Chapter 395: Three Seconds Gap
After Sima Qiqi finished speaking, the judge looked at the big screen again, looked at Zhuo Ao and said slowly: "Plaintiff's lawyer, please re-play video evidence 1 and 2."
Zhuo Ao heard the judge say this, his expression was slightly embarrassed and nodded, Zhuo Ao re-played the video, and narrowed the two video windows, only to see three pictures appear on the big screen of the court, Sima Qiqi stared at the big screen with full attention, and soon Sima Qiqi asked Zhuo Ao to press pause.
Sima Qiqi pointed to the screen and said: "Your Excellency, the picture in the No. 1 video evidence at 00:45 and the No. 2 video evidence at 00:45 is the same, from here you can see the picture from two angles, the picture in the No. 1 video evidence is a normal distance picture, obviously, due to the angle, the advertising column of the bus stop just blocked the old lady, at this time, if the injured person is knocked to the ground, then the surrounding pedestrians will not be so indifferent."
Sima Qiqi said, picked up the laser pointer and drew a few circles on the picture on the big screen, emphasizing that the judge observed the reaction of the pedestrians in the circle, Sima Qiqi put down the laser pointer and looked at the judge and said slowly: "Your Excellency, it can be seen from the pedestrian reaction in the screen at 00:45 during the broadcast period that there was no situation on the bus stop at that time, and these pedestrians were able to see the bus stop, but it is obvious that their expressions have not changed too much because there are no special circumstances on the bus stop."
Sima Qiqi looked at the judge's reaction, although the judge did not show too much on his face, but Sima Qiqi knew that the judge had been moved by his own words, although he did not imagine that the judge had confirmed Li Xiaona's innocence in his heart, but it was obvious that the judge's mind was shaken again, as long as the judge was not allowed to decisively accept the reasonable hypothetical collision proposed by Zhuo Ao before, the purpose of Sima Qiqi's statement this time has been achieved.
The judge thought for a long time, looked at Sima Qiqi and asked, "Does the defense lawyer have any other questions to state?"
Sima Qiqi nodded and said with a smile: "Yes, Your Excellency, please continue to play the plaintiff's lawyer."
Zhuo Ao heard Sima Qiqi's words, very reluctantly pressed the play button, after two seconds, Sima Qiqi hurriedly asked Zhuo Ao to stop playing, Zhuo Ao felt that he was completely led by Sima Qiqi's nose at this time, Sima Qiqi looked at Zhuo Ao with a smile, picked up the laser pointer again and pointed at the big screen and said slowly.
"Your Excellency, please note that it is 00:47 in the video evidence playing period, at this time, my client has already gotten on the bus, and then please see the reactions of these passers-by, they all looked at the bus stop in unison, that is, at this time, an unexpected thing happened on the bus stop that attracted their attention, from 00:45 to 00:47 during the broadcast period just now, everyone noticed that the injured person did not appear in the video screen again."
When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he looked at the big screen again, and recalled it again, and it seemed that it was indeed as Sima Qiqi said, and the judge slowly recorded it on the paper.
Sima Qiqi looked at it with a smile
Zhuoao said: "Then the trouble for the plaintiff's lawyer to play video evidence, it only needs to be played for one second!"
Zhuo Ao heard Sima Qiqi say this, his face was already white with anger, but there was no way, the video evidence was provided by him, so he could only let the operation, Zhuo Ao pressed the play button, when the time jumped to 00:48, Sima Qiqi made a gesture, Zhuo Ao quickly pressed the pause button, but at this time, although there was no change in the expression on Zhuo Ao's face, in fact, his lungs were about to explode.
Sima Qiqi glanced at Zhuo Ao, and then said: "Your Excellency, please pay attention to the reaction of the pedestrians in the picture, these pedestrians seem to have noticed that there is a special situation on the bus stop, and there is already a movement to go to the bus stop, look at this, and this ......"
The judge looked up at the big screen, his eyes followed Sima Qiqi's laser pointer movement, and found that there were indeed a few pedestrians in the picture who were changing their movements, and the judge picked up the pen and quickly recorded it on the paper.
Sima Qiqi put down the laser pointer and said slowly: "Your Excellency, the video evidence is provided by the plaintiff, the plaintiff's original intention is to prove that the hypothetical collision of the point he put forward is valid, but unfortunately, the hypothetical collision must be at the same time and in the same place, as can be seen from the video, my client and the injured met in the same place, but there is a certain time difference between the time when the injured fell to the ground and my client crossed the bus stop, the time is three seconds, we have learned physics in junior high school, and the effect of force is mutual, If my client really knocked down the injured person during a fast run, then there's a problem here, my client should be going backwards, but ......"
Sima Qiqi said and looked at Zhuo Ao, Zhuo Ao looked at Sima Qiqi expressionlessly at this time, Sima Qiqi smiled and said: "I'm sorry plaintiff lawyer, please move the video forward a few seconds, starting from 00:40 in the playback period!"
Zhuo Ao heard Sima Qiqi say this, took a deep breath, slowly operated, the video started to play again at 00:40, and when it was 00:45, Sima Qiqi snapped his fingers, Zhuo Ao pressed the pause button heavily, Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and said with a smile.
"Your Excellency, from 00:40 to 00:45 during the broadcast period, we can clearly see that the trajectory of my client's movement is continuous, and there is no stagnation or disharmony in movement, that is to say, ......"
Sima Qiqi said and looked at Zhuo Ao, Zhuo Ao was already so angry that his forehead was bruised, Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and said with a smile: "Your Excellency, that is to say, my client did not collide with the injured, the injured fell to the ground and was injured, the real injury of the injured should be from the video playback period 00:45 to 00:48 This short three seconds, the injured may be due to their own reasons, it may be the surrounding environment, in the absence of conclusive evidence, I hope that the court will not use reasonable hypothetical collisions to adjudicate against our client. ”
When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he nodded slightly, and Sima Qiqi looked at Zhuo Ao and said with a smile: "Then, the plaintiff's lawyer, please discuss with the plaintiff again.
Judging from the current situation, I think the argument that my client injured the old lady and left despite the old lady's injuries should also be untenable, is the plaintiff willing to withdraw the complaint against my client? ”
Sima Qiqi watched Zhuo Ao finish his statement slowly, waiting for Zhuo Ao's answer.
The judge also looked at Zhuo Ao at this time, Zhuo Ao nodded to the judge, pointed to the plaintiff beside him, the judge understood that Zhuo Ao was going to negotiate with his client, the judge nodded slightly, and announced to everyone: "Due to the new direction of investigation in this case, this court adjourned for fifteen minutes, and after fifteen minutes, the plaintiff's lawyer asked you to tell me whether you are willing to withdraw the charges against the defendant."
Zhuo Ao hurriedly got up and nodded to the judge.
During the adjournment, Sima Qiqi and Li Xiaona slowly walked out of the courtroom, Li Xiaona saw her sister and Liao Shaoming who were already waiting outside, and hurriedly ran over, and hurriedly came to Sima Qiqi's side, pinched Sima Qiqi's shoulder and said with a smile: "Oh, Qiqi, you are amazing, you are simply screaming in the courtroom, a blockbuster, I think Zhuo Ao is estimated to be unable to take public transportation now!"
Sima Qiqi looked at it with a puzzled expression, smiled and said: "Now that Zhuo Ao is on fire, I think it has become a flammable and explosive product, how can he get on public transportation again!"
Sima Qiqi heard the joke, with an indifferent expression, smiled awkwardly and said, "What a bad joke!"
The two were joking with each other, at this time Liao Shaoming and the other three came to Sima Qiqi, Liao Shaoming excitedly grabbed Sima Qiqi's hand, and said gratefully: "Lawyer Sima, thank you, I originally thought that Xiao Na hit and injured people regardless of other people's injuries, but now it seems that Xiao Na is very likely to be innocent, in fact, losing money is a trivial matter, but if it is really Xiao Na who hurts someone, then Xiao Na's life brochure has a bad record, which will be a devastating blow to Xiao Na who has not yet started her social life, If Cortana can be proven innocent, then Cortana's future life will be much smoother. ”
Liao Shaoming said, Nina also nodded hurriedly, Nina pulled Li Xiaona to Sima Qiqi, bowed again and again, saw this scene, pretended to cough, Liao Shaoming looked at it suspiciously, smiled and said: "That scholar, don't just thank Lawyer Sima, you also thank me, let's talk about business!"
Pulling Liao Shaoming aside to speak, Sima Qiqi saw the gratitude of the two Nina sisters to herself, and hurriedly waved her hand and said: "You two don't have to be so excited, I just pointed out the doubts in the evidence provided by the plaintiff's lawyer in court, if Ms. Xiao Na really hit someone, then I will not play with the law to find legal loopholes to help Ms. Xiao Na get rid of the crime, this is my bottom line."
When Nina heard Sima Qiqi say this, she nodded again and again, and said very excitedly: "If it is really this stupid girl who caused the trouble, then let her bear it herself."
Although Nina said so, her left hand tightly grasped Li Xiaona's hand, and she finished chatting with Liao Shaoming on the side.
With a happy face, he came to Sima Qiqi's side.
"It seems that you have negotiated a big deal again, please be more restrained, others still think you have picked up hundreds of millions!"
At this time, he whispered: "This business is negotiated, it's like picking up hundreds of millions for nothing, by the way, Qiqi, what do you want to eat at night, I'm positioned, I think this case will end soon, and when the time comes, call Liao Shaoming and Lao Song and others to celebrate together."
Sima Qiqi looked at him in surprise and said, "Who said that this case is going to be over?"
Just as he was about to speak, Sima Qiqi gently poked his chest with one hand, and said with a slight smile: "It's not the first time you have met Zhuo Ao, he has so much hatred for me, do you think he will agree to my suggestion just now?"
(End of chapter)