Chapter 140: Self-defeating

Judge Cheng frowned, turned to him and said, "Defendant, please pay attention to your emotions, if you have any questions, you will talk about them when the plaintiff finishes asking questions." ”

Nan Zhiyi's eyes were full of disbelieving, and he originally wanted to speak, but when he saw Ling Li shaking his head lightly at him, he finally stopped talking and endured his words.

After accepting Judge Wang Qi and Cheng's questions, Yang Zhongchun glanced at Nan Zhiyi, who was angry just now, and quickly buried his head, and his voice was also low: "Mr. Nan encountered difficulties back then, which caused the seeds to be delayed in the market, which affected his plan to quickly complete the work of Huayi Hi-Tech and become a professor at Funan University. At that point, if he had said he needed PIGM, I would definitely have stayed to help delve further into the site. But Mr. Nan didn't say anything, I thought he didn't pay attention to PIGM, so I went to Ganxi. ”

Judge Cheng did not judge his testimony, but he was muttering in his heart, this witness is very clear in his words, even if he is talking nonsense, but the witness who has the courage to go to court to be questioned must be fully prepared.

If the defendant can't break through his psychological defense, then this lawsuit will be less auspicious.

Thinking of this, he turned his head directly to look at the defendant's seat: "Defense, now please start questioning witnesses." ”

Ling Li nodded and began to ask.

The first question is: "Witness, could you please state your relationship with our client?" ”

Yang Zhongchun was stunned for a moment, and slowly said the experience of studying for a master's degree with Nan Zhiyi in the past three years.

As soon as his words fell, Ling Li immediately asked: "You were born in 1987, my client was born in 1985, you are only two years apart, but one is a tutor and the other is a student." Honestly, will you be unwilling? Will you be jealous and discredit my client? ”

Yang Zhongchun didn't seem to think that Ling Li would ask such a question, and his eyes flashed with astonishment. However, for a moment, he returned to his usual complexion.

Qin Beibei had already reacted, and immediately said loudly: "Oppose the defendant's agent to make inducing questions." ”

Ling Li also immediately looked at Judge Cheng: "The defense drew the attention of the collegial panel to the fact that people pay attention to details when lying, and Yang Zhongchun's previous testimony even remembered very small things five years ago so clearly, which is completely unreasonable." Ask the court to investigate clearly. ”

Qin Beibei chuckled: "Lawyer Ling, we are in court, whether the testimony of the witness just now counts depends on the judge's free testimony, not that you can get away with two sentences of criminal psychology." ”

Judge Cheng nodded thoughtfully, and immediately said to Yang Zhongchun: "Witness, you don't have to answer this question. ”

Yang Zhongchun shook his head and said that he didn't care: "It's okay, I can go back to this question head-on." ”

After that, his voice was sonorous: "There has never been a shortage of prodigies in the field of science, Mr. Nan is a genius valued by Guo Laodu, which is rare for decades, and his academic achievements have nothing to do with age." And my professional quality can only be described as a high mountain. However, it is rare to be talented, but the accumulation of ordinary people may not be a blockbuster. So, I have nothing to be jealous of, and nothing to feel resentful about. ”

These words were reasonable, not humble or arrogant, and even the three judges of the collegial panel nodded secretly.

Unexpectedly, the witnesses were upright and upright, and after a few words, the aggressive defense lawyer just now fell behind.

Ling Li bit her lip tightly and immediately moved on to the next question: "You just said that our client asked the student to send you a message saying that there is something to discuss and ask you to withdraw the lawsuit, is there any evidence to prove this matter?" ”

Yang Zhongchun didn't answer this question immediately, lowered his eyes thoughtfully, and then looked at Nan Zhiyi deeply, as if he had made up his mind.

After that, he said: "I believe that Mr. Nan has a hard time, but then I thought that Mr. Nan stopped his research on rice more than a year ago, not necessarily because he encountered a bottleneck. After all, he taught me a lot, so I agreed to drop the lawsuit.

As for the evidence you want, I don't have it, but I'm just a researcher who has just been rated with a title, poor and white, although the withdrawal of the lawsuit also charged me tens of thousands of legal fees, which is worth a few months' salary, is it necessary for me to spend money to buy it? ”

His voice was a little melancholy, and there was a look of forbearance and regret in his eyes.

However, these seemingly good words have very sinister intentions, and they are said in a sanctimonious manner, but they reveal that Nanzhi Yi Jianglang has no academic development.

In this way, it is understandable that he plagiarized the academic work of his own students.

Such an attitude unsurprisingly annoyed Nan Zhiyi.

He raised his head, and his gaze swept to Qin Beibei and Wang Qi opposite, intentionally or unintentionally, his pupils suddenly tightened, and his face was full of fierceness.

After all, Wang Qi has been through a hundred battles and can not change his face, but Qin Beibei has a feeling of sitting on pins and needles, and the hand he puts under the table can't help but grasp the edge of the table.

At first glance, this person is nothing special, and can even be said to be handsome. But when he looked at it with a blank look in his eyes, it was really terrifying.

The person with such a look in his impression seems to be the pervert he represented when he first started practicing law and killed his entire family and calmly dismembered the corpse, and was finally sentenced to death and executed immediately.

How can this nerd have such a look?

The more he thought about it, the more frightened he became, and he only felt cold sweat on his forehead. Fortunately, Nan Zhiyi put away the knife in his eyes after a few seconds, and turned his head to look at Yang Zhongchun: "You speak, don't you have a conscience?" ”

Rao is Wang Qi, who had been holding a stiff face and was still a little hairy by Nan Zhiyi just now, heard this, and couldn't help but sneer, and his mood suddenly relaxed.

Regarding whether the court is reasonable or conscientious, it is just like what Nan Zhijun said in the Nanxi Industrial Park before.

In court, evidence is emphasized, law is emphasized, and causation is emphasized, and the so-called reason and conscience are not the basis for adjudicating cases.

As a group of judges and lawyers, they have an unusually stubborn attitude when talking about evidence and law, and in his eyes, running to the court to talk about conscience is naturally a legally blind behavior that makes people laugh.

Nan Zhiyi continued to say angrily: "You almost couldn't finish your studies because of stealing experimental equipment, if I hadn't helped you cover up, you would have been expelled from school." If I knew you were a white-eyed wolf, I shouldn't have helped you! ”

Yang Zhongchun was stunned for a while before he said, "Teacher Nan, I am also worthy of you, you know that the experimental equipment in the inventory is only processed by my hands, but you still have to say this." ”

Hearing his defense, Nan Zhiyi snorted coldly, and then raised his head: "Do you think you can be ashamed if you propose a PIGM?" I'm telling you, in front of me, this little thing is not enough to see! I don't know if I didn't get a scholarship because the course Introduction to Chromosome Methods and Techniques didn't affect the scholarship, and I was carrying a bottle of inferior wine and begging my grandfather to sue my grandmother everywhere, or I helped you get it? As for your flirting with schoolgirls and putting pinhole cameras in the locker room, there's ......

Hearing this, Wang Qi quickly interrupted him: "Presiding judge, the incident that the defendant said has nothing to do with this case, he is interfering with the testimony of witnesses. ”

Nan Zhiyi was irritated, stood up and looked at the collegial panel, and gritted his back molars: "Judge, the witness and the plaintiff maliciously colluded to slander me, and I ask the court to investigate this matter." ”

Without waiting for Judge Cheng to react, Ling Li hurriedly pulled him to sit down and patched his voice: "The past incident mentioned by our client is likely to be related to the grievances between him and the witnesses, and we request that these facts be ascertained." ”

The collegial panel was still talking to each other, and Yang Zhongchun on the witness stand was obviously stunned, looking incredulous.

After a while, he lowered his head, and his voice was flat: "Teacher Nan, I didn't expect you to slander me out of nothing in order to get out?" If you are unkind, don't blame me for being unjust. Aren't you very clear why I withdrew the lawsuit? That day, you gave me an IOU of three million, and later threatened me that if I didn't withdraw the lawsuit, I would ruin my reputation, so I compromised. ”

As soon as these words came out, it was like a pot exploded in the courtroom. Not only did the collegial panel begin to exchange heads, but the five people in the plaintiff's seat and the defendant's bench were stunned.

A few minutes later, Yang Zhongchun went down to court, however, the topic of IOUs remained in the courtroom.

The collegial panel deliberated for a while, and Judge Cheng finally looked at the plaintiff's seat: "Do you have any grasp of the IOU that the witness just mentioned, the plaintiff?" Is it confirmed to be submitted to the collegial panel as evidence? ”

Wang Qi and Qin Beibei had also been struggling with this matter just now. Originally, this IOU was intended to be put forward as a fatal blow in the second instance of the Supreme People's Court, but I didn't expect Yang Zhongchun to be forced by Nan Zhiyi to say it one step earlier.

However, if the IOU is denied at this time, this evidence cannot be used as new evidence in the second instance and will not play a role.

Wang Qi pondered for a while, and finally nodded: "The plaintiff agrees that the evidence should be submitted to the collegial panel, and the collegial panel is requested to review it." ”

After speaking, he motioned to Qin Beibei and took out the IOU from the folder he was carrying.

The letterhead is the word IOU, and the lower row reads, "Nanzhiyi borrowed 300,000 yuan from Yang Zhongchun, and the loan term will be returned within three months." Late returns will be subject to an interest rate of 2% per month. ”

After the names of the two people, the ID numbers were clearly written in parentheses, and the time fell three days before Yang Zhongchun withdrew the lawsuit.

At the place where the borrower settles off, it is a very recognizable signature of Nanzhiyi, and the dragon and phoenix dance stretch wantonly, occupying the entire lower right corner.

Judge Cheng silently read the IOU and sighed in his heart.

Such an IOU, there is no proof of transfer, there is no other evidence, if Yang Zhongchun takes the IOU and asks Nan Zhiyi to repay 3 million, the court will definitely not support it.

However, what he has to prove now is only that Nanzhiyi will agree to withdraw the lawsuit on the condition of issuing an IOU.

As long as it can be proved that the signature is indeed Nanzhiyi's, such an IOU is to form a legal relationship of rights and obligations, and it is not the focus of the relationship in this case.

He asked the clerk to hand the IOU to the dock and said, "Defense, what are your opinions on this evidence?" Now ready for publication. ”