Volume 2 Chapter 24 Reasoning in Court (3)
"Presiding judge! I object! Witness Wu Gan is simply doing a trial!"
"The opposition is valid, the witness Wu Gan asks you to pay attention to your words, you are just a witness, understand?. ”
In court, Xu Hong can be regarded as pulling back a game.
That's right, Wu Gan just now did say a little too much, but...
"Presiding Judge, I understand. "Wu Qian is still quite sincere.
The presiding judge gave a look at the "......" and signaled that prosecutor Liu Xindi should say something.
"Witness, you ......" Liu Xindi felt himself ...... at this time Does this case still have anything to do with you?
Well, it's true, Wu Qian seems to have become a prosecutor and fought with Xu Hong, the defense lawyer.
Now, the auditoriums of the courtroom and the audience on the Internet are all thinking this way.
Liu Xindi asked, "Witness, do you have any solid evidence?"
Wu Qian said with a smile: "What I have, to put it simply, the first evidence has come out, that is, the comments on this online store, that is, why do you want to buy such a pair of dumbbells? Pay attention to this dumbbell, iron sheet, iron rod, moreover, the packaging is very poor, the outside is just a layer, which is very in line with the elements of the murder weapon." Well, if that's not evidence, then I'll say one more piece of evidence, it's ......"
Wu Qian made a long note, which aroused everyone's expectations.
What the hell is he going to say?
"Time of the crime!"
As soon as this remark came out, many people were disappointed, is this evidence?
Even the face of the presiding judge changed a little, you know, he really helped Wu Gan.
But Wu Gan didn't care about this, and then said: "Please allow me to state completely, the evidence I provided, specifically, is the time of the crime and the time when the express delivery arrived." ”
Well?
What does this mean?
Wu Gandao: "The time of the incident was at 6:20, and the time of signing for the express delivery was 6:15, and the two times were very close. ”
Before he could finish speaking, Xu Hong couldn't help it again.
"Witness Wu Qian, we all know this, don't you need to emphasize it anymore, okay?"
Wu Qian said: "Yes, we all know this, but the time of the crime is very close to the time of the courier, which proves what I said before!"
"What are you talking about?"
"I'm saying, a person who wants to kill someone, and he's done it, let the person he wants to kill buy knock-off brand dumbbells, buy them from a small store that doesn't pay much attention to packaging, and then wait for the courier to arrive, and he wants to complete the killing, and make the killing look like a manslaughter, then, what else does he need to do?"
"He ......" Xu Hong was a little stunned.
"He also needs to make sure that no one knows that he actually knows that the package is a dumbbell!
The audience was stunned.
Wu Gan finally added, "Therefore, he must commit the murder in the shortest possible time, which is why the time of the crime in this case is so close to the arrival time of the express." ”
Wow~~
There was a burst of exclamation from the auditorium, and everyone really didn't expect this.
It must be said that this so-called evidence is placed in front of everyone's eyes, but no one has found it, and there is such a meaning.
"No, no......" Xu Hong was already panicking at this time.
As for Wang Lian, he was restless.
Wu Gan continued, "It is precisely because of this that Wang Lian has been staring at the entrance and exit of the dormitory No. 33 on the 28th, and the express did not come that day, so he has to continue to stare at it on the 29th, because only in this way can he complete his murder plan, a murder that seems to be a manslaughter but is actually a murder that has been premeditated for a long time!"
With these words, this case is simply going to be judged.
But at this time, the presiding judge spoke, "Witness Wu Gan, please pay attention to your words, otherwise, this seat will sentence you to contempt of court!"
By the way, a warning has been given before.
Wu Qian had no choice but to say, "I'm sorry, presiding judge, I'm a little excited. ”
Suddenly, Xu Hong attacked again, "No! Witness Wu Gan, the so-called evidence you gave is not direct evidence!"
When Wu Qian heard this, he smiled and asked, "May I ask what kind of law school lawyer Xu Hong graduated from?"
"What do you mean?"
"What I mean is, if I had a son, I would never let him be your alumnus. ”
"Witness Wu Qian! You, you are insulting me!"
"If a professional lawyer can't even understand the chain of evidence, then this is an insult to his school!"
To put it simply, in the absence of direct evidence, there are many indirect evidence that can form a logical chain of evidence, which can be regarded as decisive evidence.
The chain of evidence mostly appears in civil litigation, especially economic disputes and debt cases, because sometimes there is no IOU, but as long as sufficient indirect evidence can be provided, such as proof of withdrawal from the bank, no proof of the use of other funds, etc., to form a chain of evidence that 'the defendant borrowed my money', it can be supported by the law.
In this case, Wu Qian could only provide circumstantial evidence, and in fact, his tactics all along were to improve his chain of evidence.
Xu Hong was a little depressed, he didn't expect Wu Gan, the witness, the former police officer and now the detective, to understand the law, but he was unwilling, he still had something.
"Presiding Judge, please allow me to present evidence!"
"Yes. ”
Soon, Xu Hong took out an A4 piece of paper and said: "On this piece of paper, it is actually the chat record of the WeChat group of dormitory No. 33 on the day of the crime.
That is to say, it can be fully proved that this whole incident, my party did not have subjective intention!"
There was a message on this piece of paper, which was sent by Xie Fan, "Wang Lian, you kid come over to me!"
Once, this appeared in the media, and Xie Fan's arrogant and domineering image of the second generation of wealth was formed in this way. So, there was not much reaction from the auditorium.
Indeed, if judging from this evidence, Wang Lian was called over by Xie Fan, so how could he be premeditated?
And Wu Gan smiled, "Finally, take this thing out." ”
"What do you mean?" Xu Hong asked.
Wu Qian said to Liu Xindi: "Please ask the prosecutor to come up with a few similar things." ”
What the hell is this for?
Liu Xindi is still very procedural, "I ask the presiding judge to allow me to present evidence. ”
"Yes. ”
Sheets of A4 paper appeared, all with this sentence on them.
"Wang Lian, you kid come over to me!"
It's weird.
Wu Gan explained: "You see, this sentence has appeared many times, especially, every time it appears, the defendant goes to the victim's bedroom, but I ask you to think about it, although this seems to be the victim ordering the defendant on the surface, is it possible that this is actually a code between the victim and the defendant?"
"Password?" Xu Hong's eyes widened, and he said he didn't understand.
"Yes, a code between good friends. Wu Qian smiled, "Moreover, please think about it, is it possible for this code to be explained in this way, the victim, that is, Xie Fan, typed such words, in fact, telling the defendant Wang Lian, 'The things you want me to buy have arrived'." ”
As soon as these words came out, the audience was shocked.
When Xu Hong heard this, he was going crazy, "What evidence do you have?!"
Bang bang!
The presiding judge knocked on the table and said to Wu Gan: "Evidence!"
Almost instantly, everyone's eyes were cast on Wu Gan's body, because it was too unbelievable.
"I have proof. Wu Qian pointed, "Everyone, please see, the shoes on the defendant's feet are AJ1 Sakuragi black and red." ”
Wang Lian unconsciously shrank his feet in.
"What's wrong with this? Oh, are you Wu Qian accusing the detention center of not changing my client's shoes?"
Hearing Xu Hong's words, Wu Qian laughed even more, "Based on the defendant's economic situation, if he is wearing a pair of fakes, then this is more reasonable, but I am confident and sure, as long as I find an expert to come and take a look, I can know that the pair on the defendant's feet is genuine! The price of the real thing, on the Internet, is conservatively estimated to be more than 5,000 yuan!"
Wow!
The face of the whole audience, even the presiding judge, changed.
Wu Gan continued: "Moreover, I have witnesses and evidence to prove that the defendant not only has this one, but he also has more than a dozen pairs of these limited-edition sneakers, with a total price of tens of thousands of yuan! All of them are genuine! Did he steal them? How could he buy them? I still have evidence to prove that these shoes were bought by the victims!"
Wow ......ahhh
The shock of the crowd was beyond measure.
"Silence!" the presiding judge knocked on the table and faced Wu Gan, "What about your evidence?"
"Presiding Judge......
Before Wu Gan finished speaking, Sun Bo in the auditorium stood up directly, "Presiding Judge, I can prove that Xie Fan has many shoes, and they are all genuine, because I took these shoes to the Internet and sold them! Moreover, we can all testify that the relationship between Xie Fan and Wang Lian, they are really good friends, although our classmates were also deceived before, but they are really good friends, otherwise it would be impossible to buy such expensive shoes, there are many pairs!"
Ho!
Another surprise.
However, many people next to him, Lin Bing, Li Xue, Liu Fatzi, etc., are pulling Sun Bo down, because he has not yet appeared.
Sun Bo was excited, he felt that this scene was a little enthusiastic, and he couldn't help but stand up, and his words made everyone have such a judgment in their hearts.
Since, even such expensive shoes, the victim can buy them for the defendant, what is a pair of dumbbells?
That is what Wu Qian said, the real buyer of dumbbells is Wang Lian, who has received quite favorable support.
But!
"Silence!
The presiding judge's face was a little unsightly, and if the court couldn't control it, it wouldn't be good, so he said solemnly to Wu Gan: "Witness Wu Gan, you should know the law very well, then you should also know that judging from the current situation of this case, the relationship between the defendant and the victim is not absolutely directly related to the key to this case, that is, whether the defendant subjectively and intentionally committed murder. Now, I hope you can come up with key evidence, witness Wu Gan, do you have such evidence!"
As soon as these words came out, many people were strange in their hearts, but they couldn't find anything wrong, after all, the presiding judge was going to try this case, the murderer had already confessed to murder, the key was the nature, and the presiding judge focused on the key points, which was right.
So, does Wu Qian have it?
All eyes were focused on Wu Gan's body.