Volume II, Chapter 25 Reasoning in Court (4) The Perfect Chain of Evidence!
"Presiding Judge, I have evidence!" Wu Gan said this sentence again, with a serious attitude.
Wu Qian also understood in his heart that the presiding judge was not too interested in all the details of this case.
"Okay, witness, please. β
"Thank you, Presiding Judge. β
Wu Qian was about to continue, but Xu Hong's contemptuous eyes were ushered in, and the lawyer expected that the opponent had no key evidence.
"The collegial panel, and everyone present. Wu Qian first looked around, but gave Qin Yan a special look.
Qin Yan understood what this meant, but he looked at the sky with his eyes...... In my heart, if you dare to betray Lao Tzu, you will eat your kid in the future, and eat it for a lifetime!
Unexpectedly, Wu Gan said this next.
"As you should know, I, as a detective, only started investigating this case on Monday. β
Highlighted the difficulty?
"In the process of investigation, I absolutely abided by the laws of the country, and when I looked at dormitory 608 of dormitory No. 33, which was the scene of the crime, I only looked at it from the outside, and the seal was not touched. Someone can testify for me, in addition, I did not get the details of the police investigation, only the employer Mr. Xie Feng provided some rough information, and the other clues were all from me who offered a reward, that is to say, I don't know much about the details of the crime scene, I only have a general understanding, I say this, everyone understands, right?"
This is clear, but everyone is confused, what are you trying to say as a detective?
It's just that Lin Bing whispered to Li Xue, "This guy is selling off again." β
However, I heard Wu Gan continue: "However, I can make a hypothetical description of the murder process here, and I have enough evidence to prove that my hypothesis is correct in this description! That is to say, the defendant's murder process is exactly the same as I said!"
This...... Finally understood!
But, that's too hard, isn't it?
Even people who don't understand the law and don't understand the work of cracking can completely imagine the difficulty.
Not to mention the auditorium, even the presiding judge, Xu Hong, and Liu Xindi couldn't believe it.
However, Wu Qian said very confidently: "The facts of the case confessed by the defendant are probably like this, after the defendant entered the 608 dormitory, he had a quarrel with the victim and got into an argument...... Lick him...... Well, I won't go into detail about this, there are witnesses, that is, the prosecutor, and she is listening. β
Liu Xindi nodded,
But now many people are very curious, and the focus is on 'licking'.
"But! This is definitely false!" Wu Gan became more and more solemn, "My assumption is this:
After the defendant entered the 608 dormitory at 6:20 p.m. on June 29 this year, he immediately picked up the express package that was still at the door, that is, the dumbbells in the package, and hit the victim, and the victim should have reacted, so the location of the hit should be near the right temple, not the back of the head, and then the victim should have fallen to the groundοΌβ
Huo...... There was a commotion in the auditorium.
"Silence!" the presiding judge knocked on the table again and asked Liu Xindi, "Prosecutor, what is the result of the police investigation?"
Liu Xindi was stupid just now, because the blow site mentioned by Wu Gan ...... "Presiding Judge, the investigation by the public security organs showed that the victim was injured in three places, indeed two at the back of his head and one on his right temple. β
God!
The key is this right temple, just like what you see with your own eyes.
Everyone who watched this trial had this feeling, this Qian Tan, this Wu Gan, was too powerful.
Can you guess it out of thin air?
Not to mention the rest, just the position of this hit, this is too accurate.
Lin Bing and Li Xue, as well as the three in the 306 bedroom, are also stupid. Of course, there were also the Xie family and his wife who were stupid together, and they were very emotional, the money was worth it.
Not to mention them, even Xu Hong is stupid, how could this Wu Gan judge so accurately.
Only one person is different in heart......
"Your uncle's money skewers! You're too fucking good at pretending!" Qin Yanbei, his heart is so complicated at this time...... This is all the information that Lao Tzu quietly gave him.
But!
"Witness Wu Gan, what evidence do you have to prove that the defendant is as you said, and he will do it when he enters the house. β
"Presiding Judge, I have witnesses and physical evidence!" Wu Qian smiled, full of confidence, "Ji Wei, who lives in dormitory 508, heard on June 29 this year, when the crime occurred, 'knock, crackle, knock', which completely confirmed my statement."
That is, the previous 'bang' was the second of the defendant's three heavy blows, at which time the victim had already fallen to the ground, so there was such a sound, and the crackling sound was that the defendant was smashing the mobile phone and laptop. The last two knocks were seen by many students, that is, the defendant had a quarrel with the victim, and everyone rushed over, and at this time, the small curtain of the bedroom door of 608 fell, and the defendant's approach was to make the last heavy blow, which should have a lot of blood, which was a bang, and the second knock was that the defendant threw down the murder weapon, the dumbbell in the express package. The location where the victim fell to the ground, because of the angle of the small window of the dormitory door, the students outside could not see the specific situation of the victim being hit, they could only see the defendant waving the express package. β
That makes sense.
But.
Xu Hong asked loudly, "But the classmates at that time heard the quarrel between my client and the victim, how can this be explained?"
"It's simple. Wu Qian easily coped, "The quarrel should be recorded in advance of the voice of the deceased before his death, and it was placed in the defendant's mobile phone, and at that time, after the defendant hit the victim twice, the main job was to release the voice in the mobile phone, and only needed to use the external function of the laptop."
At this time, the defendant also wanted to do one thing, that is, to smash other things in the room with the dumbbells in his hand, that is, the messy scene we can see, this action is purposeful, that is, to make the sound more indistinct!
At the same time, the defendant also had to respond loudly to the voice of the deceased.
What can prove my statement is that a classmate provided me with clues, and he only vaguely heard Xie Fan's voice at that time, but it was not very clear.
In fact, there is a very clever way to confuse the public, that is, since this is Xie Fan's room, and he is also in it, then, when there is a quarrel, anyone will first think that one of the quarrelers must have Xie Fan.
In other words, Wang Lian simply acted in a one-man show by himself. β
This clue, that is, I can't hear Xie Fan's voice clearly, after all, it was a recording playback, of course, it was provided by the onlookers at that time, and Wu Qian spent more than 20,000 yuan for this, which is worth it.
Wu Qian continued: "This also explains why the defendant smashed the mobile phone and laptop, he did it to destroy the evidence, and there are also call records between the defendant and the victim, which can expose the true relationship between the two of them." β
Liu Xindi unconsciously asked again, "If the phone is broken, it will ......"
"WeChat. Wu Qian just said these two words.
I understand it all, change my phone, and the previous WeChat record is gone, but many people don't understand this detail, unless there is a special backup, otherwise it will all disappear.
"Evidence!" the presiding judge knocked on the table again, and the prosecutor's performance was not very qualified.
Wu Gan said naturally: "I, Wu Gan, have not seen the details of the investigation of this case at all, and I have not seen the evidence I am about to say, that is to say, I have not really come into contact with that evidence, but I am absolutely sure." This evidence can prove that my hypothesis is correct, and moreover, exists!"
The word existence landed, and everyone at the scene, even all the viewers who watched the live broadcast on the Internet, all had a strong expectation, and they all wanted to know what evidence Wu Gan, a witness, could come up with, and he had not seen this evidence yet.
Even Xu Hong, a lawyer, had expectations, but of course, he was soon destroyed by himself.
The presiding judge's eyes were wide at this time, not to mention the others, one is counted as one, Liu Xindi, Lin Bing, Li Xue, Xie Jia and his wife, Liu Fatzi and others......
I only heard Wu Gan say in a calm tone: "This evidence is the clothes of the victim Xie Fan!"
Clothes?!
Everyone was stupid again, only one person was very excited, and that was Qin Yan, who knew the key.
Wu Qian said: " There will be a lot of fine glass chips on the back of the victim's clothes, which are splashed after the mobile phone and other electronic products are smashed, but there will be no on the front, and this confirms all my above assumptions, and at the same time overturns the defendant's confession, that is, what the defendant said, he killed the victim after a verbal dispute and smashed something, especially the defendant also emphasized that the victim had dropped his mobile phone, then, if the mobile phone was broken first, then, if the victim fell to the ground again, the front of the victim's clothes must have a lot of glass fragments stickedγ
As for the specifics, that is, the police took photos of the victims, and there should be many small light spots on his back, which should be caused by flash. β
As soon as these words came out, the key question came, isn't that the case?
But at this time, someone couldn't hold on.
Wang Lian broke down and said: "I plead guilty! I murdered Xie Fan! Please, don't say it, don't say it again......"
Crying while talking, admit it!
At the same time, Xu Hong collapsed, and he collapsed in his seat like a fool at this time.
But that's not all.
The presiding judge faced Liu Xindi, "Prosecutor, do the public security organs have any evidence as mentioned by the witnesses?"
Liu Xindi was a little dazed, but she quickly said loudly: "Presiding judge! collegial panel! Yes! Yes...... You can see the photos!"
Liu Xindi's excited hands were a little shaky, and she took out a few photos of the victim provided by the Evidence Department of the public security organ.
Xie Fan's positive photo is very ordinary.
But in the photo of his back, there are many small dots of light on his clothes.
The clothes Xie Fan was wearing that day were black, and in the photo, it was as if there were many small stars in the night sky.
Moreover, there is another key in this, that is, according to the evidence number, the photo of the back of the victim Xie Fan was taken by the Evidence Department first, because he was lying on the ground, that is, it did not exist at all, and the possibility that the clothes were stained with glass slag after turning the corpse.
Here's the proof!
Conclusive evidence!
Liu Xindi didn't stop, she was still looking, and finally found a piece of paper, "Here is the police identification report on the deceased's clothes!"
Liu Xindi was still very confused last night, and she didn't understand why Wu Qian wanted her to prepare these photos.
It turned out to be for this, and this evidence, to tell the truth, is too small. Moreover, in this case, because the pressure of external public opinion is too great, and the murderer is directly caught, that is, there is no investigation process, only the defendant's confession, then, what the police have done is to complete all their investigation and evidence collection, and hand it over to the procuratorate.
This evidence is too easy to be ignored, not to mention a rookie like Liu Xindi, even an experienced prosecutor may not notice it.
You must know that in terms of case-handling procedures, everything found before is a clue, and it can only be called evidence after it is presented in court, but with the development of science and technology in our case, there are more and more clues, and the evidence department is very powerful, but there are so many clues, which one is useful, this is the key.
It's really not too normal for such a tiny clue to be overlooked.
Now, all the evidence cited by Wu Gan, especially when combined with the previous ones, has become the key evidence, forming a chain of evidence that cannot be broken.
The truth of the case was revealed.
There are huge waves surging in everyone's hearts, and everyone understands that even the legal blind can understand it, and this case has been turned over!
It's definitely a murder!
But Wu Gan looked back and smiled.
The look in his eyes was Qin Yan.
Qin Yan secretly gave a thumbs up, but this guy was ...... in his heart Money skewers, this is forcing you to pretend!
The most angry thing is that he can't be debunked yet, but what he was shown at the time was only a copy of the photos of the scene, and it is amazing to be able to notice such a subtle clue.
Qin Yan was a little complacent, he had also discovered this clue early in the morning, but unfortunately, he was too restricted this time to exert his fists and feet...... The case was not their own, plus the school wanted to make a big deal small, and there were news media, these ......
Alas, wait a minute, haha, our old Qin is pressing the money skewer this time!
Just when Qin Yan was stunned in his heart, Wu Qian still had something to say.
"Presiding Judge, Collegial Panel, As a witness, I have many details of this case, and I ...... it."
But before he could finish speaking, the presiding judge knocked on the table.
"I declare that the court is now adjourned!"