Chapter 170: A counterattack that starts with a piece of paper

“... Back then, the Roman Empire was dominant, and the conquest brought glory to the empire and a steady stream of wealth.

But soon, the original simple Romans fell at the feet of money and indulged in the debauchery of the dogs and horses, and the empire finally fell apart in this decay and depravity.

In the Middle Ages, Catholics once prided themselves on being clean, but the magic of money finally broke through the place where moral beliefs were stationed.

For the sake of money, Pope John XXII openly marked the price of the crimes of the world!

Are you guilty of stealing/stealing?

It doesn't matter, as long as three gold coins you can go unpunished.

Have you committed adultery?

Don't be afraid, five gold coins will give you peace of mind.

Even if you commit the crime of killing, it's not a big deal, as long as seven or eight gold coins can guarantee that your soul will still go to heaven..."

The two arguments and a series of comparisons say that "money is the root of all evil" is "hearty", which makes people can't help but think that "all sins" are caused by "money".

Finally, he concludes: "The Bible says that it is more difficult to bring a rich man into the kingdom of God than to put a camel through the eye of a needle." However, in the eyes of those who are hungry for profit, the gate of heaven is open to the south, and if you are virtuous and have no money, you should not come in. ”

If there is an ancient one, then there will naturally be a modern one, and only a consistent one from ancient times to the present can be more convincing.

The second argument continued: "In modern times, the sun of social progress is shining on the earth, but the shadow of money evil still lingers.

Because of money, the freedom-loving lighthouse people are slow to give their freedom to black slaves;

Because of money, the Helan people, who advertised equality, wanted to force the Eastern countries to sign unequal treaties with him;

Or because of money, the blast furnace people who sing "fraternity, benevolence and righteousness" have forgotten to give love to the tens of thousands of child laborers who work all day long, but still can't eat. ”

Another series of rankings!

The atmosphere of the scene was very warm by the horse team, and the audience at the scene was also very face-saving.

Jiang Ge whispered to Zhu Quan next to him: "What now?" Seeing that their momentum is very strong, the audience at the scene was taken away by them! ”

Zhu Quan gave her a relaxed look and said, "Debate, it's not just about having an advantage in momentum!" How about the ornate rhetoric just by ranking? Returning to the debate itself, it is more important to have something to say and be reasonable. ”

Zhu Quan had already thought of the method of argumentation, wrote down a few points of note on scratch paper, and secretly passed them on to Yu Lei and others.

After seeing Zhu Quan's plan, several people nodded heavily.

There are only eight words written on the manuscript paper: "Blur the bottom line, diverse arguments".

As a debater, after seeing these eight words, he immediately understood Zhu Quan's strategy.

Because the argument of the Zhengfang Horse Team has put forward that "human nature is not evil", if the bottom line of "human nature is evil" is strengthened at this moment, it is too naked.

Therefore, without putting forward the bottom line, it is directly said that "people's extreme beliefs cause evil", "people's lust is caused by excessive catharsis", plus "people's irrational violation of values causes evil", these three arguments prepared in the audience.

None of these three arguments directly states that "human nature is inherently evil", but every word says that "human nature is inherently evil".

In the end, Lai Ma said to the second debate: "The ancients said: "Taking history as a mirror, we can know the rise and fall." "In the face of the history of the East and the West, we can't help but ask: money, how many sins are born by you, and how many prosperous times are died by you?

Thank you. ”

The audience applauded!

There were even cheers and whistles to celebrate!

Victory, it seems, is already in sight!

But Zhu Quan and others don't see it that way.

When the second team had just argued, the process of argumentation was not quite right, and the order was reversed like the mistakes they put down on one side.

Taking 10,000 steps back, if "10,000" really does not mean "everything", then at least explain what the meaning of "10,000" found in "Cihai" is true, rather than directly denying it.

Most people don't stop to look up reference books when they watch debates.

Therefore, it can only be said that the judgment should be understood according to common sense, and aside from the topic of the debate competition, most people may understand the "root of all evil" as "the root of all bad things".

Finally, "Is everything in all hands?" This small sentence was gently carried by this second argument.

As far as this round is concerned, it is not difficult to see that Zhengfang's definition of the word "10,000" has actually worked hard, and the level of argumentation has been carefully designed, so it can be said that it is very well prepared, but it has only been played by this second argument with a sixty percent effect.

When the first argument of the positive side has lost the opportunity, the second argument still fails to recover this point, so don't blame Zhu Quan for chasing after the victory again.

The host Cen Ying controlled the scene and said: "Thank you, the second debate student. Let's take a look at how Zhu Quan, the second argument of the opposing side, refutes the positive viewpoint, the time is 3 minutes, please. ”

There were a lot of Chinese, Chinese students and staff at the scene, and there were about three or four percent of them.

It can be said that it is also the "home field" of the Huaguo team.

The barrage can be described as "covering the sky and covering the sun".

"My boss Zhu Quan is finally on the field!"

"Come on, tremble!"

"Zhu Quan is mighty 87!"

"The aura is different! More momentum than the players of the Laima team! ”

"I finally understand why there was thunderous applause after the second debate of the horse team, I guess this is to welcome me Zhu Quan!"

"Zhu Quan's eyes have dark circles on them, is it okay? It's hard for him, he just participated in the finals of the "Host Competition" yesterday, and now he has flown all night on the old airway to participate in the semi-finals of the "College Debate Competition". Woo, distressed!! ”

"With great power comes great responsibility!"

...

Zhu Quan stood up, looked relaxed, straightened his suit, and after politely thanking the host, he said, "Thank you." Hello everyone. ”

As he was talking, Zhu Quan picked up a blank A4 paper in front of him and said to the camera: "Look, everyone, this is a blank A4 paper, when I..."

Zhu Quan wrinkled the paper as he spoke, and continued: "... It's a crumpled piece of paper. But in essence, it's still paper, right? ”

Then, Zhu Quan continued to tear the crumpled paper in half and said, "... It's a shredded piece of paper. But in essence, it's still paper, right? ”

Then, Zhu Quan entered the topic of the debate and stated: "Today, the other party seems to have cited many kinds of "evil" in the world for us, but in essence, there is actually only one..."

Zhu Quan paused, and then said: "... That's greed for money. ”

This paragraph uses a simple single piece of paper to explode the audience!

There are no flowery words, there are just real, real, and clear truths.

It is very simple and easy to understand, so that the audience can understand what Zhu Quan wants to express at once.

If this is a completely random game, everyone does not rely on pre-game preparation, no arguments, and completely fights to react on the spot, then Zhu Quan relies on this sentence:

Today, the other party seems to cite many kinds of "evil" for us, but in fact, there is only one, and that is greed for money. ”

You can get the best debater in the game.

This sentence is the foothold of all the attacks of the opposing side!

The lethality of this sentence lies in the fact that the criterion for judging the proportion of evil is forcibly pulled from quantity to type.

That is, the evil caused by money is reduced from "ten thousand" to "one".

The comparison between ancient and modern China and foreign countries, and a large section of the two debates just now, was beaten by Zhu Quan here and solved together, which is simply amazing logically, and it is likely to be the most lethal sentence in the history of debate.

"Absolutely, absolutely! This cope! ”

"This is the strength of the big guy!"

"Four or two thousand pounds!"

"Who says the moderator can't debate? This is called not being able to debate, who is still called being able to debate? ”

...

The barrage is all in support of Zhu Quan, and the momentum is huge.

Zhu Quan continued: "... And is there really only one kind of evil in the world, greed for money?

Today, the other party said that today's "10,000" is not called "complete".

Then I would like to ask the other side, today I said, "You must not agree with my position", does it mean that you disagree most of the time, but occasionally you can agree? ”

This little analogy made the audience laugh.

"That's it, you can't agree, according to the meaning of the team, that is, most of the time you don't agree, but occasionally you can agree."

"Haha, Zhu Quan's reflexes are too strong!"

"Please call me Zhu Wit Quan."

...

"The logic of the opponent's argument today is very interesting, he tells us today that because the pursuit of money is unlimited, and the possession of wealth is limited, money is the root of all evil.

In that case, I say that my pursuit of morality is also unlimited, but the morality I possess is also limited, so morality is also the source of all evil? ”

Zhu Quan's wit once again won the applause of the audience.

“... According to this logic, health is also the root of all evil today! Today, love is also the root of all evil! ”

Zhu Quan stood up and talked eloquently.

Compared with the fragment of the discussion of "10,000" in the second debate of the positive side, Zhu Quan's expression is very smooth, and he doesn't know how high he is in terms of technique.

It's a blast!

Jiang Ge and Jiang Feng, who were sitting next to them, and Wu Tian, who was sitting in the audience, all three girls looked at Zhu Quan with starry eyes, and the admiration and admiration in their eyes could be felt as long as they were not "blind".