Chapter 394: Hypothetical Collision

I saw Zhuo Ao plug in the U disk and play a video on the big screen of the court, the picture is a bus stop, I saw a bus slowly driving into the bus stop, when the bus stopped, a group of people got off the bus, and at this time a woman not far away was running towards the bus quickly.

At this moment, Zhuo Ao pressed the pause, and the judge pointed to the big screen and looked at Zhuo Ao and asked, "Plaintiff lawyer, please explain, what is the significance of this video that you presented in court?"

"Your Excellency Judge, thank you for allowing me to present this evidence, this video is the picture taken by the Sky Eye at the intersection of the bus stop, please look at the date and time, it happened to be the day of the crime, we also checked with the emergency center, at about 3 o'clock in the afternoon of the same day, there was indeed a call from this bus stop, that is to say, this time period is the time when the injured and the defendant collided."

Zhuo Ao said, took out a document and handed it to the court secretary, the court secretary handed it to the judge, the judge looked at it, and asked the court secretary to hand it to Sima Qiqi.

Sima Qiqi took the document and read it carefully, and found that there was indeed only one emergency call near the bus stop at three o'clock, Zhuo Ao was right, Sima Qiqi turned his head and looked at the suspended picture on the big screen of the courtroom again, and had a bad premonition in his heart.

Sima Qiqi returned the document to the court secretary, and the court secretary returned to his place and sat down, Zhuo Ao replayed the picture at this time, only to see the running woman running quickly from behind the platform to the bus, and when the bus left, some people gathered on the platform one after another.

At this time, Zhuo Ao paused the picture again, Zhuo Ao looked at the judge and said slowly: "Your Excellency, on the day of the crime, at 14:58 in the afternoon, that is, the time period of 00:48 in the video playback, we can see from the picture that when the bus leaves the platform, many passers-by gather on the platform, and it can be seen from their standing posture that they are not waiting for the bus, but watching what is the big thing, what is the big thing, in fact, I think everyone already knows, that is, an old man fell to the ground, and no one knows what to do."

Sima Qiqi frowned when he heard Zhuo Ao say this, the judge quickly recorded on the paper, Zhuo Ao played the picture again, and soon Zhuo Ao pressed the pause and pulled the picture to, Zhuo Ao pointed to the screen and said: "Please pay attention to the video playback 01:02, please note that this person in the picture is picking up his mobile phone to make a call."

Sima Qiqi glanced at the big screen and picked up a pen to record it, Zhuo Ao was about to play the video, the judge looked at Zhuo Ao and said slowly: "Plaintiff lawyer, how long is your video?"

Zhuo Ao looked at the judge and said with a smile: "Your Excellency, this video is only more than two minutes, and it will be over soon!"

"You're not going to pause for more than ten seconds, right?"

The judge looked at Zhuo Ao with a worried face and said slowly, Zhuo Ao smiled and said: "Your Excellency, no, I will complete this evidence soon, please rest assured that I will not waste the time of the court trial."

The judge heard Zhuo Ao's answer, nodded helplessly, and Zhuo Ao played the video again, this time only

Focusing on the man who had enlarged the picture and making a phone call before, when the video was about to end, Zhuo Ao pressed the pause button, pointed to the screen and said slowly: "Your Excellency Judge, everyone, please pay attention to the playback time at 02:10, at this time, the man who called hung up the phone, according to the time, the call time was at 14:59 in the afternoon on the day of the crime, and the hang-up was at 15:00, which coincided with the time I provided before to call the emergency number."

The judge nodded slightly, and then Zhuo Ao replayed a new video, Zhuo Ao looked at the judge and said, "Your Excellency, please allow me to present the second video evidence of the plaintiff in court."

The judge nodded, Zhuo Ao got an agreed reply, and began to play the video, the video has two screens, at first, both pictures are the same bus stop, as the bus slowly moves into the platform, the picture begins to change, the left screen zooms in on the position of the back door of the bus, yo becomes just the enlarged picture of the street going to the bus stop.

In the video, after the bus stopped, the front and rear doors were opened, there were few people on this platform, but there were a few people who got off the bus, just as everyone was watching the picture carefully, Zhuo Ao paused the picture again, pointed to the screen and said: "Your Excellency, at 00:30 in the video playback period, please note that this person, according to the plaintiff's confirmation, is indeed the injured."

I saw Zhuo Ao zoom in on the picture and make a mark, and at this time everyone noticed an old lady with gray hair, and the outline of her facial features was vaguely recognizable.

"Your Excellency, this is the bus travel schedule, the current buses have electronic monitoring, to avoid the bus too late to the platform and install on each bus, we according to the number of bus routes and license plate numbers shown in the video to find the bus company to ask them for relevant information, I want to submit this document to the court, please approve it."

Zhuo Ao said very sincerely, and the judge nodded and said slowly: "Agreed, but the plaintiff's lawyer, please pay attention to your speed, don't delay too much."

Zhuo Ao nodded and handed the document to the court secretary, and the court secretary handed it to the judge, the judge took a cursory look, and then asked the court secretary to transfer it to Sima Qiqi, who took the document and glanced at it roughly, and returned the document to the court secretary.

"Does the defense lawyer have any questions about the relevant documents provided by the plaintiff's lawyer?"

Sima Qiqi stood up and looked at Zhuo Ao, and said slowly: "There is no problem on our side, Your Excellency Judge."

The judge nodded slightly, signaling Zhuo Ao to continue, Zhuo Ao said slowly: "Your Excellency Judge, after our investigation, the bus carrying the injured person entered the platform at 14:56, of course, it did not stop immediately, and the bus driver will not open the door until the bus is completely stopped, this time should be around 14:57, which can correspond to the video time, and the video presented in the previous court was at 00:48, that is, at 14:58 at the time of the crime, so the time I said is completely correct."

Zhuo Ao said and glanced at the judge, the judge nodded slightly, Zhuo Ao saw the reaction, the corners of his mouth rose slightly, Zhuo Ao pointed to the picture on the right and said slowly: "Judge."

Your Excellency, please look at the picture on the right, at this time, there is a fast running man on the street, and we will continue to watch the video content. ”

Zhuo Ao said, playing the second video again, and there was indeed a woman running quickly to the bus stop in the picture on the right.

Zhuo Ao paused the video again, pointed to the two screens and said: "Your Excellency, please pay attention to the situation in the left and right screens, let's look at the left screen first, this is the injured person, at this time she happened to be on the bus stop, walking towards the street behind the platform."

Zhuo Ao glanced at the judge, only to see that the judge was recording quickly, Zhuo Ao was waiting for the judge to finish writing, Zhuo Ao saw that the movements of the judge's hand slowed down before continuing: "Then look at the picture on the right, you can clearly see that the woman who is running towards the bus quickly at this time has also run behind the bus stop."

The judge nodded, and then Zhuo Ao replayed the video, only three seconds, Zhuo Ao pressed the pause button again, Zhuo Ao said slowly: "Your Excellency Judge, please pay attention to the picture on the right, at this time, the woman running fast has left the bus stop and ran towards the front door of the bus, and then look at the picture on the left, the injured person is gone, please look at the video playback period, it shows 00:45, I have already said that the previous video left the bus platform at 00:48 during the playing period, that is, at that time, there were pedestrians watching the bus stop one after another."

The judge nodded, and Zhuo Ao saw a slightly smug expression on the judge's nodding face, and Zhuo Ao continued: "According to the injured person and the defendant......"

The judge interrupted: "Wait for the plaintiff's lawyer, the outline of the female facial features running fast in the video is not very clear, defense lawyer, does your client admit that it is her who is running fast in the video?"

Sima Qiqi and Li Xiaona whispered for a while, Sima Qiqi said a few words to Li Xiaona, only to see Li Xiaona reluctantly nodded, Sima Qiqi seemed to ask Li Xiaona's opinion again, and with Li Xiaona's consent, Sima Qiqi stood up and said: "I'm sorry Your Excellency, Your Excellency, I just confirmed with my client, and I didn't deliberately delay and not answer."

The judge nodded slightly to express his forgiveness for Sima Qiqi's behavior of not answering immediately, and Sima Qiqi smiled slightly and said, "Your Excellency, my client is sure that the woman running fast in the video is herself."

The judge nodded and recorded on the paper, and the judge said without raising his head: "Plaintiff's lawyer, please continue!"

Zhuo Ao nodded and continued: "Your Excellency, according to the walking path of the injured person and the defendant in the second video, we have reason to suspect that the injured person fell to the ground and was sent to the hospital for medical treatment, which was caused by the defendant?"

When the judge heard Zhuo Ao say this, he raised his head and said with a slight puzzlement: "The video evidence provided by the plaintiff did not directly capture the collision between the defendant and the injured!"

Zhuo Ao hurriedly replied: "Yes, Your Excellency, due to the existence of a certain blind spot, however, at the same time and in the same place, the two of them are facing each other, we have decided to ask the judge to determine that the defendant injured the injured person in the collision and bear the medical expenses of the injured person in the future

Living expenses. ”

As soon as Zhuo Ao finished speaking, Sima Qiqi stood up and said: "Objection, Your Excellency, the hypothetical collision that the plaintiff's lawyer said must be in the same direction at the same time, and there must be no deviation in the slightest, but in the two video evidence presented by the plaintiff's lawyer just now, I found a problem, in the second evidence, at 00:45, my client has run out of the bus stop and ran towards the front door of the bus, and the pedestrians in the first video are 00:48, which means that the time it takes for the injured person to fall to the ground is three seconds different from the time it takes for my client to leave the bus stop. ”

(End of chapter)