After listening to Yue Sanchuan's explanation of "cold hypnosis", Sima Qiqi nodded and pointed to the big screen in the courtroom and asked, "Professor Yue, then now I want to ask, what do you think of the knock sound in the audio materials?" ”

"Objection, Your Excellency, the knock sound in the audio is not enough evidence at all, because we don't even know what the specific thing that made the knock sound is, how can a sound that is not of clear origin appear as evidence in court."

The judge looked at Sima Qiqi, and Sima Qiqi said slowly: "Your Excellency, it is impossible for us to make such a low-level mistake, this is the inspection report obtained by our professional analysis of the audio data. ”

Sima Qiqi said respectfully handing over the report to the court staff, and the staff handed over the inspection report provided by Sima Qiqi to the judge, who read it carefully, Sima Qiqi explained: "According to the analysis of professionals, the sound that appears in the audio, in addition to the sound of talking, walking and decoration we heard, there are two sounds, one is the knock sound just now, and the other is the rustle of the gel pen writing on the paper, so the professionals speculate that the slight knock sound should be made by the gel pen body hitting the desktop." ”

The judge listened to Sima Qiqi's explanation and continued to look through the information, Sima Qiqi paused and continued: "Professionals have verified the gel pens sold on the market, and we have also found the table materials purchased by the police station. ”

Sima Qiqi said and took a gel pen in his hand and showed it to everyone, the judge listened to Sima Qiqi's explanation and read the relevant information provided by Sima Qiqi, and motioned to the staff to hand over the information to Fang Aoqin, Fang Aoqin hesitated for a moment or took the information.

Sima Qiqi saw Fang Aoqin's unconvinced look, and said slowly: "If the prosecutor still doubts the information we provide, we can give time for the prosecutor to verify." ”

Sima Qiqi looked at Fang Aoqin with a smile on his face, Fang Aoqin flipped through the information slightly, sighed and closed the information, stood up and said slowly with a calm face: "No need, I believe that the defense lawyer's professional level and ability will not make any low-level mistakes, Your Excellency Judge, please continue the trial." ”

When the judge heard Fang Aoqin say this, he nodded slightly, looked at Sima Qiqi and said, "Defense lawyer, you can continue to question your witnesses." ”

Sima Qiqi nodded to the judge to express his gratitude, and looked at Yue Sanchuan to ask the question just now, Yue Sanchuan said slowly: "I have heard this audio material, and I found that the sound of tapping on the desktop is always made after the person asking the question finishes, which seems to be very common, but I used the relevant computer to analyze, and I found that the time point of each tapping is completely consistent, that is, the person who taps the desktop with a pen accurately grasps the strength and rhythm." ”

When Yue Sanchuan stated his opinion on the "dong dong" sound in the audio materials, Sima Qiqi motioned Xiao Yan to take out the relevant information, Xiao Yan put the information on the big screen of the court, Yue Sanchuan saw the relevant data appear on the big screen of the court, and the staff explained to Yue Sanchuan how to operate, Yue Sanchuan pointed at the screen with a laser pointer and said.

"You can take a look, there are five knocks in the audio materials, each knock knock, in two consecutive sounds, I use computer software to analyze, knock knock sound in the possible strength and rhythm of the knock, the similarity of the five knock sounds is 80%, because this is a human rather than a machine, so 80% is already very high. From my professional point of view, I think that the defendant was subjected to indirect hypnosis when he was questioned to get a confession, well, I'm done. ”

Sima Qiqi nodded and thanked Yue Sanchuan, Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and said: "Your Excellency, just now the witness looked at the knocking sound that occurred when my client was heard of with his professional eyes, and thought that someone was indirectly hypnotizing my client. In other words, the police filed a case against my client based on my client's confession, which is not valid on the key point of the legality of the evidence, so I ask Your Excellency the judge to remand the case to the police for re-investigation. ”

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he felt embarrassed, this hypnosis was originally a matter of legal disagreement, Sima Qiqi used Xia He to be hypnotized to defend, how to prove that Xia He was not hypnotized This is Fang Aoqin's business, Sima Qiqi just questioned, the judge couldn't help but look at Fang Aoqin, Fang Aoqin was put together by Sima Qiqi, because the audio material became part of the video material, Sima Qiqi did not submit a new application for evidence, Fang Aoqin did not expect Sima Qiqi to be so tricky, Defend with hypnosis as an argument.

Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and Fang Aoqin, Sima Qiqi knew that he had a problem for Fang Aoqin and the judge, but judging from Sima Qiqi's several battles with Fang Aoqin, Fang Aoqin was not a person who gave up easily. Although Sima Qiqi felt that the balance of victory was tilted in favor of him, he still did not dare to take it lightly. Everyone in the auditorium saw Sima Qiqi raise a big problem, and they all held their breath and looked at Fang Aoqin, and many people were thinking about how to break this deadlock.

Just when everyone was quiet, the judge suddenly opened his mouth to break the quiet atmosphere: "Prosecutor, do you have any other questions for the defense witnesses?" ”

Fang Aoqin heard the judge say this, it was obvious that the judge kicked the ball to himself, Fang Aoqin knew that this case was particularly important, for no other reason, that is, because this case appeared after the new law was released and completely fit the description of the new law, whether this is the end of the new law or the new law to maintain the image of justice, it depends on how this lawsuit is fought, the judge is still throwing the problem to himself, to put it bluntly, when the time comes, the judge will make the final judgment based on the statements put forward by the prosecution and defense, even if the verdict is not guilty, it is impossible to blame the judge, And only Fang Aoqin can bear this punishment by himself, a smart person like Fang Aoqin naturally understands this truth, but now Fang Aoqin is like an intern who has just graduated from the law department, there is no way at all.

Fang Aoqin stood up and looked at Yue Sanchuan who didn't speak for a long time, this is a dead end in Fang Aoqin's eyes, it should be said that it is a dead end in the eyes of any legal worker, Sima Qiqi defended Xia He with hypnosis, in fact, he knew that Fang Aoqin couldn't produce any evidence to prove that Xia He was conscious at that time, and Sima Qiqi took advantage of a loophole, she did not prove that Xia He was unconscious, but used environmental evidence to prove it, Fang Aoqin had a feeling of lifting a stone and hitting his own feet.

The judge saw that Fang Aoqin stood up and didn't speak for a long time, coughed, Fang Aoqin came back to his senses, the judge saw that Fang Aoqin's eyes changed, and he glanced slightly, signaling Fang Aoqin to ask if he had a question, and now everyone is watching.

Fang Aoqin looked at Yue Sanchuan and thought for a moment, then asked stubbornly, "Witness, your profession is a psychology professor, right?" ”

Yue Sanchuan heard Fang Aoqin ask himself this question, looked at Fang Aoqin blankly, and slowly answered yes, Fang Aoqin pretended to be calm at this time, at this time, Fang Aoqin had never asked such an idiotic question since he was in the industry, Fang Aoqin looked at Yue Sanchuan and said: "You just thought that the defendant was in a state of being hypnotized, just by those five knocks?" ”

Yue Sanchuan heard Fang Aoqin ask, thought for a while and replied slowly: "Yes, I also said just now, indirect hypnosis does not need to use drugs or the like, as long as there is a rhythmic sound or light, or even some patterns, it can make people's consciousness relax, and the ideology of the hypnotized person is in a relatively slight hypnotic state......

"Okay, witness, thank you for your explanation, I also want to ask you a question, even if it is indirect hypnosis, do you need to guide the hypnotized person?"

Fang Aoqin calmed down and suddenly found a question that he had ignored, and Sima Qiqi frowned when they heard Fang Aoqin ask this question, this question was also asked by Yue Sanchuan before, Yue Sanchuan told the two that if the knock sound was a hypnotic sound, then it would just put the inquirement's brain in a relaxed state, and if there was no guide vocabulary, it would not answer casually. However, Sima Qiqi still raised this doubt in court with the mentality of giving it a try.

After Fang Aoqin calmed down, he suddenly thought that hypnosis could not have an answer if he didn't ask a guiding question, when Fang Aoqin asked this question, he deliberately looked at Sima Qiqi and found that Sima Qiqi frowned, Fang Aoqin knew that this dead end could be said to have been solved by him.

Yue Sanchuan hesitated for a moment, nodded and said: "You're right, hypnosis needs guidance, the sound of dong dong just now is very rhythmic, but it is just a state that makes people's brains relax, in this state, through some guiding questions, you can get corresponding answers." ”

Fang Aoqin heard Yue Sanchuan's answer, the corners of his mouth rose slightly, and Fang Aoqin felt that the tilted balance was gradually balanced, and he even had a state of tilting in his direction.

Fang Aoqin looked at the judge, although his face looked calm, but his voice reflected that Fang Aoqin was already slightly excited at this time.

"Your Excellency Judge, since the defense witness said that the knock may just make people's brains relax, then in the case of relaxation, it is impossible to get the corresponding answer without a guiding question, we have just listened to the information of the relevant questioning several times, when the police questioned, did not ask whether the defendant stabbed the deceased four times, but asked how many times the deceased was stabbed, and there were no guiding words, and the behavior of tapping the table with a pen, I think many people will have, therefore, The argument of the defense lawyer that the defendant pleaded guilty under hypnosis does not hold water. I request the Tribunal to continue the hearing, ignoring the request of the defence counsel. ”