Fang Aoqin said unhurriedly: "Your Excellency, the defendant was attacked by the deceased, the first three knives, we believe that the deceased was stabbed when the defendant's life was threatened, but when the deceased fell to the ground because of the injury and could not further injure the defendant, the defendant may think that if the deceased does not die, not only the defendant himself, but also the defendant's family and the defendant's lover, who is the fuse of this case, Dr. Xue Moxuan, in order to prevent the deceased from continuing to act excessively, so the defendant took the knife in his backhand, He stabbed the deceased in the abdomen again, and it was this last stab that pierced the deceased's liver, causing the deceased to bleed to death. After killing the deceased, the defendant examined the wounds on the deceased's body and found that the number of wounds was four cuts, so when he was questioned by the police for the first time and the second time, the defendant was able to clearly answer the exact number of wounds, which was a kind of confession by the defendant, and it was also a practice for the defendant to protect his family and lover, so as not to let the police harass the defendant's mother and Dr. Xue Moxuan. Your Excellency, I have concluded my statement. ”

Fang Aoqin bowed to the judge and sat down, and the judge thought that Fang Aoqin's explanation of the video evidence was very reasonable, and couldn't help but nod.

The judge recorded the main points stated by Fang Aoqin just now, looked back at Sima Qiqi and asked: "Defense lawyer, you have made the defendant's confession too perfect before, and now the prosecutor has provided the prosecution's explanation on the perfect oral basis, do you still want to defend your client's innocence, this court can give you time for you to discuss with your client......

Sima Qiqi stood up and interrupted the judge, and said with a smile: "Your Excellency, no, my client is innocent, I will not change this, and my client is willing to let me continue to defend her innocence." Thank you, Your Excellency, for your kindness. ”

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he nodded and said slowly: "Since the defendant insists on pleading not guilty, then the trial continues." Defense lawyer, you can start your case. ”

Sima Qiqi calmly bowed slightly to the judge to show respect, raised his head and said slowly: "Your Excellency, the prosecutor just gave an explanation for why my client's confession is so perfect, it seems to make sense at first glance, but in fact, it is not right at all, please allow the court to play the video materials just now." ”

The judge was surprised to hear that Sima Qiqi was going to make a statement about the video material, but the judge couldn't refuse. The judge nodded and approved Sima Qiqi's request.

Sima Qiqi played the video material played by Fang Aoqin just now, and Sima Qiqi reminded everyone before the video was played: "Please listen carefully, there are any strange sounds in this video." ”

After Sima Qiqi finished speaking, he started to play the video, and when the video was over, Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and asked with respect: "Your Excellency, may I ask you, did you hear any strange sounds in the video?" ”

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he thought for a moment, shrugged his shoulders and said, "There doesn't seem to be any strange sound, except for the sound of talking and walking, ah, by the way, there is a sound of decoration in the video." ”

Sima Qiqi said with a smile on his face: "Your Excellency, what else?" ”

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi's question, he was stunned, as if there was no special sound in the video that caught his attention, and then Sha Yu, who was sitting in the auditorium, asked in a puzzled voice: "What other strange sounds are there in this video?" ”

"Didn't you hear the knock? It's the sound of a pen hitting the table. ”

Without looking at it, Sha Yu replied in a low voice.

When Sha Yu heard this, he said with a puzzled expression: "And this voice, why didn't I hear anything, you won't lie to me, right?" ”

Hearing Sha Yu's questioning, Yu Guang glanced at Sha Yu, smiled slightly and whispered: "Calm, it's not just you, you see that the judge didn't hear it." Let's wait to see the show. ”

The judge thought for a long time, and didn't seem to find any additional sound from the video he had just watched, then Fang Aoqin couldn't sit still, stood up and said loudly: "Your Excellency, are we wasting so much time on this video sound, this video defense lawyer has already checked it, and there is nothing suspicious, just ask if there is any strange sound in it that deserves our attention, there is a sound of decoration in the video, according to the report, the police station where Officer Wu Tong was located was undergoing some renovation projects at that time, Therefore, there will be a sound of decoration, and the defense lawyer said that this video material is mysterious, but there is no strange sound in it. ”

Sima Qiqi looked at the judge and replied slowly: "Your Excellency, I still have a copy of information in my hand, which is the audio data in the video just now, only the sound has no picture, I asked professionals to analyze the audio in it, and found a strange sound, and this strange voice, I think it is the reason why my client's confession is perfect, I believe Your Excellency the judge will understand after listening." ”

As soon as Sima Qiqi's words fell, Fang Aoqin stood up and said loudly: "Objection, Your Excellency, according to the evidence application for the court, the defense did not apply for the relevant audio materials to be presented as evidence. ”

Sima Qiqi heard Fang Aoqin's objection, looked at the judge calmly and said: "Your Excellency, according to the evidence application process, as long as the same evidence is used for the same trial, there is no need to apply repeatedly. ”

After listening to Sima Qiqi's statement, the judge thought for a moment, nodded and said: "According to the law, a video file is submitted as evidence in court, and every frame and sound in it is a part of the video material, and there is indeed no need to submit an additional application. ”

When Fang Aoqin heard the judge say this, he looked unconvinced but looked at Sima Qiqi helplessly, Sima Qiqi took a salary from the bottom of the kettle, and applied with the help of Fang Aoqin's video evidence, and he did not submit an application for the audio part stripped out of the video, paralyzing Fang Aoqin, and this time Fang Aoqin was defeated.

Sima Qiqi began to play the audio materials he had prepared, and the sound was exactly the same as the video materials played by Fang Aoqin just now, but there was no picture on Sima Qiqi's side.

After the playback, the judge looked at Sima Qiqi with a puzzled look and asked: "Defense lawyer, I don't know what your purpose is in playing this audio material, isn't this information the same as the video material played by the prosecutor just now, but you are missing a picture here." ”

Sima Qiqi looked at the judge with a smile and replied: "That's the case, Your Excellency, when we checked this video material, a person with a developed sense of hearing found that there was a strange sound in it, in order to verify, we asked a professional to strip out the audio part inside and analyze it, so when we turned off the decoration sound in this audio and turned down the sound of talking and walking, please listen to it again." ”

Sima Qiqi replayed the audio material, and everyone in the courtroom held their breath to capture the strange sounds that might appear in the audio material, and just when the judge was a little impatient, suddenly a "dong dong" sound came out of the audio material. Then every once in a while, there was a "dong dong" sound, and when the audio material was played, the judge looked at Sima Qiqi with a puzzled look and asked.

"Defense lawyer, why is there a knock in this audio material, but it was not heard in the previous video material?"

Sima Qiqi replied with a slight smile: "Your Excellency, because this voice is very small, and there are voices in the video and the sound of decoration, it is not easy for ordinary people to notice, but fortunately, there is a person next to me who has a relatively developed hearing system, and he captured this abnormal sound, so that I can find a new breakthrough direction." ”

"Lawyer Sima won't be the person who praises you, right?"

"Or else?"

Hearing Sha Yu's questioning, he asked rhetorically.

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi say this, he looked at Sima Qiqi in surprise and asked, "A new direction for breakthrough, defense lawyer, this knock is indeed not very normal, but this court does not see what kind of ability this knock has to provide you with a new breakthrough direction." ”

Sima Qiqi smiled slightly and said, "Your Excellency, I request that the defense witness, Mr. Yue Sanchuan, associate professor of psychology at Shunan University of Arts and Sciences, be summoned. ”

The judge looked at the information in front of him and nodded in agreement with Sima Qiqi's request. When Yue Sanchuan came to the witness stand and sat down, Sima Qiqi looked at Yue Sanchuan and asked Yue Sanchuan about his profession and research direction, and when Yue Sanchuan replied that his research direction was cold hypnosis, the judge interrupted.

"Excuse me, what is cold hypnosis?"

Sima Qiqi heard the judge's question and hurriedly replied: "It's indirect hypnosis, Your Excellency Judge." ”

When the judge heard Sima Qiqi's explanation, he nodded and recorded Sima Qiqi's explanation, and after the judge took the record, he motioned for Sima Qiqi to start questioning the witnesses.

Sima Qiqi nodded in response to the judge, Sima Qiqi looked at Yue Sanchuan and asked, "Witness, can you explain why there is such a thing as cold hypnosis, which is indirect hypnosis." ”

Yue Sanchuan nodded and said: "Generally, hypnosis will use language, music and even drugs to achieve direct hypnosis, while indirect hypnosis is actually a kind of psychological suggestion, for example, a person has been staring at the rotating fan, he will feel very tired, but his consciousness is relatively clear, and he can also achieve a hypnotic effect through lights or some regular things such as taking the elevator and reading the shining numbers of the elevator." Because many people are still more resistant to this kind of direct hypnosis, indirect hypnosis is gradually accepted by psychologists. ”