After Fang Aoqin finished speaking, he finally breathed a sigh of relief in his heart, the problem given by Sima Qiqi was too difficult to solve, this judge had been kicking the ball to himself, if it wasn't for Fang Aoqin to calm down, this Xia He would have been acquitted.

After Fang Aoqin finished speaking, he sat on the chair to calm down, even Fang Aoqin admired himself in the rebuttal just now, Fang Aoqin seemed to have just experienced a life-and-death struggle, Fang Aoqin felt that he was already on the verge of death, and as a result, he survived with his tenacious vitality.

This problem returned to Sima Qiqi's side, Sima Qiqi didn't expect Fang Aoqin to be calm enough to find a breakthrough in such a difficult situation, the judge saw that Sima Qiqi's face was solemn now, and he finally breathed a sigh of relief, if Sima Qiqi won the lawsuit so easily, then his future is estimated to have no hope.

The judge looked at Sima Qiqi with a relaxed face and asked, "Defense lawyer, do you have anything to add to the prosecutor's point of view?" ”

Sitting in the auditorium, he looked anxious, but there was nothing he could do. Sima Qiqi thought about it, looked up at the judge and said slowly.

"Your Excellency, we have no new evidence for the time being, but we do not believe that the reasons given by the prosecutor are sufficient to bring this trial to an end."

When the judge and Fang Aoqin heard Sima Qiqi say this, they both looked at Sima Qiqi with solemn faces, Sima Qiqi dared to say this, he must still be prepared, Fang Aoqin never despised his opponent, especially Sima Qiqi, who was defeated by Sima Qiqi several times, and Fang Aoqin had no reason not to recognize the strength of this powerful opponent.

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he was stunned, came back to his senses and asked: "The defense lawyer thinks that the reasons given by the prosecutor are not enough to refute your statement that the defendant was under a kind of indirect hypnosis?" ”

Sima Qiqi nodded, looking at Fang Aoqin's face like frost, anyone who looked at the current Sima Qiqi instantly felt that they were in an extremely cold area surrounded by icebergs, even if Fang Aoqin had seen countless powerful defense lawyers, the sense of oppression that Sima Qiqi gave people was completely indescribable.

Sima Qiqi put away her cold expression, looked at the judge and said very politely: "Your Excellency, the reason given by the prosecutor is that the police did not say any guiding words or give hints when my client recorded the confession, which I agree, but whether my client's brain was in a state of indirect hypnosis at that time, whether the prosecutor did not explain. ”

Before Sima Qiqi's words fell, Fang Aoqin stood up and said loudly: "Objection, Your Excellency, the defense lawyer's previous statement that the defendant is in a state of hypnosis and the confession he made is not legal, we have already explained in the opinion just refuted that the defense lawyer is now repeating the previous statement, and we believe that the defense lawyer is wasting court time and wasting taxpayers' public funds." ”

After Fang Aoqin finished speaking, he sat back in his place, the judge looked at Sima Qiqi, hoping that Sima Qiqi would give a reasonable explanation, Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and said calmly: "Your Excellency, the reason for the rebuttal given by the prosecutor just now, I thought about it carefully, the prosecutor does not have any evidence at all to prove that my client is not in a state of indirect hypnosis, the prosecutor just proves that no one guides my client to answer relevant questions when my client's brain is in a relaxed state, of course, I also reserve my doubts." According to the professional testimony of our previous witness, Professor Yue Sanchuan, the five knocks were similar in strength and rhythm......"

Before Sima Qiqi finished speaking, Fang Aoqin stood up again and said: "Objection, Your Excellency, I have already said before, writing with a pen in hand, many people have their own small movements, and the small action of tapping the table with a pen does not mean anything, the strength is similar and the rhythm is similar, just because the same person sent it." ”

As soon as Fang Aoqin finished speaking, Sima Qiqi continued: "Your Excellency, the prosecutor thinks that the same person can make a knock sound with a similarity of about 80%, but we don't think so, yes, a person has his own habits, such as eating, but in the same period of time can reach more than 80% similarity, I think it is almost impossible, I ask Your Excellency the judge to approve the conduct of a social survey, and ask the relevant universities to assist the court in the investigation, collect and analyze data." ”

When Fang Aoqin heard Sima Qiqi say this, he said loudly with a surprised face: "Your Excellency, I firmly oppose the use of time-consuming and laborious methods such as social investigations, because similar knocks waste a lot of manpower and material resources to conduct completely unrelated investigations, which is a waste of taxpayers' public funds. ”

When the judge heard Fang Aoqin say this, he was in a dilemma for a while, Sima Qiqi saw that the judge frowned and had a difficult face, coughed and said slowly: "Your Excellency, the reason why my client's case has attracted the attention of all parties in society is because not long after the release of the new law, my client's case is like the content of the new law, and different voices appeared in the society when the new law was released, and some people think that the new law is to better protect the safety of doctors and nurses. Some people think that someone may use the new law to kill someone and still be innocent. However, if the court sentences my client in a controversial case, I think that public opinion will once again vigorously discuss the solemnity and justice of the law, and in order to preserve the solemnity and justice of the law, I ask Your Excellency the judge to give careful consideration to my proposal. ”

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, the boss had a reluctant expression on his face, but the judge looked at the people sitting in the auditorium, ordinary lawyers, and a bunch of reporters, these reporters were staring at themselves at this time, like a hungry hyena looking at their prey, and the judge's own careless behavior may make the entire system face a crisis of confidence, the judge thought about it and couldn't help swallowing his saliva and said slowly.

"The defense lawyer raised the doubts of the case, and this court carefully considered that it was true that the defendant was not guided, and the police did not have any irregularities during the interrogation, but what kind of situation the defendant was in at that time, there is no way to know, this court believes that the appearance of the five knocks may be a coincidence, but according to the information provided by the defense witnesses, the five knocks are 80% similar in terms of both the force of the knock and the rhythm of the interval, and the court also believes that this situation needs to be explained clearly. In order to resolve the social doubts, this court approved the defense lawyer to launch a social investigation based on the similarity of the five knocks, and jointly conducted data collection and analysis with the three major professional institutions of Southwest University of Arts and Sciences, Shunan University and the Institute of Social Behavior, and the case was postponed until the relevant investigation results came out, and the trial time will be announced to the public one week before the formal trial. The case was postponed, and the defendant was not released on bail and remanded in custody pending trial because he was still suspected of murder. Retire from court! ”

After the judge announced his verdict, he struck the gavel hard, and when Fang Aoqin heard the judge say this, he closed the document in front of him with an unconvinced face.

Sima Qiqi was worried that the judge would not approve his request after weighing the pros and cons, so he kept looking at the judge with a nervous face, and when the judge officially announced, Sima Qiqi sat on the chair with relief, and showed a tired smile at Xia He, Xia He looked at Sima Qiqi blankly.

Sima Qiqi smiled at Xia He, although Xia He didn't know what this trial meant to him, but seeing Sima Qiqi showing the smile of the confidant big sister when he was a child, Xia He felt a lot more down-to-earth, and hurriedly came to Sima Qiqi Xiaoyan with Sha Yu.

Seeing Sima Qiqi's tired look, he hurriedly reached out to help Sima Qiqi get the bag, and the four of them walked out of the courtroom, Sha Yu asked curiously: "Then can I ask, what is the purpose of you asking the court to agree to that social investigation, I don't think this social investigation has any effect?" ”

bumped Sha Yu's stomach, and said with a disgusted face: "Of course the method that my family Qiqi thought of is useful, and you are not a lawyer, of course you don't know what the purpose of my family Qiqi is, but to be honest, I am also very curious, why do you ask for a social investigation." ”

Sha Yu heard that he didn't know the results of his own results, so he slapped him with disgust, Sima Qiqi took a few breaths of fresh air and said slowly: "My purpose is to prove that the five knocks did not appear by chance, but appeared in the police video materials in a purposeful and targeted manner, as long as this can be proved and amplified, this is the breakthrough, my bureau has been completed, I am curious about what method Fang Aoqin will use to solve it." ”

Sima Qiqi showed a confident smile, suddenly looked back at Sha Yu, and said slowly: "If this bureau is to be completed, it depends on you." ”

"Ah, I'm going to get involved too?"

Sha Yu asked reluctantly when he heard Sima Qiqi's words.

Hearing Sha Yu's question, he slapped Sha Yu on the body without saying a word, glared at Sha Yu, Sha Yu immediately looked at Sima Qiqi with a smile and said, "Sister-in-law instructs, the little brother must do it properly, I don't know what to let the little brother do?" ”

When Sima Qiqi heard Sha Yu say this, he smiled mysteriously and said: "It's very simple, I want you to find as many people as possible to knock out five dong, all ages, the more from all walks of life, the better, I want to use statistical big data this time to let Fang Aoqin see my determination to defend Xia He's innocence." ”

Hearing Sima Qiqi say this, the two frowned in unison, this matter is easy to say, but in practice, it is a lot of expenses, Sha Yu looked back and hoped to persuade him, and after thinking about it, he answered Sima Qiqi categorically.

When Sha Yu heard the promise to Sima Qiqi, he almost fainted, and thought, "It's better to take the money and go to the water!" ”