The judge didn't even raise his head: "The objection is valid, please pay attention to the way the defender asks questions." ”

Huo Ran smiled faintly, and looked at Zhang Yan motionlessly: "That is, you only heard the sound of the two arguing, right?" What did you do after answering the phone for five minutes? ”

Zhang Yan said: "I went to the 4012 gate, I was afraid that something would happen, but after I walked, I still heard the sound of men and women arguing inside, our hotel is an express hotel, so the sound insulation is not very good." I listened for a while......" she bit her lip, "I thought it should be a normal couple arguing, so I left quickly." ”

Huo Ran repeated lightly: "Ordinary couples quarrel, that is, this time you still only heard the quarrel between the two?" No screams, fights, and cries for help? ”

Zhang Yan replied quickly: "Yes." ”

Huo Ran nodded, his eyebrows slightly constricted: "Presiding Judge, the inquiry is over." ”

This was followed by the prosecution's physical evidence, with the bailiff showing a fruit knife and Xie Shen's blood-stained blazer at the hotel.

The prosecutor explained: "The fruit knife was the criminal suspect Xie Shen's crime tool extracted by the Dongcheng District Public Security Bureau, and the fruit knife had his fingerprint information on it. ”

On the court screen are photographs of the on-site investigation, forensic findings, physical evidence examination reports, on-site inquest records, and surveillance video of Xie Shen entering and leaving the hotel.

The prosecutor concluded: "The time of Sheng Wan's death was between 6 and 7 o'clock in the morning, and we can see from the surveillance that Xie Shen left the door at 6:40 in the morning, and there were his fingerprints on the knife, and there were traces of his blood at the scene, plus his testimony and the testimony of other witnesses corroborated it, it can be proved that the defendant Xie Shen stabbed Sheng Wan to death with a fruit knife." ”

As soon as her words fell, Xie Shen sneered: "Illogical reasoning, I said, I am justified defense." ”

The presiding judge glanced at Xie Shen and asked Huo Ran: "Does the defender have any objections to this?" ”

A faint light flashed in Huo Ran's eyes, and he subconsciously glanced at Su Yu in the audience, Su Yu happened to be looking at him, she nodded lightly towards Huo Ran, and there was a faint smile on her lips slightly pursed.

Huo Ran's eyebrows were calm, and he looked at the PPT flashing on the screen slowly.

That is the point of his defense today.

He stood up, tall, with clear eyebrows, and he lifted the corners of his lips: "Presiding judge, I have four doubts about this evidence. ”

"First, in the "Physical Evidence Examination Report", the police extracted a number of bloodstains from Xie Shen and Sheng Wan's bodies for testing, but the results of the test showed that there was no blood stains on Xie Shen's body, and there were no traces of Xie Shen's blood on Sheng Wan's body." His eyes narrowed, and his gaze swept over the faces of judges and prosecutors.

The judge, who has many years of trial experience, only looks up when she hears something interesting.

She raised her eyes now, looked straight at Huo Ran, and put on a listening look.

The prosecutor frowned slightly and looked at Huo Ran expressionlessly.

Huo Ran continued to explain: "Sheng Wan has several deep knife wounds on his body, in the chest, neck and waist, and the common cervical artery is a fatal injury, we think that the fruit knife in the hands of the police is only 11 cm long, if Xie Shen directly stabbed Sheng Wan with a knife, and the blade is not long, then Sheng Wan's blood will definitely be stained on Xie Shen's body, not to mention, Sheng Wan's common neck artery is cut off by a knife, in this case, blood must be splashed out, but Xie Shen actually has no Sheng Wan's blood on his body." ”

The female prosecutor's hand holding the pen tightened, and surprise flashed in her eyes.

The presiding judge pursed his lips, his face a little serious, as if he was thinking about something.

Su Yu's fingers on the notebook curled up and loosened, these doubts were all found by her and Huo Ran, she was not worried, she was worried about Xie Shen.

So her eyes shrouded Xie Shen for a moment, and the contours of Xie Shen's side face became more and more tense, his handcuffed hands were tightly clenched, and the green tendons on the back of his hands were abrupt, and the joints were pale because of excessive force.

Huo Ran didn't leave everyone time to digest, and he also directly guessed: "Sheng Wan and Xie Shen have no blood stains on each other's bodies, can it also be indirectly proven: During the entire injury, there was no physical contact between the two parties?" If the two have had close contact and injury, they will inevitably leave blood stains on each other. ”

The crowd in the auditorium looked at each other, almost everyone frowned, their faces were incredulous, and after a few seconds of silence, there was a wave of small noise.

"What is this defense lawyer talking nonsense?"

"He means that the wounds on our Wanwan's body were not injured by Xie Shen?"

"No wonder everyone is scolding this Lawyer Huo, he really dares to talk nonsense! Received the money, reversed black and white, and Sheng Wan was not killed? Does he want to say that Sheng Wan committed suicide? It's really a joke, Xie Shen admitted that he stabbed Sheng Wan, and he was a lawyer who was more anxious than the client. ”

"A lawyer is like this, he has no sense of morality, don't scold, the more he scolds other lawyers, the happier he may be, and if he has a reputation, the more shameless people will go to him to defend next time."

The presiding judge struck the gavel: "Silence! ”

Huo Ran was not affected by his surroundings at all, and his thinking was clear: "Second, looking at the five bloodstains extracted from the scene, the bloodstains around the bed (four directions: the ground on the west side, the wall on the north side, and the ground on the south side) are all Xie Shen's, and only the blood stains near the pillow on the bed sheet are Sheng Wan. ”

His voice was clean and clear, with a slight chill: "Looking at the photos of the scene, the blood stains of Sheng Wan are very concentrated, and they only appear around the part where she is lying on her stomach. It can also be seen that Sheng Wan has almost never struggled and resisted, if Sheng Wan has too much resistance or struggle, then her blood stains will not be so concentrated, but will definitely be scattered around her body. What's more, the cut of the neck artery, as long as there is a little struggle, will follow the movement, spray on the surrounding walls and the ground, and never just on the sheets. Why didn't Sheng Wan struggle? If she was really stabbed to death by Xie Shen, she was shocked and suffered from excessive blood loss and died slowly, under the instinctive reaction, people would definitely struggle. ”

Everyone present felt slightly shocked.

The point of blood stains is indeed a point that many people ignore, including the prosecutor, and the elements of her prosecution only need Xie Shen's presence and intentional intent to hurt people.

Because from the distribution of bloodstains, the conclusion that can be inferred is too ridiculous - Sheng Wan was not killed by Xie Shen? It could even be suicide?

This conclusion is ridiculous.

Xie Shen admitted that he had stabbed someone, and also admitted that he stabbed the other party during an argument with Sheng Wan, looking at the existing evidence and logic, it is in line with Xie Shen's intentional injury to death.

Now Huo Ran has put forward a guess: judging from the distribution of blood stains, Sheng Wan and Xie Shen did not have any physical contact during the entire process of injury.

If there is no physical contact, does it mean that it is not the person Xie Shen killed?

But how is that possible? Xie Shen looked so eager to exonerate himself, if it was really not the person he killed, he would have defended himself a long time ago, how could he turn to justifiable defense instead?

Assuming that it was really not the person Xie Shen killed, but there was no trace of a third person at the scene, does that mean that Sheng Wan committed suicide?

How can it be?

This is the thought of all those present.

Sheng Wan had so many knife wounds on her body, deep or shallow, all of them were not killed by a single knife, she finally died of shock from excessive blood loss, that is, she let herself bleed, slowly felt the pain, and then died.

How could anyone commit suicide in such a masochistic way?

Xie Shen didn't say that before Sheng Wan died, he still wanted to ask him for money, such a person didn't look like a person who would commit suicide the next day.

Xie Laoying's eyes were sharp, he heard Huo Ran's words, leaned back in his chair, and smiled.

The smile made people unable to distinguish whether they were happy or angry, but there was an obvious sarcastic smile in his voice, as if he was very satisfied with Huo Ran's dog.

"What does Huo Ran mean is that Sheng Wan committed suicide? was really guessed by Ah Shen, and Lawyer Huo really wanted to say that Sheng Wan committed suicide. His voice was a little hoarse, and his left hand rubbed the jade wrench of his right hand for a while.

"Suicide in the evening? Scold. He shook his head, as if he thought it was funny.

Mr. Xie should have never looked up to a lawyer, he smiled: "Huo Ran, this kid's professional ethics are really strong, he deserves to be a cutting-edge lawyer in City B, he can say black to white, there is no shame, and only such a lawyer can be trusted by clients." ”

Su Yu was silent for a while, and said lightly seriously: "Old Xie, you underestimate Huo Ran too much. ”

Xie Lao didn't even look at Su Yu, his smile seemed to be deeper, but his eyes didn't have much temperature: "Su family girl, you are too optimistic about Huo Ran, no foundation, no background, he is in B City, but he relies on his youth and daring to break through, and in a few years, seeing that he has offended many people, how can he still mix?" ”

Su Yu did not answer Xie Lao's statement, and he felt that there was no need to answer.

How good Huo Ran is, she knows, that's enough.

Su Yu believes that it is possible for people to commit suicide by masochism, when she and Huo Ran determined this suspicion, she checked a lot of information, there have been more than 100 precedents of suicide abroad, and there have been dozens of suicide cases in our social news.

A grand evening is indeed possible.

Su Yu looked at Huo Ran intently, and Huo Ran continued to raise his next suspicion: "Look at this transcript, it was said by the cleaner who called the police, she said that she saw Sheng Wan 'lying on the bed, with her hands folded on her chest', but looking at the photos at the scene, Sheng Wan's hands were stretched out. Looking at the record in the "Scene Investigation Record", he mentioned that the fruit knife was placed on the sheet on the bed on the right side of Sheng Wan's head, but according to the police's "Crime Solving Report", it was said that the fruit knife was found under Sheng Wan's body. ”