The last nonsensical remark of the Li siblings made both the judge and Lawyer Zhao feel inexplicable, and the presiding judge couldn't help asking: "What does it mean to be unable to fulfill the relevant responsibilities?

Li Lao Er still lowered his head and didn't say a word, the eldest brother and sister of the Li family exchanged glances with each other, and said helplessly: "So far, there is nothing to hide, the situation of our brother, you also know, he is not doing a good job, has no fixed income, relies on relatives and friends for daily life, and has long been divorced, and now he doesn't even have a complete home, how can he have the ability to fulfill the responsibility of repayment!"

The judge disagreed, "He has no ability to repay, doesn't he still have your brother and sister? You are also the children of the elderly, and you can't shirk this responsibility." ”

"Mr. Judge doesn't know, our brother and sister left home when they were young, and have been working and living in other places, and our parents have not inherited any property from our parents except for raising us to adulthood, and the old man has long said that our brother will provide for him in his old age, so we are not obliged to bear these debts. In addition, we are all ordinary working families, and we are retired, and now we live on a meager pension, and we also have a family, although my brother is in a bad situation, we are not able to help him. "It turned out that the eldest brother and sister of the Li family wanted to stay out of the matter.

The judge thought for a moment, "I understand your situation of leaving home at a young age, and since your brother does not object to your statement, I also believe that your parents may have said something on the issue of providing for your parents in old age." My question is, have they ever left a will?"

The Li family brothers and sisters shook their heads and said, "It's just that when we got together many years ago, the old father said something similar verbally, and said it more than once. ”

"This is a bit difficult to do!" Although the judge sympathizes with the brother and sister, the law is iron-faced and ruthless, "If there is no will, no matter how many times you say it verbally, it is useless, and there is no basis for what you say, and the court pays attention to evidence! Your old father has died, and if there is no witness, you must have physical evidence, and if the old man does not have a will, it will be useless for you to say anything." Therefore, you two sisters and brothers cannot shirk their responsibilities. ”

"This is the court, is there any legal basis for such a statement?" The eldest sister of the Li family looked very dissatisfied with the judge's judgment.

"It is precisely because it is a court of law, and you cannot produce a will that proves that this matter has nothing to do with you, whether it is analyzed from the perspective of the grace of parenting or the legal perspective of the maintenance law, you are not able to get rid of it. ”

"But as we have already said, we live on our pension only, and we have a family of our own, so to speak, also moonshine people, who have no savings, and to be honest, if the court has to hold us accountable, we can't do anything either. ”

No wonder Guan Yuntian suspected that the other party was premeditated, it seems that the other party had already expected such a result, the second child of the Li family has put on a posture of a dead pig who is not afraid of boiling water from the beginning, and now, their eldest brother and sister have also begun to cheat!

The judge reminded: "Since you have refused to mediate again and again, you have to come to the trial stage, you should accept the outcome of the trial, and I hope you will respect the law and not make unnecessary denials." ”

"Mr. Judge, we accept the outcome of the trial, but it has been made clear that we will not be able to meet our repayment obligations due to the conditions of our three parties

(This chapter is not finished, please turn the page)

, what can be done about this?" The three brothers and sisters of the Li family are completely in a laipi tone.

"Don't think that you can escape your responsibilities by cheating, and don't forget that once the trial court transfers the results to the enforcement court, your bank accounts will be frozen, and in addition, there will be an auction of your property. ”

The Li siblings may have calculated that their brothers have nothing but a dilapidated building, and as for the siblings who live in other places, they have no other property except the house they live in and their pension account. They argued that the court's enforcement chamber could not auction off the house where the brothers lived out of humanitarian considerations, and that the enforcement chamber was a bit out of reach for the two of them, whose homes were out of town. So, they didn't take the judge's warning seriously.

Seeing this situation, lawyer Zhao reminded: "There is still a sum of money, I don't know if the Li family brothers and sisters have considered it? After the death of your old father, according to the policy, you can receive a funeral fee, and according to the conditions of the old man, this money is basically equivalent to the various expenses you owe." ”

As soon as they heard this, the expressions of the Li brothers and sisters instantly became nervous, and what they were worried about finally happened. originally thought that they could get away with the old father's funeral expenses by playing tricks and crying poor, and after getting the old father's funeral expenses and getting a share of the money, the three brothers and sisters went their separate ways, but they didn't know that the other party's lawyer knew everything and had already been eyeing the money.

As a senior lawyer who has been practicing for many years, Lao Zhao has handled countless civil dispute cases, to be honest, in this case, if you really want to do as the presiding judge said, through the enforcement court auction property seizure account and other measures, so that the judgment can be enforced, lawyer Zhao believes that it is not advisable, on the one hand, the amount involved is only tens of thousands of yuan, even if the Li family sisters and brothers have property, it is very troublesome to operate, and it is not worth it, in addition, the most important thing is that except for their brother has a dilapidated building, they do not have any property in the local area.

After judging the direction of the case, Lawyer Zhao's first thought was the old man's funeral expenses, and if the Li brothers and sisters agreed, the matter would become very simple, so when he saw the Li brothers and sisters cheating, he did not speak to avoid intensifying the conflict.

Listening to the judge's negotiation with the Li siblings, the other party did not mention the money, and Lawyer Zhao believed that they did not know, but wanted to deliberately conceal it.

Lawyer Zhao learned that the receipt of funeral expenses not only requires the signatures of the elderly's immediate family members, but also various procedures issued by the relevant departments, because the aftermath of the elderly surnamed Li is handled by the elderly service center, and the relevant procedures are naturally in the hands of the elderly service center.

As far as the current situation is concerned, no matter whether it is the Li brothers and sisters or the elderly service center, no one can take out the money alone, and only if the two parties reach an agreement, the Li sisters and brothers sign it, and the elderly service center provides the relevant procedures, can the purpose be achieved.

After listening to Mr. Zhao's explanation, the judge also felt that this was more convenient, but the court needed to mediate again to let the two parties reach a consensus.

"The three brothers and sisters of the Li family, what do you think of using your old father's funeral expenses to offset the various expenses in arrears?" the judge asked in court.

"This is the money left to us by the old father, to offset the debt, isn't it a bit against the old man's wishes!" The boss of the Li family was very reluctant.

Lawyer Zhao took it, "Conceptually speaking, this money is not the property left to you by the old man, why should the government give this money? Because after the old man dies, in order to reduce the burden on the family in dealing with the aftermath."

(This chapter is not finished, please turn the page)

Dan, but also in order to reflect the government's humanistic care, this money has the meaning of subsidies and pensions. In the course of your old father's treatment and funeral, if you were present, the money should have been paid by you, and because of your absence, my client advanced the money for you, shouldn't you use the money given by the government to return it to my client?"

"What I want to emphasize here to the Li brothers and sisters is that according to the nature of this money, even if you do not agree to the request of the plaintiff's agent, you will not be able to withdraw this money without the formalities provided by them, please weigh the pros and cons. The trial judge said.

Now, the three brothers and sisters are completely cold, the two purposes of the original plan have completely failed, not only failed to knock a sum in the elderly service center, but also can't even get the old father's funeral expenses, and the frustration is beyond words.

However, if they obey like this, the three brothers and sisters are really unwilling, but they really can't think of other ways to deal with it, and in desperation, the Li family brothers suddenly said: "If this money is more than the arrears, what should I do?"

"You can rest assured, my client will not ask for a penny more than to get back the medical expenses you paid in advance and the fees you owe to the elderly service center. For the arrears of the elderly service center, according to the agreement, a certain amount of late fees should be charged, but they are very generous, after all, your old father is gone, and decided to open up to you. Lawyer Zhao said.

"Mr. Judge, allow us to discuss it individually. Boss Li pleaded.

"Agree to the request, you can go to the next lounge to discuss. ”

After about ten minutes, the three Li brothers and sisters returned to the courtroom.

"How about it, have you three discussed it? The case is not complicated in the first place, are you thinking a little too much?" looked at the complicated expressions on the faces of the three brothers and sisters, and the judge asked.

"In principle, we agree with the other party's proposal, but we have a request. ”

"Oh, tell me, what do you want?"

"Our father has lived in the elderly service center for nearly two years, it is understood that Changda Holdings is a large listed company, and now that the elderly are gone, can the service center give us an appropriate reduction in arrears?"

"This ...... No one expected that the Li brothers and sisters would make such a request, and the judge paused, "This matter does not fall within the jurisdiction of the court, and the opinion of the plaintiff's agent must be sought." ”

There are such cheeky people in the world! Lawyer Zhao thought it was incredible. Yes, Changda Holdings is indeed a listed company with a large scale, but what does this have to do with your Li brothers and sisters? People don't want late fees, and you still ask for fee reductions, Lawyer Zhao thinks that this kind of behavior is purely a villain's act of messing around!

I didn't want to deal with the other party, but because of the judge's feelings, Mr. Zhao had no choice but to say: "I don't have the right to decide this kind of thing, and I need to seek the client's opinion." ”

"In view of the fact that the conditions of the Li family are not good, then ask Lawyer Zhao to ask your client to see if you can give them appropriate relief?"

Lawyer Zhao came out of the courtroom, he dialed Guan Yuntian's phone and roughly explained what happened, "Mr. Guan, do you think you should consider the other party's request?"

(End of chapter)