The prosecutor spoke: "What was your reaction when you found out that she was going to stab you?" ”

"I don't remember exactly, I just remember that I went to grab her knife, and she took the opportunity to slash me in the face several times, and then I don't know where to hit her, she lay on the bed, and I saw the fruit knife fall on the floor, so I picked it up, I must have stabbed her."

After Xie Shen finished speaking, he added: "You look at the whole process, I am justified in defense, right?" It was she who threatened me with a fruit knife and wanted to kill me, and I was already in danger of my life at that time, could I not pick up the knife? ”

Prosecutor: "You said that when you picked up the fruit knife, Sheng Wan was lying on the bed?" ”

"That's right." Xie Shen didn't think twice.

The prosecutor's voice also became faster: "Why is she lying on the bed?" ”

"I said I don't know." There was a hint of impatience in Xie Shen's tone.

"Did you hit her?"

Huo Ran's long legs were overlapped, his eyes were light, his voice was indifferent, and he said directly: "Oppose, the prosecutor induces questions." ”

Judge: "The objection is valid. ”

The prosecutor smiled, she didn't look at Huo Ran, stared at Xie Shen's expression intently, didn't let go of every change in his mood, and moved her lips: "Okay, defendant, you were arguing at the time, but Sheng Wan was lying on the bed, have you ever thought about what she was doing on her stomach?" ”

"Didn't think about it." Xie Shen answered quickly, and he answered any question from the prosecutor without thinking, without thinking about whether there were any pitfalls, and whether his answers were inconsistent or logically flawed.

Huo Ran slowly raised his eyes and looked in Xie Shen's direction.

He knew that Xie Shen was about to fall into the prosecutor's preset questions, and he was powerless to stop them, because there was nothing wrong with the prosecutor's questioning.

The prosecutor clenched the pen in his hand: "What kind of posture is Sheng Wan lying on his stomach?" ”

Xie Shen smiled suddenly: "I don't know, after so many days, where do I remember so clearly, and what kind of posture can I have when I lie on my stomach, just lying motionless like that." ”

Sure enough, it was exactly the same as Huo Ran thought.

Xie Shen mentioned the words "motionless".

Huo Ran's Adam's apple rolled, his eyes deepened a little, the corners of his lips were silently hooked, and there was some cold mockery, not knowing what he was thinking.

A dark light flashed in the prosecutor's eyes: "Sheng Wan is motionless, you are out of danger, but you still stab her with a fruit knife?" ”

"What's this? If you don't move, can't you stab her? Xie Shen still didn't care, he even asked the prosecutor rhetorically, "Or, do you think that if she is motionless, I can't justify defending if I stab her again?" He raised an eyebrow, "Have you been a prosecutor on the front line for two years?" There was such a case in the High Court of Province F, which was finally found to be justified in self-defense and acquitted. Of course, you might say that our country is not a case law country and does not need to follow previous jurisprudence. Then if you look at Professor Zhang Zhaolin's point of view, he also thinks that my situation is justified defense......"

This time, before he finished speaking, he was interrupted by the presiding judge, whose face was tense and his voice was a little louder: "Defendant, this is my court, please respect the court, and the prosecutor does not need criminal suspects to popularize the law!" ”

Hearing this, Xie Shen smiled, and his slender fingers lightly tapped on the table casually: "Okay, of course your court is up to you." ”

The prosecutor finally asked him again: "In other words, are you sure you stabbed her with a fruit knife when you were motionless in the middle of the night?" So where are you poking? ”

"I don't remember." Xie Shen still said the same sentence, "Maybe the neck, the right?" ”

"Do you know that there are many large arteries in the neck, and it is easy to lose too much blood and die of shock?"

"Yes."

The prosecutor smiled, withdrew his gaze from Xie Shen, raised his eyes to look at the judge, and said, "Presiding Judge, the prosecutor's interrogation of the defendant Xie Shen is here for the time being. ”

Su Yu's chest rose and fell shallowly, she lowered her head, she pursed her lips, and wanted to rush up to block Xie Shen's mouth.

How can there be such a defendant? Step by step, he took the initiative to jump into the trap set by the prosecution, and pushed himself in the direction of guilt step by step, first admitting that Sheng Wan was motionless, and after he was out of danger, he took the initiative to stab someone, ruling out the reason for legitimate defense, and then admitting that he knew that there were many carotid arteries and were prone to shock and death, which was equivalent to admitting that he had the intention to harm (kill), so how could Huo Ran defend himself?

If he really confessed his guilt, it would be forgotten, but he was full of his innocence and that he was wronged.

It's really in response to that sentence, either bad or stupid.

Su Yu lowered her eyes, her fingertips tightened, she really didn't understand, what did Xie Shen want?

The presiding judge glanced at Huo Ran: "Does the defender want to question the defendant Xie Shen?" ”

Huo Ran put down the pen in his hand, raised his eyes, his expression did not change much, he looked at Xie Shen, his thin lips were faint, and he slowly sorted out the cuffs of his suit, his knobly fingers tapped the table one after another, his long eyebrows stretched, and his tone was calm and comfortable: "Don't ask questions for the time being." ”

Xie Lao, who was sitting next to Su Yu, couldn't sit still at first, his face changed suddenly, he clenched his teeth, tightened the lines of his cheeks, and his sharp eyes were majestic and solemn, and he glanced at Huo Ran.

Huo Ran didn't even look at him.

Xie Lao turned his head and looked at Su Yu coldly, the back of his hand holding the dragon's head was a little skinny, but the green muscles were distinct, he pursed his lips tightly, and suppressed his emotions: "What is Huo Ran doing?" Why pass up this opportunity? He can guide Ah Shen to say some good things to the judge! ”

Su Yu swallowed her throat and suppressed the anger that was about to erupt, she couldn't argue with Huo Lao now.

The judge was not at all surprised by Huo Ran's behavior of not asking questions, she said directly: "Okay, now the prosecutor will provide evidence to the court on the facts of the crime of the indictment alleging that the defendant Xie Shen intentionally injured and died." ”

The first witness called by the bailiff was Liu Linjie, the hotel's cleaner.

Sister Liu Lin stood on the witness stand, and began to take the initiative to state: "I am the cleaner of the Wanlin Hotel, at eight o'clock that morning, I began to clean the room on the fourth floor of the hotel, I cleaned up 4011, turned around and saw that the door of 4012 was not hung Do Not Disturb, knocked on the door a few times, and did not hear anyone respond, so I thought that the guest had checked out and left, so I took the universal room card to open the door, pushed the door in, and saw a woman lying on the bed covered in blood, and the white sheets were full of blood. I walked over in fear, touched the woman's nose, and found that she was no longer breathing, so I quickly called the police. ”

The prosecutor looked at her and asked, "When you opened the door, did you see anyone else at the scene?" ”

Sister Liu Lin thought for a moment and shook her head: "No, there is only the deceased lying on the bed in the room, and there is no one else." ”

The judge asked Huo Ran if he had any objections to the testimony of witness No. 1, and Huo Ran still said lightly: "No." ”

Old Xie's face was already ugly.

He couldn't sit still.

Xie Shen lowered his eyelashes, and his long eyelashes fell a thin layer of shadow under the light, so that people couldn't see his expression clearly, but it was a little difficult to distinguish between joy and anger.

The second witness summoned by the bailiff was Zhang Yan, the front desk of the hotel.

The prosecutor looked at Zhang Yan, the contours of her face softened a little, and she asked, "Zhang Yan, what is the relationship between you and the defendant Xie Shen?" ”

Zhang Yan said: "I am the front desk of the Yunlin Hotel, and that night, Xie Shen's hotel check-in business was handled by me. ”

Prosecutor: "Did Xie Shen stay alone?" ”

"No, Xie Shen moved in with a woman, and at that time he said that the woman was his girlfriend, so I opened a double room for them."

"Do you know that the woman who lived with Xie Shen at that time was the victim of this case, Sheng Wan?"

"Yes."

"In addition to check-in, have you ever crossed paths with Xie Shen and Sheng Wan?"

Zhang Yan subconsciously glanced at Xie Shen, and from her point of view, she could only see Xie Shen's cold jaw line, and Zhang Yan said, "Yes." Not long after Xie Shen checked in, he called the front desk that night and asked the hotel housekeeper to bring him a bowl of decanting soup. ”

"Anything else?" The prosecutor bowed his head and recorded.

Zhang Yan pursed the corners of her lower lip: "And the next morning, around 6 o'clock, the front desk phone suddenly rang, I answered, fed several times, but no one replied, but I heard the noisy voice on the other end of the phone, I looked at the room number of the call, it was 4012, I realized that it might be a call from a guest accidentally, because usually guests often accidentally press the front desk phone at the head of the bed." ”

The prosecutor continued: "What did you hear on the phone?" ”

Zhang Yan: "I heard the sound of the two arguing in the room. ”

"What are they arguing about?"

Zhang Yan: "I don't hear it very clearly, it seems that the woman is complaining about the man and ruining her life, and the man is shouting that he wants to kill her......"

The prosecutor smiled lightly and nodded: "Presiding judge, there is no problem on our side." ”

The presiding judge lifted the frame of his glasses and looked at Huo Ran gesturely, this time, Huo Ran sat up straight, raised his head, a faint smile appeared on his clear face, the suit on his body set off his tall figure, the bridge of his nose was particularly straight under the illumination of the light, and he said, "I have a question to ask." ”

The presiding judge nodded and motioned for Huo Ran to start asking questions.

Huo Ran's eyes didn't have much emotion, he stared at Zhang Yan, his thin lips moved slightly: "How long have you been listening to the phone?" ”

"About five minutes."

"Do you hear anything other than the two arguing?"

Zhang Yan pursed the corners of her lower lip, was silent, and shook her head: "No." ”

"Is there really not? For example, screams, fights, cries for help, ......? ”

Before he could finish giving an example, the prosecutor sitting opposite him directly frowned coldly and shouted to the judge: "Objection, the opposing lawyer repeats and asks questions with inducement." ”