Qi Yuandao sat on the high platform, his face blue and white for a while. He wanted to refute Du Jinning, and wanted to hit Du Jinning's question back fiercely, but the question Du Jinning raised was the loophole of the qi theory itself, Qi Yuandao himself was in the game, and he was not the creator of this theory, how could he have the ability to make up for these loopholes? If there were, he would have put it forward in his own doctrine long ago, and he would not wait until now for Du Jinning to put it forward.

Scholars, although they also value qualifications, but they also pay more attention to ability. It is self-evident who is more respected than the seventeen-year-old young jinshi.

If everyone looked at Du Jinning at the beginning as young and with little qualifications, and looked at him like an ignorant child, but as soon as her two questions were raised, everyone's eyes on her were completely different.

So at this time, Du Jinning continued to ask further questions, not only did everyone not think that she was delaying time, but they were more attentive to listening to her than at the beginning.

"Mr. Qi said: 'Nature is in people, just like water nature in ice, although the condensation is different, it is the same thing; The light is small and large, dim, and its illumination is the same. 'Say' that people are rigid and soft, slow and urgent, talented and untalented, and biased.' The nature of the ginseng is not biased, and the qi is nourished, and on the contrary, it is not biased, and it is all natural. Since the 'temperament' of rigidity, softness, and urgency are the nature of heaven and earth, why does Mr. Qi emphasize learning, qi cultivation, humility and courtesy? Why do we need to change the temperament to make the 'nature of temperament' reverse to the 'nature of heaven and earth', and finally dwelling in nature is good? ”

Qi Yuandao opened his mouth, but he couldn't say a word, not only was cold sweat on his forehead, but the placket on his back was soaked inside and out.

Qi Yuandao has been operating academically for many years, and he has received countless disciples, and these disciples and Qi Yuandao are both prosperous and loss-making. Qi Yuandao is beautiful, and his disciples are naturally respected wherever they go; Once he was torn off the altar, his disciples would naturally be gray and faceless.

At this time, seeing that Qi Yuandao was speechless for a long time after being asked by Du Jinning, and his face was even more pale as paper, a disciple in his forties with a mustache got up and said coldly to Du Jinning: "This little minister, since you have asked such a question, you want to have an in-depth study of this issue, it is better for you to tell everyone what you think." ”

If Du Jinning only knows to raise problems and can't solve them, it is just Qi Yuandao's own theory, or Zhang Zai's theory, something is wrong, as long as Qi Yuandao admits that his theory is not perfect enough, then the criticism just now can be gently lifted, and Qi Yuandao will also end up with a good reputation for daring to admit his own shortcomings and being good at reflecting on his own theories - the theories of Confucius, Mencius and other sages are not perfect without a trace of flaws. Therefore, if there is a deficiency, we are not afraid, and we will see how to deal with this crisis.

As long as Du Jinning is asked, so that she can't make any more difficulties, Qi Yuandao can say a few words of self-humility, and then let several other respected scholars explain Qi Yuandao, and this embarrassment can be transformed.

Sure enough, as soon as this person's words came out, everyone's eyes moved away from Qi Yuandao and fell on Du Jinning. Someone was still whispering.

Lu Jiuyuan pinched a cold sweat for Du Jinning.

It is relatively easy to find loopholes in other people's theories, and it is relatively easy to put forward your own opinions. It is not an ordinary difficulty to put forward one's own point of view when finding a loophole in someone else's theory in order to fill this loophole. It's like Gong dam, it's not difficult to find a hole in the embankment, and it's not difficult to build a new embankment, but it's much more difficult to repair a leaking embankment.

Lu Jiuyuan admits that Du Jinning's thinking is different from ordinary people, he can always be very keen to find problems, solve problems, and put forward very novel ideas, he is a genius. But he is finally a little younger, and his knowledge is not profound enough, and if he wants to put forward an impeccable theory when finding loopholes, Lu Jiuyuan feels that Du Jinning has no way to do it.

He was about to speak out to relieve Du Jinning, when he saw Du Jinning smile slightly and said: "Whether the qi of the void is clear or turbid, because it is not human, it is not human nature." In any case, as long as water does not condense into ice, it is not ice. Human nature can only be spoken of after the condensation of qi. Therefore, I think, 'There is no such thing as asexual in the world.'" If you have this thing, you have this nature; If there is no such thing, there is no such nature. ’”

When everyone heard this, they all nodded.

This little Xiucai is very reasonable, and it is true.

The disciple didn't let go of Du Jinning, and forced him to ask: "Since Xiao Xianggong has such a high opinion, then Xiao Xianggong must also have his own opinions on the relationship between 'temperament' and 'nature of heaven and earth', right?" ”

Du Jinning didn't sell Guan Zi either, and said directly: "'The nature of heaven and earth' is natural, and the 'nature of temperament' is real, changing temperament makes the nature of real temperament reverse the nature of heaven and earth, and human nature is not binary but monistic." The reason is explained in this way, and there is no loophole in Mr. Qi's doctrine. ”

As soon as these words came out, there was an uproar in the audience.

The theory of human nature in Qi is "dualism", and this little minister surnamed Du directly negated the theory of others and put forward the view of "monism". This is to fundamentally and directly eradicate Qi Yuandao's reasoning.

But I have to say that what Du Xiaoxianggong said is indeed reasonable.

So, is it possible that Qi Yuandao's doctrine is not only flawed, but that the entire theory is fundamentally wrong?

Everyone looked at Qi Yuandao, who was sitting in the middle of the stage, and had deep doubts about his theory.

What is the most important thing about a doctrine? It is the recognition and respect of the readers, and everything about it is based on recognition and respect. Once this recognition is lost, it is like a castle in the sky without a foundation, but it collapses in an instant.

At this time, everyone's trust in Qi Yuandao and the Qi Science that has been recognized and respected over the years has been shaky. If Qi Yuandao does not put forward a rebuttal and refutes Du Jinning's statement theoretically, then his theory, all his prestige and status, will be like a snow-capped mountain collapse, completely incorrigible.

His disciples' faces changed drastically, and they called to Qi Yuan, "Teacher." "Expect him to say something to refute it.

Qi Bokun's political struggles were very rich. Lu Jiuyuan and the others, even Yuan Xiuzhu, they were all scholars, and they were all immersed in the victory of the academic discussion and couldn't care about anything else, but Qi Bokun kept a clear head.

He knew that he needed to ease the atmosphere at this time, and it was not appropriate to be aggressive, otherwise Qi Yuandao would be so angry that a mouthful of old blood would spurt out at this time, although Du Jinning won Qi Yuandao academically, but he would be criticized for being in the world, and felt that he was too disrespectful to his predecessors and the elderly, and he was unforgiving.

He hurriedly pushed Yuan Xiuzhu and whispered a few words in his ear.

Yuan Xiuzhu immediately said loudly: "Brother Ning, don't be rude. Mr. Qi has studied Confucianism for decades, how can you, a yellow-mouthed child, question it? You are still ashamed to say that you still want to change other people's dualism to monism, and you don't know how thick the sky is. Why don't you apologize to Mr. Qi quickly? ”

Du Jinning breathed a sigh of relief, she was also very worried that Qi Yuandao would be so angry that she vomited blood. In fact, she still had a lot of questions that she hadn't raised, and when she saw Qi Yuandao like this, she didn't dare to say any more. This old guy is too weak to say a word, it's really boring!

She hurriedly arched her hand and said: "I'm sorry, Mr. Qi, I've only been studying for a few years, and I'm only shallow in my studies, and I don't know how thick the sky is, and my words just now were too radical." If there is anything inappropriate, please Mr. Qi look at my young face and don't worry about me. ”

She didn't say that it was okay, but this said, Qi Yuandao, who was looking for a way out, was suddenly blocked from the way, and there was no way to retreat. He let out a "poof", and a mouthful of old blood spurted out of his mouth.

And he vomited blood at this time, and everyone's perception of him and Du Jinning was very different.

Everyone shook their heads and sighed: "Alas, this Mr. Qi is too narrow-minded. If there is a problem with his theory, don't you let others put it forward? Over the years, he has been too smooth sailing, and he really takes himself seriously. But that little minister, even if he found a theoretical loophole, he was still humble, he was really a young man, and he was amazing. ”

Please remember that the first domain name of this book is .. Mobile version reading URL: m.