In the face of Yang Ji's question again, Liu Xuan was already excited, in the previous debate, although he was slightly at a disadvantage, although the other party has been questioning the authenticity of the ancient text "Shangshu", but this feeling of meeting the opponent made Liu Xuan feel that the blood in his whole body was boiling. Pen @ fun @ pavilion wWw. ｂｉｑUｇE。 ｉｎｆｏ

Real gold is not afraid of fire, I want to see what so-called flaws you can find in the ancient text "Shangshu"!

Taking a deep breath, Liu Xuan opened his mouth and said, "Yang Sima, please speak!" ”

"There are two questions about Houxue, one of them, "Biography" Yunxiaoshui out of the north and south mountains of the river, and the later study consulted historical materials and found that the two Han Dynasty were really out of the city, and the geographical chronicles of the "Book of Han" and "Book of the Later Han" are the same records, and by the time of the Jin Dynasty, the water has been diverted, the province of Yucheng, out of the North Mountain!"

"Second, the "Biography" Yunji Stone Mountain is in the southwest of Jincheng, but Emperor Zhao of the Han Dynasty began to place Jincheng County in the sixth year of the first century, and there was no Jincheng County when Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty!"

Speaking of this, Yang Ji took a deep breath, and then asked loudly: "Kong Anguo's ancient text "Shangshu" has been lost after the Yongjia Rebellion, and Emperor Shi Mei of the Jin Yuan Dynasty said that the ancient text "Shangshu" he dedicated is the ancient text "Shangshu" of Kong Anguo in the Han Dynasty..."

"At that time, Mei Zhen also presented the "Preface to the Book of Shang" and "The Biography of the Book of Shang", which was also written by Kong Anguo according to his words, and was presented to the Han court together with the ancient text "Book of Shang".

"If what Mei Zhen said is true, why did the "Shangshu Biography" of Emperor Wu use the new way of the Jin Dynasty to describe the flow of the water? Why did the "Shangshu Biography" that appeared in the world at the time of Emperor Wu actually use the name of the place that only existed when Emperor Zhao, the son of Emperor Wu!! ”

"I can't learn it, I can't understand the truth, and please ask Mr. to answer!!"

Yang Ji's words were loud, and as soon as the words fell, Liu Xuan's face changed after only a slight thought, and he wanted to say something but couldn't open his mouth.

Because he had read countless books, he recalled Hanshu and various historical books according to Yang Ji's doubts, and was not sure about the problem of the diversion of the water as mentioned by the other party, but vaguely remembered that Jincheng County seemed to be the first place of Emperor Zhao of the Han Dynasty.

If the other person is not wrong, then it means...

"The Biography of Shangshu" is a forgery by people after the Han Dynasty, so the "Preface to Shangshu" and the ancient text "Shangshu" presented by Mei Zhen together are also very likely to be forgeries.

Therefore, the ancient text "Shangshu", which I have been reading for decades, is very likely to be a forgery?

With a snap, the charcoal pen in Zhang Hua's hand broke, this was because of excessive force, Zhang Hua, who was a shorthandman, heard Yang Ji's questioning, and his heart was already turbulent.

In the early Han Dynasty, whether it was Fu Sheng's modern text "Shangshu" or Kong Anguo's ancient Confucian text "Shangshu", it was lost after the Yongjia Rebellion, and no one knew its true face.

It was not until later that Yu Zhang's Shi Mei Zhen presented the "Book of Shang", and there were "Book of Shang Preface" and "Book of Shang Biography", Mei Zhen claimed that this was the ancient text of Kong Anguo's Confucian wall "Book of Shang", and then it was verified by many famous scholars as true, and it was established as an official school.

For hundreds of years in the Southern Dynasties, the "Book of Shang" that scholars learned was the "Book of Shang" offered by Mei Chen, and Zhang Hua was no exception, he had read for decades and was convinced of the statement that Mei Chen's ancient text "Book of Shang" was a real book.

As a result, it turns out that this is highly likely to be fake? Yes?

Not only Zhang Hua, Zhang Ke, who originated from the Southern Dynasties Department, and Zheng Tong, have been hit by five thunders, they have been hit by five thunders from the beginning of their studies, the teacher or the elder professor's "Shangshu" is the ancient text of Mei Zhen "Shangshu", as a result, the result...

As long as there is still reason, we should accept Yang Ji's two doubts about the "Biography of Shangshu".

Although they may not have known that the Qianshui changed lanes during the Han and Jin dynasties, they may not have remembered that the Han book said that the Qianshui came from the city, and they may not have known that Jincheng County was only set up by Emperor Zhao of the Han Dynasty, but this did not prevent them from leaning towards Yang Ji's view.

Maybe Yang Ji is talking nonsense, but this is unlikely, because when he dares to talk nonsense on such an occasion, when the truth is revealed afterwards, this person's reputation will stink, not to mention that Zheng Tong and others can still trust Yang Ji's personality.

Therefore, the ancient text "Shangshu" dedicated by Mei Zhen, who I have been regarded as a model for decades, is very likely to be fake?

Downstairs, Xu Shao wiped the cold sweat on his forehead, his mind was a little messy, so he had to sort out his thoughts, Yang Ji's doubts he was inclined to believe, but he didn't know whether to believe or not.

Because once it is determined that the "Shangshu Biography" is a forgery, then it will be accompanied by proof that the ancient text "Shangshu" of Mei Zhen is very likely to be a forgery.

During the reign of Emperor Yuan of the Jin Dynasty, Mei Zhen presented 58 articles of "Shangshu", including 33 articles of "Shangshu" of Fusheng Jinwen, 25 articles of "Shangshu" of Kong Anguo's ancient text, and "Shangshu Biography" and "Shangshu Preface", which were written by Kong Anguo in the Han Dynasty according to Mei Zhen.

That is to say, Mei Chen's dedication to the book includes the modern text "Shangshu", the ancient text "Shangshu", Kong Anguo's "Shangshu Biography", and Kong Anguo's "Shangshu Preface".

At that time, the scriptures had already determined that the present text "Shangshu" was not "Shangshu", so the ancient text of Confucius "Shangshu" was the source, and the "Shangshu" learned in the Southern Dynasty for hundreds of years was the ancient text "Shangshu" offered by Mei Zhen.

Everyone believes that this book is the ancient Confucian text "Shangshu" of Kong Anguo in the Han Dynasty, and the appearance of "Shangshu Biography" and "Shangshu Preface" at the same time is naturally the source, and the ancient text "Shangshu" scriptures, "Shangshu Biography" and "Shangshu Preface" are one.

And now? Yang Ji questioned the "Preface to Shangshu" before, and his questioning sounded reasonable, but Liu Xuan's answer also sounded reasonable, so there were probably doubts about the authenticity of "Preface to Shangshu".

Then there is the "Shangshu" scriptures, in which Yang Ji's questioning of "Da Yu Mo" makes people feel quite reasonable, and Liu Xuan's explanation sounds a little pale.

Aside from these, Liu Xuan can't refute Yang Ji's two doubts about "The Biography of Shangshu", and the questioning sounds reasonable, which shows that "The Biography of Shangshu" is fake.

Xu Shao has been a county guard for several years and has solved countless cases, so he has huge doubts about the credibility of the so-called evidence from the perspective of judging cases.

The ancient texts "Shangshu", "Shangshu Chuan", and "Shangshu Preface" are one, and as a result, "Shangshu Chuan" now seems very likely to be forged, so what is his motive?

According to Mei Zhen, "The Biography of Shangshu" and "Preface to Shangshu" were written by Kong Anguo in the Han Dynasty, which is an important circumstantial evidence to prove that the ancient text "Shangshu" he dedicated is true, so the other party actually used a forgery to prove that the "Shangshu" he presented was a real book, so the motive was about to come out.

In a homicide case, the suspect has alibi evidence at the time of the crime, which is supposed to clear the suspicion, but it is later found that the alibi evidence was forged by his brother, what does that mean?

The brother of the suspected murderer is covering up, and if you want the government to believe that your brother has no time to commit the crime, what are they covering? It's a suspected murder!

Therefore, it is very likely that the ancient text "Shangshu" presented by Mei Xun is fake, and in order to increase credibility, he compiled two other "Shangshu Biography" and "Shangshu Preface", which were written under the name of Kong Anguo, so as to deceive the scholars of the imperial court as circumstantial evidence.

Of course, it is also possible that Mei Zhen obtained the "Biography of Shangshu" and "Shangshu Preface" from elsewhere, mistakenly recognized these two books as genuine books, and presented them to the imperial court together with his own collection of ancient texts "Shangshu".

However, according to Yang Ji's doubts before, there are more and more doubts about the ancient text "Shangshu" presented by Mei Zhen, if it is really a fake book, then...

On the podium, Liu Zhuo looked at Liu Xuan and Yang Ji, swallowing his saliva with difficulty, he doubted his memory for the first time, because after listening to Yang Ji's questioning, his first reaction was that the other party was not wrong: Jincheng County was indeed set by Emperor Zhao of the Han Dynasty.

What does this mean? The "Biography of Shangshu" that Mei Zhen dedicated is said to be written by Kong Anguo, but it is actually forged by later generations!

Liu Zhuo thought of a terrible possibility, and suddenly felt cold hands and feet, he began to doubt his memory, and trembled his hand to signal the scholar to step forward: "You... You immediately go to the library and put the Book of Han, the Book of the Later Han... And "Water Scripture Note" all brought over! ”

Without waiting for the scholar to leave, Liu Xuan took a deep breath, then saluted Yang Ji and said, "What Yang Sima asked, Liu was speechless and taught!" ”