three, and now he is only in his early thirties, and he has already made quite achievements.

It's a pity that, like those parties with high IQ scientific research backgrounds that he has come into contact with in the cases he has tried in the past, not to mention whether their emotional intelligence is low or low, their personalities are much more stubborn than ordinary people, and they can't listen to persuasion.

They always feel that they hold the truth in their hands, and they don't care about what the reality of the world is like, and they refuse to compromise with the established rules, so they often fail.

Judge Cheng was about to explain the impact of whether or not to recognize the signature on the case, but saw Nan Zhiyi suddenly pick up the IOU on the table, and it was torn to pieces in just an instant.

Wang Qi was shocked: "Presiding judge, the defendant deliberately destroyed the evidence. ”

Qin Beibei didn't come back to his senses, and after a while, he took out a piece of paper from his bag and said, "Presiding Judge, I still have a copy here, but the original has been destroyed, what should I do?" ”

And Ling Li also seemed to be stunned, and she was about to cry in the next second, and her voice couldn't help but get louder: "You, you...... You're legally blind, and you've done all sorts of things like destroying evidence! What do you want! ”

Nan Zhiyi argued: "What evidence, it's obviously fake......"

was interrupted by the sound of a mallet.

Judge Cheng knocked lightly three times, and then motioned to the clerk to put away the evidence that was torn into slag by Nan Zhiyi, and said: "We will repair the evidence, and now the plaintiff provides a copy for reference." ”

After saying that, he rubbed the corners of his forehead, and he had a headache.

The noise just now, as if he had been a judge for many years, had not encountered it a few times.

The defendant quarrels with the witnesses, the defendant quarrels with the lawyer, and the defendant tears up the evidence.

On the contrary, it was the plaintiff, who sat firmly on the Diaoyutai and looked calm, and seemed to have the chance to win.

Judge Cheng has tried cases for so many years, and he is used to seeing litigation participants lying in court out of their own interests.

It is quite common for the defendant to lie, the plaintiff to lie, and the witness to lie, and generally speaking, the result depends on which objective evidence is weaker or stronger.

The testimony of the witnesses who had been cross-examined, as well as the IOU that even the defendant himself admitted to signing, was more probative than the defendant's inference that the blank signature was forged.

The current situation seems to be very unfavorable for the defendant......

Wang Qi looked at Nan Zhiyi's somewhat distracted appearance, and the uneasiness in his heart disappeared slightly.

In Yang Zhongchun's testimony, although there were some accidents, although there were some accidents, they finally died down.

Fortunately, except for the evidence reserved for the Supreme People's Court, which was exposed in advance, everything else did not deviate significantly.

At this time, the trial had already been carried out to the second witness of Yamazaki Seeds, Ke Hongsheng.

That's right, in order to refute the testimony of Ke Hongsheng in Ling Li's hand, Wang Qi pushed out another chess piece that Wang Qi had buried.

When he came on the field, he naturally wanted to deny the validity of the testimony in Ling Li's hand.

After the plaintiff asked a few questions, Ke Hongsheng answered them one by one, not only refuting the validity of the testimony in Ling Li's hand, but also making the case clearer.

Similar to Yang Zhongchun's statement, Ke Hongsheng said that he was coerced by Nan Zhiyi to make the previous testimony. And considering Nan Zhiyi's far-reaching influence, he had to give in.

After listening to the questioning, Judge Cheng turned his head to look at Ling Li: "Defense, do you have any questions to ask the witnesses?" ”

Nan Zhiyi shook his head slowly, and Ling Li also replied: "No." ”

Wang Qi was a little surprised, he actually gave up struggling so quickly? looked at the defendant and lawyer on the other side, who seemed to be angry couples, and their hearts were clear.

One is still resentful, and the other complains that the law blindness does not go through the brain, which makes her a big heel in her disadvantage, and sure enough, when the disaster comes, they fly separately.

Seeing that the witness was about to end, Wang Qi was relieved, and was a little happy, Ling Li suddenly raised his head: "Ah, I remembered, Ke Hongsheng, did you also accept the IOU from our party?" You and Yang Zhongchun have the same amount? ”

Ke Hongsheng just stood up from the witness stand, turned his head and replied: "Mine is not three million, but two million." ”

Wang Qi, who had been looking at the information in his hand with his eyes slightly down, instantly raised his eyes and almost shouted: "Ke Hongsheng has no IOU in his hand!" ”

Ling Li's eyes lit up, and she immediately asked: "Lawyer Wang, you said you didn't know about the IOU in Yang Zhongchun's hand just now, and the judge asked you again and again before he expressed his willingness to submit it to the collegial panel as evidence." When my client tore up the original IOU, you took out a photocopy of it, which seems to have known in advance. Why did you get to Ke Hongsheng, you are so sure that he doesn't have an IOU in his hand? ”

Wang Qi was speechless.

Yang Zhongchun's behavior just now disrupted their plan and led to a loophole, and now when this rookie brings it up, it seems that they deliberately deceive the collegial court.

But for the time being, they can't care about the IOU that has been submitted, the key is that Ke Hongsheng in their plan is simply to testify and leave, where did the IOU come from?

So, he pretended not to hear Ling Li's questioning: "Ke Hongsheng has no IOU in his hand, no matter what the opposing lawyer says, he will not submit it as evidence." ”

Ling Li argued: "The plaintiff's witness Ke Hongsheng not only said that he had an IOU in his hand, but also said that the amount of the IOU in his hand was 2 million instead of 3 million. Obviously, it is not the same as the situation stated by the plaintiff's lawyer. I suspect that there has been a case of abetment of perjury by witnesses and now ask Ko to provide an IOU in order to ascertain the facts. ”

The three judges of the collegial panel obviously did not anticipate this situation, especially Judge Cheng, who had some knowledge of the background of the case.

He knew that there was a lot of water in this case, and the game of chess played by Yamazaki Seed Industry was very big, and there were doubts everywhere. But Yamazaki Seed Industry has also made full preparations, no matter the IOUs, meeting minutes, financial statements or anything provided, they are all solid and objective evidence, and Nanzhiyi himself admitted that those signatures were his, and basically the collegial panel must determine the validity of these evidence.

The so-called evidence collected by the defendant, except for some notarized documents that are not painful, is almost all witness testimony. The key point is that even if a witness's testimony has been cross-examined at trial, its probative effect cannot catch up with objective evidence.

If Ke Hongsheng really has an IOU in his hand, and it can be proved that the IOU is fake, it may be a turning point.

Judge Cheng cleared his throat: "Ke Hongsheng, do you really have an IOU in your hand?" ”

Ke Hongsheng, who originally thought that he had nothing to do, suddenly panicked, and he was at a loss and didn't know what to say.

Although Wang Qi didn't know what was going on, causing Ke Hongsheng to say something unexpected, he immediately stabilized his position and once again emphasized to the collegial panel: "There is no IOU, and the witness is wrong." ”

"Can you still know the amount of Yang Zhongchun's IOU by slip of the tongue? Isn't that a coincidence? Ling Li said word by word.

Ke Hongsheng didn't know how to respond to this, but Wang Qi reacted quickly, and immediately added: "Both of them were in the witness room just now, and it is possible that they had communicated in advance, and it is normal to know the inside story." In addition, it is normal for the witness to be nervous for a while and the communication with Yang Zhongchun to make a mistake for a while. ”

Obviously, there is no reason to refer to the deer as a horse, but Wang Qi is very calm, and he just talks nonsense with a straight face, and Ling Li is amazed.

In the end, he was conclusive: "I would like to remind the opposing party's lawyer that I have a special authorization from Yamazaki Seeds, and I have such a right to admit the evidence of our witnesses." ”

The three judges in the collegial panel exchanged their heads and ears, and for a while, Judge Cheng had regret in his eyes: "Ke Hongsheng, you can go out." ”

The implication is that they are not prepared to delve into whether there is another IOU.

In this way, Ling Li had no way to continue questioning, and let Ke Hongsheng come out of the court.

Wang Qi breathed a sigh of relief.

He didn't expect anything wrong with the witnesses, since Yang Zhongchun couldn't hold his breath and was exposed in advance, he had been worried that Ke Hongsheng would make a mistake.

This witness was because he inadvertently knew that there was a conflict with Nan Zhiyi, and he got the news from Nan Zhiyi's side that they would collect evidence from him, so he planned to add another straw that crushed the camel.

Mixing up their testimony is secondary, and the most important thing is to make Nan Zhiyi mess up. When he remembered where he learned the source of Ke Hongsheng's disadvantage, Wang Qi suddenly felt a chill in his back.

If this witness was deliberately sent to them by Nan Zhiyi, does it mean that Nan Zhiyi already knew who was unreliable around him.

He frowned and looked at Qin Beibei.

Qin Beibei also thought of this, her eyes were a little stunned, she turned her head to look at him, and her voice was a little anxious: "Teacher, this ......"

"Don't panic, don't scare yourself." Wang Qi whispered.

Qin Beibei nodded, and the uneasiness in her eyes disappeared slightly.

comforted Qin Beibei, but couldn't comfort himself. Wang Qi looked at Ling Li on the other side with his head down, and suddenly felt a little deceived.

The rookie who was still in a panic just now, at this time, how can he not act in a hurry or slowly?

Just now, the desktop was a mess of laws and papers, but after a few minutes, how could it be neat and tidy?

Also, Nan Zhiyi, who was a little depressed a moment ago, why did he suddenly look at the rookie with a smile in his eyes, as if he hadn't sulked just now?

Sensing that the situation seemed to be not good, Wang Qi had alarm bells in his mind, vaguely predicting that the next trial would not proceed according to the trajectory they expected. His somewhat relaxed mood dissipated instantly, and he was ready to deal with the opponent's counterattack next.