Wu Tong heard Sima Qiqi's question, nodded and replied, "Yes, the defendant's two interrogation statements were made in this room. ”

"Why choose the same room?"

Before Sima Qiqi's words fell, Fang Aoqin stood up and said: "Objection, Your Excellency, the police only need to conduct the confession questioning in the legal confession room, and the law does not stipulate that the police must or may not be in the same confession room every time they are questioned. ”

Sima Qiqi heard Fang Aoqin's objection and hurriedly looked at the judge and said: "Your Excellency, we still think that there are unreasonable aspects in the process of obtaining my client's confession, and we insist that my client's confession was obtained by the police by unconventional means, and cannot be used as evidence for my client's confession, so why did the witness choose the same confession room for confession questioning, I think it is necessary for the witness to answer." ”

After listening to this, the judge thought for a moment and said slowly: "Prosecutor, your objection is legally tenable, but in this case, the defense has always believed that the defendant's confession is problematic, so if there is anything that needs to be explained, this court believes that the witness has the obligation to explain clearly." Therefore, prosecutor, your objection is invalid, and the witness asks you to answer the question just asked by the defense lawyer. ”

Wu Tong shrugged his shoulders and said calmly: "That's the case, the defendant has been in a state of nervous tension because he was attacked by the deceased before his death, and the doctor also reminded us that the police should try to choose an environment that the defendant is more familiar with for confession questioning. Since the first defendant recorded his confession in this confession room, the second time we still chose to conduct the confession examination in the same confession room. ”

When Sima Qiqi heard Wu Tong's answer, he said calmly: "Witness, how many confession rooms are there in the Chengnan Police Station?" ”

"Objection, the witness has already answered why he chose the same confession room for the confession examination, and the defense lawyer is now questioning the same question in a different way."

Fang Aoqin felt more and more that Sima Qiqi was chasing the problem of the confession room, this confession room must be tired, but the current time is too little for Fang Aoqin, Fang Aoqin can't figure it out, and Fang Aoqin defined ordinary people to fight back against Sima Qiqi's social survey results, but Sima Qiqi didn't panic at all, Fang Aoqin felt as if he had entered an invisible net woven by Sima Qiqi. Before, he was drawn from the bottom of Sima Qiqi's kettle, and he actually used the evidence he submitted to apply for a defense, and Fang Aoqin still has palpitations.

The judge looked at Sima Qiqi, as if waiting for Sima Qiqi's answer, Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and said slowly: "Your Excellency, the witness just now replied that the confession questioning work in the same confession room was to take care of my client's mental condition, but the witness's so-called same environment, is the confession room of the same police station also different, and why the same witness was chosen The statement just now is not fully explained. ”

The judge looked at the witness and said, "Witness, your answer just now is indeed ambiguous, prosecutor, the objection is invalid, and this court also wants to know why." ”

Fang Aoqin sat down helplessly and began to think quickly, but the more nervous people are, the brain can't work properly.

Wu Tong said slowly: "There are four confession rooms in the Chengnan Police Station, and all four are decorated with the same decoration. It's just not the same direction. ”

At this time, Sima Qiqi projected a picture on the big screen of the court, took the laser pointer and said: "Your Excellency, this is the distribution map of the four confession rooms in the witness's mouth, two of which are in the same direction, and this is the confession room where the witness recorded a confession for my client twice, so there is another question here, witness, you said that you are looking for an environment that my client is familiar with, so choose the same confession room, so why not choose the one next to it, I agree that my client is nervous when he is hurt, So you need a familiar environment, but the room next to it, whether it's decorated or anything else, is the same as the room where my client recorded the confession, and it's closer to the police gate, so why don't you choose the one closer and the one farther away from the police gate? ”

Sima Qiqi looked at Wu Tong with both eyes, Wu Tong raised his head and glanced at Sima Qiqi, Wu Tong only felt that Sima Qiqi's eyes flashed coldly, making him, an old police officer who had been on an errand for more than 20 years, actually feel a little shivering.

Sima Qiqi waited for Wu Tong's answer, Fang Aoqin heard Sima Qiqi ask, and also looked at Wu Tong with a worried face, after all, this case has a high degree of social attention, as long as there is a slight suspicion, the media personnel sitting in the auditorium will be infinitely magnified, Fang Aoqin does not know whether Sima Qiqi wants to guide the direction of public opinion, but Fang Aoqin always feels that Sima Qiqi is not so superficial.

Wu Tongwei smiled and said: "Because the scenery of the confession room next to it is different, and there is a tree outside the window of the confession room next to it, the sunlight can't shine in, I think the defendant will be much more relaxed physically and mentally when he is illuminated by the sun, so that it is convenient for the police to carry out the work of confession questioning, and there is no need to delay the defendant's personal time too much." ”

Wu Tong was very satisfied with his explanation, Fang Aoqin couldn't help but breathe a sigh of relief when he heard Wu Tong's explanation, although Wu Tong's statement was a bit far-fetched, but it was a good explanation of why he chose to be far away from the confession room near the door, and Sima Qiqi had no evidence to refute Wu Tong's explanation just now.

When Sima Qiqi heard Wu Tong say this, he said with a surprised face: "I see, Officer Wu really takes care of my client abnormally, so may I ask again, witness, have you studied criminal psychology?" ”

"Objection, Your Excellency, criminal psychology and all kinds of criminal investigation techniques are what every police officer must learn, and the defense lawyer wants to prove that nothing can be used to target witnesses uniquely."

The judge nodded and said: "The objection is valid, defense lawyer, if you want to raise doubts, you must ensure that your questions are only for witnesses, this court believes that any police officer with rich work experience will be familiar with the basic knowledge of criminal psychology that the police need." ”

Sima Qiqi nodded apologetically and said, "I'm sorry, Your Excellency, I'll ask you again." Witness, may I ask you, have you studied cold hypnosis specifically? ”

"Yes."

Although Wu Tong denied it in his heart, but after thinking about it, Sima Qiqi could ask such a question, it must have been investigated, if he denied it at this time, he would be caught by Sima Qiqi later, and it would be even more difficult for Fang Aoqin's side, so Wu Tong still decisively admitted it after thinking about it.

Sima Qiqi smiled and said, "Witness, how are you learning cold hypnosis?" ”

Wu Tong said casually: "It's so-so." ”

When Sima Qiqi heard Wu Tong's answer, he smiled slightly and said, "Witness, you are so humble. This is the essay you wrote for cold hypnosis, and the score is 87 points, which is already considered an excellent grade for the level of the essay. ”

"But I didn't get 90 points!"

Wu Tong looked at Sima Qiqi with a smile on his face and said.

Sima Qiqi suddenly realized, and said with a smile: "The witness is really strict with himself, in the witness's paper, it is mentioned that the practical application of cold hypnosis in the process of investigating the case, and many examples are also given, taking the ancient Bao Zheng night trial Guo Huai and so on mentioned that under reasonable circumstances, cold hypnosis can be appropriately used to help solve the case, but it also puts forward the thinking that cold hypnosis is helpful for solving the case, and the hypnotized person is not considered a person with full civil capacity. It's really well written, and since the witnesses are all thinking about it in their own papers, why did the witnesses take the lead in using the information obtained from cold hypnosis as the confession of my client's guilt in reality? ”

Sima Qiqi put Wu Tong's paper on the table and looked at Wu Tong with a serious face, Fang Aoqin heard Sima Qiqi say this, and quickly stood up and said: "Objection, Your Excellency, the defense lawyer has no evidence to prove that the witness used cold hypnosis in the process of recording the defendant's confession. By doing so, the defence counsel is suspected of maliciously falsely accusing the witness, which is unfair to the witness. ”

The judge looked at Sima Qiqi, and Sima Qiqi's face softened a little and said, "Your Excellency, I have evidence to prove that my client was indeed in a state of cold hypnosis when he recorded his confession. ”

Sima Qiqi re-released a picture, or the picture of the confession room just now, this is the picture that Sima Qiqi took from the video materials given by the police, Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and asked: "Your Excellency, why don't you come and see what's strange about this picture?" ”

Hearing Sima Qiqi say this, everyone's eyes were focused on the picture, even Xia He looked at the picture, the judge looked at it for a moment, shook his head and said: "This, it's very ordinary, there is nothing abnormal, the defense lawyer or you should explain." ”

Sima Qiqi smiled and nodded and said: "A table with four legs, two chairs, each with four legs, two police officers who inquire, four hands, this confession room does not have a door number, but it happens to be room 104 opposite, and even the lights are four light bulbs, the number four Judge Judge did you appear many times in your mind in the process I just said." ”

"Objection, the defense lawyer wants to explain that the defendant was in a state of cold hypnosis when he was questioned about the confession, which is too far-fetched, what a table and two chairs, then these are also numbers, why did the defendant not answer that he stabbed the deceased one or two times, but directly answered four times."

Fang Aoqin retorted loudly, and Sima Qiqi said calmly: "When the police questioned my client, they said, 'How many stabs did you stab the deceased', please pay attention to these words, we all know that only a few are used when three or more, that is, the police cleverly made my client only think about the number of three or more when questioning." And there is a hypnotic method in cold hypnosis, to give a lot of numbers and a few missing, the first thing that appears in the brain is the missing number, or give a lot of the same number, then the brain is also the same number, although the picture appears in numbers like 1 and 2, but the police used guiding words when questioning, so we think that there is something unreasonable in my client's confession, and we request that the case be remanded and re-investigated. ”