After listening to Sima Qiqi's statement, the judge looked at Fang Aoqin, Fang Aoqin stood up and said: "Your Excellency, as I just said, as long as the police officers have seniority, they will learn the corresponding criminal investigation techniques, and they can't think that the defendant was hypnotized because the witness has studied cold hypnosis, which is completely untenable in law, even if the defense lawyer cites this large pile of tables and chairs, will these as evidence that the defendant was hypnotized?" ”

Sima Qiqi heard Fang Aoqin's words, stood up and said: "Your Excellency, in the previous statement, the prosecutor once proved that professionally trained people can make a similar frequency of knocking sound well, and the witness is a professionally trained person, and there are indeed voices with similar frequency in the police video materials, and what is even more coincidental is that the witness used to focus on the direction of cold hypnosis, and we believe that so many coincidental factors appear in the same case, Our point of view should be taken into account for the re-investigation of my client's case. ”

The judge was obviously moved by Sima Qiqi's words, although the current evidence is very fragile and cannot explain anything alone, but when the sound of Dongdong, the direction of Wu Tong's learning, and the on-site furnishings in the video materials are combined, these seemingly broken and fragile evidence gradually become solid, even Fang Aoqin can't seem to find any flaws, the only thing that can be refuted is that Sima Qiqi has no evidence to prove that the defendant Xia He was in a hypnotic state at that time, because if you want to prove it, Xia He's brain should have been proved using brain forensics at that time, of course, everyone knew about it, and it was impossible to achieve it.

The judge looked embarrassed and turned his head to look at Fang Aoqin, who also understood that if there was no strong rebuttal point on his side, the judge was likely to agree with Sima Qiqi's statement based on comprehensive consideration.

Fang Aoqin slowly stood up and said, "Your Excellency, based on the complicated situation now, we request an adjournment of thirty minutes to allow us to reorganize the information. ”

When the judge heard Fang Aoqin's request for an adjournment, and knew that this was Fang Aoqin's last means of delay, the judge looked at Sima Qiqi and said, "Defense lawyer, because the amount of information in your statement just now is too large, I don't know if you agree to ......."

The judge asked tentatively, and before he finished speaking, Sima Qiqi looked at the judge with a smile and said: "Of course you can, the trial has been going on for so long, and I think my client is also very tired, I agree to adjourn the court for thirty minutes, but after thirty minutes, I think that if the prosecutor can't come up with a very strong argument to refute our statement, I think Your Excellency the judge should consider my proposal just now, right?" ”

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he was stunned, nodded slowly and said: "Of course, when there are so many doubts, the court will not immediately convict the defendant based on the principle of never suspecting the guilty, and we will know the result in thirty minutes." ”

The judge's words seemed to be an answer to Sima Qiqi, but in fact, Fang Aoqin knew that it was the last reminder to himself, Fang Aoqin sighed, packed up the information and walked out of the courtroom.

Came to Sima Qiqi with Sha Yu, and said excitedly: "Amazing, Qiqi, I didn't expect you to find so many useful clues, it seems that your little sister Xia He must be fine this time." ”

Sima Qiqi smiled and said, "It's not thanks to you, you found that unusual knock sound, so I have these connections, but don't be too happy, it can be seen that neither the judge nor Fang Aoqin seems to be willing to agree to my proposal just now." ”

"I think that Fang Aoqin has been forced by Lawyer Sima to be powerless, these thirty minutes are just an extension of time, and it shouldn't affect the outcome of the trial."

Sha Yu said with a puzzled expression.

Sima Qiqi shrugged his shoulders and said: "There are so many doubts now, but I only prove that Xia He's confession may not have been treated fairly during the questioning, and there are unreasonable places in the confession, but I also have no way to prove that Xia He is not a murderer." ”

Hearing Sima Qiqi's concern, he hit Sha Yu's stomach with an elbow, looked at Sha Yu calmly and said, "Hey, didn't you ask you to investigate the deceased's enemy before, how did you investigate?" ”

Sha Yu said with a disgusted face: "I open a gossip magazine, not a detective agency, but the deceased usually has a bad temper and often offends people, so he has a lot of enemies." ”

"And what about the one who wants his life?"

Sha Yu whispered: "Sometimes it's not because of a little thing that kills people, how do I know who will take his life and who won't." ”

Sima Qiqi hurriedly said: "This is not necessarily, what you said about killing people because of some small things is caused by impulse, unless it is a small matter in the eyes of the deceased, but it is a big thing in the eyes of the injured person, so that it is possible to kill people in comparison with the two, and it is not an impulsive killing." We guessed that a third person appeared at the scene, so the third person did not appear at the scene for no reason, but had a premeditated plan to follow the deceased to find a chance, this kind of person, that is, he had a deep grudge with the deceased, or the deceased did something before his death to hurt this mysterious person deeply, but the deceased did not know. ”

looked at Sha Yu and said slowly: "Hear it, Sha Fatty, is there such a person?" ”

Sha Yu said with a look of contempt: "I'm fat, you're not fat, call me fat again, I really turned my face." But I found someone to investigate, although this guy has a bad temper, but it is also a quarrel between neighbors and colleagues, and there are really no other things that have deep grudges or too deep hurt, although his colleagues don't like him, but the deceased did not hinder anyone's promotion, and the neighbors are also quarreling because of garbage, but they don't say who really hurts. ”

"Isn't there a third person?"

looked at Sima Qiqi with a puzzled look and asked.

"No, definitely, maybe we're thinking in the wrong direction. Don't care about these for now, you go to investigate, I have to deal with the trial and wait, even if this trial can't get Xia He out of the crime, I have to retreat and let Xia He be released on bail. ”

Thirty minutes passed quickly, everyone returned to their positions, and the judge looked at Fang Aoqin and asked, "Prosecutor, do you have new evidence that can effectively refute the defense lawyer's previous statement?" ”

Fang Aoqin stood up and said, "Your Excellency, we have evidence that we want to present in court. ”

When Sima Qiqi heard Fang Aoqin say this, he stood up and said, "Your Excellency, I object, if the prosecutor has new evidence to be submitted to the court, it should be carried out in accordance with the normal procedures for applying for evidence to be submitted to the court. It is impossible to say that they have new evidence to present in court, so let it be presented in court. ”

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he looked back at Fang Aoqin, and Fang Aoqin said calmly: "Your Excellency, the evidence we have requested to be presented in court is not new evidence. It is the layout of the remaining confession rooms of the Seongnam Police Station. ”

Sima Qiqi heard Fang Aoqin's explanation and said with a smile: "Prosecutor, several other confession rooms in the Chengnan Police Station did not appear in the previous trial, isn't this new evidence, and in the previous evidence submission application materials, there are no other confession room related applications of the Chengnan Police Bureau, and now the prosecutor, you have to submit these materials to the court temporarily, it is not in accordance with the rules." ”

Sima Qiqi said and looked at the judge, the judge couldn't help coughing and looked at Fang Aoqin, Fang Aoqin said slowly: "Your Excellency, the defense lawyer proposed that there was a layout plan of the Chengnan Police Station in the evidence presented in the court, but the defense lawyer only intercepted the internal layout of one of the confession rooms in the video materials, thinking that the defendant was being hypnotized and was questioned for confession, and wanted to prove that the defendant's confession was unreasonable and did not meet the possibility of becoming evidence, but the defense lawyer ignored the layout of several other confession rooms, therefore, The evidence I presented in court is only a supplement to the evidence of the defense lawyer, and in fact it is also included in the evidence presented by the defense lawyer. I just took some of it out. ”

Fang Aoqin said the last sentence very confidently, and when he heard this, he remembered that Sima Qiqi had taken out the audio in the video materials alone without applying for evidence to submit it to the court, which caught Fang Aoqin off guard. I didn't expect Fang Aoqin to treat others in his own way this time, but Sima Qiqi's evidence this time is very relevant, but he is not worried that Sima Qiqi will be caught off guard by Fang Aoqin.

After Fang Aoqin finished putting the photos of the other three confession rooms, he said slowly: "Your Excellency, you can see that the layout of the other three confession rooms is the same, and according to the regulations on the police interrogation confession workflow, two or more police officers must be present at the scene for the confession to be valid. ”

When the judge heard Fang Aoqin say this, he nodded, Sima Qiqi saw the judge nodding, and understood that the judge was still unwilling to return Xia He's case for re-investigation with many doubts, Sima Qiqi stood up and said: "Your Excellency, even if the prosecutor said that the confession room was not deliberately arranged, but the five knocks and the witness's study profession also have the possibility that my client was hypnotized when questioned, and the prosecutor should not be able to prove that my client's confession is completely reasonable. ”

Sima Qiqi said and slowly glanced at Fang Aoqin, Fang Aoqin was stunned by Sima Qiqi's words, and the judge interrupted: "There are many doubts in this case, but it is not enough to prove that the defendant did not kill the deceased. ”

Sima Qiqi hurriedly said: "It is true that I can't prove whether my client killed the deceased, but since there are so many suspicions, I think it is possible that someone else killed the deceased and blamed my client, and my client should not continue to be detained, I ask for bail." ”

"Against!"

Fang Aoqin heard Sima Qiqi say this, and hurriedly stood up and said.

The judge hurriedly knocked on the gavel, looked at Fang Aoqin and said: "Prosecutor, the defendant has not been convicted now, he is still only a suspect, and there is currently a lot of evidence in favor of the defendant, this court believes that it is unfair for the defendant to continue to detain the defendant, and this court approves the defendant's release on bail pending trial." ”