Although everyone had an enlightened expression on their faces when they listened to Qi Yuandao's discussion, this did not prevent some people from taking this opportunity to fight for prestige. Especially just now Zhao Chang followed Qi Yuandao into the arena, he was not very old, he was still a fresh face, and then thinking of some things about Qi Yuandao, everyone guessed in their hearts whether this young man was the noble man in Beijing?

Whether it is or not, showing your face in front of this noble person is good and good. Therefore, everyone got up one after another and asked Qi Yuandao their questions.

After listening carefully for a while, I heard that although these people got up in the name of rebuttal, due to the level relationship, the questions asked were more like "asking for advice", hoping that Qi Yuandao could "solve his doubts" instead of refuting his theory. Qi Yuandao has lectured countless times in the past ten years, and he is familiar with this kind of painless "interrogation", and Zhao Chang feels bored.

He leaned into Du Jinning's ear and said, "Won't Du Gongzi go up and say a few words for a while?" ”

Du Jinning nodded, and pointed to Lu Jiuyuan, who was talking to Qi Yuandao, and said, "Mr. Lu, after they finish speaking, I will play." ”

Although Lu Jiuyuan is knowledgeable and has his own theories, his understanding of theories is still shallow; Qi Yuandao is experienced in a hundred battles, he has been debating with others for more than ten years with this theory, and he has already eaten it thoroughly, even if Lu Jiuyuan asks deeper questions than others, in the end, Lu Jiuyuan is still defeated by Qi Yuandao.

Peng Shicheng was anxious, and seeing that Lu Jiuyuan was about to be defeated, he hurriedly called Du Jinning: "Jinning, hurry up." ”

Du Jinning stood up unhurriedly, and when Lu Jiuyuan was speechless by Qi Yuandao's refutation, he arched his hand and said to Qi Yuan: "Mr. Qi is a great Confucian in the world, and I am a little talent, so I am not qualified to question Mr. Qi. It's just that the younger generation reads Mr. Qi's article, and there are always some questions that I can't understand, so I take this opportunity to ask Mr. Qi a few questions. ”

Qi Yuandao naturally didn't take Du Jinning seriously, even if Du Jinning had written two articles and expounded some views, but he felt that this son's behavior was the same as his grandson's, but he was just borrowing some of the arguments of his elders to sell his reputation. At this time, Du Jinning got up, and he also felt that this move was just to find a step for Lu Jiuyuan, so that Lu Jiuyuan would not be too ugly.

He has a deep dislike for Du Jinning, not only because his grandson has to think about it at home for more than a year because of Du Jinning; There are even five princes who abandoned him and ran to Du Jinning's side, and behaved intimately with Du Jinning, which can be regarded as a taboo for Qi Yuandao.

He decided to give Du Jinning an ugly look, it was best to let him lose face in front of the scholars, make his reputation stink, and walk in front of people again without shame in the future.

He said lightly: "Please speak." ”

"'Too void and formless, the essence of qi', 'Qi has gathering and scattering but not giving birth to heaven, Qi gathering is visible and forms all things, and Qi is dispersed and formless and visible into too void'. Are these Mr. Qi's views? ”

Qi Yuandao didn't want to answer Du Jinning's question, but in front of so many people, he had to maintain his character of being generous, benevolent, and caring for his juniors, so he nodded patiently and said, "Yes." ”

"'Ghosts and gods, the good ability of the two qi. The Holy One is said to be sincere and heavenly; The god is too vain and wonderful. All the phenomena of heaven and earth are the dregs of deification'. That's also Mr. Qi's point of view, right? Du Jinning asked again.

Qi Yuandao couldn't help it, and said sarcastically: "This little friend, if you don't know or understand my doctrine, you can go back and read the article a few more times." This is the place to talk about the text, so please don't waste your time. ”

As soon as they heard Qi Yuandao say this, those scholars who didn't know Du Jinning looked at him strangely.

Although Du Jinning is now more than 1.6 meters tall, no different from a man of medium stature, her fourteen-year-old face full of collagen is still immature, plus she just reported to her family, saying that she is just a showman, these people think that she is making trouble - not to mention Xiucai, even ordinary lifters are not qualified to enter here to participate in the debate.

At this time, hearing Qi Yuandao say this, the old man who presided over the lecture wanted to stand up and dissuade Du Jinning from talking anymore.

Du Jinning said with a smile: "The juniors do not know what they don't understand, isn't this asking you for advice?" The younger generation is very curious to know, you say that the void is the formless and imageless qi, and you say, 'the way that is transported in the formless, and the metaphysical is not enough to say', but you also say that 'the scattered and can be like qi, and the clear and not like the god', so I want to know, which is the greater or lesser of the 'god of the void' and the 'visible qi' that you are talking about? Since this 'god' is everywhere and all-encompassing, what is the difference between it and the gods of Buddhism? ”

"......" Qi Yuandao opened his mouth, but he was dumbfounded for a while.

The mountainside, which had been a little noisy just a moment ago, gradually quieted down.

The one who didn't have a deep study of Qi Yuandao's theory, looked at Qi Yuandao who couldn't speak, and his face was full of inexplicability; But those who had studied Qi Yuandao's theory fell into contemplation.

Indeed it is. The few theories that Du Xiaoxiucai said were from Qi Yuandao's article. It's just that these theories are not based on an article, and there will be a large paragraph of theories as a basis before these words appear, and everyone only feels impressed after reading them, and never thinks deeply about the contradictions of these theories.

After Du Jinning's question, everyone found that Qi Yuandao's theory seemed to oppose the god and the qi, and exaggerated the difference between the void god and the tangible qi. He explained the so-called "gods" in a very subtle way, and he was really divine, so that his qi monism, like Buddhism, was also shrouded in a veil of mystery.

Isn't it a contradiction to oppose Buddhism and create a "god" on the other?

Du Jinning didn't need him to answer, and continued to ask: "Mr. Qi said that the energy of qi can change its nature, and this nature runs through the void and all things, so it is eternal. However, Mr. Qi believes that this nature is also the nature of human beings, so the nature of human beings is also eternal, so he came to the conclusion that "those who know the immortal of death can be separated from the nature of speech", and believes that there is an immortal nature after death, what is the difference between this and Buddhism? ”

“……”

There was silence again on the mountainside.

If it is said that when Du Jinning's previous question was raised, there were still people talking about it in a whisper, then as soon as this sentence came out, the audience was silent.

The Buddha preached the afterlife, believing that after death, people exist as a soul and are finally reincarnated in the next life; Tao preaches immortality, believing that as long as people are diligent in cultivation, they can attain immortality. And if Qi Yuandao's theory thinks that people are immortal after death, what is the difference between this and the teachings of Buddhism?

But just now Du Xiaoxiu had already said Qi Yuandao's theory, and Qi Yuandao himself admitted that he was refuting Buddhism. There is such a point of view in his theory, so did he slap himself in the face? How much does his old face hurt?