Volume II, Chapter 23: Reasoning in Court (2)
The trial of Wang Lian's murder of Xie Fan has just begun, but it is about to usher in a climax.
Wu Gan, as a witness, directly threw out a statement that surprised everyone, that is, the real buyer of dumbbells is Wang Lian.
This is really challenging everyone's cognition, the key is that he also said before that this dumbbell was purchased by Xie Fan online.
Lawyer Xu Hong was desperate, "Witness Wu Gan! What evidence do you have!"
Liu Xindi looked at Wu Gan, and there was a strong lack of confidence in her eyes.
In other words, not long ago today, Wu Qian had a long telephone chat with Liu Xindi, to put it simply, it is all the weirdness that Public Prosecutor Liu has shown at present, which are all directed by Wu Gan.
Now, what to do?
What about Wu Qian?
He looked at Wang Lian confidently, and he noticed that at this time, Wang Lian was slightly sweating on his forehead.
"Collegiate panel, I, Wu Gan, have evidence. ”
Everyone wanted to have a ...... Tell me about it!
The Xie family and his wife were the most anxious, just hearing Wu Gan's words, they could see hope, especially Mrs. Xie, her hands were trembling at this time.
But I heard Wu Gan say: "On the issue of the murder weapon, let me first talk about a few doubts.
Suspicion one, do you pay attention, the dumbbell that Xie Fan bought, that is, this store and the brand, are characterized by being small, the store is very small, and the brand has hardly been heard, like a copycat. ”
As soon as this suspicion was said, Xu Hong couldn't help it, "What's wrong with this?"
Wu Qian said with a smile: "If you are an ordinary person, of course there is no problem, but what kind of person is Xie Fan? He is a rich second generation!"
When everyone heard this, they understood.
That's right, the rich second generation buys things, isn't that still valuable?
In particular, everyone knows that Xie Fan is a high-flying rich second generation, and it should be so.
Xu Hong sat down again.
Wu Qian continued: "I believe everyone already has a spectrum in their hearts, that is, a rich second generation does not buy a big brand, such as Hyde, but buys a small brand, and only places an order in a small store, which is definitely a strange thing, but I tell you that the reason why this is the case is that it is necessary."
Okay, don't worry, I'll start with the second point.
Suspicion 2, Xie Fan has a fitness card, and I have communicated with his personal trainer, Xie Fan's exercise purpose is mainly to health, simply put, he doesn't want to train too many muscles.
That is, he doesn't need to buy any dumbbells at all. ”
Yes?!~
After this second point came out, there was a sigh in the auditorium.
It seems that if this continues, Wu Gan will really be able to define the case as murder.
The presiding judge asked at this time, "Witness Wu Gan, do you have any evidence for what you said?"
"Presiding judge, you can find the personal trainer at that gym to testify. ”
Wu Qian went to that gym for a purpose, and when he wrapped it up, it looked more sassy on the surface, but in fact, he killed three birds with one stone.
"Please continue. Naturally, the presiding judge was speechless.
Wu Qian nodded, and continued:
"Suspicion three, this time it takes a long time to shop online, and this store, although it is small, is actually here in the magic capital, in the same city. However, for some reasons, Xie Fan's order time was on the 27th, but this dumbbell, delivered to Xie Fan's hands, was already on the 29th. ”
This...
Online shopping is too common now, and everyone has relevant experience, but everyone thinks that it's nothing.
Xu Hong attacked again, "Witness Wu Gan, what kind of suspicion is this you talking about!?"
Wu Qian replied with a smile: "Of course, it is not a suspicion to look at it alone, but I learned through investigation that someone saw the defendant appear in the water bar of Dormitory Building 32 opposite Dormitory Building 33 on the afternoon of June 28, and he kept looking at Dormitory Building 33. ”
"What does this mean?!" Xu Hong gave an inexplicable look.
Wu Qian replied simply: "What did I say before? The real buyer is the defendant. ”
"......" When Xu Hong heard it, he was dumb at that time.
That's right, according to the logic of online shopping, whoever buys it will stare at logistics.
But...... Wait a minute.
Many people feel that something is wrong, there is a detail in this, that is, Wang Lian can't see the logistics of this online shopping at all!
This online shopping is Xie Fan.
It seems to be a little confused.
Qin Yan frowned when he heard this, but he didn't say anything.
Wu Qian seemed to know the confusion in everyone's hearts, and he immediately continued: "I believe that when I say this, everyone has doubts in their hearts.
Since it is Xie Fan who buys online, why is Wang Lian so concerned?"
Xu Hong suddenly interjected: "Although my client was watching it at the time, it doesn't mean that he was waiting for the express!"
Wu Qian said, "That's right, it's true that I can't be sure, but don't worry." ”
To tell the truth, the current courtroom situation is very strange, not the prosecutor vs. the defender, but the defender and the witness, which is too strange, and what is even more strange is that the presiding judge doesn't care at all.
In fact, at this time, the presiding judge was really attracted by Wu Gan's statement.
But I heard Wu Qian say: "Why is this happening? Let me give you a few points, and I believe that everyone will understand after listening to them."
First, why not buy big brands?
The reason is very simple, you can take out your mobile phone to see what the dumbbells of the big brands look like, and look at the packaging of the big brands, such as the one I said about Hyde, a set of 499, have you seen it?
That's right, the dumbbells of big brands, the packaging is very beautiful, this one from Hyde, there is a box on the outside, and there is a thick sponge wrap.
Got it, right? Such dumbbells, with a courier box on the outside, can't kill people!"
Wow!
In the auditorium, and even on the rostrum of the courtroom, the judges and jurors all exclaimed.
That's right, that's it, according to the packaging of big brands, you don't need to set express boxes, you will definitely not be able to kill people. Because it's a box, a box with plastic and sponge as the main body.
At this time, Wang Lian was already trembling a little.
Wu Gan hasn't finished speaking, "Second, let's take a look at the defendant, is it a little thin?"
You don't need to look at it to know it, but why mention this?
"The defendant had a reason to buy dumbbells, and this reason can be ......"
Xu Hong stopped, jumped up and said, "Wu Gan, you can't use this kind of subjective speculation to testify!"
The presiding judge immediately followed, "Witness, please note that you can only give evidence. ”
Wu Gan nodded, and then said: "Okay, I will only provide evidence, the third point, that is, why did the defendant make the appearance of waiting for the express delivery on the 28th? It is very simple, because he knows that Xie Fan placed an order on the 27th, that is to say, on the 28th, the dumbbells will definitely arrive." I have witnesses who saw him, and, on the 29th, he did the same thing that day before committing the murder, and even the defendant waited longer on this day. ”
"Proof!" Xu Hong thundered again.
"Attention defenders. The presiding judge reminded him, and then reminded Wu Gan, "Witnesses, please show evidence." ”
"I have witnesses who saw that the defendant was drinking water at the water bar on the 28th, and the defendant was at the tea bar on the 29th, and the shop owner can testify!" Wu Qian continued, "Before, I also talked to the owner of this fitness equipment store on the Internet, why this order was not delivered until the 29th? Because on the 27th, he bought Germany, lost, went to drink, forgot to deliver the goods, and did not deliver the goods until the evening of the 28th, so the list arrived on the 29th, which is very normal. That is, it was an unexpected event.
And such an accident exposed the defendant.
The fact that the defendant had the same wait-and-watch behavior for two days in a row proved that the dumbbells were actually what he wanted.
In addition, my evidence is ...... This is my mobile phone, please check the collegial panel to check the store where Xie Fan buys dumbbells online, the focus is on the comments of this store. ”
Wu Gan's mobile phone was handed over, but what was this for?
Before, no one knew which store Xie Fan was shopping from, but before, Liu Xindi had already mentioned the name of the store when he made a statement, so now he has an advantage with a good memory.
In the auditorium, many people were looking through their mobile phones.
"Wow, that's it!"
"Packaging! A lot of complaining about packaging!"
"The package is very poor, not tight, boss, you are too saving. ”
"The boss replied: It's iron anyway, and it won't break, why is the bag so tight?"
The presiding judge has the right to knock on the table, but this time, he didn't, but waited for the discussion to slow down, because everyone understood a little.
"Do you understand?" Wu Qian said with a smile: "Why do you have to choose this store? So many big stores, better brands, and better quality don't choose them? Because the dumbbells sold in this store have poor packaging, and such packaging makes the dumbbells' iron rods and iron pieces completely suitable for use as murder weapons!"
Why did the defendant keep an eye on dormitory No. 33 so that when the courier arrived, the courier would send his murder weapon, and the defendant's series of actions were all for the purpose of killing!"