Hearing Liu Sheng's opinion, Rao expected Liu Sheng's gradually maturing heart, and Shentu Jiaman couldn't help but be a little surprised on his appreciative face.

- I have to say that Liu Sheng's perspective on today's debate is really a bit beyond Shen Tujia's psychological expectations.

"I originally thought that Childe's view of today's debate would be from the perspective of the country and the society, which would lead to the rebellion that was about to be triggered by the "Cutting Strategy";

"Or, like King Liang and Gongzi Rong, they will regard this matter as a prelude to the ownership of the storage position."

"I never thought that what Gongzi noticed was the rise and fall of Huang Lao's theory······"

With a smile on his face, Shen Tujia couldn't help but stop, and nodded at Liu Sheng with a smile full of approval.

Then, after Shen Tujia's face, a touch of sighing and sighing immediately appeared.

"Indeed, as Gongzi said: Huang Laoxue arose during the Warring States Period;"

"After Emperor Taizu Gao established the Han Dynasty and decided to recuperate and recuperate with the people, it gradually flourished in my Han family, and even became the most influential school in the Han world."

"This is because Huang Lao's 'no law prohibits, there is no blame', advocating local inaction, and Emperor Taizu Gao recuperating and recuperating, which coincides with the concept of the people's beginning."

"But after so many years, especially the governance of Emperor Xiaowen of the former Taizong, the world that was once shattered by war has regained the scene of peace and prosperity;"

"Under such circumstances, Huang Lao's doctrine has gradually lost the necessity of its existence, and it is only because of the general trend that it has not been immediately banned."

"It's just that so many years of 'comfort' have made the old Huang school become complacent and unenterprising;"

"Up to now, Huang Laoxue has actually decayed to the point that even people like Huang Sheng can become Huang Lao's 'everyone'······"

In the end, Shen Tujia couldn't help but shake his head and sigh, and nodded to Liu Sheng again.

"Childe is right."

"Today's debate will surely accelerate the decay of Huang Laoxue;"

"In another three or five years, no more than ten years at most, I am afraid that there will be no young people in the world who are willing to study and delve into Huang Lao's theory·······

Unreservedly expressed his recognition of Liu Sheng, Shen Tujia sighed and sighed, but also recognized Liu Sheng's rapid growth.

Shen Tujia is very sure: Liu Sheng has already predicted the future of Huang Lao's theory through today's debate, so it is impossible not to think of other factors.

For example, Liu Qi, the Son of Heaven, summoned Huang Sheng and Yuan Gu into the palace and asked so many people to observe today's debate.

However, Liu Sheng did not care about these, or deliberately 'ignored' them, but focused his attention on the long-term issue of 'alternating schools of government'.

Thinking of this, Shen Tujia quietly had the same thought as Liu Qi, the son of heaven, in his heart.

"Jia Ji, why isn't she the queen?"

"Or Childe, why wasn't he born a few years earlier······

Just as he was thinking about it, Liu Pengzu's inquiring voice sounded in his ears, so that Shen Tujia could only hurry back to his senses and throw that strange thought out of his mind.

"Teacher;"

"-Is what Huang Sheng said wrong?"

saw Liu Pengzu stop with doubts, and didn't forget to look at his younger brother Liu Sheng beside him;

"I didn't mean to refute Ah Sheng;"

"I know what Ah Sheng just said is right."

"But putting aside Huang Sheng's 'disregard for Taoism and nature', it doesn't seem wrong to discuss Huang Sheng's views alone?"

"As a courtier, shouldn't you be loyal to the monarch instead of taking the opportunity to stand on your own?"

Hearing Liu Pengzu's question, Shen Tujia only nodded subconsciously: "This is natural." ”

When this sentence came out, he saw that Liu Pengzu's face was even more puzzled, and Shen Tujia finally reacted;

Smiled and shook his head, and looked around without a trace;

After thinking about it again and again, he finally felt that this was not the place to speak, so Shen Tujia turned around indifferently and looked at Liu Pengzu again.

"Childe said that today's debate was ultimately the result of a draw, and it was not wrong."

"-But this draw is not because Huang Sheng and Yuan Gusheng performed very well, but because these two people made mistakes."

"As for Your Majesty, it's not that you don't think what these two people said is reasonable, so you can't make a judgment;"

"It's because today, what these two people said is unreasonable, and Your Majesty really can't tell who is more unreasonable, so he didn't make a final judgment."

After tasting the words of restraint, he saw Shen Tujia looking left and right pointedly, and then looked at Liu Sheng and Liu Pengzu again.

"I haven't been to the door for many days, and the old man misses the two sons;"

"If there is no other important matter, why don't the two sons go to the house and sit for a while?"

·

took Liu Pengzu and Liu Sheng to sit down in the pavilion in the old Anhou Mansion, and watched Liu Sheng leave obediently and bring a bowl of tea and soup for himself;

Grabbing the tea bowl and pouring it violently, feeling that the dry itch in his throat was relieved, Shentu Jiacai took a deep breath and told the key to it.

"In today's debate, Huang Sheng's mistake is to abandon Huang Laoxue's principle of 'Taoism and Nature';"

"Putting this aside, there is nothing wrong with Huang Sheng's argument alone."

"As a courtier, of course, you should be loyal to the king, and when the monarch makes a mistake, you should persuade and stop it, not replace it."

"As for the Shang Tang and Zhou Wu revolutions, whether they obeyed the orders of heaven or killed the monarch and usurped the throne, there have been different opinions on the hundreds of schools of thought for hundreds of years;"

"Huang Sheng thinks that it is a usurpation of the king, and there is no problem."

"-After all, after so many years, no one can prove why Shang Tang and Zhou Wu rebelled against Xia Wei and Shang Xuan."

"According to the debate rule of 'if it cannot be falsified, it will not be refuted' during the Warring States Period, Huang Sheng has no problem expressing today's arguments."

Hearing this, Liu Pengzu and Liu Sheng, who were sitting intently in front of the desk, couldn't help but nod their heads slowly.

Regarding this 'unspoken rule' of the Warring States period, the two brothers have an understanding.

Because of the current Han family, it has only been more than 40 years since Emperor Taizu Gao Liu Bangli Han Guozuo, and the Warring States Period is not too far away for today's Han family.

And this rule of debate, in the words of later generations, is: as long as there is no clear evidence to prove that the opponent's argument is completely wrong, there should be no rebuttal.

If you want to refute, you must come up with conclusive evidence as the basis for refutation.

It's like one day, someone jumped out and said: The first emperor is a very benevolent monarch!

According to the rules of debate during the Warring States period, or debate etiquette, those who want to debate with them need to come up with conclusive evidence to deny the opponent's arguments.

For example, the Great Wall of Qin~

Ah Fang Palace~

Straight~

The tax rate~

Even forced emigration, the flowering of both sides of the southern and northern wars, and the sending of Xu Fu to seek immortals and ask questions, etc., can be used as evidence that 'the first emperor is absolutely not merciful'.

The same is true for today's debate.

Huang Sheng said: Shang Tang and Zhou Wu killed the monarch and were self-reliant, and they were rebellious ministers and thieves, and if Yuan Gu wanted to refute it, he also had to come up with similar evidence to show that Huang Sheng was 'talking nonsense'.

For example, at that time, what did Shang Tang and Zhou Wu do, which could prove that they didn't want to be the Son of Heaven and the like.

- You said that Huang Sheng was talking nonsense, so you should show the evidence!

Take out the ironclad evidence that Shang Tang and Zhou Wu 'don't want to take Xia Wei and Shang Xun instead'!

But the crux of the problem is that the passage of time makes it possible for people in the world today to peek at the mysterious corner of that distant history only through history books;

However, that period of history has long disappeared in the long river of history with the book burning order of the first emperor Yingzheng and the Xianyang Palace ordered by Xiang Yu to be burned.

From this point of view, there is no way to directly falsify the argument that Huang Sheng said that 'Shang Tang and Zhou Wu killed the monarch to be self-reliant'.

Not only is it unfalsifiable, but today, no one can directly refute the argument that 'Shang Tang and Zhou Wu killed the monarch and became self-reliant'.

And this is precisely the reason why similar arguments have emerged in an endless stream in the past 100 years, but they have never been conclusive.

——In the case of the history book being 'out of print', no one can come up with conclusive evidence to prove that Shang Tang and Zhou Wu are not self-reliant.

Thinking like this, Liu Pengzu was already full of doubts, and couldn't help but be more entangled.

"Is there anything wrong with what Yuan Gu said?"

"——If Shang Tang and Zhou Wu are self-reliant by killing the monarch, isn't it just as Yuan Gu said: Emperor Taizu Gao has also become a chaotic minister and thief who usurped power and seized the throne?"

was full of doubtful questions, but Shen Tujia shook his head and smiled bitterly, and looked at the two brothers with full confidence.

"This brings us to today's debate, what is the mistake that Yuan Gu made."

"Huang Sheng's mistake was to ignore Huang Lao's position of 'Taoism and Nature', and there is no problem with the argument."

"But the stubborn mistake is precisely on the argument."

"-Because Emperor Taizu Gao, and Shang Tang and Zhou Wu, are not the same at all!"

"Yuan Gu is an old Confucian, he looks sanctimonious, but in fact, he is a scum who uses sophistry to stand up!"

"Because Emperor Taizu Gao's 'obeying the heavens' is innumerable!"

Without hesitation, Shen Tujia's eyes couldn't help but bring a little determination!

When he spoke of Yuangu's tone, he carried an undisguised disdain.

"In the last years of the Zhou Dynasty, the first to show the opposite was King Qin Wu Yingdang, who asked Zhou Ding about his importance."

"In the end, it was the King of Qin who destroyed the Zhou family and ruled the world."

"If you really want to talk about the rebellious ministers and thieves who 'destroyed Zhou', it should be Qin, not Han."

With a touch of remembrance appearing on Shen Tujia's old face, the anger in Shen Tujia's tone gradually subsided.

Then, half of the former Anhou Mansion was immersed in Shen Tujia's calm and gentle tone.

"——At the end of Qin, Chen Sheng and Wu Guang rebelled in Daze Township, and the world jointly elected King Chu Huai as the leader of the anti-Qin Dynasty."

"Emperor Taizu Gao, as a subordinate of King Chu Huai, participated in the struggle against Qin."

"Later, Emperor Taizu Gao entered Xianyang first, but he did not commit any crime against the people of Guanzhong, and he also made three chapters with the respected old man: death to the murderer, injury and theft."

"For the third son, Emperor Taizu Gao did not act excessively, but just invited the third child out of the palace."

"It's Xiang Yu, after arriving in Xianyang, he beheaded the third son and baby outside the market in Xianyang."

"On the other hand, Emperor Taizu Gao, not only did he approve of Xiang Yu's move to behead the child, but also mourned the child after his death."

"Therefore, the rebellious ministers and thieves who 'destroyed Qin' should be Xiang Yu, not Emperor Taizu Gao."

As he spoke, Shen Tujia's emotions had completely calmed down;

There is no longer the slightest disdain for Yuan Gu, who vainly tries to accuse 'Emperor Taizu Gao of being the same as Shang Tang and Zhou Wu'.

Yes, just endless indifference and dismissive disregard.

"Emperor Taizu Gao was awarded the title of King of Han, and it was Xiang Yu who was crowned;"

"And at that time, Xiang Yu was also after obtaining the permission of the righteous emperor Chu Huai, and he divided the anti-Qin princes from all walks of life."

"Therefore, Emperor Taizu Gao was established as the king of Han, and there was no slightest trespass in etiquette."

"It wasn't until Xiang Yu killed King Huai and established himself as the 'Overlord of Western Chu' that the world surged again, and Emperor Taizu Gao also raised troops against Chu."

"-for, not to fight with Xiang Yu for the world, but for the anti-Qin rebel commander: the blood feud of the righteous emperor Chu Huaiwang."

"In the end, Emperor Taizu Gao won Xiang Yu, and he was also the princes of all walks of life, formed a coalition army for the blood feud of King Huai, and jointly elected Emperor Taizu Gao as the commander;"

"After Xiang Yu was defeated in Wujiang, it was also the princes of all walks of life who acted together to force Emperor Taizu Gao to ascend to the throne of the Son of Heaven in Luoyang······"

As Shen Tujia's tone fell, the faces of Liu Pengzu and Liu Sheng were already sluggish;

It's not because of the two brothers that they don't know about this past.

It was Shen Tujia's 'interpretation' that made the brothers a little dumbfounded······

- If they hadn't been born in the Liu family, the two brothers would have even suspected that something was wrong with their own brains!

Liu Bang, Emperor Taizu of the Han Dynasty, doesn't want to fight for the world?

I think that back then, when I entered Xianyang City, I carnivaled in the Qin Palace, and the wine pond meat forest, and the most fun thing to play was Liu Ji, the prince of Pei!

After being named the king of Han, Liu Bang didn't even care about repairing the palace of the Han Dynasty, and just waited for Xiang Yu to return to Guandong, so he immediately couldn't wait for the dark Chen Cang, and returned the three Qins from Hanzhong!

After pacifying the three Qins in Guanzhong, Liu Bang gathered other princes in the name of 'avenging the king of Chu Huai' and formed a coalition of princes to crusade against Xiang Yu!

And Liu Bang's power as the 'commander of the coalition forces' is precisely because of Liu Bang, who is the initiator of the crusade against Xiang Yu!

Later, not to mention.

——Pengcheng was defeated, and the 560,000 princes led by Liu Bang were killed by Xiang Yu's 30,000 Chu cavalry, and they were scattered with a bang;

On the way to escape, Liu Bang was even more anxious to kick his son Liu Ying and daughter Liu Le under the car, for fear of being caught up by the pursuers behind him!

If it weren't for the loyal groom Xiahou Ying, who picked up Liu Ying and Liu Le several times, I am afraid that there would be no Emperor Xiaohui and Princess Lu Yuan in the later Han family.

After that, Taigong Liu Xuan and Gao Hou Lu Pheasant were both arrested by Xiang Yu, and Xiang Yu sent someone to blackmail Liu Bang, trying to force Liu Bang to comply.

The result?

- Xiang Yu said, 'If you don't surrender, I'll cook my father', but Liu Bang replied: After cooking, remember to share a bowl of meat with me······

As for the princes from all walks of life who 'forced Liu Bang to ascend the throne', let alone mention.

Han Xin, the king of Chu, was killed by a bamboo pole;

Peng Yue, the king of Liang, let the rope strangle to death;

King Gongwei of Linjiang, King Zang Di of Yan, and King Yingbu of Huainan raised troops to rebel and were defeated and died;

Han Wangxin defected, surrendered to the Xiongnu, and died in the Han-Hun battle.

The princes with different surnames who supported Liu Bang at the beginning also died well in the two of them, Wu Rui, the king of Changsha, and Zhang Er, the king of Zhao.

- That's it, or because these two died early!

Even if these two died early, it still failed to change the tragic fate of future generations.

Zhang Er, the king of Zhao, died in the fifth year of Emperor Taizu Gao, that is, the year when Taizu Liu Bang ascended the throne;

Just a few years after Zhang Erxue's death, Zhang Ao, the second-generation king of Zhao, was demoted to the Marquis of Xuanping because of the rebellion of the country.

As for the king of Changsha, we must always be on guard against Zhao Tuo in Lingnan, not to mention, in Changsha's poor countryside, deep mountains and old forests, it is better to be a rich man in the Central Plains!

The lineage of the Wu family of the king of Changsha, which was founded by the ancestor Wu Rui, has also been eliminated two years ago with the death of the fifth generation of the king of Changsha.

In the early Han Dynasty, seven princes with different surnames, five of whom were not allowed to die well, one of whose descendants lost their titles, and one of whom was sealed to Changsha's 'Feng Shui Treasure Land', passed on to the fifth generation and became extinct······

is like this, can Liu Bang be a person who is 'unwilling to be the Son of Heaven'?

Thinking like this, the two brothers looked at Shen Tujia's gaze, but it became more and more strange······

- Then again, Shen Tujia is so round, he can really be round!

No matter what Liu Bang thought in his heart at that time;

At least Shen Tujia said these things, Liu Bang did it in real time, and left behind historical records and oral folklore!

Feeling the strangeness in the eyes of the two brothers, Shen Tujia didn't pretend to be stupid, but only smiled meaningfully.

"Rotten Confucianism is stubborn, I really underestimate Emperor Taizu Gao······"

"A wise and wise monarch like Emperor Taizu Gao will never leave such a hidden danger as 'usurping the previous dynasty and standing on his own' to future generations to have a headache·········

A sentence full of deep meaning, Shen Tujia couldn't help but smile a little, and looked at Liu Sheng on the side with a slightly serious gaze.

"Gongzi thinks that Huang Laoxue can have such a 'everyone' as Huang Sheng, which means that Huang Lao's learning is exhausted and cannot last long;"

"And I think that Confucianism can produce such a 'doctor' as Yuangu, which can also prove that the situation of Confucianism is not much better than that of Huang Laoxue."

"Whether Yuan Gu is trying to confuse the public in order to defeat Huang Sheng, deliberately confusing Emperor Taizu Gao with Shang Tang and Zhou Wu, or because Yuan Gu really treats Emperor Taizu Gao like that;"

"Today's debate is enough to prove that since the Han Dynasty, Zhongni's theory, which has been weak, has not made much progress."

"Especially at the moment when Huang Laoxue is gradually declining and most of the hundreds of schools of thought are withering, Confucianism like this today is not enough to become the new manifestation of my Han family after Huang Laoxue."

"Perhaps, it is precisely for this reason that His Majesty will gradually favor the Legalists, and take the Legalists like Chao Cuo and Zhidu as the humerus henchmen around him;"

"—not because in the eyes of His Majesty, how good the Legalists really are;"

"It's because apart from the Legalists, Your Majesty, there is no other choice······"

This is the first watch, and the remaining three watches will be sent tomorrow afternoon.

Because the first subscription only counts this chapter, that is, the number of subscriptions for the first paid chapter, if the four chapters are sent out together, it will have an impact.

Thank you for your understanding, and I would like to ask for your support.

I wish you all a happy National Day

(End of chapter)